Apple Faces iTunes Test Case In Norway

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Norway's top consumer advocate is taking Apple to court to try to force the company to open iTunes to all music players. This ought to be interesting, I am not familiar with the laws in Norway but if they are successful, you can bet other countries will follow suit.

Norway is leading a European campaign that began two years ago to get Apple to make its iTunes online store compatible with rivals' digital music players. "We discussed this at a meeting two weeks ago, and decided that Norway will do the test case," Consumer Ombudsman Bjoern Erik Thon said by telephone. "This could have international consequences."
 
You know, I'm not a big Apple fan... but seriously, this is their product. They should be allowed to do what they want with their products/services.

What is up with Europe lately and these lawsuits? I don't think I would be shocked if companies stop to offer their business to these nations.
 
You know, I'm not a big Apple fan... but seriously, this is their product. They should be allowed to do what they want with their products/services.

What is up with Europe lately and these lawsuits? I don't think I would be shocked if companies stop to offer their business to these nations.

Agreed.
Buy an iPod, you dicks.
(I also am not an apple worshiper, but apple invented the thing; if they don't like it.......take a hike, losers.)
 
As others have said and how I have always said, its apple's shit. They can do what they want with it. Whats next... people firing off lawsuits because FCP can't run in windows?

I will also say that ever sines EU somehow got MS by the balls they have been going after everyone they can. Sounds like the crusades all over again.
 
and yet again ignorance from Americans...

two things for you yanks to read
1) http://www.boingboing.net/2008/09/26/walmart-shutting-dow.html
after reading that and seeing that a DRM shop closing down AND/OR changing the scheme renders what you paid for is BAD!!!
If itunes becomes the "standard", a "standard" that other shops can sell via (without an apple tax) and other apps can hook upto it then it reduces the risk of one small player pulling out (that or just fucking drop DRM!!! it only hurts the innocent

2)
EC antitrust rules? blame the US...

Us companies like Microsoft, Intel, Qualcomm and Rambus may moan about EC
investigation into their business practices, but they only have the US to blame
for then EC antitrust rules

The EC drew heavily on America's 1890 Sherman Act, which encapsulated US
competition law, when it drew up Artical 81 of the Treaty to establish the
European Community which was signed in 1957
"The influence of US antitrust law was profound during the early years of the
development of competition policy in Europe" according to Mario Monti, a former
Competition Commissioner at the EC. "Today, after 50 years of application and
development of antitrust rules in Europe, we share the same goals, and pursue
the same results, on both sides of the Atlantic."

Back in 1890, the Americans were seemingly, very keen to stamp out
anti-competitive practices. "In the 1950s the Americans taught us antitrust, now
we're teaching them back." Kurt Biedenkopf, former Prime Minister of the German
State of Saxony and a distringuished practitioner of competition law, told me.
"If you form a quasi-monopoly or a duopoly in the US, it will influence the
European market, and we will not agree to a combination that will produce a
dominant position," said Biedenkopf.

In fact it is not the dominant position per se which is illegal under EU/US
competition law, but the means used to either create or to sustain a monopoly.
A monopoly achieved by sheer prowess is not illegal. But if other means then
merit are used to create or sustain a monopoly then it can be judged illegal.
As one of the authors of the Sherman Act, Senator George Hoar of
Masachussetts, said, a company which won the business bacause "nobody could do
it as well as he could" would not be in violation of the act


ElectronicsWeekly: 18-24 June 2008

That was copied from that engineering publication, go find it if you want to read the original (copied word for word)


ie
1) DRM is bad mmmkay
2) the EU anti-competitive laws are what the US laws were ment to be
 
...

ie
1) DRM is bad mmmkay
Agreed, but if you dont like it, dont buy it. Use your wallet, not the courts.

