Arctic Silver vs Tuniq Tower Thermal Compound

Averhoeven

n00b
Joined
Apr 24, 2007
Messages
18
Why does Arctic Silver seem to have such a strong following? Is it really that different from other thermal compounds?

I just got the majority of my parts and was contemplating starting to put the PC together. I have a Tuniq Tower 120 that comes with some thermal compound. Would there be anything different about me using that as opposed to waiting until I order my final pieces (another hard drive and a few small things) and including a small tube of Arctic Silver?
 
I'm not sure about Tuniq Tower paste but I did compare Arctic Silver 5 to the thermal paste that comes pre-applied to the Intel OEM cooler and I found no difference.

When using the AS5 method of putting a line down the center of the core I actually ended up with higher temperatures. When I re-did it and applied an equal layer directly over the core area I managed to equal the OEM paste but if it was better it was only by 1C degree at a full load temp of 70C.

It's very hard to find a good review from a reputable main stream site likely because the difference in temps is pretty minor and very difficult to measure any significant difference between a lot of pastes.

With a Tuniq you could probably use tooth-paste and still end up with some great temps. :D
 
The only thing I can say is I've got a TT 120 in my closet collecting dust (I guess it came with TIM :confused: ), I have 3 Zalman HSF's with little bottles of their TIM and I still prefer to use AS5 and always will. I have a E6600, a E6420, a E6400, a E6300 at the present all folding happily and cool 24/7. I have never, unless I didn't or couldn't get any AS5, used any type of TIM other than a Artic Silver paste (depending on the use) AS5, AS3, Artic Silver "C" something (non-conductive, I think and their sticky stuff for capacitor HS's, NB HS's, MB HS's, etc.) I have used these flavors on everything from HSF's to capacitor HS's.

Edit: It works especially well for NB HSF's and Video card HSF"s and it worked well for all the HS's on both of my P5B Deluxe mobo HS's (all the tube connected HS's)
 
I just ordered the regular p5b as part of my e6420 build... would it be a good idea to put AS5 on northbridge/southbridges? I mean, if they're removable. I'm just switching from AMD to Intel so I'm not sure what the heat issues are.
 
i think to get the best results you have to make sure that after the heatsink is on that every mm of the IHS has arctic silver on it allowing for the most ammount of area for heat transfer. a line down the middle might be enough to cover the IHS right above the cores but i would think if you made sure there was enough that it moved all the way out to the edge of the IHS without squishing over it should cool far better than any stock thermal paste that comes with any hardware.

even if you have to apply it clean it off and apply it again a few times so you can see how the coverage is so you can get it just right will help.

and dont forget about the 200hour break in period if you check the temps right away you might only see a 1-5c drop after the break in period it could be as much as 12c if applied properly. atleast thats what i saw with my older x2 3800+.
 
Back
Top