Anything new smaller than SG05?

Ulti

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 11, 2010
Messages
189
Heya HFers,

I've been away from SFF for quite a few months now and just wondered if there was anything new in the SFF scene that would allow a full size PCI-E card that was smaller than a SG05?

I've just had a look at Lian Li and Silverstone's website but didn't see anything smaller with some quick calculations.

Thanks!
 
For stuff that is actually available, the SG05 is the gold standard at the moment. There are a couple projects on this forum which may come to fruition (specifically, the SG05 Evolution thread) and significantly up that standard :)
 
For stuff that is actually available, the SG05 is the gold standard at the moment. There are a couple projects on this forum which may come to fruition (specifically, the SG05 Evolution thread) and significantly up that standard :)

Ours is a bit bigger than the SG05, I'm afraid. Gives you some serious flexibility with the extra space though, for sure (dual rad anyone?). But it sounds like one of Cmadki4's custom cases might fit the bill for <SG05 size.
 
Hmm the Langear Infinity is too expensive when compared to the readily available SG05.

I was following the "SG05 evolution" and although it was awesome, unfortunately it is also bigger. Cmadki4's custom case looks pretty good too but it's still early stages from what I see.

I guess SG05 is still the gold standard as Machupo put it. Guess I'll have to check in a few months again as case design takes time.
 
I like the SG08. Not entirley sure if its smaller then the SG05. I also like the lian li Q08. These are my first 2 choices in going itx route. I kind of like the look of langear infinity. I will read up more on that.
 
The SG08 is longer than the SG05 (351mm vs 276mm) and also 14mm taller leading to a volume of 14.8 litres, 4 larger than the SG05.

I haven't worked with a Q08 but the Q07 is 11.6 litres and will only take graphics cards up to 7"
 
Hmm the Langear Infinity is too expensive when compared to the readily available SG05.

I was following the "SG05 evolution" and although it was awesome, unfortunately it is also bigger. Cmadki4's custom case looks pretty good too but it's still early stages from what I see.

I guess SG05 is still the gold standard as Machupo put it. Guess I'll have to check in a few months again as case design takes time.
Necere and Wahaha360's SG05 Evolution (actual name yet to be relieved), will be awesome when it materializes, even though slightly larger than the SG05, it packs tons of features the SG05 does not.

And as far as the development of my SFF cases, it is on going, but being the manufacturer I can make cases on demand. No need to wait for M3A1 to take shape, I can make the "Ulti SFF" ;). But I am hoping to make some serious headway over the next couple of weeks so that the M3A1 prototype can be powder coated early January.

When you say smaller than the SG05 what are you envisioning?
 
@Barbarian_PT:
The Node 304 does look nice but it's almost 20L! It's one of the biggest m-ITX cases from what I've seen.

@KrAzYaZnFLiP808:
The SG05 seems to be the smallest case in the Sugo range.

@Proplus:
Yep I've got a Q-07 and I used it for my sibling's build. As it uses a full size ATX PSU and has space for a 5.25" ODD, quite a bit of small is wasted to that.

@cmadki4:
Thank you for your offer, but unfortunately as I'm student I'm not really able to afford a custom case.

Yeah it's true that Necere+Wahaha360's build is brilliant, I don't need that much power haha.

After reading some reviews on the SG05, it really seems that it's pretty much the smallest it can get without having to worry too much about ventilation/airflow.

I would love to see a SG05 in person, I can't believe it's only 176mm wide.

Realistically speaking, I don't think one would be able to shrink the SG05 much more without losing too much.

I'll do some little sketches just for my own curiosity but I wasn't looking for a custom case at all.
 
it's 176mm tall, I believe the width is 222mm (and depth to be somewhere around 285mm).

Honestly there is a lot of room to shrink the SG05 (take a look at my Neutronium build), but it requires custom work and sacrifice of some possibilities (namely, watercooling and full length GPUs). I think cmadki4 is on the right track to the minimalist "full-GPU" system (mine is limited to short-pcb GTX 670's).
 
Ah yeah, I realised that it was 176mm tall but forgot to edit my post.

After looking at your post, and doing some sketches, I realised there's pretty much only two ways to reduce the size and that's to reduce the height or depth of the case. There's no way to reduce the width as it's already as "thin" as it can be.

Reducing the height of the case would mean less room for a CPU cooler. After a certain threshold, it would also mean that graphics cards with the PCI-E power connectors on the side wouldn't be viable. Reducing the depth of the case would mean less depth for the GPU, meaning a shorter GPU would need to be used (including the space for the connectors at the end). In both cases the slim ODD would have to be omitted.

