Apple's `Mighty Mouse' Violates Trademark

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Apple and CBS are being sued over the use of the name "Mighty Mouse". A company named Man & Machine already had a “mighty mouse” computer mouse back in 2004 and is suing Apple for damages.

Apple started selling computer mice under the name ``Mighty Mouse'' more than a year after Man & Machine Inc. began selling waterproof and chemical-resistant computer mice to labs and hospitals under that name in 2004, according to the suit filed yesterday in Greenbelt, Maryland. Man & Machine claims its earlier use trumps Apple's, even though Apple sells more products.
 
NO NO NO

Apple owns everything

they invented everything

they are the pioneers of everything

in fact they should sue everybody for using just about anything

did you hear about MacAir? or iWater? We should pay for that too.
 
Sounds like Apple grabs words which are cool and leave the originators in the dust... that or their trademark team sucks hardcore.
 
I hope apple has to pay through the nose. Seriously, like that wouldn't have turned up on a quick google search...
 
What the hell is going on through Apple's head? Even if they had missed the other Mighty Mouse product used in hospitals, surely they'd realize they might run afoul of the cartoon mouse's namesake.
 
It's kind of a shitty mouse anyway with its awkward clicking mechanism. I can think of half a dozen "mightier" mice off the top of my head.

Fairly cut and dry case it seems. I'd expect Apple to pay damages eventually.
 
What the hell is going on through Apple's head? Even if they had missed the other Mighty Mouse product used in hospitals, surely they'd realize they might run afoul of the cartoon mouse's namesake.

Trademarks have specific fields of use. It doesn't really apply to cartoons.
 
Trademarks have specific fields of use. It doesn't really apply to cartoons.

I wouldn't agree.

You go register Microsoft as a shoe business and see how far you get or try opening a car business and call it Dell.

As for your cartoon comment, try using the name Mickey Mouse on a product, see how far you get. Cartoon names are copyrighted.
 
Normally I see these lawsuits as frivolous but this one is ridiculous. Not only does the other company have nothing to do with Computer Mice but they sell mice to hospitals? What on earth does that have to do with PC Mice and how do people get the two confused?
 
Oh ignore my comment above, I see why they are suing. They also make computer mice. I saw the Sells Mice to Hospital in the story and failed to realize they were also selling computer Mice with the same name. Oops.
 
What the hell is going on through Apple's head? Even if they had missed the other Mighty Mouse product used in hospitals, surely they'd realize they might run afoul of the cartoon mouse's namesake.

As taken from the Bloomberg article:

Bloomberg.com said:
The names of both products play on the 1942 animated superhero mouse whose trademark rights are owned by CBS, the owner of the second-most-watched television network. New York- based CBS is accused of licensing ``Mighty Mouse'' to Apple for computer devices when its trademark doesn't cover such goods.

Man & Machine and CBS both hold trademark applications for the term and are challenging each other for approval at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. Man & Machine says it began using the name earlier than CBS.

Man & Machine is seeking money damages and a court order blocking Apple's use of ``Mighty Mouse'' to sell computer devices.
 
Originally Posted by Bloomberg.com
The names of both products play on the 1942 animated superhero mouse whose trademark rights are owned by CBS, the owner of the second-most-watched television network. New York- based CBS is accused of licensing ``Mighty Mouse'' to Apple for computer devices when its trademark doesn't cover such goods.

Man & Machine and CBS both hold trademark applications for the term and are challenging each other for approval at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. Man & Machine says it began using the name earlier than CBS.

ROFL, that is hilarious. Just when I think litigation over patents and trademarks is out of control in this country, I read stuff like this.
 
Mr. Trouble never hangs around
When he hears this mighty sound...
"Here I come to save the day!"
That means that Mighty Mouse is on the way.
Yessir when there is a wrong to right
Mighty Mouse will join the fight
On the sea or on the land
He gets the situation well in hand
So though we are in danger
We never despair
Cause we know that where there's danger
He is there!
He is there!
On the land!
On the sea!
In the air!
We're not worryin' at all
We're just listenin' for his call
"Here I come to save the day!"
That means that Mighty Mouse is on the way!

;) LOL
 
I wouldn't agree.

You go register Microsoft as a shoe business and see how far you get or try opening a car business and call it Dell.

As for your cartoon comment, try using the name Mickey Mouse on a product, see how far you get. Cartoon names are copyrighted.

Copyright != Trademark

10050258.jpg
 
so this isn't about the cartoon mighty mouse vs. apple's mighty mouse, it's about some product for lab rats? wait, nobody went after this guy, why is he going after apple?

whatever, people will flame me for being sympathetic to apple because i own a macbook and an iphone even though i despise the mighty mouse
 
so this isn't about the cartoon mighty mouse vs. apple's mighty mouse, it's about some product for lab rats? wait, nobody went after this guy, why is he going after apple?

whatever, people will flame me for being sympathetic to apple because i own a macbook and an iphone even though i despise the mighty mouse

lol, no, it is about a company that makes COMPUTER MICE for hospitals and labs. The products are in the same market (more or less), so the company that made the initial mighty mouse likely has a valid trademark that apple violated.
 
OK I just browsed the article and saw they made sturdy COMPUTER mice for hospitals etc. so unless we have a bunch of people being deliberately obtuse, we have a LOT of poor readers in here today.

CBS may have sold the rights to Apple for the name to its' mouse, but the fact is they let this company exist for a few years, and SHOULD have turned up the listing when doing research for Apple.

As far as I am concerned, this is exactly like the Apple/APPLE debacle and will end in the same way.

CBS has no leg to stand on suing this guy, and Apple will try to buy him out, or bankrupt him with legal fees (I doubt they will EVER change THE name to one of their products)
 
I wouldn't agree.

You go register Microsoft as a shoe business and see how far you get or try opening a car business and call it Dell.

As for your cartoon comment, try using the name Mickey Mouse on a product, see how far you get. Cartoon names are copyrighted.

Microsoft is sort of a unique name. Dell on the other hand isn't. I could use "Dell" all day. Its only when I slap it in front of "____ Computer" that I have a problem. :p

This is retarded. Why didn't they come out and make a fuss when it first came out? Well we all know that answer. Good job bundling the mice with all your new computers, Apple. Prepare to pay out of the ass for every single one you sold. LAWLZ

:rolleyes:
 
I think they only have to pay damages, if awarded, from the time they are "Put on notice"
 
Back
Top