Apple Is Not THAT Valuable

Wow, only 1 fanboy post so far?

Where is everyone? Some huge piece of the internet take a shit this morning or what?

;)

What's the point? I have better things to do than argue with you Apple haters. I would have more productive results arguing with a brick wall.
 
What's the point? I have better things to do than argue with you Apple haters. I would have more productive results arguing with a brick wall.

No, we just recognize that Apple is an overhype bullshit company. You're at a PC enthusiast forum where we play with toys that's a generation ahead of the "magical" crap that Apple releases every year.
 
I don't know who pulls the strings around [H] but they need to sort that out. You're right in that it's been increasing in frequency and fervour over the last couple of years.

[H] needs to stick to what it's respected for and throttle back on the unprofessional stuff. It might just be one person with a pathological grudge against Apple but it reflects badly on the entire website and drags the other excellent contributors down, imho.

I tried sending Steve a PM with regards to this exact concern a couple of months back, but it is pretty obvious from his response, he could care less.
 
No, we just recognize that Apple is an overhype bullshit company. You're at a PC enthusiast forum where we play with toys that's a generation ahead of the "magical" crap that Apple releases every year.

You are exactly correct. I am at a PC enthusiast website, so why the hell do I have to wade through the anti-apple news stories that seem to be more abundant on this site than actual PC articles?
 
You are exactly correct. I am at a PC enthusiast website, so why the hell do I have to wade through the anti-apple news stories that seem to be more abundant on this site than actual PC articles?

So go play at the Apple Enthusiast forums where you can brag with others that you plonked down a couple grand for a generation old computer.
 
So go play at the Apple Enthusiast forums where you can brag with others that you plonked down a couple grand for a generation old computer.

Sorry, I have a Digital Storm PC, so I plunked down a couple grand for a state of the art computer. I have never owned an Apple MAC, guess you shouldn't go making assumptions - it doesn't work out so well for you.
 
If Apple disappeared over night, it would hardly have a huge impact on the world as we know it. If a company like Intel, IBM, Cisco, GE, etc. disappeared over night, it would make a HUGE impact.

So who's more valuable?

Your confusing value with importance.

Apple is more valuable.
Cisco is more important.
 
Your confusing value with importance.

Apple is more valuable.
Cisco is more important.

One could argue those two things are one in the same however. If something is important, does that not make it valuable?

I never meant to imply that Apple isn't a hugely successful company, and by pure dollar figure they ARE the most "valuable" company out there. I just don't think it's fair to go throwing out the title of "Most Valuable" without at least an asterix.
 
[H] needs to stick to what it's respected for and throttle back on the unprofessional stuff. It might just be one person with a pathological grudge against Apple but it reflects badly on the entire website and drags the other excellent contributors down, imho.

Thank you for your input.

What exactly is unprofessional about this article. I said it would piss off the Apple faithful and here you are.

The facts are...

There are 15 Apple related stories in the news today already.

4 deal with what the iPhone 5 might look like.
4 are iPhone 5 rumor round-ups
3 are most wanted iPhone 5 features
1 is an Apple patent application for a fingerprint-less screen
1 is a guess how many iPhones will ship this year
1 Cinemax App Approved by Apple
1 THIS STORY.

Being that we are a PC site (not an Apple fan site) we post the technology news that appeals to our readers (you know...the 99.95% of our readers that aren't Mac users). We cater to the majority of our readers and it seems to have worked remarkably well for well over a decade.

Last week we posted the story about Apple having more cash than the government and so on. THIS STORY is the opposite side of the coin and something that is obviously of interest to our readers and related to the original story.

We LOVE our readers that use Apple products. Sure we kick Apple in the nuts when they deserve it but name a company we haven't kicked in the nuts when they messed up. Calling us bias / anti-Apple because you don't like the story only bolsters/reinforces the opinion people have of fanatical Apple users.
 
One could argue those two things are one in the same however. If something is important, does that not make it valuable?

