Apple Gives Thief A Replacement Phone

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
This has to be the customer service story of the day. Your phone is stolen and the store won't help you at all. In the mean time, the crook that stole your phone gets a replacement in a matter of minutes. :eek:

Apple's policy of not intervening in the theft of their products from customers is costing them a wad of cash, after store employees in Toronto handed over a new iPhone to a thief.
 
That is a sticky situation, I'm not sure AT&T or Big Red would do any different.
 
So they proclaim "no involement" but still give out phones to anyone who brings one in?

True genius indeed. In the grand scheme of things I'm not too sad to see apple get ripped out of a 500 dollar phone.

Soapbox: we could have taken a huge bite out of crime had the cops caught this person, reclaimed the property and then taken the thief right hand. As punishment. It worked very very well in the old days you know.
 
lol at cutting peoples hands off for stealing, I can't even believe how often I am hearing/reading that now.
 
Why would the employee just give the guy a new phone. Dont you have to go through that whole warranty process?
 
Why would the employee just give the guy a new phone. Dont you have to go through that whole warranty process?

Yeah I am confused too. Wouldnt they have to verify he is the one who bought the phone? Or do they just hand new phones out to anyone? Must be the first company ive heard of that does not require a receipt or proof of purchase.
 
That is a sticky situation, I'm not sure AT&T or Big Red would do any different.

Having dealt with AT&T customer service in the past, I guarantee absolutely nothing would be done "in a matter of minutes"...Days? Unlikely. Weeks? Perhaps. Months? 50/50.
 
Once a more then couple of years ago , I had a phone stolen. I had Alltel , I went in to have the phone shut of. It took talking to a manager and a threat to call someone higher up to get the Phone shut off and a new phone which I had to pay for. Before leaving I ask 'What if the thief was to try to reactivate the phone or trade it in for another?" The manager response was that they would reactivate the "NEW CUSTOMER" phone. :eek:

So Apples response is no surprise..
 
Yeah I am confused too. Wouldnt they have to verify he is the one who bought the phone? Or do they just hand new phones out to anyone? Must be the first company ive heard of that does not require a receipt or proof of purchase.

It's been a very long time since I've been in an Apple store, but six or seven years ago they required no proof of purchase. You could simply bring in your busted iPod and they would give you a new one. That was all there was to it.
 
How can they have a policy of "not being involved?" If someone tells you that something is stolen goods and has proof and you go ahead and deal with those goods anyway, how is that not abetting theft?
 
How can they have a policy of "not being involved?" If someone tells you that something is stolen goods and has proof and you go ahead and deal with those goods anyway, how is that not abetting theft?

All they had was someone calling in to say that their phone was stolen and someone made an appointment to have it fixed. The police didn't get involved until after the exchange took place. The owner's not law enforcement, or anyone they can just take their word for. Imagine this thread if they refused to look at a phone because the guy's friend called in and jokingly told Apple that it was stolen.
 
It's been a very long time since I've been in an Apple store, but six or seven years ago they required no proof of purchase. You could simply bring in your busted iPod and they would give you a new one. That was all there was to it.

That's because you pay for five up front with their outrageous pricing on most things.

What I love about Apple is the hypocrisy. When one of their phones went missing, it was a national emergency and practically a federal crime in their eyes, yet when a customers goes missing it's simply "we don't want to get involved". How about when the next prototype goes missing (conveniently), law enforcement uses that same excuse?
 
That is a sticky situation, I'm not sure AT&T or Big Red would do any different.

At&t won't give out replacements in stores, you have to call their center prove identity and they'll ship you one on their dime. But you'll have to prove ownership, or at least know ssn and other information of owner.
 
If this is true it is pathetic and I will tell you why. One of the biggest arguements the phone companies made for getting rid of sim cards and locking phones was to deter theft. Yet they do not even do a basic check to see if the right person has a phone to deter theft.
 
So obviously this dude that got the new phone should be traceable by that phone. Why don't they just use the GPS to go get him?
 
An unconditional guarantee used to be considered good business. Why would Apple require proof of purchase for a product that only they manufacture? The only answer would be to assist law enforcement, and I for one am glad when private companies don't play cop.

The police investigating the matter are free to get video footage of the person exchanging the phone from Apple, and any other information they need to link that person to the actual crime such as identifying information for the replacement phone.
 
haha i know some dude that found a ran over iphone and got it replaced i guess you can make everyone happy. he just took it straight it and got a new one.
 
This is a strange system, here you need a proof that you bough it (invoice, warranty papers to the device etc) and in case you bought it from operator you usually need even your ID card (or signed letter from original owner) to prove that you are the owner of the phone.
 
This is not a wrench, you dont need a serial number or anything. Apple already has all your info which I am sure you were required to give before you could even turn on the phone. Customer service is the goal and they did not service their customer you know the one who actually paid for the device.
 
i wann buy a free app gift card for the thief and use stolen CC for it :D i guess i know where i'll be moving in future.
 
An unconditional guarantee used to be considered good business. Why would Apple require proof of purchase for a product that only they manufacture? The only answer would be to assist law enforcement, and I for one am glad when private companies don't play cop.

Except when Apple shows up to your house to do warrantless searches or kick your door in to find a missing prototype.

Seems they DO play cop...but only if the phone belongs to them.

:D
 
So obviously this dude that got the new phone should be traceable by that phone. Why don't they just use the GPS to go get him?

Apple doesnt have the ability to just track anyone they want.




oh wait.........
 
Dang, I can't believe you could just go into store like that and get a replacement without showing any sort of ID.
 
Back
Top