Apple’s MobileMe is a MobileFail

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Want more proof of Apple’s bungling of the MobileMe launch? How about this status report at Apple’s website? Wow, some of these numbers are really ugly.

We particularly regret to report the loss in the affected accounts of approximately 10% of the messages received between July 16 and July 18.
 
Haha, at this rate they'll be giving away subscription extensions for the rest of the year. :p
 
Devices for the end-user might be going well, but you've got to have the backbone to keep the stuff running...

On two different occasions (Probably a year apart), when I visited Apple.com for whatever reason, they had servers down. One was on the forums and another was on some general sales page.
 
Apple fail at semi-enterprise type stuff? Who woulda thunk it.

:p

There is a reason Apple is not used in the major corporations of the world, it can look good and amaze small user groups, but is a huge let down in hardcore IT worlds.
 
The day we launched MobileMe, we had a lot more traffic to our servers than we anticipated,

IMO this is a lame excuse from any company. Especially for a company who wants to make you think (and currently, is) outselling everything out there, and is the "hot item"... Keep up with the stinking demand. They know how many devices are rolling out the door- keep up with it.


I remember the Xbox Live issues around Christmas time... No excuse for it at all.
 
At least we got a free game when XBL was down....and we didnt lose anything like important emails, many people/companies cannot deal with lost emails...it is truly lost profits and bad for business.
 
IMO this is a lame excuse from any company. Especially for a company who wants to make you think (and currently, is) outselling everything out there, and is the "hot item"... Keep up with the stinking demand. They know how many devices are rolling out the door- keep up with it.

Apple's big problem is that they aren't expanding as quickly as they should given how thinly they are spreading themselves out with new projects these days. It was fine keeping everything lean and nimble back when it was just computers, operating systems, and simple things like mp3 players, but things are different now. The fact that they pushed back the release of OS 10.5 by several months in order to get the iPhone out the door says it all. Sure, Microsoft had Longhorn development delayed by years due to the resources they had to divert to fixing security in XP, but you're not going to hear me saying anything good about that either. Apple needs to expand to keep up with the additional projects they are taking on, period.

I remember the Xbox Live issues around Christmas time... No excuse for it at all.

Ugh, that was brutal... Then again, I remember what an absolute clusterfuck Steam was for the entire first year it was out, and now it is one of my favorite pieces of software. :)
 
At least we got a free game when XBL was down....and we didnt lose anything like important emails, many people/companies cannot deal with lost emails...it is truly lost profits and bad for business.

True. Which leads me to think: Does Apple think their machines "just work" so well, they don't do any sort of backup or redundancy?
Microsoft, if they ever have any issues (rarely... Xbox Live was the biggest issue they've had in a while), bounces back... It's just inconvenienced time.


I'd just hope Apple compensates everyone in some form though.
 
Apple needs to expand to keep up with the additional projects they are taking on, period.

QFT, couldn't agree more.

As OS X becomes a bigger target, you'll have more security issues to deal with. Even if you disagree with "security through obscurity", if not just for the simple fact that more people are using it and more people will be finding issues. Either expand or fail. Seems to me they are suffering in the Mac avenue.... iPhone and iPod are doing quite well, obviously (well, save for this MobileMe thing- but issues like this always expected).
 
and, to top it all off, the install mobil me with the newest version of itunes.. without telling you.. i get done with a fresh install of vista, grab itunes.. and go looking around... run acrossed mobilme in my control panels wtf.. i dont remember installing this... go and look in add/remove software and there is no uninstall WTF i got a fucking trogen somehow on a clean install of vista... ohh no.. thats just apple forcing software on people again *--safari--* from what i understand is that the only use for it is if you have an iphone... so what; every one that uses itunes must have an iphone??? whats so hard with asking in the installer: do you have an iphone? if so check here X.... i had to do a google search to figure out WTF it was to begin with, and a different search to figure out how to uninstall it.

/pissed

/rant off
 
Seems to me they are suffering in the Mac avenue.... iPhone and iPod are doing quite well, obviously (well, save for this MobileMe thing- but issues like this always expected).

Based on their quarterly financial filings for the last two years, the Mac has been the biggest driver of profits and growth for Apple. That and the iPhone are the main reasons for its run in stock price. The iPod has stagnated in comparison for the last two years (that market is nearly saturated, just how much bigger can it get?). The iPhone is currently picking up the slack for the iPod.

I'd just hope Apple compensates everyone in some form though.

