Apple Sued for Copyright Infringement

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
A photographer is suing Apple for copyright infringement based on an image that is allegedly used without authorization on promotional materials for the i.TV iPhone app. This isn’t the 1st time Louis Psihoyos has sued Apple for infringing on his image but he dropped the 1st complaint in 2007 without public comment.

"Version 1.0 of i.TV directly infringed on Mr. Psihoyos' copyright by incorporating the 1000 TVs image without permission," attorneys for the photographer claim in court papers filed this week in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.
 
Isn't that app made by someone else? That would be kind of like suing Best Buy because Samsung used a copyrighted picture on their product.
 
Yeah, Apple will fight this one.

I mean, when Apple itself was infringing, with their ads for the AppleTV, it was one thing (and the artist dropped that suit!) but in this case, Apple isn't even the infringer.

Hell, I can't even find anything relating to i.TV that might even remotely be infringing.

Is this a late second lawsuit relating to the AppleTV? And the artist just doesn't seem to realize that "i.TV" is separate from "AppleTV"? (When Apple first announced the AppleTV, they did call it "iTV", but also said that "iTV" was just a codename, and that it would NOT be the final name; since they knew that multiple companies already had "iTV" trademarked.)
 
Yeah, Apple will fight this one.

I mean, when Apple itself was infringing, with their ads for the AppleTV, it was one thing (and the artist dropped that suit!) but in this case, Apple isn't even the infringer.

Hell, I can't even find anything relating to i.TV that might even remotely be infringing.

Is this a late second lawsuit relating to the AppleTV? And the artist just doesn't seem to realize that "i.TV" is separate from "AppleTV"? (When Apple first announced the AppleTV, they did call it "iTV", but also said that "iTV" was just a codename, and that it would NOT be the final name; since they knew that multiple companies already had "iTV" trademarked.)

Not only did you not read the original article, you didn't even read the freaking snippet in the OP.

A photographer claims Apple stole one of his images to help promote a mobile app that allows users to search for television programs and other entertainment content on their iPhones.
 
Apple doesn't care about copyright. Have you looked through the App Store? There are thousands of apps that blatantly rip off copyrighted material. Hell, there's that one Mario GPS game that just outright stole images from various Mario games.

Those games get approved, but Wikipanion gets an NC-17 warning because you can search for boobies. They need to pull their head out of their ass with this App Store stuff.
 
Here's the image:

1000-tvs.jpg
 
The tables turn again on litigation happy Apple. :D
 
The tables turn again on litigation happy Apple. :D

I thought they saw their doom when Cisco sued them for the term iPhone (Which Cisco owned)...

Usually Apple can just pay someone off or just hold out long enough to where the other party drains all their funds on legal fees... They couldn't do that with Cisco. Cisco kindof had Apple by their balls for a little bit... Cisco not only owned "iPhone" but also had freaking devices manufactured... And in that whole legal proceedings it was actually discovered Apple had created fake companies trying to register the name and stuff as well...
AIK is Apple is paying Cisco out the butt for the licensing permission to use the name iPhone... Because it was dropped after a meeting behind closed doors.
 
(cr)Apple thinks that they're allowed to sue but not get sued. :rolleyes:

But like others have said, they'll make this incident go away. :(
 
So someone can use photoshop and make money? That does not look like a real photograph only a montage or some convoluted mess of other images.
 
even if it was photoshoped, the image has to be 75% different from the original image to avoid copy write infringement. atleast, thats what i was told in my photoshop class. someone chime in on that too maybe?
 
even if it was photoshoped, the image has to be 75% different from the original image to avoid copy write infringement. atleast, thats what i was told in my photoshop class. someone chime in on that too maybe?

Interesting. How does one quantify "75% different" In terms of # of pixels that were changed? That seems like a very high number.
 
So someone can use photoshop and make money? That does not look like a real photograph only a montage or some convoluted mess of other images.

if you copyright it, yes. there is nothing wrong with copyrighting your own work. it does not necessarily have to be 'natural' :rolleyes:
 
Interesting. How does one quantify "75% different" In terms of # of pixels that were changed? That seems like a very high number.

i cant remember the nitty gritty details, but it seems thats what it was. maybe photoshop has a calculator that shows percentage of change since originally opening the file? haha wouldnt that be the shit
 
i cant remember the nitty gritty details, but it seems thats what it was. maybe photoshop has a calculator that shows percentage of change since originally opening the file? haha wouldnt that be the shit

Yeah, I can't imagine quantifying it any other way than the pixel method.

What if someone took an existing picture and just added pixels outside it to hit 75%? In other words, make the image bigger by adding more black or white in each direction. :cool:
 
Yeah, I can't imagine quantifying it any other way than the pixel method.

What if someone took an existing picture and just added pixels outside it to hit 75%? In other words, make the image bigger by adding more black or white in each direction. :cool:

hey if you added 75% more border around the whole thing, sure!
 
even if it was photoshoped, the image has to be 75% different from the original image to avoid copy write infringement. atleast, thats what i was told in my photoshop class. someone chime in on that too maybe?
Fair use doesn't have a quantity or percentage associated with it because its a case by case basis that is decided in court. And pretty much anyone can sue anyone for pretty much any reason
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use

For instance if you adjusted the color balance to change 75% of pixels by a slight amount, it might not be enough. Or adding a border as someone mentioned.

If you look under the amount section under the wiki article, in one case only including a page or 2 from an entire book was enough to be infringing, so counter examples could probably be found the other way as well.

IANAL and this is only my opinion based on some reading, and isn't legal advice.
 
Fair use is subject to interpretation, which is why some people think it's so flawed. That is, the ones interpreting them are often flawed.
 
Back
Top