App Developer Takes On Patent Troll

I am of the opinion, that patent trolls, have set back technological advancements more in the last 20 years, than the dark ages did in a 1000 years.

I am also of the opinion, that there needs to be a legal definition of patent troll, and that the crime of patent trolling should be punishable as a felony with a nice hefty fine, and prison time for not just the individuals that engage in that crime, but the CEO, CFO and other corporate officers of any corporation that engages in it.
 
Every time I hear about these sorts of shits, it makes me wanna find them and punch them in the face..... with a sledgehammer. I feel sorry for the dude. What I don't get though, is how is he being sued? It's Google's system.
 
Thanks for posting this Steve, very much appreciated. I'm a big fan of X-Plane and it's horrible to see him or anyone go through this.

Paten office is totally broken and these lawyers are the scum of the earth.
 
They need to completely rewrite patent and copyright laws.

It ain't going to happen though, the lobbyist and corruption has already gotten so deeply entrenched into the system that it'd be almost impossible to do.
 
It's not the patent laws that need to be rewritten per se. It is the lawsuit process that needs to be fixed. What needs to happen in the US is that if the plaintiff loses, they must pay the defendant's legal fees. This would stop a lot of frivolous lawsuits, and make it easier for defendant to defend themselves rather than going for the less expensive route of settling. So this isn't an indicator of a broken patent system as much as it is an indicator of a broken civil court system.
 
did anybody watch the vid below? the number one judge that sides with the trolls is the father of one of the top troll lawyers in his district! how the fuck can they get away with that?! the patent office needs to get their shit together and stop passing obvious ideas and stupid shit. amazon holds a patent for the IDEA of launching a rocket and landing it on a boat. it was a drawing that looked like a 5 years drew it, no tech details, nothing and now they could potentially sue spacex for actually doing it. WTF?!


weaselly looking mofo
 
It's not the patent laws that need to be rewritten per se. It is the lawsuit process that needs to be fixed. What needs to happen in the US is that if the plaintiff loses, they must pay the defendant's legal fees. This would stop a lot of frivolous lawsuits, and make it easier for defendant to defend themselves rather than going for the less expensive route of settling. So this isn't an indicator of a broken patent system as much as it is an indicator of a broken civil court system.
Ture but it still a bit of both, I mean come on just at some of patent there a joke.
 
Ture but it still a bit of both, I mean come on just at some of patent there a joke.

If it was made such that the plaintiff had to pay the legal defense fees if they lost, the defendant would be much more inclined to fight a battle to invalidate the patent.
 
1- Many of these software patent claims have died off after the SCOTUS' Alice decision, and if the guy in the 2nd video is really having issues with this lawsuit, he has a shitty attorney.
2- Let's differentiate between trolls and NPEs. Trolls are those who threaten lawsuits based on weak or bad patents, against those who are unsophisticated and dumb or vulnerable and cannot affort a lawsuit. An NPE is someone who owns a legitimate patent, but does not practice it; instead they license it out to other companies.

Trolls bad, NPEs good.

Trolls prevent innovation by applying a downward pressure on innovators by increasing the costs of participatinging the market.
NPEs increase innovation by creating new tech and licensing it out to others to fun new innovation.

3- The things the guy says periodically indicate he has no idea what he is talking about.
 
Hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees? His lawyers are better at the patent trolling business than the patent trolls.
 
If it was made such that the plaintiff had to pay the legal defense fees if they lost, the defendant would be much more inclined to fight a battle to invalidate the patent.
I'm ref to patent office it self a long with patent troll
 
I'm ref to patent office it self a long with patent troll

The patent office itself is limited by manpower. For not so obvious things, it's sometimes better to just sign off on it rather than take a lengthy amount of time reviewing it and comparing it to whatever exists, and let the legal system deal with it. The problem is the legal system is broken.
 
The patent office itself is limited by manpower. For not so obvious things, it's sometimes better to just sign off on it rather than take a lengthy amount of time reviewing it and comparing it to whatever exists, and let the legal system deal with it. The problem is the legal system is broken.
I bet the government would have something to say if their defense contract would just sign things off rather than careful review because it takes too long. Seriously, these patent examiners might as well not exist given the shit that gets through.
 
I bet the government would have something to say if their defense contract would just sign things off rather than careful review because it takes too long. Seriously, these patent examiners might as well not exist given the shit that gets through.

Apples and oranges. You can't compare the two. One has human lives at risk. The other just has money.

These government workers (paper pushers) probably aren't smarter than your average [H] visitor, and most likely significantly less tech savvy. You can't hire smart people to push paper unless you're paying them a lot. And I highly doubt patent office workers get paid anywhere near what defense contract reviewers and auditors get paid.
 
Human lives or not, they don't expect a good job on their side, but expect it on the other side. They pay patent examiners a fair amount. 80k. It's not the world, but it ain't bad. Then again, considering the seemingly shit work they do, maybe too much.
 
What you sometimes get is paid stooges shouting "TORT Reform!!! We need TORT Reform!! Get rid of all these stupid lawsuits!!"

That's a dangerous over simplification and one the corporations like to push. A big chunk of TORT is consumer rights and protections. This is usually the 'Reform' those that shout about it want. They want to take away the consumers right to sue a corporation or company for harm or damages caused by their products or services. I doubt the 'reform' will stop it working the other way round which is how Patent Trolls and corporations work.

Sure the system needs some changes to try to eradicate ANYONE who abuses the system. But just listen to both sides of the story and carefully read the small print before you sign on the dotted line.
 
