Asus MW221U vs. Dell E228WFP

Tracker

Weaksauce
Joined
Jan 20, 2007
Messages
107
So I noticed that Dell FINALLY came up with a 22" monitor to bridge the gap they have beetween 20" and 24". Unfoutunetely its not an "UltraSharp" monitor, but a crappy TN panel. I realize that Dell are using a Chemi panel, but i guess its not one of their best ones. I was thinking it was the one on the 24", wich is amazing.
On the other hand, Asus has had a "pretty good" 22" monitor for a while now.. well at least in Canada.

Asus:
-Not a TN-panel.. possibly 8-bit?
-2ms response time
-No connections other than DVI/VGA
-No way to adjust the monitor
-Wastes space with silver line on the bottom
-Has Speakers wich are useless and make it less cool

Dell:
-TN-panel.. 6-bit crappiness
-5ms response time
-No connections other than DVI/VGA
-No way to adjust the monitor


Basicly, what I care about is Backlight Bleeding and an 8-bit panel. I guess I'll deal with the Asus having those unsightly speakers and non-black wasted space at the bottom.

I think it sucks that Dell finally make a 22" monitor and it sucks.. But that depends - I'm upgrading from a 17" Viewsonic VA712.. so maybe i wont notice a difference. I dont know if its 6 or 8 bit.

So what do u think? Does the Dell really suck because of its 6-bit of color and higher response time, or do they both suck and i should just find a way to steal a 24" ultrasharp?

Cheers,

Chris
 
Honestly I don't know anything about either of these monitors but....if the Asus 22" is indeed not using a TN panel then it is probably a P-MVA if AU Optronics is making a 22" panel these days. In that case I would definitely go with the Asus unless the cost is too much higher and/or other issues I'm not aware of. Personally, none of the 22" panels excite me...all you are gaining by going 22" over 20" is a little extra screen area (yet the same resolution) and cost would be the only reason not to step up to a 24".
 
Honestly I don't know anything about either of these monitors but....if the Asus 22" is indeed not using a TN panel then it is probably a P-MVA if AU Optronics is making a 22" panel these days. In that case I would definitely go with the Asus unless the cost is too much higher and/or other issues I'm not aware of. Personally, none of the 22" panels excite me...all you are gaining by going 22" over 20" is a little extra screen area (yet the same resolution) and cost would be the only reason not to step up to a 24".

Those 2 inches are a big difference. The 20" is no higher than a 17" monitor.

Actually, I dont live in the US, so im paying the price of a 24" for a 22". If i were in the US i would be able to buy the 24".
 
The AUO panel is TN also. I dont think anyone is making a non-TN 22 inch panel yet.
 
Back
Top