Apple Has Started Tracking iPhone Users Again

Let's say I work closely with Law enforcement, I know because I have seen it.

Might be similar to google? The first time i turned on my Nexus, i had to login with my email. And then all my apps, contacts, and configuration data got downloaded into it before i even put in the sim card. This tells me Google does keep an image of your phone on their servers. Does Apple have the same database on theirs?
 
Settings > General > About > Advertising > Limit Ads

That's all it takes...though hiding it in About is pretty tricky.
 
Might be similar to google? The first time i turned on my Nexus, i had to login with my email. And then all my apps, contacts, and configuration data got downloaded into it before i even put in the sim card. This tells me Google does keep an image of your phone on their servers. Does Apple have the same database on theirs?

It's pretty similar. It really is an open secret. They have blobs and images that they check against their baseband and carrier database. Not really news if you follow the jailbreaking community. Smartphones are great if you have a job/reason to use them. Personally, I try to take any opportunity to be disconnected and be take time for myself without the distractions of the world intruding. If I really need the internet I always have my ultrabook with me.
 
Doesn't Apple have to track users now so it can figure out if they got lost using their new maps program? It'd totally be a liability thing if they didn't do something to find lost people.
 
Doesn't Apple have to track users now so it can figure out if they got lost using their new maps program? It'd totally be a liability thing if they didn't do something to find lost people.

You've been so quiet lately ... I thought you didn't arrange your cat's blanket just right and he smacked you into tomorrow ;)
 
You've been so quiet lately ... I thought you didn't arrange your cat's blanket just right and he smacked you into tomorrow ;)

I've been hiding all sneaky-like so the zombies don't eat my brains. Then I figured out that I'd been looking at the wrong month on the calendar and it wasn't December yet so I crawled out from under my bed and started posting stuff again. :)
 
I've been hiding all sneaky-like so the zombies don't eat my brains. Then I figured out that I'd been looking at the wrong month on the calendar and it wasn't December yet so I crawled out from under my bed and started posting stuff again. :)

Zombies don't come out til April. Everyone knows that.
 
Zombies don't come out til April. Everyone knows that.

Oh, so it must be the Tamagotchi Robot Mayan Kitteh Lawyer Apocalypse that happens in December. I keep getting my end of the world events mixed up.
 
If rights aren't given, they cannot be taken away by a corporation.

Way to misconstrue what I said. I phrased that statement as I did for a reason. We have rights as natural human beings, I am of the view that a freedom to privacy is a natural right. Our very existence as sentient, conscious, beings gives us the right to keep secrets in the mind, this right should extend onto our possession and actions. A right not given by the government but by what we exist as. Privileges are given, rights are always there whether they are noticed, appreciated, protected, or downtrodden.
 
Way to misconstrue what I said. I phrased that statement as I did for a reason. We have rights as natural human beings, I am of the view that a freedom to privacy is a natural right. Our very existence as sentient, conscious, beings gives us the right to keep secrets in the mind, this right should extend onto our possession and actions. A right not given by the government but by what we exist as. Privileges are given, rights are always there whether they are noticed, appreciated, protected, or downtrodden.

I think everyone should have a right to privacy within their own homes. It gets trickier when you go into public spaces. The internet is especially tricky. We have a technology that was developed and funded by governments and corporate interests. However, we then want to criticize them when they try and recover value from that or monetize that. If someone wants to forego technology then privacy is definitely possible. I think the question is do people have a right to technology AND privacy ... I think those are mutually exclusive most of the time so you have to choose which you want more ;)
 
And to add I do not think they should not be allowed to track people, but they should offer it as a completely optional choice, absolutely no right to tracking without being authorized by the individual to do so, with the right to opt out at anytime and have all data deleted.
 
Way to misconstrue what I said. I phrased that statement as I did for a reason. We have rights as natural human beings, I am of the view that a freedom to privacy is a natural right. Our very existence as sentient, conscious, beings gives us the right to keep secrets in the mind, this right should extend onto our possession and actions. A right not given by the government but by what we exist as. Privileges are given, rights are always there whether they are noticed, appreciated, protected, or downtrodden.

Close, but, no cigar.