No, it doesn't, as they are two different things. One implies economic worth, the other implies significant worldly consequence. Apple is more valuable based on PE ratios, etc. Cisco is more important in terms of worldly impact.

val·u·a·ble
adjective
1.having considerable monetary worth; costing or bringing a high price: a valuable painting; a valuable crop.

im·por·tant
adjective
1.of much or great significance or consequence: an important event in world history.


I just don't think it's fair to go throwing out the title of "Most Valuable" without at least an asterix.

There doesn't need to be an asterisk. By definition of value, they *are* the most valuable company if the calculations are indeed correct. It's not open to interpretation.
 
One could argue those two things are one in the same however. If something is important, does that not make it valuable?

I would say the most profitable, rather than most valuable. Value is subjective; yes we can go by the market price, but again that is based on profits. If Apple went away overnight, the world would keep on going with barely a hitch. If Intel went away, it would be a catastrophe.

By the same token, some Wall St douche who repackaged subprime CDO's into CDO's cubed to make them some kind of AAA rated wonderbond probably was more valuable in terms of profits (at the time, at least) but I would say a teacher is more important.
 
Sorry, I have a Digital Storm PC, so I plunked down a couple grand for a state of the art computer. I have never owned an Apple MAC, guess you shouldn't go making assumptions - it doesn't work out so well for you.

No idea who Digital Storm is but okay.
 
i hate apple (the company) and even i realize [H] loves bashing them, possibly even unfairly. :)
 
i hate apple (the company) and even i realize [H] loves bashing them, possibly even unfairly. :)

I disagree.

In fact, the only case I've really seen where an idiot bashed a company is that fool Charlie and how he bashed Nvidia.
 
idk, people seem dumb enough to keep all their gimmicky crap super popular for a while, at least until the economy completely tanks and they cant afford all this crap they dont need
 
No, it doesn't, as they are two different things. One implies economic worth, the other implies significant worldly consequence. Apple is more valuable based on PE ratios, etc. Cisco is more important in terms of worldly impact.

val·u·a·ble
adjective
1.having considerable monetary worth; costing or bringing a high price: a valuable painting; a valuable crop.

im·por·tant
adjective
1.of much or great significance or consequence: an important event in world history.

You forgot the rest of the definitions
val·u·a·ble   [val-yoo-uh-buhl, -yuh-buhl] Show IPA
adjective
1.
having considerable monetary worth; costing or bringing a high price: a valuable painting; a valuable crop.
2.
having qualities worthy of respect, admiration, or esteem: a valuable friend.
3.
of considerable use, service, or importance: valuable information.
4.
Usually, valuables. articles of considerable value, as of personal property, especially those of relatively small size: They locked their valuables in the hotel safe.

"Value" is subjective. While in some cases the word may strictly mean monetary worth, the author of the article clearly expressed that "importance" is part of what he feels is valuable.
 
idk, people seem dumb enough to keep all their gimmicky crap super popular for a while, at least until the economy completely tanks and they cant afford all this crap they dont need

I always find comments like this amusing. I used to get mad at Steve years ago for all the apple bashing, but it doesn't matter at all to me anymore. I can't argue that a lot of Apple fan boys like apple at all costs and tend to be arrogant smug little pricks. I see follies in Apple with regards to a closed ecosystem, but I also see lots of innovation and cool products. Always good and bad, just like any other company.

Apple fan boys remember that when you're on top you'll be hated, but come to a pc based site and you'll be hated either way. Just learn to live with it and don't take it personally even when they call you an idiot. If you do, then they've got you. :p I'm just glad I'm not dumb enough to stick with only 1 platform and I have windows, linux and os x and all used for different things and I'm proficient and enjoy all of them.
 
No idea who Digital Storm is but okay.

Really? And you are calling me out on not being a PC enthuist? If you had read any PC Magazine from the last 4 years, you would know. PC Gamer?, Maximum PC?? PC World??? because their systems are quite often reviewed in those mags - always with high marks, and they always advertise there.

And of course, before you tell me real enthusiasts build their own PC's, yes, I have built several, and after the last one which caused me to pull my hair out over a USB Over-voltage issue that would prevent booting, I decided to let someone else do it this time.
 
