ASUS Rampage III Formula issue...(?)

der_jackal

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 11, 2006
Messages
412
At my wits end here. Had an RMA and the second board has the same issue, so I am wondering if anybody else has seen this or can see if this happens.

All 6 DIMM slots are populated with matched Patriot Viper Extreme 1600 4GB sticks (PX-312G1600LLK). The system only shows 20GB at the BIOS level and in Windows

I tested out all sticks in all slots, and found the final DIMM slot, C2 was the one not reporting. I tested all sticks in the other slots again and all worked without issues, save the C2 slot not reporting to the BIOS.

Running memtest shows only 20GB, and everything passed in every RAM / slot configuration.

CPU-Z does show a stick populated in that slot. :/

I swapped out alternating sticks for some OCZ Reaper HPC 1600 2GB sticks I had pulled out of another system, and which I knew were good. Same thing. C2 showed nothing.

When I first got the RAM on the original board, all 24GB showed up. Only after I had dropped in a SATA III HDD did this happen. Even after pulling the new HDD, only 20GB.

i980x never been OC'd. Now been reseated three times in two boards.
Enermax 1250 PSU
Two XFX 5970 Black Editions stock speeds.

I am willing to accept it is still RAM, but having tried other RAM and seeing it exhibit the same issue makes me wonder.

This is just driving me bonkers....
 
Last edited:
wow thats kinda strange...couple of thoughts, have the latest bios...is the ram on the compatability list or are there other posters running this ram on this board with success...increase ram voltage..what is your voltage set at for ram?
 
QPI/DRAM core is set to auto showing 1.230
DRAM Bus is set to auto showing 1.654
DRAM Res are all set to auto.

If bump the QPI up to XMP profile 1 of 1.3v and Bus up to 1.656, nothing changes.

Running current BIOS. ASUS doesn't have any 4GB stick configurations on their support list for this board. Yet all x58 based systems advertise maximum 24GB support.

I did a little looking around, but didn't see anybody with this issue or this kind of configuration. But I did find some running 24GB on the board. :s
 
Last edited:
That's incredibly strange, especially as it only shows 20gb at bios level.

Was it the same situation with both boards? That the RAM slot in question stopped working after plugging in a SATA III drive?

I guess there's the very small chance that it's just a design problem, especially as the Marvell implementation on this board is notoriously buggy. It's not really something that many people can try to replicate though; I know no-one with a Crucial C300 and 24GB RAM :p.
 
Yeah, both boards, both C2 slots were failing to register, even with 2GB sticks populating the secondary (black) DIMM slots.

This is just flippin' weird. Guess I'll work with ASUS some more...
 
It is the CPU not the mobo. Same problem here, three different boards, different ram sets etc. but the same CPU. Single channel works, dual does not. Windows 7 x64 says only 2Gb are usable. The memory controller is weak and is a problem.


http://vip.asus.com/forum/view.aspx...rd_id=1&model=P6X58D Premium&page=1&count=301


Doesn't explain how it did show 24GB and only dumped the last slot after the SATA III drive went in.

:/

Would just appear at this point that this whole x58 platform is wrought with issues. Can't move to Sandy Bridge until those stop lumpy yawning the SATA II ports...Guess I'll just live with 20GB for a while. ;)
 
Oh noes 20gb!! My 6GB is all shrivelled and wrinkley in comparison :(.
 
Doesn't explain how it did show 24GB and only dumped the last slot after the SATA III drive went in.

:/

Would just appear at this point that this whole x58 platform is wrought with issues. Can't move to Sandy Bridge until those stop lumpy yawning the SATA II ports...Guess I'll just live with 20GB for a while. ;)

The same goes for P55. 20GB is not too shabby.:D
 
I've seen this on some older P6T Asus boards when I had 12GB of ram.

Try upping your QPI a bit. Those damn bloomfields love QPI when a bunch of drives and all ram slots are filled. I've got the same proc, same board, same memory (but only 12GB of it) and it all works flawlessly. But mine's also overclocked.
 
I have called Intel and provided all the motherboards and ram kits I used and said dual channel does not work. They said to send it in and I will get replaced. I am quite impressed. It makes me want to keep my Sandy.:)
 
I've seen this on some older P6T Asus boards when I had 12GB of ram.

Try upping your QPI a bit. Those damn bloomfields love QPI when a bunch of drives and all ram slots are filled. I've got the same proc, same board, same memory (but only 12GB of it) and it all works flawlessly. But mine's also overclocked.

Yeah, I just tried futzing with the QPI, got it to the point the OS wouldn't even load w/o a BSOD. nada...

I am going to condense the number of drives on the system this weekend for other reasons. It will be interesting to see if anything changes...

I'll keep my table at the pity party. :)
 
Best thing to do is to do what the others suggested: RMA the CPU or contact Intel for a replacement. You've replaced everything except the processor...
 
Best thing to do is to do what the others suggested: RMA the CPU or contact Intel for a replacement. You've replaced everything except the processor...

Same CPU / system earlier showed 24GB until the SATA III HDD went in. Still not sure it's a CPU issue as it's only having issues on the C2 DIMM slot. Seems odd a defective memory controller on a CPU would only have trouble reading one specific DIMM slot though. The forum link Iching posted to does show that the CPU / x58 platform is having memory issues on the whole, so..*shrugs*

ASUS is stumped so I will go talk to Intel to see if they have any hints. It's their first revision of controller on CPUs so it wouldn't surprise me if there were architectural bugaboos.

Anyway, I'm likley to bag this whole system and move up to a SandyBridge when the next rev of boards are out and the upper limit CPUs are out as well.

It's rock solid other than the -4GB, so no big hurry. And as I've now rebuilt this system 4 times in the last month, I'm kinda tired of ripping it apart and building it back up. :)

My whole configuration;
i980x
1x 600GB WDC SATA III at 10K
1x 1TB WDC SATA II
1x 1TB Seagate SATA II
1x 750GB Seagate SATA II
1x LG BD-RE SATA II
2x XFX 5970 BEs
24GB Patriot Vipter Extreme Triple Channel
Creative X-Fi PCI-e 1x
 
Last edited:
Back
Top