The two generally recognized natural rights are the right to person and the right to own property in external resources. The first right, the right to person, says that an individual has the sole right to exercise control over their own body provided that they respect other people's rights. Under the first right, for example, prohibitions on drugs, sexual acts, and euthanasia/suicide when done consensually are immoral because that entails that the state or the aggressor owns your body in some way (which is slavery). The first right, the right to person, derives from the fact that we inhabit our own bodies and thus are uniquely and best qualified to make decisions regarding it.

The second right is the right to derive property in external resources, either through homesteading or through contractual acquisition. If I take an unowned piece of land and homestead it, that is, if I invest work in it to make it my own, then I have a right to it because I was there first and I invested the work in to it. Legitimate property rights must derive from either homesteading or through acquisition that can be traced back to the original homesteader.

The only way that any of these rights may be morally infringed upon is in response to an act of aggression. If someone, for example, murders someone, they have committed an act of aggression against that person's body and, as such, lose their right to control their body. Any crime must derive from an aggression against either person or property.

Privacy is a tricky subject. Your mind, as part of your body, is your own. No one may force you to reveal anything as that would be immoral. Your physical possessions, such as your computer hard disk, are your own. One cannot, however, own an idea, such as the contents of your data, because ideas are not scarce goods, in that, they may be freely copied without deriving the original person of possession of them.

In the case of Apple, you are transmitting your data to their servers. Their servers are their property and, barring some kind of contractual agreement to the contrary, they can do with the data you send them what they please without violating your natural rights. If Apple choses to voluntarily cooperate with the state, that is their prerogative even if you and I may disagree with it. A rights violation would only occur if the state subpoenaed that information as subpoenas are an inherent act of aggression against an unrelated third party who has done nothing to warrant such and that violation would be against Apple and not you.

You were not required to purchase a device that sends your data to Apple. You were not required to send your data to Apple. What they are doing is immoral but it does not justify using aggression against them. We can fight this not through coercion or laws, but through protesting, boycotts, and peaceful means of protest.
 
Close, but, no cigar.

The two generally recognized natural rights are the right to person and the right to own property in external resources. The first right, the right to person, says that an individual has the sole right to exercise control over their own body provided that they respect other people's rights. Under the first right, for example, prohibitions on drugs, sexual acts, and euthanasia/suicide when done consensually are immoral because that entails that the state or the aggressor owns your body in some way (which is slavery). The first right, the right to person, derives from the fact that we inhabit our own bodies and thus are uniquely and best qualified to make decisions regarding it.

The second right is the right to derive property in external resources, either through homesteading or through contractual acquisition. If I take an unowned piece of land and homestead it, that is, if I invest work in it to make it my own, then I have a right to it because I was there first and I invested the work in to it. Legitimate property rights must derive from either homesteading or through acquisition that can be traced back to the original homesteader.

The only way that any of these rights may be morally infringed upon is in response to an act of aggression. If someone, for example, murders someone, they have committed an act of aggression against that person's body and, as such, lose their right to control their body. Any crime must derive from an aggression against either person or property.

Privacy is a tricky subject. Your mind, as part of your body, is your own. No one may force you to reveal anything as that would be immoral. Your physical possessions, such as your computer hard disk, are your own. One cannot, however, own an idea, such as the contents of your data, because ideas are not scarce goods, in that, they may be freely copied without deriving the original person of possession of them.

In the case of Apple, you are transmitting your data to their servers. Their servers are their property and, barring some kind of contractual agreement to the contrary, they can do with the data you send them what they please without violating your natural rights. If Apple choses to voluntarily cooperate with the state, that is their prerogative even if you and I may disagree with it. A rights violation would only occur if the state subpoenaed that information as subpoenas are an inherent act of aggression against an unrelated third party who has done nothing to warrant such and that violation would be against Apple and not you.

You were not required to purchase a device that sends your data to Apple. You were not required to send your data to Apple. What they are doing is immoral but it does not justify using aggression against them. We can fight this not through coercion or laws, but through protesting, boycotts, and peaceful means of protest.

I believe what I said is exactly what you say will work. Is this not a way to get people to think about the matter in a new point of view, one that changes their view and makes them motivated to go out and protest, boycott, etc...? Again you are focusing on the legal definition of right and what we are currently told are our rights. I'm advocating for the addition of a new right, a right to greater privacy than we are afforded now.
 