Really? And you are calling me out on not being a PC enthuist? If you had read any PC Magazine from the last 4 years, you would know. PC Gamer?, Maximum PC?? PC World??? because their systems are quite often reviewed in those mags - always with high marks, and they always advertise there.

And of course, before you tell me real enthusiasts build their own PC's, yes, I have built several, and after the last one which caused me to pull my hair out over a USB Over-voltage issue that would prevent booting, I decided to let someone else do it this time.

I build my own computers, thank you very much.
 
You forgot the rest of the definitions

.....

"Value" is subjective. While in some cases the word may strictly mean monetary worth, the author of the article clearly expressed that "importance" is part of what he feels is valuable.

First, I didn't forget any definitions. I listed the ones pertinent to the scope of the stock market, which is all about monetary value. The stock market doesn't give two craps about worldly importance (outside of the prospectus on future earnings) and what would happen if that company mysteriously vanished overnight (because it's not going to happen).

Second, the "author" of the article is a god damned moron for not understanding the scope of the usage of the phrase "most valuable" as applied to stocks. You don't get to pick and choose importance of PE ratios, etc. willy-nilly.

Look , if my height is 5'6" and your height is 5'8", I can't claim to be taller because I'm in better physical shape than you. 5'8" is always taller than 5'6". It's not open to discussion, it's a fucking fact. You being taller doesn't mean you are healthier than I am, it means exactly what the application of the word says, that you are taller than me, nothing more, nothing less.

The way company values are calculated, by the definition of "value" used on Wall St., Apple IS the most valuable company. It's not up for debate. It's a mathematical calculation of earnings, debs, assets, etc. This doesn't mean that you necessarily want to buy their stock, or that the world couldn't do without them. It just means that withing the narrow scope of value as defined by Wall St. that they are the most valuable.
 
First, I didn't forget any definitions. I listed the ones pertinent to the scope of the stock market, which is all about monetary value. The stock market doesn't give two craps about worldly importance (outside of the prospectus on future earnings) and what would happen if that company mysteriously vanished overnight (because it's not going to happen).

Second, the "author" of the article is a god damned moron for not understanding the scope of the usage of the phrase "most valuable" as applied to stocks. You don't get to pick and choose importance of PE ratios, etc. willy-nilly.

Look , if my height is 5'6" and your height is 5'8", I can't claim to be taller because I'm in better physical shape than you. 5'8" is always taller than 5'6". It's not open to discussion, it's a fucking fact. You being taller doesn't mean you are healthier than I am, it means exactly what the application of the word says, that you are taller than me, nothing more, nothing less.

The way company values are calculated, by the definition of "value" used on Wall St., Apple IS the most valuable company. It's not up for debate. It's a mathematical calculation of earnings, debs, assets, etc. This doesn't mean that you necessarily want to buy their stock, or that the world couldn't do without them. It just means that withing the narrow scope of value as defined by Wall St. that they are the most valuable.


Yes, it is up for debate which is precisely why the market changes daily, people short stocks, etc. It was only a week ago the Dow swung 500+ points up and down 4 days in a row. Then take a look at the financial crisis, Enron, etc. To say that the stock market is the end-all-be-all of value is short sighted, and a perception that causes a lot of problems in our society, IMO.
 
Yes, it is up for debate which is precisely why the market changes daily, people short stocks, etc. It was only a week ago the Dow swung 500+ points up and down 4 days in a row. Then take a look at the financial crisis, Enron, etc. To say that the stock market is the end-all-be-all of value is short sighted, and a perception that causes a lot of problems in our society, IMO.

This doesn't mean the formulas for calculating value are up for debate. What you are seeing is the fact that the inputs are dynamic and subject to change.

In the narrow scope of value as defined by WS, Apple is the most valuable company at this time. Period.
 
This doesn't mean the formulas for calculating value are up for debate. What you are seeing is the fact that the inputs are dynamic and subject to change.

In the narrow scope of value as defined by WS, Apple is the most valuable company at this time. Period.

