Apple More Profitable Than Microsoft

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
The numbers are in for Q3 and even though Microsoft beat the analysts’ expectations, Apple surpassed Microsoft in quarterly earnings. The King is dead: Long live the King.

The monolithic Microsoft put it in cruise control while it counted the revenue from Windows and Office while the scrappy Apple quietly reinvented the music player, mobile phone and tablet computer.
 
I wonder if it has anything to do with their markup...

They have put out a lot of new products lately though. Interesting.
 
Thats because there are more stupid people than smart ones.
Half the kids in my high school want a Mac because "Its a Mac". :rolleyes:
Ipods are decent, but honestly nothing special only good part is jail breaking ipod touches but thats about it.
 
Considering Apple is a hardware maker, where as Microsoft is a software maker, Apple to oranges comparison.

Why it is they never compare Apple to dell, hp, and other companies that actually do what apple does?
 
Considering Apple is a hardware maker, where as Microsoft is a software maker, Apple to oranges comparison.

Why it is they never compare Apple to dell, hp, and other companies that actually do what apple does?

Because then there wouldn't be articles like this to write...
 
Valve is probably more profitable than both of them... thats a long stretch that article is making...
 
Both companies make both hardware and software.

Microsoft does not make computers, tablets or phones. Also, MS makes the great bulk of its software sales to OEM's and enterprise users where margins are much thinner. Apple makes the vast bulk of its sales in the retail channel with very fat margins...which is why Apple can have a higher total profit on far fewer sales. So no, it really isn't a valid comparison.
 
Apple, EVGA, COD and Gustin Bieber overtakes MS, [H], BF and Raul Di Blasio. what’s next?!
 
Microsoft does not make computers, tablets or phones. Also, MS makes the great bulk of its software sales to OEM's and enterprise users where margins are much thinner. Apple makes the vast bulk of its sales in the retail channel with very fat margins...which is why Apple can have a higher total profit on far fewer sales. So no, it really isn't a valid comparison.

But they do hardware, xbox.:eek:
 
Considering Apple is a hardware maker, where as Microsoft is a software maker, Apple to oranges comparison.

Why it is they never compare Apple to dell, hp, and other companies that actually do what apple does?
Apple should be compared to the Church of Scientology. Their core business is not to sell hardware, but to create and exploit mindless fanboys.
 
Microsoft does not make computers, tablets or phones.
And Apple doesn't make webcams, game consoles, game console accessories or USB joypads. If I had to make a guess, I would venture to suggest that Microsoft offers as many individual hardware products as Apple does. So what is your point?
 
Microsoft does not make computers, tablets or phones. Also, MS makes the great bulk of its software sales to OEM's and enterprise users where margins are much thinner. Apple makes the vast bulk of its sales in the retail channel with very fat margins...which is why Apple can have a higher total profit on far fewer sales. So no, it really isn't a valid comparison.

The thin margins are the OEMs' concerns, not Microsoft's. :p Beyond development and distribution costs, software revenue is pretty much profit.
 
And Apple doesn't make webcams, game consoles, game console accessories or USB joypads. If I had to make a guess, I would venture to suggest that Microsoft offers as many individual hardware products as Apple does. So what is your point?

At this point my point would seem to be that you are incapable of gracefully admitting that you're engaging in a stretch at best or that you're just wrong at worst.

You're talking about niche products and trying to make a comparison that just isn't there. MS is primarily a software company. Apple is primarily a hardware and media company. One has thin margins. One has consumers convinced that paying more makes them "cool."
 
And despite the fact this is Microsoft's most profitable quarter yet in company history...their stock took a dive.

Seriously, what the fuck? I could live to 500 years old and I'll never understand the workings of the stock exchange.
 
At this point my point would seem to be that you are incapable of gracefully admitting that you're engaging in a stretch at best or that you're just wrong at worst.
What is it, specifically, that I am wrong about? Does Microsoft not make the hardware products I mentioned? Is Microsoft not both a hardware and software company?

You're talking about niche products and trying to make a comparison that just isn't there.
I wasn't aware the Xbox 360 was a niche product. But, yes, Microsoft certainly does have some niche products. As does Apple. Apple's currently more profitable than Microsoft, however, because they appear to focus on developing products that are in high demand by consumers (and for various others reasons) whereas Microsoft's focus is on products that should have very high margins but, due to their business model, is not.

MS is primarily a software company. Apple is primarily a hardware and media company.
Microsoft and Apple have somewhat different business models with different products targeted toward different consumer demographics. There is, however, significant overlap, and both companies compete directly with each other in various markets. Therefore I see absolutely no compelling reason why net income figures cannot in any way be compared between the two companies solely because each has a somewhat different business model. Is there really a more appropriate company Apple should be compared to if not Microsoft?
 