Realistically, the smallest size is most likely to be 220mm (W) x 152mm (H) x 240mm (L) (~8L) which is pretty significant I guess as it's roughly a 25% reduction in volume. This would reduce the maximum card length support from 10" to roughly 8.5" cards meaning cards will most likely be limited to the GTX670 or HD7850. The maximum CPU cooler height would then be reduced from 82mm to 58mm high coolers which isn't that easy to come by. However, for more casual users, I think it roughly fits the bill.

Btw, your build is pretty awesome!
 
Ah yeah, I realised that it was 176mm tall but forgot to edit my post.

After looking at your post, and doing some sketches, I realised there's pretty much only two ways to reduce the size and that's to reduce the height or depth of the case. There's no way to reduce the width as it's already as "thin" as it can be.

Reducing the height of the case would mean less room for a CPU cooler. After a certain threshold, it would also mean that graphics cards with the PCI-E power connectors on the side wouldn't be viable. Reducing the depth of the case would mean less depth for the GPU, meaning a shorter GPU would need to be used (including the space for the connectors at the end). In both cases the slim ODD would have to be omitted.

Realistically, the smallest size is most likely to be 220mm (W) x 152mm (H) x 240mm (L) (~8L) which is pretty significant I guess as it's roughly a 25% reduction in volume. This would reduce the maximum card length support from 10" to roughly 8.5" cards meaning cards will most likely be limited to the GTX670 or HD7850. The maximum CPU cooler height would then be reduced from 82mm to 58mm high coolers which isn't that easy to come by. However, for more casual users, I think it roughly fits the bill.

Btw, your build is pretty awesome!
Yep, you've hit that wall that most SFF custom builders hit the first time around when chasing the "smaller" milestone, when you realize it can't get any smaller without major sacrifices. But we have our ways, muhahaha :p
 
Wow, what would be the smallest build. I am interested aswell. I have a asrock itx, and PNY GTX 680. Smallest I have seen is the SG08 for gfx card wise, and power supply. I would go smaller with gtx 670 if I can get a nicer case. Still not sure what cooler as the H80 would be a tight fit in a SG08. Oh well, I wanted a super powerful pc, so thats what I am building. Thanks.
 
Yep, you've hit that wall that most SFF custom builders hit the first time around when chasing the "smaller" milestone, when you realize it can't get any smaller without major sacrifices.

I think some people focus too much on benchmarked performance and lose sight of just having a "good enough" computer.

My home computer is a 2600K@4.5GHz and a GTX 560 Ti (used to be two in SLI).

I had to spend more than half this year 2000+miles away from home. I built this SFF computer in an Antec ISK 300-150 with stock clocked 2500K and Radeon 6670 (upgraded from the graphics card in my build thread). I used it when I was away from home, and even at LAN parties. I played TF2, LoL, MW3, etc. and games ran just fine at 1920x1080 resolution and "auto" settings. Did I know what exact FPS I was getting? No. Did I crank up all the graphics quality to HIGH? No. Did I enjoy gaming? Yes.
 
You've hit the nail Zap, the thing is, computer components are pretty affordable nowadays so for those that know how to build SFF PCs, they'll go for the high end hardware, whereas those who don't, they'll just buy a Mac Mini or something.

For me, the form factor of the Mac Mini is amazing, but the hardware isn't so. On the other hand, I don't need a 2600k@4.5ghz or a GTX680. I'm very happy with an i3-2100, 1GB HD7850 and a 256GB SSD with no other HDDs. I don't need my CPU to run at 20 degrees C either.

Tbf, I don't really game much nowadays on my PC as I've got iOS devices, a PS3 and a Wii but when I can get a HD7850 for so cheap, I definitely wouldn't wanna go for anything cheaper.

I downsized my mATX rig to a mini ITX rig with a low profile 7750 but I'm not really happy with the 7750 when I game. I only play low spec games though like LoL, Diablo 3 and some MMORPGs like RaiderZ but even then, it's probably only a few times a month. My mini ITX rig is pretty big though, it's the Streacom F7C case.

If I didn't have a 2560x1440 monitor I wouldn't mind getting a Mac Mini but the fact that the Mac Mini has no front USB ports and requires an active adapter gets to me. I wish there was an FM2 ITX motherboard that outputted dual link DVI, then I could build a very small system.
 
A mid-range setup in a case smaller than the SG05 is not unreasonable.

Maybe you should wait, since the world didn't end Dec 21, there is hope in 2013.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top