2) the EU anti-competitive laws are what the US laws were ment to be
This reeks of typical Euro arrogance, but the US laws were designed to protect against monoplies in critical industries, oil, coal, telegraph, things people really NEED, not luxury items like MP3's

Soldier on brave Euros, the unwashed masses need their itunes!!! Regulate! Socialize! Make a LAW!!!
 
so why was/is such US laws used against Microsoft? they are not a "critical industry" as you said yourself
 
anti-competitive laws are anti-competitive laws. You can't just pick and choose who they apply to

"It illegal to kill someone, but if you do it on a lunar eclipse while wearing a pink tutu its ok"

Oh please! laws apply to all!
 
Oh great, the european trolls have arrived.....
 
Why would anyone want to use iTunes. :confused: I'm glad my Archos just acts as an external hard drive and everything is drag and drop. Hell, even updating the firmware was dragging and dropping one file then hitting a button on the Archos.
 
so why was/is such US laws used against Microsoft? they are not a "critical industry" as you said yourself

really? business and government don't run off of computers? You guys over there use abacuses?
 
really? business and government don't run off of computers? You guys over there use abacuses?

Careful. The Chinese invented and own the abacus. The EU might sue them next.

Eeyjmr, if you don't like our products, make your own. We have our laws and you have yours. Don't presume that we have to follow yours.
 
Eeyjmr, if you don't like our products, make your own. We have our laws and you have yours. Don't presume that we have to follow yours.

but if a company operates within the Eurozone they must adhere to the EU laws (just like EU companies operating in the US must adhere to US laws, or do you expect special treatment cause you are the socialist USA?)

If they don't like it they have the option to pull out

Don't presume that we need these companies
 
Then make your own, then we won't have a reason to sell products to you, right?

Talk about biting the hands that feed you. You ungrateful pricks.
 
Then make your own, then we won't have a reason to sell products to you, right?

Talk about biting the hands that feed you. You ungrateful pricks.

why when

1) DRM is full of sooo much fail its rediculous
2) there are plenty of other companies out there that sell mp3/drm applications and don't have a problem

I suggest you have a look at creatives players and Microsofts players. Microsoft licence their DRM for other applications and stores to use. The EU doesn't have a problem with them do they? They have a problem when a company gets big and actively goes out of their way to stop people entering their market

if you fail to understand the way EU deals with competition then I suggest you don't bother posting in these threads. You clearly get over-excited and shoot your mouth off before understanding even the basics
 
why when

1) DRM is full of sooo much fail its rediculous
2) there are plenty of other companies out there that sell mp3/drm applications and don't have a problem

I suggest you have a look at creatives players and Microsofts players. Microsoft licence their DRM for other applications and stores to use. The EU doesn't have a problem with them do they? They have a problem when a company gets big and actively goes out of their way to stop people entering their market

if you fail to understand the way EU deals with competition then I suggest you don't bother posting in these threads. You clearly get over-excited and shoot your mouth off before understanding even the basics

pot meet kettle, wot?
 
standardise on either WMA or mp4 (or whatever itunes uses) and there wouldn't be an issue.
Having a proprietory/non-licensable format which means consumers are locked into a product is against EU law

ipod/itunes DRM ONLY works on ipods which means a person is either locked to using apple players (even if they want to change make) or have to burn and rip and lose quality ...
 
Why would anyone want to use iTunes.
Because I have to :)

iTunes isn't terrible, but it definitely needs to be overhauled on the Windows side, and Apple should absolutely open up the architecture so more file formats can be supported (such as FLAC). If they can do those two things, I'd probably be in the position of using it as my primary music player. As it stands, it's too damn slow and clunky.

I don't particularly miss drag-and-drop functionality, and the idea of having a singular, centralized media library conflicts with the idea of having drag-and-drop functionality. You can't really have your cake and eat it too here.
 
standardise on either WMA or mp4 (or whatever itunes uses) and there wouldn't be an issue.
So, you expect Apple to go from their proprietary copy protection system on an ISO-standardized audio format (AAC) to a proprietary copy protection system on a proprietary audio format (WMA)? Are you kidding?

