Asus U3S6 Card + SSD

Burner27

Supreme [H]ardness
2FA
Joined
Oct 23, 2000
Messages
6,868
I purchased an Asus U3S6 card and have it in the recommended slot on my Asus P6T Deluxe V2 board. I was wondering if someone could answer this question:

I have been reading reviews of this card, and I am trying to see if it would be more beneficial to have only my SSDs attached to it or not. My SSDs are not SATA 6GB/sec capable but I figured I could isolate them from the ICH10R and perhaps get better IO performance from them. Does this seem logical?

Thx
 
No, you are unlikely to get better performance than ICH10 by using your Asus SATA card, unless you have already saturated the bandwidth of the ICH10 channels.

The only way you are likely to get better performance with the card is if you had a SATA 6.0 Gbps SSD (RealSSD).
 
Thanks for the reply. Here's my dilemma: I have 7 HDDs in my machine:

80GB Intel SSD G2 (OS and apps)
128GB Patriot Torqx (Oracle VirtualBox machines)
1TB Western Digital SATA HDD
4 x 2TB Seagate SATA HDDs

I also have 3 optical drives:

LG BluRay/HD-DVD/DVD Burner SATA
LiteOn SATA DVD Burner
Samsung SH-S223F SATA DVD Burner

I have an ASUS P6T deluxe V2 and it has the 6 SATA ports off the SouthBridge. I was running the 4 x 2TB HDDs off of a PCI based SATA I (150MBps) RAID card in RAID 5 but the RAID 5 failed. I also felt I was handcuffing myself by only having the drives running at SATA I and having it run off of a PCI based card. So I was trying to figure out the best way to do this. Upon further reading, I have found that the cheap SATA RAID cards are still considered software based because they have no 'brains' on the card and are not suitable for anything above RAID 0 or RAID 1. So........

I bought the U3S6 to perhaps isolate the SSDs and have them dedicated to that card. I purchased a 2 port SATA II (300MBps) PCIe 1x card that can be used in either RAID 0 or RAID 1 or I can flash the firmware on the card to a non-RAID card and use it to hook up 1 optical drive and the 1TB HDD to.

This would leave me with 2 optical drives on the native SATA ports plus the 4 x 2TB HDDs could go on the native SATA ports as well. This way I could run the Intel Matrix RAID on the 2TB drives in RAID 5 (yeah I know it is still software based RAID), boot my OS from the U3S6 card and not have any performance bottlenecks.

What do you think?
 
I tried hooking up the HDDs this way:

2 x SSDs + 4 x 2TBs on the ICH10R
1 optical + 1TB drive on the U3S6 card
2 x optical on the Silicon Image RAID card

Could easily boot to the opticals from either the Silicon Image card or the U3S6 so that is confirmed. I reloaded Windows7 because I changed the ICH10R from AHCI mode to RAID mode and set the 2 SSDs to Un-Raid and the 4 x 2TB drive to RAID 10.

Performance wise it was 'ok', but what I did notice is the 1TB HDD that holds all of my DLed software seemed much slower in terms of installing software on to my SSD drive when it is connected to the U3S6 card. Hence, confirming what has been said previously that the U3S6 card has lower I/Os than the onboard ICH10R.

I also tried switching the 1TB HDD to the Silicon Image card and the results were the same.

But, I switched the 1TB HDD with one of the SSDs(not my OS drive, obviously) and tried installing software from there and it performed much better.

So, I am kinda of stuck now. I do not want to limit the performance of any of the HDDs (either the SSDs or the HDDs) but I am limited in the number of ports I have on the ICH10R. I guess my only other option is to get rid of the U3S6 card and the 2 port Silicon Image card in favor of a 4 port PCIe raid card for the 2TB HDDs.

Thoughts?
 
Back
Top