Thats because there are more stupid people than smart ones.
Half the kids in my high school want a Mac because "Its a Mac". :rolleyes:
Ipods are decent, but honestly nothing special only good part is jail breaking ipod touches but thats about it.

indeed many of them want Mac or ipod or ipad because it's apple made not because they've use for it.

i never had iphone, and never will, ipod touch, yep i've them cause i've use for them, ipad freaking who wants to carry that big thing around, now on long trip it'll be ok to use, but not on vacation cause i'll be enjoying myself, the two month i visited india this January and February, i didn't use PC for single day and i was happy with it having too much fun with friends back home.

i like smart phones no problem, but don't have use for it, just to use the GPS i'm not gonna pay $90 in monthly bill, i'll stick with my $40 talk plan.
 
People like my girlfriend make this possible... I have showed her tech specs vs price for PCs and apples... Apples ridiculous markup because it has an apple logo on it... but none of that matters. If it has an apple logo on it. She wants it.
 
Maybe Macbooks are a status symbol for people or something, like expensive hand bags and jewelry. Atleast a Mac is more useful. Personally I'm all for Apple doing great, gives MS a reason to improve their products. They might still be selling that godawful mobile OS 6.5 if Apple didn't release the iphone.
 
How's that whole console thing working out for you now,MS? Maybe if you hadn't abandoned PC gamers (and encouraged developers to do the same) your bottom line would have been bigger.
 
People like my girlfriend make this possible... I have showed her tech specs vs price for PCs and apples... Apples ridiculous markup because it has an apple logo on it... but none of that matters. If it has an apple logo on it. She wants it.
It's fashion.
People like to buy $300 clothes/handbags/etc. though they cost $5 to make in China.
 
It's fashion.
People like to buy $300 clothes/handbags/etc. though they cost $5 to make in China.

I just watched a documentary called The Corporation, which was recommended on here in the Apple has four different badges thread. A t-shirt priced at $14.99 awarded the workers who made it $0.03. A Liz Claiborne jacket which goes for $178 afforded its impoverished manufacturers $0.74. An Alpine car stereo, cost $0.31. Clothing manufactured by Wal Mart pledges to donate money to different non-profit organizations while the people who made them can't eat three meals a day. :(
 
MS's stock hasn't done diddly in about 10 years.

I so wish Bill Gates would make at least a temporary comeback, get rid of Ballmer, and get that company firing on all cylinders again.

Give Apple credit where it's due even if you don't like HOW they do it: They're kicking ass.
 
MS's stock hasn't done diddly in about 10 years.

I so wish Bill Gates would make at least a temporary comeback, get rid of Ballmer, and get that company firing on all cylinders again.

Give Apple credit where it's due even if you don't like HOW they do it: They're kicking ass.

But do the ends justify the means?
 
Apple made 5.99 billion profit on 24.67 billion in revenue. Microsoft made 5.23 billion in profit on 16.43 billion in revenue. Apple made more money but Microsoft's margin is still a good bit better.
 
But they do hardware, xbox.:eek:

The Xbox devision in fact about a year or two ago finally generated a profit. So even considering that end of the business its tiny fraction of what there software business generates. I believe the Xbox is the only hardware business they are currently into , they just discontinued the Zune hardware a month or so ago.

MS is a primarily software driven business , Apple focuses much more on hardware. If Apple suddenly switched entirely over to a software business they would be far under MS in terms of a profit margin.

Apple is trendy now and will probably stay that way ..until Jobs either finally quits or dies. Apple without jobs (if you take into account past history) always ends up at the shit end. However competition is good and MS needs a strong opponent otherwise they get complacent and fuck over its customers more frequently. So I'm all for Apple doing well. And MS fanboy should be as well since without Apple doing well we probably wouldn't have Windows 7.
 
As for the future Microsoft's challenges are the cloud, the effect of phones and tablets on traditional form factor PCs and how well Windows Phone and Windows 8 does, especially on

I think Apple's biggest challenge will be margins. I think that the days of the base model $500 iPad will be limited as more ARM devices get out there and with Windows 8 running on ARM.

I think Microsoft's growth prospects are a bit better than Apple's over the next 5 years. Windows Phone is projected to over take the iPhone in sales in 4 years and Microsoft won't be in the media tablet business until next year in earnest with Windows 8 ARM. Plus there's opporunitues with the cloud, Kinnect coming to Windows an so forth.

Neither company is in any trouble, they'll both make many billions of dollars a year for the rest of my life at least. I do see Microsoft getting significantly more aggressive beyond traditional PCs as they have known for years that they would need to do but only now seem to be actually doing it. In terms of revenue I see Apple being well ahead but profitability being much closer with Apple making more profit in general but with Microsoft having bigger years when they release new products like Windows 8 but also taking a hit with the new Xbox.
 
And Apple doesn't make webcams, game consoles, game console accessories or USB joypads. If I had to make a guess, I would venture to suggest that Microsoft offers as many individual hardware products as Apple does. So what is your point?

Microsoft doesn't really make any money on its direct hardware sales and Apple on it's direct software sales that's the biggest difference between Apple and Microsoft. The Xbox and subsided by software sales and doesn't stand on it's own as a hardware offering.
 
Back
Top