Man, this makes me totally sick.
My son is learning some python and he said he would love to be a coder and create fun little games. I was telling him if he works hard and becomes talented enough he could write games for Android and sell them on Google play. Be totally independent, not have to work for anyone but himself. Turns out that is bad advise because of patent trolls.
And he is RIGHT; the #1 funder of the democratic party is trial lawyers. They control them; there is NO legislation that is going to take money out of their pocket that is going to pass.
 
And he is RIGHT; the #1 funder of the democratic party is trial lawyers. They control them; there is NO legislation that is going to take money out of their pocket that is going to pass.


And another bunch of slimy manipulative assholes fund the Republicans. Welcome to a 'modern democracy'.

Actually none of us have proper democracy. Just the illusion.
 
And another bunch of slimy manipulative assholes fund the Republicans. Welcome to a 'modern democracy'.

Actually none of us have proper democracy. Just the illusion.
You must not know many lawyers. It is pretty rare to find a republican in a room full of them.
 
Maybe he did, but you seem to want to blame republicans for some reason.
 
Maybe he did, but you seem to want to blame republicans for some reason.

No, where did you get the impression I was blaming Republicans for Patent Trolls? Just saying whilst the slimy lawyers and others support the Democrats for their nasty agendas, other slimy industry/interest groups pushing their less than citizen friendly agendas support the Republicans.

They are as bad as each other. They all fight over the scraps.
 
That was the impression I got since you only mentioned republicans.
 
You missed my point entirely but it doesn't matter.


Not saying Republicans are without blame; then again I ask, How may lawyers do you know? I have met many and out of probably 20 or so I only know of 1 that was a republican.
It is WELL KNOWN that trial lawyers donate millions to the DNC and democrat candidates. This is why any reform of law that is demanded by the people,
and even if they become bills and go into congress; they are killed by democrats that are bought by the trail lawyer lobby.
In today's America the court system is a system where law firms run LEGAL EXTORTION RACKETS. It is call Patent trolling and Tort law.
 
This is an obvious conflict of interest! you cannot have the plaintiff attorney and judge be related, again its a legal conflict of interest. What he needs to do is file with the supreme court for a change of venue on that conflict of interest. I ran this by my Girlfriend (Paralegal), Aunt (Lawyer) and Uncle (Supreme Court Judge). They all gave me the same information.
 
The judge has been working now for a IP law firm for around 18 months. He left the bar.
 
I didn't catch that. you google him?
lol he saw how much cash his son was raking in. f'n trolls!
 
Patent US6857067 - System and method for preventing unauthorized access to electronic data

Uniloc developed this technology themselves, and patent it in 2000, when product licensing typically consisted of nothing more than a CD Key check. They are exactly the kind of good-guy inventors that Ars Tech et al. talk about when they say things like "patents should be given to real inventors who actually made it, not trolls!" Their patents have repeatedly withstood validity challenges and at least one major company (MS) was found to willfully infringe them.

Has it ever occurred to anyone that maybe they actually invented something novel, and deserve to get paid for it?
 
Patent US6857067 - System and method for preventing unauthorized access to electronic data

Uniloc developed this technology themselves, and patent it in 2000, when product licensing typically consisted of nothing more than a CD Key check. They are exactly the kind of good-guy inventors that Ars Tech et al. talk about when they say things like "patents should be given to real inventors who actually made it, not trolls!" Their patents have repeatedly withstood validity challenges and at least one major company (MS) was found to willfully infringe them.

Has it ever occurred to anyone that maybe they actually invented something novel, and deserve to get paid for it?
How about they sue Google then? Probably because they'll probably lose. Is it not Google's system that is implemented into Google Play store?
 
they purchased that patent with a shit tonne of others.
Original Assignee: Martin S. Edelman
 
That Uniloc patent is a shining example of how broken the PTO is. Too Vague, Obvious under the Art. And yet it was granted.

I blame Republicans because they DID fuck up the PTO. In the name of 'Reform' Ronny Raygun changed the agency to one funded entirely by it's Fee revenues.

So of course the natural result is, they will accept anything, they will approve anything to collect the Fee's and let the Court system sort it all out, not my problem.

So I just laugh, welcome to a completely screwed up world, best of luck all you business geniuses, feeding off each other sue or be sued, etc.

The Patent system worked fine for over 200 years, America built an enormous technological society on it, and then along came Lord Alzheimer.
 
That Uniloc patent is a shining example of how broken the PTO is. Too Vague, Obvious under the Art. And yet it was granted.

I blame Republicans because they DID fuck up the PTO. In the name of 'Reform' Ronny Raygun changed the agency to one funded entirely by it's Fee revenues.

So of course the natural result is, they will accept anything, they will approve anything to collect the Fee's and let the Court system sort it all out, not my problem.

So I just laugh, welcome to a completely screwed up world, best of luck all you business geniuses, feeding off each other sue or be sued, etc.

The Patent system worked fine for over 200 years, America built an enormous technological society on it, and then along came Lord Alzheimer.
You have no idea what you are talking about. The USPTO makes more money off a patent application that has been denied than one that has been issued.

Also, making fun of Alzheimer's patients is just a dick move, man. Dick move
 
Random things that occur to me, an obvious non-lawyer, after watching the videos:
  • If it's Google's system that is enabling the alleged infringement, the troll should be forced to sue Google rather than some random app developer who uses the service. That applies to all the cases where trolls pick and choose relatively vulnerable (i.e. not super rich) individuals while giving the big boys who are likely to put up a fight a pass.
  • If one of the claims of a patent is found to be invalid, the whole patent should automatically be invalidated. Is that seriously not how it works? WTF.
  • If the patent office is found to have wrongly approved a patent, they should bear some responsibility for people who are sued for infringement of that patent. I bet a lot fewer shitty patents would be awarded if that were the case.
 
Back
Top