And, just so you know, there is no standardized copy protection system available for the AAC format.

ipod/itunes DRM ONLY works on ipods which means a person is either locked to using apple players (even if they want to change make) or have to burn and rip and lose quality ...
They don't necessarily have to lose quality. If you burn a disc from iTunes and rip it securely to a lossless format, you lose zero quality. Obviously the trade off is that the file size will end up ballooning by a factor of 5 to 10.

What's amusing is that Steve Jobs regularly talks about the burn-and-rip method as a valid method of bypassing their own DRM system. iTunes users are never locked to FairPlay-locked music, so stop acting as if they are.
 
I can explain my country in few words: Strict, rich, nice, cold, warm, long, good internet, good services.

And also best country to be a consumer i think...


3 year warranty on almost everything, if you guys buy a 1 month warranty product, its sold with 3 years here, and i dunno how many times ive argued with some companies when i send directly to them.

anywayz, rules are to make it best for us consumers here, more open, iphone had to be able to get kind of Unlocked, solution to only one ISP for the iphone, was sell it with the shit, then pay a 300 bucks for unlocking it, and use any sim you like.
to mention it, i earn 30 bucks n hour, start payment in the post branch, so ima part time postman ;)

no company have managed to find sneaky ways on our rules.
 
Epic fail in word comprehension
Well sure sign you have lost any new debating material if you go all grammar nazi and personal as a means to make an arguement :rolleyes::rolleyes:
Good luck with your Public banks btw

If you dont need them, why so much angst?
This is a EU ruling that influences EU members, any ruling here will not effect how apple operate in the US so why so much "angst" from you

Every post you make is full of ignorance and hypocrisy.
as oppose to the ignorance by yankies on how the EU works or the hypocrisy that they expect EU countries to just bend over an accept thing the way Americans do things?
I think you need to look up what ignorance and hypocrisy mean and where to apply them, although you seem to be demonstrating them quite nicely






So, you expect Apple to go from their proprietary copy protection system on an ISO-standardized audio format (AAC) to a proprietary copy protection system on a proprietary audio format (WMA)? Are you kidding?

And, just so you know, there is no standardized copy protection system available for the AAC format.
I don't care whether apple allows WMA in or allows others to use AAC, as long as something happens.
A wtf does "ISO" got todo with anything
for starters Microsoft has already ruined their credibility and their relevance, to standardise on something doesn't mean an ISO standard has to exist (although one may appear out of what is commonly accepted). Look at the *.doc fileformat, that is the defacto fileformat for editable documents BUT it isn't an ISO standard

They don't necessarily have to lose quality. If you burn a disc from iTunes and rip it securely to a lossless format, you lose zero quality. Obviously the trade off is that the file size will end up ballooning by a factor of 5 to 10.
true, but joe-average would have todo that. Concidering my mom struggles with excel I doubt she would comprehend how/why such a step would be needed
 
This is a EU ruling that influences EU members, any ruling here will not effect how apple operate in the US so why so much "angst" from you

It's funny that you are European and keep talking as this regards the EU but fail to realize that the EU does not include Norway.... It's expected to adopt EU membership in the future due to it's involvement with the EEA but isn't right now a part of the EU.
 
Well sure sign you have lost any new debating material if you go all grammar nazi and personal as a means to make an arguement :rolleyes::rolleyes:
grammar nazi? No. you called the US Socialist. Coming from an Euro, thats quite hilarious. EPIC FAIL.

Good luck with your Public banks btw
How is that relevant, or is that just an unrelated attack based out of hate? Ill go with option B.!
Oh by the way, heres an interesting article about the EU buying out YOUR banks.
http://www.thestreet.com/story/10439684/1/fortis-gets-164-billion-rescue.html
(more pot meet kettle fun for the EuroTroll)
Enjoy!

