Are TN panels really that bad?

CatsGoMoo

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 20, 2004
Messages
297
Well, are they? I don't do a lot of photo editing or anything like that, but I'm really sensitive to color changes, and it drives me crazy when things "aren't quite right." Would a TN panel drive me insane? The price difference between TN and higher quality panels is pretty significant, and I'm trying to decide between 22" and 20.1" (Mainly looking at the HP W2007, as every time I've seen one they look absolutely great, but part of me wants to get something bigger).

I would really like to be able to go to a store and just check them out, but it seems every store I go to has all the monitors running through a stupid splitter, so half of the monitors are running non-native resolutions and look terrible. It's not exactly the ideal way to make an informed decision.
 
To directly answer your question, No, they're not that bad. But, if you're often going to look at your monitor from all sorts of angles then you'll probably want to pass over TN panels, especially if subtle changes "drive you crazy" ;)

Nothing wrong with being finicky, some people have to be actually. But i'd recommend you purchase your monitor(s) from places that offer hassle free returns. This is because there's a decent chance you'll end up exchanging for different models till you find the one perfect for you. Definitely do your research to narrow your field of candidates though, and remember there are tradeoffs with all the different lcd panels (accurate color -vs- response time -vs- viewing angles etc)

my 2c and good luck with your selection
 
I consider myself someone rather sensitive to slight imperfections such as things like subtle color changes from top to bottom, backlight bleed, that sort of thing. I got a Samsung 226BW, and I definitely noticed a color clarity and brightness change from top to bottom, though it wasn't severe in the least. Gaming is amazing -- This is one area where I think a 22'' monitor shines decidedly above a 20''. I've played on both, and even though they run the same resolution, the 22'' monitor is bigger by just enough of a margin to make the experience noticeably more engrossing. One is a TN (the 22, obviously), the other is S-IPS, and both had a fast enough response time that I didn't notice ghosting or input lag on either. The S-IPS panel has a much better viewing angle, but in game, the color descrepancy wasn't all that huge. On the desktop, the S-IPS had better colors and a slightly crisper image.

Again, I cannot stress enough to you that for a casual user, these differences are hardly perceptible, and even to the curmudgeon, not strong enough to demolish the surfing, editing, or gaming experience on either monitor. My best advice to you is capitalize on the advantages of your choice: If you get a 20'', make sure it's a P-MVA, S-IPS, or some other 8-bit panel with a decent response time so you can enjoy the superior color quality and viewing angles, and if you go with a TN panel, make sure it's a 22'' so as to have a larger screen and faster response to game on.

(If games aren't a factor here, it'd be hard not to recommend a non-TN panel, though if you like to sit farther away from your screen than average, the 22'' might still be nice to have.)

Also, SJetski's advice is excellent -- Hassle-free returns are a must, and make the monitor-buying situation a lot less stressful; if you find a flaw you don't like, you can always return the monitor and try another. (Also, to elaborate on that, try it for a few days before making a judgement -- the subtle imperfections I do notice with a TN panel didn't really set in until after a couple days of use.)

Best of luck :)
 
Back
Top