Apple Sued Over iPhone As E-Book Reader

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Hey look, another lawsuit against Apple.

In a 7-page complaint filed with a Virginia district court Monday, Berne, Switzerland-based MONEC Holding Ltd accuses the iPhone maker of patent infringement, unfair trade practices, monopolization, and tortious interference for allegedly treading on its January 2002 patent No. 6,335,678 titled "Electronic device, preferably an electronic book."
 
Does this company even have a product for it's patent or was it another one of those companies waiting for someone else to make their product so they can cry patent infringment?

BTW, I've read books on PC's too so why arent' they suing every other company that makes PC's?
 
"Unfair trade practices" and "monopolization"? How is Apple doing this, but not this company who is actively PREVENTING Apple from doing what it does? Sounds like they're monopolizing the market on eBook readers to who they want. And, as for the trade practices,

MONEC claims to be in the business of "developing and marketing equipment for the transmission of data to mobile electronics communication systems, managing and utilizing patents in this area and awarding licenses."

In other words, they farm patents. I think this is the "unfair trade practice" here, not anything Apple is doing. I like to rag on them as much as the next guy (along with MS), but c'mon, sometimes it's just so blatantly a cash grab it's not cool anymore.
 
Does this company even have a product for it's patent or was it another one of those companies waiting for someone else to make their product so they can cry patent infringment?
Doesn't matter, they have a patent.

BTW, I've read books on PC's too so why arent' they suing every other company that makes PC's?
This however is where they'll lose, Apple will just cry prior art, and bammo invalid patent.... then they'll turn around and try to patent it themselves (booo apple!)
 
Just like with the douzins of other things Apple stole or copied then used their lawyers to legalize, they'll take this one too.

I've seen people read books on their iPhones and I don't see what the big deal is. I can put text files on my computer and other devices, does that mean I'm breaking some law?
 
I didn't read the entire complaint, but what about the Amazon Kindle.

Wouldn't the fact that it is an e-book reader be "infringing" this literally unknown company's "product?"
 
I didn't read the entire complaint, but what about the Amazon Kindle.

Wouldn't the fact that it is an e-book reader be "infringing" this literally unknown company's "product?"

They're waiting until the Kindle starts making them money before they sue Amazon. Don't you know that's the way it works? :p
 
I tried out the Amazon Kindle app last night and it was pretty cool.
 
"unfair trade practices, monopolization, and tortious interference"

And my mom used to say _I_ exaggerated LOL
 
Back
Top