This is a EU ruling that influences EU members, any ruling here will not effect how apple operate in the US so why so much "angst" from you
Im not uptight, you are. I think its funny! You guys would make laws against bad weather if you could find someone to levie taxes against.

as oppose to the ignorance by yankies on how the EU works or the hypocrisy that they expect EU countries to just bend over an accept thing the way Americans do things?
I think you need to look up what ignorance and hypocrisy mean and where to apply them, although you seem to be demonstrating them quite nicely
How am I ignorant? In what precise way have I made an incorrect statement? What incorrect facts?

You are the ones that are arrogant, but you cant see past your own hatred and prejudice.
The truth is, I really don't care what you guys do. It's your country/countries. If I was Apple, id just pull out and tell you guys to f*ck yourselves.
 
ahhh good point
BUT it has swallowed a load of EU laws, and as you said is part of the EEA
 
as oppose to the ignorance by yankies on how the EU works or the hypocrisy that they expect EU countries to just bend over an accept thing the way Americans do things?
You know, you've been using "yank" and "Yankee" derogatorily from the get-go. Knock it off.

A wtf does "ISO" got todo with anything
Standards. It has to do with standards. (are we not on the same page here?)

Look at the *.doc fileformat, that is the defacto fileformat for editable documents
Defacto? Debatable. Standard? No.

true, but joe-average would have todo that.
How is this Apple's problem?
 
So the US gov'n hasn't nationalised some US banks then? do you even watch the news
:D:D:D:D:D

Do you even know what nationalised means?
Theres a difference between nationalising and buying out the debt, just like the savings and loans scandals of the 80's.

Seriously, you're a troll. GO back to your ignorance cave, goodbye.
 
So the US gov'n hasn't nationalised some US banks then? do you even watch the news
The bailouts were necessary due to a lack of operating regulations imposed on independent institutions (institutions were allowed to spiral out of control). If you're going to make the "US is socialist" argument, odds are this isn't the platform you should do it with ;)
 
As others have said and how I have always said, its apple's shit. They can do what they want with it. Whats next... people firing off lawsuits because FCP can't run in windows?

I will also say that ever sines EU somehow got MS by the balls they have been going after everyone they can. Sounds like the crusades all over again.

It seems only fair that if an antitrust rule applies to one (Microsoft), it should apply to others (Apple.)

Bitch and moan all you want about the situation, but when it comes to monopolic practices, Apple is by far worse than Microsoft has ever been. Their market share isn't an excuse.

You CAN buy computers without Windows. You CAN install Windows on any x86 computer you wish.

You CANNOT buy a Macintosh without MacOSX. You CANNOT install MacOSX on any computer you choose without the threat of Apple's impotent EULA.

Apple is anti competitive, point blank.

Lest we forget that Apple refuses to license FairPlay to other music retailers and even sued Real for reverse engineering their music store format to work on iPods.
 
Apple are marketing an online store and a media player. They are then preventing competing media players from using their online store. That is the very essence of anti-competitive behaviour. What they are doing with OSX and their Mac hardware is anti-competitive to the same degree. As said above, Apple's disregard for or misunderstanding of the law is staggering.
 
The bailouts were necessary due to a lack of operating regulations imposed on independent institutions (institutions were allowed to spiral out of control). If you're going to make the "US is socialist" argument, odds are this isn't the platform you should do it with ;)

uhh the Government buying private institutions is socialism. Pure and simple. It's a perfect platform to make that argument.
 
You know, I'm not a big Apple fan... but seriously, this is their product. They should be allowed to do what they want with their products/services.

What is up with Europe lately and these lawsuits? I don't think I would be shocked if companies stop to offer their business to these nations.


their product

MY music
 
Do you even know what nationalised means?
Theres a difference between nationalising and buying out the debt, just like the savings and loans scandals of the 80's.

Seriously, you're a troll. GO back to your ignorance cave, goodbye.