Apple has already offered two 30 day extensions for MobileMe users. For people using the 30 day trial, this brings the number of free days to 120 before they have to decide to pay for a subscription.
 
and, to top it all off, the install mobil me with the newest version of itunes..
Just like Safari...

I don't care what company it is- this is a bad thing to do. One of the characteristics of malware is installing shit you didn't ask for.

Based on their quarterly financial filings for the last two years, the Mac has been the biggest driver of profits and growth for Apple. That and the iPhone are the main reasons for its run in stock price. The iPod has stagnated in comparison for the last two years (that market is nearly saturated, just how much bigger can it get?). The iPhone is currently picking up the slack for the iPod.

It didn't used to be that way, iPod used to be selling well. I didn't know it had already saturated the market ;)
That said- isn't a good thing. To turn that around and have the Mac be the #1 selling item, is not a good thing... It's basically like the #2 item becoming #1, because the #1 item saturated the market. Not really a success.

I have no idea what their longterm goals are, but I'd more willingly bet on iPhone than the Mac. Release some other versions of iPhone. Figure out some way to get a slide-out QWERTY keyboard without adding thickness. Improve on it... Will sell very well IMO.
Mac... I just don't see them ever becoming a leader in this market. Their support (backend devices) just isn't there. Third-party support just isn't there. They'd have to compete with Microsoft to ever make a go at it, and to be honest, I think they're pretty damned scared to do that.
 
So, the logo looks just like Windows ME, and it's about the same quality as it too. Good to know.
 
It didn't used to be that way, iPod used to be selling well. I didn't know it had already saturated the market ;)
That said- isn't a good thing. To turn that around and have the Mac be the #1 selling item, is not a good thing... It's basically like the #2 item becoming #1, because the #1 item saturated the market. Not really a success.

I have no idea what their longterm goals are, but I'd more willingly bet on iPhone than the Mac. Release some other versions of iPhone. Figure out some way to get a slide-out QWERTY keyboard without adding thickness. Improve on it... Will sell very well IMO.
Mac... I just don't see them ever becoming a leader in this market. Their support (backend devices) just isn't there. Third-party support just isn't there. They'd have to compete with Microsoft to ever make a go at it, and to be honest, I think they're pretty damned scared to do that.

The iPod is still selling well. You need to remember that growth is one of the main measures of a businesses success and increasing stock price (since the stock market valuation factors in future earnings and growth). Year over year growth in iPod sales slowed because everyone and their grandmother owns one. It doesn't mean that sales are poor, they are as good as ever, but you aren't seen the 30%+ year over year increase in sales like the old days.

What you say is a "bad thing", having the #2 item become the #1 item, that is exactly the opposite of reality in the business world. You want product lines that leapfrog each other in growth. As a company you don't want to rely on a single product line with a narrow economic moat, you want multiple products that can leapfrog each other when one product line inevitably slows down. Investors underestimated Apple last year, then they come out with quarterly numbers showing sustained explosive growth in Mac sales. That continued to send their stock price moving up. Lord knows that there were analysts that were making the same case you were, that Apple is an "iPod company" that doesn't have much else driving their bottom line. Surprise! It isn't that they are selling less iPods, it is that they are selling way more computers, how is this a bad thing?

The iPhone is the third leg that will expand growth when it flags in one of their other areas. You want a diversified portfolio of strong products. If Apple only had the iPod they wouldn't be in nearly a strong a position as they are now.

Hope this helps you understand things a bit better.

As far as their computer sales go, they are competing very well against other PC builders these days. The goal isn't to crush Microsoft in the number of OSX machines out in the wild versus Windows machines, one because it isn't possible, and two because Apple sells computers, not standalone operating systems. Their real competition are companies like Dell, Acer, and HP, and in that realm they are only actively pushing in the consumer, educational, and professional media arenas. They don't need to sell more Macs than copies of Windows licenses to succeed, they only need to keep growing their chunk of the desktop/notebook market against other PC companies. This is showing no signs of slowing down, let alone topping out anytime soon.
 
Just like Safari...

I don't care what company it is- this is a bad thing to do. One of the characteristics of malware is installing shit you didn't ask for.

exactly

I have no idea what their longterm goals are, but I'd more willingly bet on iPhone than the Mac. Release some other versions of iPhone. Figure out some way to get a slide-out QWERTY keyboard without adding thickness. Improve on it...

add sone thickness... and give it longer battery life and a HDD.....