Sure it does. For example, over time acceptable P/E ratios and other such measures have changed, and people have argued for both sides whether it makes sense. You have actors taking multiple sides of bets at all times based on very different formulas for calculating value.

I guess we'll have to agree to disagree. I think you're actually agreeing with me though by needing to state, "As defined by Wall St." Their subjective definition by no means has to be the only one.
 
I guess we'll have to agree to disagree. I think you're actually agreeing with me though by needing to state, "As defined by Wall St." Their subjective definition by no means has to be the only one.

The thing is the author of the article is disputing the value (as defined by Wall St.) of Apple. In order to say they aren't, they have to hold everyone to those same standards (Wall St. definition of value. The author essentially makes up his own standards of value. You can't mix standards (his and Wall St.) and come up with a valid comparison.

In the scope of Wall St. standards, Apples is the most valuable. Period. Do I necessarily feel that Wall St.'s standards are always correct? No. However, this is a subject for another debate, and does not belong in an article titled, "Apple Is Not THAT Valuable". It's as if the author is writing down a recipe for "Chocolate Cake" and titling the index card "Blueberry Pie".

If the author wanted to make his point properly, he should have questioned how Wall St. comes up with their values, not single out a particular company and hold different ones to different standards, and placed it in an appropriately named article. I question the article author's journalistic integrity by failing to title the article properly, and failing to hold consistent standards as defined by Wall St. when discussion value as determined by Wall St.
 
Really? And you are calling me out on not being a PC enthuist? If you had read any PC Magazine from the last 4 years, you would know. PC Gamer?, Maximum PC?? PC World??? because their systems are quite often reviewed in those mags - always with high marks, and they always advertise there.

And of course, before you tell me real enthusiasts build their own PC's, yes, I have built several, and after the last one which caused me to pull my hair out over a USB Over-voltage issue that would prevent booting, I decided to let someone else do it this time.

You bought your PC from some review's and an advertisement inside a tabloid? I gave up reading that trash years ago when I realized it those magazines were just that, trash.
 
...<snip>...

If this arm-chair CEO (whoops, he prefers "consultant") has such insight into how Apple's future value will compare to other companies, he should short AAPL and buy whoever will go up.

How do you know he hasn't already done just that? :) Personally, I don't care what some pundits say about the "value" of Apple at any one point in time. I'll never buy their stock. And if you don't like it that's Fine by me! :cool:
 
To be on topic (why do I always forget you cant edit in the news section???) depending on the definition you use, is going to determine whether Apple is or is not the most valuable company. I happen to agree with the article because I have seen first hand how ignorant most (not all) Apple owners are. My wife's brother swears up and down that his macbook pro has a graphics card has the most powerful graphics card in the world, much better then any graphics card available for PC's.
 
And of course, before you tell me real enthusiasts build their own PC's, yes, I have built several, and after the last one which caused me to pull my hair out over a USB Over-voltage issue that would prevent booting, I decided to let someone else do it this time.

Enthusiasts build their own PC's.... correctly.
 
http://arstechnica.com/apple/guides/2011/08/does-this-metric-make-my-company-look-big.ars

Since knowledge and intelligence seems to be in short supply around here.
That was an interesting article.

It compares a range of metrics to gauge whether a company has cash flow, capital, debt, revenue, how many people it employs, and compares companies according to those criteria.

Basically oil is always in the top regardless of what you're measuring.
Apple is slugging it out with Exxon for top place on the important factors--depending on whether you prioritize cash on hand to spend (apple) or physical stuff capable of generating income (Exxon).

Apple's method of calculating it's wealth are subject to scrutiny because it differs from other corporations. Usually they don't include long-range investments as Apple does. However, Apple's long term investments aren't ordinary. They invest in rock solid treasury bonds. The differences within their investment portfolio are due to maturation rates rathe than hi/low risk ventures, like other companies use.


There's my synopsis of the article.
I doubt Boomstick read it.

