Apple Settles Disability Lawsuit

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
AppleInsider says that Apple has settled a long running lawsuit filed by two disabled customers. The company has agreed to make its store handicapped accessible (which it should have been from the start) and retrain its entire staff. Good move on Apple's part, it’s a wonder it took this long to settle this suit.

Both Overbo and Brown-Booker had made it clear in their suit that they were more interested in seeing helpful changes made rather than being awarded punitive damages, so news of a settlement is not surprising. The two sides agreed on a separate settlement to cover legal fees and their attorneys' compensation, and the details of that part of the case remain confidential.
 
That's pretty accommodating of them. Also good of the disabled to just get to the heart of the problem instead of protracting the litigation with trivialities.
 
Like Steve said, thats how it should be been from the start. There is that little thing called ADA which sets all the guidelines for designing stuff to be accessible by handicap people. Apple will probably go after the firm that designed the stores, assuming that they had a firm do them.
 
Like Steve said, thats how it should be been from the start. There is that little thing called ADA which sets all the guidelines for designing stuff to be accessible by handicap people. Apple will probably go after the firm that designed the stores, assuming that they had a firm do them.

The only way they'd get it done w/o an architect is by getting away w/ paying off the local gov., which i highly doubt.

The architects are not the only ones who are liable (by all means I'm not saying they aren't). There's the contractors as well, and those guys called 'building inspectors' are there for a reason. There's so many people down the line from start to finish who are responsible for making sure these things are done correctly. It's hard to imagine a scenario other than architect/contractor/logal gov. peeps backroom dealings that would allow for this to happen in the first place.

With apple's desire for things to be 'swank', and things like accessibility not always being hand in hand with that, it wouldn't suprise me if they put some pressure on the Arch's to 'make it happen' (as in skirting around reg.'s to keep the design purdy).
 
Like Steve said, thats how it should be been from the start. There is that little thing called ADA which sets all the guidelines for designing stuff to be accessible by handicap people. Apple will probably go after the firm that designed the stores, assuming that they had a firm do them.

IMHO The Americans with Disabilities Act is a BS law that has actually hurt people with disabilities by discouraging employers from hiring disabled people due to the risk of lawsuits. Heck, if you take the ADA literally then all public signs should have forward and backwards text. Dyslexia is a disability and according to the ADA you literally cannot discriminate against ANY disability.

It's Apple's store. They should be able to force you to run an obstacle course, complete a triathlon, and pray at a statue of Steve Jobs before you come in if they want to.
 
Gee, wouldn't want to allow businesses to actually run the way they want eh? Freedom sucks anyway right? Who needs it?
 
Heck, if you take the ADA literally then all public signs should have forward and backwards text. Dyslexia is a disability and according to the ADA you literally cannot discriminate against ANY disability.

That's one thing, however there's quite a large chunk of ADA requirements actually built in to local and federal building codes. Yeah if the guys crying about signs for the dyslexic fine. But a lot of the stuff is things that are just supposed to be done correctly. Any arch./contractor/or bldg. inspector claiming to have not know or whatever needs to be fired.

Gee, wouldn't want to allow businesses to actually run the way they want eh? Freedom sucks anyway right? Who needs it?

Why stop with ADA, lets just forget building codes alltogether and let them build whatever they want, regardless of how many people it will kill when the structure fails?

The rules are there for a reason.
 
Why stop with ADA, lets just forget building codes alltogether and let them build whatever they want, regardless of how many people it will kill when the structure fails?

The rules are there for a reason.

The argument isn't that rules are bad, the argument is that badly written laws like the ADA do more harm than good. Building codes keep everyone safe, the ADA allows (and encourages) any person with a disability to sue over pretty much anything that they have trouble with.

Penn and Teller did an episode of Bullshit! about the ADA. They put a guy in an iron lung and went around town complaining about how different stores weren't ADA compliant since he couldn't get in. :D
 
The argument isn't that rules are bad, the argument is that badly written laws like the ADA do more harm than good. Building codes keep everyone safe, the ADA allows (and encourages) any person with a disability to sue over pretty much anything that they have trouble with.

Hence my agreement w/ you on the point about 'signs for dyslexic people'. My point was that a great deal of ADA rules are directly integrated into building codes in a very specific manner, and for good reason. Not abiding by those regulations is against the law.

I understand that vague legislation can create opportunity for the sue happy, but the portions of ada that are integrated into building codes are not vague legal mumbo jumbo, they're very specific. And given that the guy did not sue for money for himself, but only to get apple to modify their property so that it abides by the law, i seriously doubt he was whining about dyslexic signs or lack of access for his iron lung. :rolleyes:

btw, the part of my post you quoted was in response to the guys implying that we should just let companies do whatever the hell they want.
 
Hence my agreement w/ you on the point about 'signs for dyslexic people'. My point was that a great deal of ADA rules are directly integrated into building codes in a very specific manner, and for good reason.
...
btw, the part of my post you quoted was in response to the guys implying that we should just let companies do whatever the hell they want.

Is it the government's job to ensure that every business in the country has specially designed door handles and ramps? Just because someone has a disability doesn't mean they have a fundamental right to access everything as easily as non-disabled people.

Its a feel-good law that does more harm then good. Now that employers can be sued for not being fully compliant with the ADA there has actually been a decline in employment of disabled people.
 
Is it the government's job to ensure that every business in the country has specially designed door handles and ramps? Just because someone has a disability doesn't mean they have a fundamental right to access everything as easily as non-disabled people.

Is it the governments job to make sure a proper amount of insulation is used? Or that a certain type of room has a certain amount of electrical outlets spaced in a certain way, or that counters are a certain height? Hell the last two are "accessibility rules for NORMAL people". So only normal people deserve building codes that are designed to make things accessible to them? Everyone in a wheelchair should just go make their own fucking country?