"we have this great mobil platform... but we have decided to cripple it buy only giving you 8/16gb of storage..."

corsair has 32gb usb sticks out, what is stopping them from 'stacking chips' to get more storage on the device? 4 32gb chips wont add up to that much more room if they are all desgined from the get go to be on the same substrate, and for the price of the iphone, as it is now, 130~gb is alot more like it.
 
You want product lines that leapfrog each other in growth.
But here is where that argument fails: iPod stopped growing. You yourself said that.

Apple sells computers, not standalone operating systems. Their real competition are companies like Dell, Acer, and HP
Exactly true...
However, huge price differences. If you argue Apples are "comparibly" priced, it's just folly.
Copy of XP: $90. 3 SPs: $0.
Copy of OS X: $130. 3 SPs: $390
Ain't just the hardware.

ESPECIALLY on basic machines (which is what the majority of the public uses), the cost of OS X itself (hardware aside) is getting up there to the same cost of a complete Dell/HP machine!

add sone thickness... and give it longer battery life and a HDD.....

"we have this great mobil platform... but we have decided to cripple it buy only giving you 8/16gb of storage..."
More battery? Yes.
HDD? No. HDDs add heat, crash, add thickness.

I personally think 8GB of Storage is fine, for me anyway. Unless you use it as an MP3 Player (which is what I've got my Zune for), 8GB should fit plenty of apps on it.
 
But here is where that argument fails: iPod stopped growing. You yourself said that.

First off I said that iPod growth slowed (~12% year over year at this point as opposed to the monstrous YoY growth from 2003-2006), but more importantly, did you just ignore the part where I said that growth in their other product lines is making up for slowed growth in iPod sales? That's the whole point I was making, that a company wants a diverse portfolio of products that leapfrog expected cycles of growing and slowing growth among each other.

iPod growth slows but Mac growth increases, plus they just created another leg of their business with smartphones. One product line leapfrogs the other. How does this argument fail? At some point in the future, Mac sales will reach a saturation point, growth will slow, and something else will have to step up to drive growth in the company to support the PE ratio of the stock (presumably handsets). This argument is finally backed up by Apple's massive market cap on Wall Street.

These aren't difficult concepts to grasp.
 
These aren't difficult concepts to grasp.

Neither is mine.

iPod slowed. Nowhere to really GROW to.
Mac is continuing to grow... Plenty of places to GROW to.

Therefore, Mac is the growth-center.

What's so difficult about that concept?
 
Exactly true...
However, huge price differences. If you argue Apples are "comparibly" priced, it's just folly.
Copy of XP: $90. 3 SPs: $0.
Copy of OS X: $130. 3 SPs: $390
Ain't just the hardware.

ESPECIALLY on basic machines (which is what the majority of the public uses), the cost of OS X itself (hardware aside) is getting up there to the same cost of a complete Dell/HP machine!

Again with this ridiculous argument.

Repeat after me: the move from OS 10.3 to OS 10.4 was a bigger leap than the move from XP to Vista, period. I've personally made that upgrade with both operating systems and to argue that the OS X versions amount to service packs is absolutely ridiculous. Every release rolls in more features than any upgrade in a MS operating system I've made. I wouldn't dare call the move from XP to Vista a service pack and I'm not going to do the same with OS X either.

If you want to argue hardware, yes, under $1000 you're not getting good options with the mini, but the Macbook, iMacs, and Mac Pros (still spec for spec the cheapest multicore Xeons workstations on the market) are extremely price competitive.
 
Neither is mine.

iPod slowed. Nowhere to really GROW to.
Mac is continuing to grow... Plenty of places to GROW to.

Therefore, Mac is the growth-center.

What's so difficult about that concept?

Ok, so we're on the same page. Apple has product lines that leapfrog growth with each other, that's the point I was making. How exactly is this "defeating" the argument I was making since it is exactly what I was saying in the first place?
 
Your argument is based on growth... iPod hasn't seen any real growth... Mac has CONTINUED.

So, at least in my world, a product that is growing, usually grows more than a product that isn't.
 
My argument is based on the fact that Apple has multiple product lines that pick up the slack when another one slows. The result is still overall positive net growth in their bottom line. Apple continues to make more net profit with each successive quarter despite the fact that growth is slowing (not stopping) with some of their product lines.

How is this "not really a success"?
 
We particularly regret to report the loss in the affected accounts of approximately 10% of the messages received between July 16 and July 18.

