Are the new GPUs even worth it?

Triple B

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jul 13, 2004
Messages
192
From everything I've been hearing, at this point the CPU is the current bottleneck in games. So if that's the case, and there's nothing really new on the way in the form of a faster chip (dual core has worse performance according to the benches I've seen), why are they pushing more powerful video cards? Maybe I'm missing something. I haven't upgraded in 4 years practically (sig says it all). But will a 7800GTX really be that amazing compared to a 6800u if the CPU is holding you back? What am I missing? I want to build a new box, but I'm kinda holding off til I know the answer to this. Oh, that and buying an engagement ring is expensive ;)
 
dual core will be MUCH MUCH faster once we see some multi-treaded game like the new UT game and that will cear that up as for it be slower, slower then what a FX-56 meh nothing a bit of a OC cant fix still a 4400+ A64 X2 run each core at 2.2Ghz thats only slightly slower then what im running but with the better core and dual channel mem it will make up for it + like i said you could OC it to 2.4 ~ 2.5 easy and a A64 that fast is still a realy nice CPU
 
Triple B said:
From everything I've been hearing, at this point the CPU is the current bottleneck in games. So if that's the case, and there's nothing really new on the way in the form of a faster chip (dual core has worse performance according to the benches I've seen), why are they pushing more powerful video cards? Maybe I'm missing something. I haven't upgraded in 4 years practically (sig says it all). But will a 7800GTX really be that amazing compared to a 6800u if the CPU is holding you back? What am I missing? I want to build a new box, but I'm kinda holding off til I know the answer to this. Oh, that and buying an engagement ring is expensive ;)
:) NO offense but looking at your sig tells me that yes, the current GPU's would be well worth it... not to mention the current CPU's and motherboards
 
depends on the game Ureal3/UT2k6 or whatever no single treaded games OH YEA :p
 
The OP brings up a good point. Even the mighty FX-55 overclocked to hell and back is a bottleneck in the almighty race for more frames per second. Dual-core is here, but brings with it a "Zero" increase in gaming speed. Gaming and dual core processors do have a future together but not today.

Whats the sense of having a Ferrari if you cannot drive it?
 
DandyBear said:
The OP brings up a good point. Even the mighty FX-55 overclocked to hell and back is a bottleneck in the almighty race for more frames per second. Dual-core is here, but brings with it a "Zero" increase in gaming speed. Gaming and dual core processors do have a future together but not today.

Whats the sense of having a Ferrari if you cannot drive it?


becouse you can :D :cool:
 
seanmcd said:
:) NO offense but looking at your sig tells me that yes, the current GPU's would be well worth it... not to mention the current CPU's and motherboards

None taken, but I guess I didn't make myself clear. I don't mean is it worth it for me to upgrade to one. I meant with current software and CPU technology is there a point to having a better card than the "last" generation. I suppose the point is that these are forward-looking upgrade pieces and they won't really be great until the software is out that can really utilize them. Like multi-threaded games. So I answered my own question :)
 
I dunno about the CPU being the bottlenecks.

I think its more the games themselves. I mean after the first couple hundred FPS in Quake 3, does it really matter for the last 3 hundred? It really seems like the games just aren't pushing the cpu as much as they could. I dunno, maybe im just talking out my ass, but i find it hard to believe that the cpu's are outdated when you can still see a difference in performance between and x800xt and a 6800U in game benchmarks. If the CPU was the bottleneck, then the FPS would be about the same.

my $.02
 
Triple B said:
None taken, but I guess I didn't make myself clear. I don't mean is it worth it for me to upgrade to one. I meant with current software and CPU technology is there a point to having a better card than the "last" generation. I suppose the point is that these are forward-looking upgrade pieces and they won't really be great until the software is out that can really utilize them. Like multi-threaded games. So I answered my own question :)

the point is for NV and ATi to make $$$$$$$$$$$
sure the cards from last gen are good but if you look at upcoming games UT2K6 Unreal3 Quake4 youll see that even last gens cards will not beable to run at max settings why run that high becouse you can

also with PPUs coming out that will take some more work off the CPU and free it up for more stuff also newer games are like 3dmark05 not so much cpu limited as GPU limited namely at high settings were having more rar speed helps
 
CodeWaste said:
I dunno about the CPU being the bottlenecks.