I, too, echo the annoyance of these types of "news" items. I guess Steve wanted to poke someone but I can't take his response seriously because in order to post it he had to gloss over two pages of forum members directly insulting other forum members. Tossing chum out into the forum lacking even rudimentary moderation of those kinds of comments is where the concerns of unprofessionalism stem from, not whether posting things this article is unprofessional in and of itself.
 
That was an interesting article.

It compares a range of metrics to gauge whether a company has cash flow, capital, debt, revenue, how many people it employs, and compares companies according to those criteria.

Basically oil is always in the top regardless of what you're measuring.
Apple is slugging it out with Exxon for top place on the important factors--depending on whether you prioritize cash on hand to spend (apple) or physical stuff capable of generating income (Exxon).

Apple's method of calculating it's wealth are subject to scrutiny because it differs from other corporations. Usually they don't include long-range investments as Apple does. However, Apple's long term investments aren't ordinary. They invest in rock solid treasury bonds. The differences within their investment portfolio are due to maturation rates rathe than hi/low risk ventures, like other companies use.


There's my synopsis of the article.
I doubt Boomstick read it.

I, too, echo the annoyance of these types of "news" items. I guess Steve wanted to poke someone but I can't take his response seriously because in order to post it he had to gloss over two pages of forum members directly insulting other forum members. Tossing chum out into the forum lacking even rudimentary moderation of those kinds of comments is where the concerns of unprofessionalism stem from, not whether posting things this article is unprofessional in and of itself.

:rolleyes:

I made $2000 in half a day with HTS last week. How did you do?
 
Apple is worth a lot more than this article gives them credit for. Sure they could crash and burn but I really doubt the creative genius of the company is all one man.
 
My wife's brother swears up and down that his macbook pro has a graphics card has the most powerful graphics card in the world, much better then any graphics card available for PC's.

LMAOs Apple can suck my freshly shaved balls.
 
I understand where this guy is going, but let's be honest here. Value itself is incredibly subjective.

The channel sellers and consultant networks that Cisco and IBM have? They have a pretty hefty education and federal sales/partners division, not to mention their 30 year lockdown on the creative and visual arts industries. While the "novelty customers only" argument may make up the bulk of their recent sales, it is worth pointing out that it's not their only revenue stream.

I am in wholehearted agreement that the company is based on a single person right now, and that its stock price literally rises and falls with the color of the Jobs' complexion at any given moment. The company doesn't pose any global systemic risk like a Walmart or Exxon might, and the features of its products are readily found other places and more highly developed. The posters on this forum are right to point these out.

There is a strong argument to be made against Apple's present valuation. Unfortunately, this guy resorted to warrants that are easily undermined by another side of the argument.

Don't worry, the rest of us know it's not bashing, it's just factual new reporting.

I'm going to go out on a limb here and assume "new"="news." I'm not sure that this article is factual, news, or reporting. It's an eristic op-ed piece, like the vast majority of "news" people seem to be reliant on.
 
Ok, that was actually funny. It was a defective motherboard though - so it would help if ASUS built their motherboards correctly.

Damn Asus with their shitty, low quality products. I can't believe anybody supports that tiny little company to begin with.
 
If Apple disappeared over night, it would hardly have a huge impact on the world as we know it. If a company like Intel, IBM, Cisco, GE, etc. disappeared over night, it would make a HUGE impact.

So who's more valuable?
People aren't thinking in this thread. If ALL of those companies went belly up, the only people immediately affected would be those in the middle of an implementation.

How many people on here are employed by companies still running XP and Office 2003, or better yet, just installed Windows 7 and Office 2010? You think they couldn't survive a few months if Microsoft disappeared? How long did the banks run on old Cobol software and US Robotics hardware? You don't think there are other services companies whose sole business is supporting all of these implementations? You think I care if Dell goes under after using this four-year old laptop that my own GIS department doesn't even support anymore?

You think Verizon wouldn't pick up the slack if AT&T fell? Delta for United? SAP for Oracle Applications?

You think Apple is less important than Starbucks, McDonald's, Coca Cola, and Las Vegas Sands?

Unbeleebabble.
 
Back
Top