App Developer Takes On Patent Troll

Random things that occur to me, an obvious non-lawyer, after watching the videos:
  • If it's Google's system that is enabling the alleged infringement, the troll should be forced to sue Google rather than some random app developer who uses the service. That applies to all the cases where trolls pick and choose relatively vulnerable (i.e. not super rich) individuals while giving the big boys who are likely to put up a fight a pass.
  • If one of the claims of a patent is found to be invalid, the whole patent should automatically be invalidated. Is that seriously not how it works? WTF.
  • If the patent office is found to have wrongly approved a patent, they should bear some responsibility for people who are sued for infringement of that patent. I bet a lot fewer shitty patents would be awarded if that were the case.
I agree with 1 and 3. But 3... why would the patent granter care? It's a government job. If anything, it'll just be government ponying up tax money.

As for number 2, I believe, it's multiple patents that does basically the same thing.
 
Random things that occur to me, an obvious non-lawyer, after watching the videos:
  • If it's Google's system that is enabling the alleged infringement, the troll should be forced to sue Google rather than some random app developer who uses the service. That applies to all the cases where trolls pick and choose relatively vulnerable (i.e. not super rich) individuals while giving the big boys who are likely to put up a fight a pass.
  • If one of the claims of a patent is found to be invalid, the whole patent should automatically be invalidated. Is that seriously not how it works? WTF.
  • If the patent office is found to have wrongly approved a patent, they should bear some responsibility for people who are sued for infringement of that patent. I bet a lot fewer shitty patents would be awarded if that were the case.
1- Not really. You can practice part of a patent and not violate the patent. If a thing you sell enables infringement, but is usable for noninfringing usses, you aren't necessarily infringing.
2- THat is not how it works. A patent can claim multiple embodiments of an invention. Just because one embodiment is invalid, not all are (this is a simplification, but close enough)
3- This is impossible. Say the patent office issues a patent, but then the law changes (this happens a lot). Or a piece of prior art is not found by anyone, through no one's fault or lack of effort? There are a ton of reasons a patent issues and is later invalidated that can actually have nothing to do with the PTO.
 
1- Not really. You can practice part of a patent and not violate the patent. If a thing you sell enables infringement, but is usable for noninfringing usses, you aren't necessarily infringing.

In this case, correct me if I'm wrong, it's a service that google provides that looks up the name. It is infringing on this so called patent. And it's google's.
 
In this case, correct me if I'm wrong, it's a service that google provides that looks up the name. It is infringing on this so called patent. And it's google's.
Well, let's not confuse what these people are CLAIMING their patent covers and what it actually covers.
But I was under the understanding that there was more than one step: searching for, holding, encrypting, linking to a key, etc.
Let's say that Google provides services that cover parts of that, but only part. That means google isn't necessarily violating the patent. Only an activity that completes ALL steps of a patent is infringing.
 
Back
Top