Asus, Gigabyte, listen up!

c3k

2[H]4U
Joined
Sep 8, 2007
Messages
2,331
Okay guys, what's the deal? You can talk all day about PCI lanes, ram support, solid caps, socket types, or BIOS upgrades. Blah.

Here's what you need to focus on: Fan control and blinking lights (yeah, Asus, I'm talking to you!)

Mobo Fan Control: my Abit (r.i.p.) IP35pro allows me to set fan profiles in BIOS. I can do that for as many fans as I can plug into the mobo headers. Make each header at least 1w. Multiple fans/header should not fry a board. While we're at it, make each header a pwm style. That way, I can choose whether to use a 3 or 4 pin fan and control it via my favored method...in the BIOS.

C'mon guys. Fans are needed in every build. Fan control is needed for every decent build.

Blinking Lights: (Gigabyte, I'll give you a pass on this, for now. That just means you really need to work on the fan control a bit sooner.) Asus, what the heck were you thinking? Really? When the computer sleeps, you make the power LED flash so I won't sleep? Most cases have LED's that are rated at 2,000 megalumens or something else insane. They are bright. That flashing LED is crazy. The computer is supposed to be sleeping, not having a seizure.

Sure, I could grab a piece of tape and cover the light. That's a slick move on a $2,000 build. Or, I could just leave the LED unplugged. Or, I could burn it out. But why should I?

Asus, include a power LED menu in the BIOS. That way I could choose how the LED illuminates based on the sleep state.

Okay, get to it!
 
And I'll add -- Make the fan control headers capable of both Voltage and PWM control. Was pissed to have to replace my 3-pin Scythe fan because my current Asus board only does fan control via PWM now
 
This thread is a great idea.
Manufacturers should always get input from users and see if they're doable, etc..
 
I don't know if they have enough technical skills to do that. My ASUS Commando doesn't leave the LCD Poster backlight off if I shutdown the computer with GNU/Linux. If I shutdown the system from Windows the backlight of the LCD will also be turned off.

That's a really bad ACPI implementation in my opinion.

So, if they have problems to do a proper ACPI implementation I can't imagine what can happen if they try to put options for controlling LED behaviour on different system events.

You know, computers are used for more than just games on Windows, I don't think it's asking too much when they have used for themselves Linux based systems and installed it for users (Splashtop for example), so making standards compliant BIOSes is not that hard.
 
Back
Top