Apple's Digital Music Showdown

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Say what you will about Apple, I like the fact that the company is sticking to its promise not to raise the price of music regardless how hard the National Music Publishers' Association tries to get a bigger share of the pie.

Apple declined to discuss the board's pending decision or its previous threat to shut down iTunes. But it adamantly opposes the publishers' request. In a statement submitted to the board last year, iTunes vice president Eddy Cue said Apple might close its download store rather than raise its 99 cents a song price or absorb the higher royalty costs.
 
I agree. Apple's given these guys a fairly clear ultimatum, and Apple's certainly in the position at this point to be giving ultimatums that really mean something.
 
Like to see someone standup against the music industry.
 
Eventually the music industry will cut off their own nose.

If they keep demanding more and more money for worse and worse music then more people will move away from downloads and go back to other ways of getting their music.
 
Wouldn't be the first time Apple stuck by their guns. They dropped NBC/Universal for almost two years because NBC/Universal wanted a bigger cut and more control over the pricing for movies and TV shows (translation, higher price for consumers and variable prices that fall out of the normal rental/purchase tiers).

Well, now they're back on iTunes under Apple's terms. Good for them not caving in. They'll do the same against the NMPA. Fortunately, having the biggest music store in the country over places like Walmart and Best Buy is a good bit of leverage. Apple understands that bumping the price up will kill the market, something the record industry is totally clueless about.
 
Wouldn't be the first time Apple stuck by their guns. They dropped NBC/Universal for almost two years because NBC/Universal wanted a bigger cut and more control over the pricing for movies and TV shows (translation, higher price for consumers and variable prices that fall out of the normal rental/purchase tiers).

Well, now they're back on iTunes under Apple's terms. Good for them not caving in. They'll do the same against the NMPA. Fortunately, having the biggest music store in the country over places like Walmart and Best Buy is a good bit of leverage. Apple understands that bumping the price up will kill the market, something the record industry is totally clueless about.

Yeah. Of all the things I occasionally complain about coming from the Apple camp, the iTunes store is not one of them. This article makes me like them even more.

Time to go buy another song I guess...
 
This makes me conflicted. On one hand, this is a raise of music prices. On the other hand, this is a raise to go 100% directly to the artists, not to the recording industries.

In all honesty, I think the recording industries should take less of a cut and give more to the artists (currently the artists get around ~5c/song, the recording industry gets around ~65c/song, and Apple keeps the remaining ~30c/song). That seems the most fair in my opinion. 65% of the sale price when they have to manage barely anything is too much IMO.
 
This makes me conflicted. On one hand, this is a raise of music prices. On the other hand, this is a raise to go 100% directly to the artists, not to the recording industries.

In all honesty, I think the recording industries should take less of a cut and give more to the artists (currently the artists get around ~5c/song, the recording industry gets around ~65c/song, and Apple keeps the remaining ~30c/song). That seems the most fair in my opinion. 65% of the sale price when they have to manage barely anything is too much IMO.

It was my understanding that the RIAA's cut was closer to .70, with the remainder split between Apple (which is mostly eaten up by actually running the service) and the artists.

I agree with you. The end price to the buyer should remain the same but the ratios need to adjust, shifting more over from the RIAA to the artists. Apple makes their money from iTunes on iPod sales, but they shouldn't have to operate their own store in the red while the RIAA collects their fat royalty for doing very little compared to them or the artists who created the music in the first place.

Gee, that story sounds familiar, same as the measly cut artists get from regular CD sales after the RIAA has taken their fat chunk. What a bunch of crooks.
 
It was my understanding that the RIAA's cut was closer to .70, with the remainder split between Apple (which is mostly eaten up by actually running the service) and the artists.

I agree with you. The end price to the buyer should remain the same but the ratios need to adjust, shifting more over from the RIAA to the artists. Apple makes their money from iTunes on iPod sales, but they shouldn't have to operate their own store in the red while the RIAA collects their fat royalty for doing very little compared to them or the artists who created the music in the first place.

Gee, that story sounds familiar, same as the measly cut artists get from regular CD sales after the RIAA has taken their fat chunk. What a bunch of crooks.

+1 !
 
Back
Top