Apple TV: The New HD Format?

low quality compressed to hell 720 HD and low price... that'll do great in the US (coincidentally for the same reason that HD DVD's only chance was in the US)....

The rest of the world wants quality and willingly pays for it.... Blu-ray (and packaged media for that matter) will always exist for people who want the best possible quality and a sense of ownership.

yep, quality is always king... i mean look at how DVD-A and SACD totally distroyed the redbook audio cd! ;)

like tv, apple will fail, see you next year when you come up with a new idea apple!

the apple tv has been around for a while... i have mine hacked and i play my DVD ISO's on it from my file server... its great :)
 
I for one doubt it. The iTunes Music Store hasn't led to the downfall of the compact disc, nor has it destroyed LPs and other forms of media, and these ~5 meg AAC downloads are within the reach of practically all users with an internet connection. What's going to be the average file size of an HD movie via iTunes, and how many users have the kind of bandwidth to make downloading very large files (say, 10 to 15 gigs a movie) in a reasonable amount of time, and how many users want to watch movies on their PC or have some sort of mechanism to stream the downloaded content to their TV (Apple TV, for instance)?

Whats a compact disc? :D Hehe

I'm hoping that verizon fios spreads across the U.S. Its incredible, 15mb/2mb connection for the same price as comcast. I've always been limited by the server's upstream bandwidth speed not my connection.

In any case we always have this same dilema, computers first bandwidth second. Downloading a 5mb mp3 on 28k connection was practically the same issue. Give it time!
 
How many years till we have 25 gig zip drives available for under $15.00? I think the movie studios should just work on copy protecting a zip drive format so it can only be played and not copied then they could ship all their movies on those. We could do away with proprietary players entirely.
 
My Xbox 360 has been streaming High Def for a while now, and it seems that all major new releases are in HD the same week it is released on DVD. Sure it's only 720p with 5.1surround, but I don't think Apple TV will be any better it's just a Mac with very low end hardware. All my home computers (4) have Vista Media Center with 3 HD home runs on the network. My main HTPC box now has the LG dual format player and I couldn't be more pleased with the amount of HD content I can watch. I'm just hoping that MS, Netflix, etc.. will release High Def streaming for Media Center or I will just find something to rip HDDVD or Blueray to my network storage for internal streaming.
 
My FiOS and uTorrent box do not agree with your esitmate. When the stupidity of the format war is over I will add HD discs to my (huge) SD DVD collection. Until then....ARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR.

Considering that it's not even in my state yet :( It's got a long way to go.
 
Apple TV only supports H264 baseline, H264 High Profile would be required before you can even start to call the Apple TV a new HD format.
 
HDDVD or BLU RAY, I'm looking forward to the day I can throw in a 50GB writable disk and easily back up my files, as well as burn data disks so I don't need to keep buying hard drives. DVDs are nice, but 5GB isn't that impressive anymore.

If/when digital downloads replace physical media, do you think we're going to see cheap BD/HDDVD burners and media for our computer? i don't think so. Look at tape drives, zip drives, etc. Who won? CDs. They can be played on almost anything.

What the world needs is a sound system for cars that plays HDDVD or BD disks filled with MP3, MP4, FLAC, and OGG.

But I don't see Apple TV taking off, no matter what they do with it. The majority of regular users I know who have broadband don't have a fancy connection. They get either 728kbps down or 1.5mbps down. That's not the kind of connection I'd like to download an h.264 HD video off of.

Look, if you have a 728kbps connection, then you're probably going to download at about 80KB/s. If you figure about 1.5GB for an HD movie, that's 1,572,864 kilobytes, at 80kilobytes a second (I'm taking some off because ISPs never give you what you pay for, which would theoretically be 91KB/s). So then, you have 19660.8 seconds to download, or almost five and a half hours. But, I'm being a little generous. Some HD h.264 videos can run up to 5GB. A 5GB file would take over 18 hours to download. if Apple gives you 24 hours to "rent" the movie, you're going to end up with ONLY 6 hours to watch the movie. Enough to watch it one night and have it expire. Of course, this is assuming it's running at full speed the whole time.

I know I'm on [h], and most of the people here are enuthusiasts with FIOS and big time cable or DSL connections, but the majority of people out there don't care, and they just want the cheapest broadband they can get (if it wasn't like this, ATT would have no reason to even bother with DSL).

Maybe for hardcore users this would hold a *slight* chance of survival, but the average consumer is going to be pretty pissed off when they see it takes 12 hours to DOWNLOAD their video they have for only 24 hours.
 
Good points, but the 24 hour timer doesn't start until the movie starts. So if a person is downloading a 5GB HD movie, you could wait the entire 18 hours or whatever, then start the movie, and you'll have to finish it within 24 hours of that point.
 
They are two completely different distribution channels.
They will exists side by side and compliment the other.

Like DVD "maybe" Blu-Ray will be the next static media standard for the next 15 years or so.
Don't need the internet to watch a HD movie when its on disk.
But it, own it, sell it, take it anywhere.

Down loadable HD content will take time... litterally.
When you don't want to own the disc.
Requires the internet wherever you are.
Blazingly fast network access: Internet2 or something similarly fast maybe like FiOS.
or Hope that Comcast really does have speed to spare.
 
What I want is a exponential increase in hard drive size, to house hd rips. I have around 40 hd dvd rips, but buying drives that are only 1tb and using them for rips that are 25gb+ is a little tedious. I will buy a blu-ray drive when I can buy a hdd that is >=2tb
 
Obviously downloading content is more practical for some of us than it is others.

I don't see how the Apple TV is a rip off. It costs $200 to buy it as a refurb off of their website, and there is very little point in including a large storage drive when you are using your network. It can access your other computers and their storage.

I don't think that it's revolutionary, and it's processing power of 5mb HD video isn't the best, but it still can look better than many dvds which have been rather half assed if you ask me.

At least those of you with HTPCs shouldn't be complaining. With every good market comes competition.
 
at the 6meg speed i use now, i can pull a dvd size x.264 in 4-5 hours. with fios, i could have it in less time than it takes to play it.
 
Back
Top