Approx. $1000 on this rig - seeking comments/advice

SamuraiInBlack

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Oct 10, 2003
Messages
5,774
http://secure.newegg.com/NewVersion/Wishlist/WishShareShow.asp?ID=1730839&WishListTitle=SHELLY'S+RIG

Friend of mine is seeking to build a desktop machine to replace her junker. She came to me on advice on what to throw together and I figured the simplest way would be to configure what I can at NewEgg. this is what I came up with.

What I want to know is if you guys would do anything different and why. The goal is to be around the $1000 mark. I've tried to do as much future-proofing as I could without going cheap on vital components. She is going to mainly use this as a Flash/Photoshop machine with Illustrator and other web design stuff for her college. But she would also like something that will allow her to play games both new and old, but she isn't a super hardcore PC gamer so she doesn't need SLI.

I wasn't sure if going dualcore would be a good route because I honestly don't know if dual core is going to be really the standard to have in the next two to three years. But even if it were, the board will still support the X2's if I'm not mistaken, so she can always change that out down the road.
 
i would DEFINATELY switch that power supply out for a different one. for example the 500w seasonic s12 is more then enough and will save some money on the cost of the system http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16817151024

i would switch out the hitachi hdd for the seagate version because of reliability/performance/warranty
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16822148025

i would switch the as5 for arctic silver ceramique just because as5 is *under certain conditions* capacitive

i would take out the asus motherboard and the bfg video card you have selected and switch it for the evga 7800gt + motherboard bundle (399 gets you both!)

does she need a case? i dont see one listed..
 
sc00ter said:
Not a bad list..but here's what I'd do:

Centruion 5 - $45
EPoX nF4 Ultra - $105
X2 3800+ - $329
Corsair ValueSelect 1GB - $80
HIS X800XL - $279 ($259 after MIR)
Maxtor 200GB HD - $85
Fortron 500W PSU - $91 NEC DVD burner - $39
Total: $1053 before MIR

Dual core will definitely help it in the future, and even right now. And as long as she's not the type that likes to play games with all the eye-candy turned on, this rig should suit her fine for a while to come.

might want to consider the evga motherboard + video card deal but still.. couldnt have done it better myself :cool:
 
heero884 said:
i would take out the asus motherboard and the bfg video card you have selected and switch it for the evga 7800gt + motherboard bundle (399 gets you both!)

does she need a case? i dont see one listed..

I can't seem to find the EVGA bundle you speak of. But I'd definitely consider it.

And no she doesn't need a case. Someone else is hooking her up with one.
 
Drop the XMS RAM, get Value Select. Put money towards an X2. Get a Maxtor HD with 16MB cache, it's the same price as the one you listed (16MB cache > SATA 3.0Gbps). Arctir Silver > Arctic Ceramique.
 
also, get her a NEC DVD burner. I heard 'bad' things about the Lite-on's on the CDrInfo forums.


edit: since this is for PS and Illustrator, she does not need a 7800GT. Either get her a used 6800GT or something 'inexpensive', e.g. a 6600GT.
 
1. Switch out the BFG 7800GT for an eVGA. eVGA is just a better overall company, and you can score a free copy of Call of Duty 2 if you order from Newegg. Also, see if you can't get in on the free motherboard deal.

2. Switch the 3700+ San Diego for an X2 3800+. With Photoshop and Flash MX, she'll see a huge benefit from using dual-core.

3. Drop the XMS to something more basic. Corsair overprices their memory out of WHACK.

4. The S12-500 is overkill for that kind of computer. I would drop down to a Truepower II 480. Take the money you save from there and put it into the processor upgrade. You should still be roughly around $1000, if you can also catch that free mobo deal.

Have fun!
 
drizzt81 said:
also, get her a NEC DVD burner. I heard 'bad' things about the Lite-on's on the CDrInfo forums.

What's so bad about the Lite-Ons? I've had 4 of them and none of them have ever given me a problem. The only thing I didn't know was the bit about upgradable firmware so I may not have had to spend extra cash getting new drives.

Edit: Just to point out, a quick search at their forums revealed this about NEC's

http://www.cdrinfo.com/forum/tm.asp?m=116244&mpage=1&key=Lite-On&#116244
 
What about a case, heh I think she'd want one of those. I don't see one on the list. You can get an Antec case w/ nice PSU for cheap.
 
Any other suggestions/recommendations guys? the list is updated with some of your recommendations.
 
Back
Top