I think its more the games themselves. I mean after the first couple hundred FPS in Quake 3, does it really matter for the last 3 hundred? It really seems like the games just aren't pushing the cpu as much as they could. I dunno, maybe im just talking out my ass, but i find it hard to believe that the cpu's are outdated when you can still see a difference in performance between and x800xt and a 6800U in game benchmarks. If the CPU was the bottleneck, then the FPS would be about the same.

my $.02

the CPU is only the bottle neck at lower settings and older less fillrate intensive games
 
Elios said:
the CPU is only the bottle neck at lower settings and older less fillrate intensive games


Yeah thats true, but when you look at the Benckmarks for say Doom 3, and HL2, and even farcry, theres still enough difference between the cards to say that the game is pushing the card as hard as it can, not the CPU.
 
well if I look at your current sig, you don't waste your money on all the new tech so you want something to last. I'd say a dual core 4400+ and something like a 6800gt or ultra would do the trick, maybe 1 or 2 gigs of ram.
But its all about what you can afford too. In the above mentioned thats around $1000 + mobo + whatever else you may need. A 6800gt is the best bang for the buck card ATM and ATM it looks like the 7800 will be around $600+ (and if the 7800 3dmark 05 marks are true) then its truely not worht it IMHO. But that should be solved today or tomarrow with its release.

my 2 cents
 
Elios said:
dual core will be MUCH MUCH faster once we see some multi-treaded game like the new UT game and that will cear that up as for it be slower, slower then what a FX-56 meh nothing a bit of a OC cant fix still a 4400+ A64 X2 run each core at 2.2Ghz thats only slightly slower then what im running but with the better core and dual channel mem it will make up for it + like i said you could OC it to 2.4 ~ 2.5 easy and a A64 that fast is still a realy nice CPU
It's sort of like 64bit CPUs....we have them but what good have they been for us? Nearly ZERO! :(

Dual core CPUs will see more of an immediate benefit than 64bit CPU cores did because the OS can move tasks around and keep stupid processes off of the core that's running your game/s. Still...to get the best bang for the buck we need to see programmers start issuing commands that make use of multiple CPU cores. Otherwise we don't see squat as far as real "innovation" and CPU speed is concerned.
 
It's kind of like the games (mostly flight simulators) you used to run on 386 computers, that could take advantage of the math processor, if you had one installed. Most games didn't support them, but the ones that did really had a benefit of it.

I predict the same future for dual-core CPUs related to gaming.
 
I wonder how much a difference dedicated physics processing units will make in decreasing CPU load, and thus increasing FPS in games?

The PPU is supposed to be available at the end of this year.
 
Elias said:
I wonder how much a difference dedicated physics processing units will make in decreasing CPU load, and thus increasing FPS in games?

The PPU is supposed to be available at the end of this year.


The statistic i heard was 3-5%. Obviously not much. But the point of having a dedicated physics unit is that later on the physics can be manipulated to a much greater detail and scale than ever possible on a CPU.

Basically the whole poinbt of the Agia (dont remember the exact name) PPU is the greater capability in the future.
 
Elios said:
the point is for NV and ATi to make $$$$$$$$$$$
sure the cards from last gen are good but if you look at upcoming games UT2K6 Unreal3 Quake4 youll see that even last gens cards will not beable to run at max settings why run that high becouse you can

also with PPUs coming out that will take some more work off the CPU and free it up for more stuff also newer games are like 3dmark05 not so much cpu limited as GPU limited namely at high settings were having more rar speed helps


By the time those 3 games come out, the 7800 GTX and the dual cores just released will all be outdated and more then likely not powerful enough to run them at max settings. lol
 
Triple B said:
From everything I've been hearing, at this point the CPU is the current bottleneck in games. So if that's the case, and there's nothing really new on the way in the form of a faster chip (dual core has worse performance according to the benches I've seen), why are they pushing more powerful video cards? Maybe I'm missing something. I haven't upgraded in 4 years practically (sig says it all). But will a 7800GTX really be that amazing compared to a 6800u if the CPU is holding you back? What am I missing? I want to build a new box, but I'm kinda holding off til I know the answer to this. Oh, that and buying an engagement ring is expensive ;)

Trust me, the whole "OMG CPU BOTTLENECK" Thing is just stupid. If you have at least 2.0ghz on your CPU (or equivilent AMD) your fine for most games. At the moment, waiting for a 7800 is definetly worth it. Im still waiting for ATI to unveil the next card, so I can make a choice.
 
Its amount new levels of image Q at High resolution. I own a 1920 x1200 24" LCD and wish to play games "the way they were meant to be played" at that resolution :D
 
Like I said this guy doenst seem like he wants to keep up with the o so new and great because to be honest its outdated in less than half a year. Just would want something that will last like his current setup has.