If it is opt out, why is it that big of a deal? It's obviously a pain in the ass to those who are less inclined to want ads, but I doubt even most users would have a problem with it.
 
Might be similar to google? The first time i turned on my Nexus, i had to login with my email. And then all my apps, contacts, and configuration data got downloaded into it before i even put in the sim card. This tells me Google does keep an image of your phone on their servers. Does Apple have the same database on theirs?

Not all they keep is your list of apps(only if you check the box backup phone to google) and a small amount of settings ( only if same thing as above is checked). It will only restore these settings if you also check restore phone from google when setting it up.
 
Not all they keep is your list of apps(only if you check the box backup phone to google) and a small amount of settings ( only if same thing as above is checked). It will only restore these settings if you also check restore phone from google when setting it up.

I meant no. not "not"
 
Not all they keep is your list of apps(only if you check the box backup phone to google) and a small amount of settings ( only if same thing as above is checked). It will only restore these settings if you also check restore phone from google when setting it up.

Yeah, it's optional, and also quite handy. My previous phone was a different model and it still got transferred so it's not an exact 'image' in the same term as we would a harddrive or DVD. But they are capable of knowing everything on your phone. Heck even if you don't tick that checkbox, google play still knows which apps are currently installed in any phone. As for the contacts, any contact on your phone is copied to your gmail contact list. Point is, as we've experienced they can have a very detailed image of what's on your device. Your email, and even your messenger service (YM or whatever) has to go through their servers so their apps don't have to keep running in the background to receive them.

And as someone else confirmed, it's done on apples side too, but more covertly. And people are so much in denial that they claim the odds of that being true is the same as a unicorn sprouting out of the ground and getting f***ed in the *ss.
 
And as someone else confirmed, it's done on apples side too, but more covertly. And people are so much in denial that they claim the odds of that being true is the same as a unicorn sprouting out of the ground and getting f***ed in the *ss.

Why does it have to be a unicorn and what's with all this violent intercourse? :(
 
Tracking a phone is far worse than tracking a pc. Thats why. Phones have gps and are carried just about everywhere you go.

All iOS apps and website that can collect GPS location from you bring up a prompt requesting this information. You can just say no. This isn't complicated.
 
All iOS apps and website that can collect GPS location from you bring up a prompt requesting this information. You can just say no. This isn't complicated.

The prompt is just a courtesy best practices recommendation. It is not required. Re: Path.
 
Actually, no its not (as of ios6)

They finally fixed that, eh? About damn time. Note that this is not necessarily an apple problem, google marketplace has been known to host some sketchy apps with far reaching code manifest. It's not gps that is the problem either it's pretty simple to write an app that requests and sends your contacts, web history, what apps you have installed and the like... all you have to do is wrap it in a "free" game that you make available for download. I don't think anyone will argue that apple (or the google for that matter) doesn't exactly have the greatest record in going over every bit of code in order to certify it for the app store. Just sayin :)
 
They finally fixed that, eh? About damn time. Note that this is not necessarily an apple problem, google marketplace has been known to host some sketchy apps with far reaching code manifest. It's not gps that is the problem either it's pretty simple to write an app that requests and sends your contacts, web history, what apps you have installed and the like... all you have to do is wrap it in a "free" game that you make available for download. I don't think anyone will argue that apple (or the google for that matter) doesn't exactly have the greatest record in going over every bit of code in order to certify it for the app store. Just sayin :)

I've seen a lot of ridiculously sketchy apps in the google market (or "play store"). The difference with the play store is that you get told up front what your app is going to use as far as system resources go, not sure how this works in the app store.
 
I've seen a lot of ridiculously sketchy apps in the google market (or "play store"). The difference with the play store is that you get told up front what your app is going to use as far as system resources go, not sure how this works in the app store.

The store doesn't tell you what it needs access to, the OS does. So the first time you launch an application, it will ask you if the application has your consent to access various system features. If at some point, you change your mind, you can turn said features off (or on) as you wish. Same as when it would ask for permission to grant access to location services, but more robust.

ios-6-privacy.jpg
 
Back
Top