Something to keep in mind is that 10% only affected 1% of their userbase. I'm not saying that the rollout of mm hasn't been a disaster so far, but it's not that they lost 10% of *all* messages, just 10% of 1% of their userbase during those ~3 days.
 
add sone thickness... and give it longer battery life and a HDD.....
Yes to battery life, no to depth and a hard disk. Even the battery life...I don't know. I watched "Lost in Translation" in H.264 the other night on my fully-charged 3G and by the time it was over, the battery indicator hadn't even gone down. Yeah, the onscreen indicator only shows maybe 10 or 15 increments, but hey...

...for the price of the iphone, as it is now, 130~gb is alot more like it.
And you're absolutely insane :)

I personally think 8GB of Storage is fine, for me anyway. Unless you use it as an MP3 Player (which is what I've got my Zune for), 8GB should fit plenty of apps on it.
No doubt. None of the apps on mine have used more than a hundred or so kilobytes.

And, much to my happiness, my iPhone is now my primary MP3 player. I just did the math, and for the bitrate I use for portable playback (Nero AAC VBR, average 140kbps), I can fit a smidge over 240 hours of music on the 14.8 or so GB remaining on my iPhone, or about ten and a half days of music. Ten days of music. What the hell do people do with those 160GB iPod Classics I have no idea.
 
Again with this ridiculous argument.

Repeat after me: the move from OS 10.3 to OS 10.4 was a bigger leap than the move from XP to Vista, period. I've personally made that upgrade with both operating systems and to argue that the OS X versions amount to service packs is absolutely ridiculous. Every release rolls in more features than any upgrade in a MS operating system I've made. I wouldn't dare call the move from XP to Vista a service pack and I'm not going to do the same with OS X either....

what?
Your first sentence was so ridiculous it almost made my head explode. Allow me to explain why:
When dealing with software versioning schemes, the major number is increased when there are significant jumps in functionality, the minor number is incremented when only minor features or significant fixes have been added, and the revision number is incremented when minor bugs are fixed.

Time for you to repeat: Vista is a completely different operating system than XP, it was built from the ground up. OS 10.3 and 10.4 are different builds OF THE SAME OPERATING SYSTEM (that being Mac OS X.)

Calling it a service pack is not correct. But neither is calling it a completely different OS.
 
Calling it a service pack is not correct. But neither is calling it a completely different OS.

I wasn't arguing that OS 10.3 to 10.4 was a new operating system. The point of my post was that the number of significant new features that were rolled out in that just that one particular upgrade were at least as much as the jump from XP to Vista. It wasn't a completely new OS like you said (although the same can be argued for Vista considering how much of it uses the same OS architecture and paradigms that XP/2000 does, nor was the kernel built from the ground up as was the initial plan with Longhorn development), but calling it a service pack is crazy.

But I'll go with your argument: not an entirely new OS but more than a service pack. That seems a bit irrelevant to me anyway; most operating systems don't regularly go through major ground up overhauls anyway. Windows doesn't, most *nix flavors don't, and OS X certainly doesn't after dumping that POS Mac OS almost ten years ago.
 
I wasn't arguing that OS 10.3 to 10.4 was a new operating system. The point of my post was that the number of significant new features that were rolled out in that just that one particular upgrade were at least as much as the jump from XP to Vista. It wasn't a completely new OS like you said (although the same can be argued for Vista considering how much of it uses the same OS architecture and paradigms that XP/2000 does, nor was the kernel built from the ground up as was the initial plan with Longhorn development), but calling it a service pack is crazy.

But I'll go with your argument: not an entirely new OS but more than a service pack. That seems a bit irrelevant to me anyway; most operating systems don't regularly go through major ground up overhauls anyway. Windows doesn't, most *nix flavors don't, and OS X certainly doesn't after dumping that POS Mac OS almost ten years ago.

No way, visually Vista and XP might be close, but Vista was built on a completely different codebase (Windows Server 2003, I think). They're two different Operating Systems.

The problem is that we're still trying to compare apples to oranges instead of laughing at TechieSooner for the dumb post that spawned this debate over semantics.
Serpico, let us laugh (or facepalm) together at TechieSooner's flawed arguement :D;)

Exactly true...
However, huge price differences. If you argue Apples are "comparibly" priced, it's just folly.
Copy of XP: $90. 3 SPs: $0.
Copy of OS X: $130. 3 SPs: $390
Ain't just the hardware...
Apples to oranges my friend, apples to oranges :p
 
Back
Top