In short, um yes, it is the governements job to do these things because private entity's will not do it on their own. As for "as easily", tell a wheelchair bound guy that even w/ those ramps his day around town is no more difficult than yours and see if you don't get punched in the nutsack. "As easily" is not always the issue, i can often mean the difference of even having access at all. If you think someone born to a wheelchair doesn't have the right to shop at the same stores as you then you're a supreme asshole in my book.....sorry. If that's the case I hope you get hit by a bus and have to have someone push you the rest of your life while you piss in a bag tied to your belt.

Some things just have to be regulated. You remove government intervention from construction entirely and see how long it takes our country to turn into a delapedated shithole of a death trap.
 
While I disagree with most of the ADA laws and it's ability to make the disabled sue-happy, at the same time I appreciate it's existence. I'm deaf and I couldn't imagine how much more difficult it would be to get a job if some boss out there takes one look at my hearing aids and scoffs and asks me to please leave the premises.

Remember how it used to be? It wasn't just the disabled. It was women too, and the racial divide. The United States wasn't a very enlightened country until only recently. The government had to step in and tell everyone to shape up or face the consequence. We're better for it.

I dislike how people take these laws for granted and tries to find every violations they can just to get rich quick, but hey, there's always going to be assholes out there.
 
In short, um yes, it is the governements job to do these things because private entity's will not do it on their own. As for "as easily", tell a wheelchair bound guy that even w/ those ramps his day around town is no more difficult than yours and see if you don't get punched in the nutsack. "As easily" is not always the issue, i can often mean the difference of even having access at all. If you think someone born to a wheelchair doesn't have the right to shop at the same stores as you then you're a supreme asshole in my book.....sorry. If that's the case I hope you get hit by a bus and have to have someone push you the rest of your life while you piss in a bag tied to your belt.

LMAO...


Some things just have to be regulated. You remove government intervention from construction entirely and see how long it takes our country to turn into a delapedated shithole of a death trap.

You forgot about the government supervised I 35W bridge in Minnesota...
 

Not sure if you're 'lmao' at what i said to him, or at my saying it is the governments job. If it's the latter, well, you don't have to agree with it, but that just the way it is, sorry.


You forgot about the government supervised I 35W bridge in Minnesota...

Lack of maintenance. Doesn't have anything to do with building codes.

Though, you also have to remember too that the codes are constantly revised and changing every 4 years or so. The codes that were enforced when that bridge was built are likely far less stringent that what's on the books today.
 
Is it the governments job to make sure a proper amount of insulation is used? Or that a certain type of room has a certain amount of electrical outlets spaced in a certain way, or that counters are a certain height? Hell the last two are "accessibility rules for NORMAL people". So only normal people deserve building codes that are designed to make things accessible to them? Everyone in a wheelchair should just go make their own fucking country?

Accessibility =! safety. We have building codes to keep buildings from collapsing or burning down.

If you think someone born to a wheelchair doesn't have the right to shop at the same stores as you then you're a supreme asshole in my book.....sorry.
Oh please. What I'm saying is that I don't think someone should have the right to sue a person or business just because they aren't accessible to whatever disability they have. If I owned a business I would certainly try to make it as accessible as possible but there are always limitations.

Some things just have to be regulated. You remove government intervention from construction entirely and see how long it takes our country to turn into a delapedated shithole of a death trap.
And again, why are you jumping from the ADA to safety regulations? Where did I say that there should be no regulation whatsoever? I do question the need to regulate things like the types of doorknobs a business can use (What? Is it degrading to open the door for a disabled person?) but its not as big a deal to me as the other issues created by the ADA.
 
Accessibility =! safety. We have building codes to keep buildings from collapsing or burning down.

The first statement is correct. The second is not. Building codes regulate far more than 'safety' alone. This in part is what I do for a living. I can walk 5ft from my desk right now, grab a codes book and give you a rediculously long list of regulations that have nothing to do with 'safety'. Most of which aren't even related to 'handicapped' people. A couple of those I already touched on in my previous post. Unless you just really want me to, I'll spare you the boredome.

Oh please. What I'm saying is that I don't think someone should have the right to sue a person or business just because they aren't accessible to whatever disability they have. If I owned a business I would certainly try to make it as accessible as possible but there are always limitations.

I don't disagree about people suing for things that are rediculous. However, I think I made it clear I was talking about the 'portions' of ada that are incorporated into the building codes. Not the ADA itself as a whole. The portions that are integrated into the codes are far from rediculous, for the most part not costly, and quite simple to execute.

And again, why are you jumping from the ADA to safety regulations? Where did I say that there should be no regulation whatsoever? I do question the need to regulate things like the types of doorknobs a business can use (What? Is it degrading to open the door for a disabled person?) but its not as big a deal to me as the other issues created by the ADA.

Because, as I'm trying to explain to you, the scope of the building codes is not limited to safety alone.....far from it. Yes, ADA itself and the building codes are not the same thing. But the accessibility standards that are adopted by the codes is what I've been talking about all along. If you read the article and look at what the complaints are about, most of them are direct violations of the building codes.
 
Not sure if you're 'lmao' at what i said to him, or at my saying it is the governments job. If it's the latter, well, you don't have to agree with it, but that just the way it is, sorry.




Lack of maintenance. Doesn't have anything to do with building codes.

Though, you also have to remember too that the codes are constantly revised and changing every 4 years or so. The codes that were enforced when that bridge was built are likely far less stringent that what's on the books today.

I was laughing at they way you got your point across...lol...

My point with the bridge is that it was a government structure with government funding for repairs and maintenence, or lack there of, which led to collaps, and the fact that the codes were less stringent is the governments fault...
 
Back
Top