As for the PPU I would say no more than a 10% increase in FPS, but the amount of "extra" physics it would yeild would be the benefit of adding the card. Personally I can't wait to see what Ageia has to offer, but I still think games need to have good content and control over graphics, physics.
 
jacuzz1 said:
Its amount new levels of image Q at High resolution. I own a 1920 x1200 24" LCD and wish to play games "the way they were meant to be played" at that resolution :D

Yes people don't seem to notice that these cards are pushing 60+ fps at resolutions that most monitors don't even support. So instead of focusing solely on more fps (which is always welcome), look at what IQ improvements the next generation will bring as well.

Looks like Nvidia will give us:

- Higher EER - which should mean true 8x8 resolution for 8xS mode
- Anti-aliased alpha textures - this could be a big deal judging from the sample HL2 shots if performance is up to par. I'm guessing it is since G70 has fillrate to burn and this technique is selectively applied to transparent textures/polygons.
- faster HDR (they claim full speed in a leaked PDF but who knows wtf that means)

ATi will most likely try to up the IQ stakes with their next generation part as well.
 
Well, if you look at it from a value-curve standpoint, you are absolutely correct; the inefficiency is definitely there and you are most certainly not getting the best value for your money. That said, the enthusiast market has never been about value-curve. I agree with those that say it's all about the $$$ because frankly, it is.

Companies know that there are enthusiasts out there and while they may not have the market share of say, OEM companies that require only the baseline product, they are none-the-less a community that is almost compulsive for purchasing the latest and greatest and they have a pocket book to match.

Factor in the truth that almost every enthusiast website will want to review your new flagship product and you have free advertising... not so much for that $800 product, but rather your company and the other, more mainstream products, which consumers and companies will now consider.

Use the FX line as an imaginary example. Rave reviews about the top-of-the-line FX cards... Editors Choice Awards left and right. Now my OEM company can include one of those cards from the FX line in each of my 1,000 computers a month and I can tout: Using state-of-the-art graphics technology based on the latest FX line of Graphics Processing Units.

Normal consumer thinks, "hey FX cards have been receiving accolades left and right, that sounds like a good deal." Nevermind the fact that I conveniently omitted the fact that the FX card in that system wasn't a top-of-the-line 5900 series but rather a baseline 5200 series card.

Flagship products were never meant to sell well, they were meant to sell the rest of the company without the company having to invest in marketing for each tier. It's all about the Benjamin's.

EDIT: Besides that point, I do agree that transition has been made to focus more on quality vs. frames. The frames have already been reached, so now modern-day GPU's can focus on enhancing the experience. Still, bottom line remains that 6 month cycles are all about dollars.

- James
 
I'm in the same box... I want to upgrade something, but I'm not sure where to start. I think I'm going to keep my current box for another year or so, and instead upgrade my monitor to a 24" Dell. That thing is solid, and I haven't really played very many games as of to late to begin with. Dual-core looks amazing, as I love multi-tasking, but hyperthreading suites me fine for the time being. Moreover, all of the current prices are pretty high since the technology has just become available.
 
CodeWaste said:
Its Threaded

Grammar is your friend :)

.... spelling, spell-check, or a dictionary would be his friend... since we like to get all cranky and nitpicking in here. Btw, no I will not fix my punctuation. Punctuation is not my friend, but my evil bastard brother. :p
 
videogamer323, you're right, I'm not all about the newest and greatest. When I build a box, I build one that will last for years, like this one has. I WILL most likely get the top of the line gear that I can for the next system because I want that to last another 3-4 years if possible. Honestly, I haven't been able to play too many of the newer games (doom 3 I chugged through at around 10fps or less... I'm a glutton). I think I've just been in the mindset that fps are still hard to attain, but looking over game benchmarks, insanely high (read 60+ fps) rates are easily attainable. I think what I really need to do is upgrade my monitor, because it certainly wouldn't handle the gear that I wan to be throwing at it. Time to post on the display forum and ask what's best :-D
 
texuspete00 said:
.... spelling, spell-check, or a dictionary would be his friend... since we like to get all cranky and nitpicking in here. Btw, no I will not fix my punctuation. Punctuation is not my friend, but my evil bastard brother. :p


lol
 
next gen hardware is typically ahead of the software. DirectX 10, 11, 12, 13 etc isn't out....and won't be out until the hardware is there to support it. Hardware comes first.

MMX
SSE
3DNow
Hyperthreading
64 Bit

all of these hardware advances came out before the software was there to really utilize it fully. It's just the way it works...No the topmost gen isn't worth it to the average computer enthusiast, but it's there to push the community forward, capture top marketing position - bragging rights, and allow for software and games to have something to look to expand towards....
 
Back
Top