They're not just "buying the debt". Taking a stake in company such as 80% of AIG is purchasing the company. Nationalizing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are the same thing.
 
NORWAY IS NOT A MEMBER OF THE EUROPEAN UNION SINCE WE LOOSE MORE THAN WE GAIN! WAY MORE.

WE ARE PART OF SOMETHING CALLED EØS IN NORWAY.

we got many rules from EU, to make it easier to travel from country to country, have same standards for how the condition the car gotta be in to be road legal( eg, how much pattern on the tires that gotta be left, and security stuff mainly. and got checks now n then.

dont say its a EU thing, its a norwegian thing, anywayz, some rules are alike, but not directly on this.
 
It seems only fair that if an antitrust rule applies to one (Microsoft), it should apply to others (Apple.)

Bitch and moan all you want about the situation, but when it comes to monopolic practices, Apple is by far worse than Microsoft has ever been. Their market share isn't an excuse.

You CAN buy computers without Windows. You CAN install Windows on any x86 computer you wish.

You CANNOT buy a Macintosh without MacOSX. You CANNOT install MacOSX on any computer you choose without the threat of Apple's impotent EULA.

Apple is anti competitive, point blank.

Lest we forget that Apple refuses to license FairPlay to other music retailers and even sued Real for reverse engineering their music store format to work on iPods.

I agree with this and have been making that point for a while. If Microsoft only allowed sales of its' operating systems on its "own brand" of computer systems they would be making billions more.. and everyone would be screaming monopoly because it is. Apple is a monopoly in the same sense - just the fact that their user base isn't as large.
 
their product

MY music

Nein.

Their Product
Their Service
Their TOS
Not your Music
Your right to listen to the music

You don't own the music, you own the rights to listen to the music.


Now if you want to get all technical, you entered the itunes store with the agreeable TOS and services guidelines.

This is like you complaining because you own the sattelite and reciever from DirecTV so you should be able to use it to connect to Dish network because it's "your" reciever and sattelite dish (which you technically don't own either).

You agree to the services, you render to the services. If you don't like it, take your business elsewhere.

They're not just "buying the debt". Taking a stake in company such as 80% of AIG is purchasing the company. Nationalizing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are the same thing.

Actually, they are buying debt, but to secure the company and to secure the company from further drowning, they needed an 80% share. This share ensures that the government can manage the company and stop executives/board members from milking the company or steering it as their own ship. It also allows to toss out corrupt members of the company board to turn the company around.

The government did this as a saving the company tactic, it's required if you want to ensure that it's not a raw investment. Just as the past, the government will sell the company or it's assets to other companies when things start turning around... it's not gonna turn into some socialized system...
 
I'm going to be on the side of Europe this time.

Its an inferior service, because of the restrictions. Letting go of those restrictions will not only loosen the Apple monopoly on the store, but open up a new market for Apple to sell to, and provide an anti-incentive to piracy.

Do they realize that Europe is the stomping ground for music piracy and that players with more functionality than iPods are dominant there, and that the people who are asking them to open it are the ones *trying* to go legit?

I know how reclusive Apple likes to be, but really, its a win-win. For consumer and Apple.

My guess is that they see that their iPods are overpriced and dont want to provide a venue for market competition. Just like they dont let you make your own Macs and especially sell them. Chocking the enthusiast market for their products out of their own sheer greed.

All money spent by Europeans in the iTunes store goes directly to the US, unless there is a vat tax.

As for European companies competing with them, there isnt enough incentive. The Apple market in Europe is for the people that want to *try* to buy mp3s legit. Most of Europe probably still pirates.

Being a competitor to Apple and losing money in a market that doesnt believe in paying for something infinitely replicable, just to spite Apple, is not good enough incentive for Euro companies. On-top of that, the more traditional European areas a lot more likely to be attached to physical formats than mp3s. Its not an easy market.

I speak most knowingly of the Eastern European market. But its not that different elsewhere.
 
Back
Top