Anyone play 'The Witcher' before?

I just remember running everywhere looking for one certain character in the kings town over and over again to try and advance the plot. It reminds me of old school rpgs where this door is shut until you get to this point in the story....a good example is the island, nothing happens there until you talk to a certain someone then all of a sudden there are monsters and the stone golem to fight. Its a good game you just dont have a lot of choices from what I remember.

It isn't sandbox, but has quite a few "choice and consequence" plot points.
 
I just remember running everywhere looking for one certain character in the kings town over and over again to try and advance the plot. It reminds me of old school rpgs where this door is shut until you get to this point in the story....a good example is the island, nothing happens there until you talk to a certain someone then all of a sudden there are monsters and the stone golem to fight. Its a good game you just dont have a lot of choices from what I remember.

I'm on that point right now and there has been heaps of stuff to do in Vizithing and the swamps. I'm actually just tabbed out of the game having killed the golem this very moment and the only point it's slowed down for me was after I paid the druids my last 500 coins to summon a storm and then they didn't due to a bug, and even then it slowed down from "five things to do at once with not enough time in the day to get them all done" to "enough time to do everything". It's hardly been dull.

Did you play the EE or the original?
 
Arggg, how do I gain Odo's trust? I keep drinking a bunch of alcohol but all he does is say That's enough! and takes a seat.
 
Arggg, how do I gain Odo's trust? I keep drinking a bunch of alcohol but all he does is say That's enough! and takes a seat.

Kill the plants in his yard after you're really really wasted. He will tell you to, just have to drink enough first.
 
I'm on that point right now and there has been heaps of stuff to do in Vizithing and the swamps. I'm actually just tabbed out of the game having killed the golem this very moment and the only point it's slowed down for me was after I paid the druids my last 500 coins to summon a storm and then they didn't due to a bug, and even then it slowed down from "five things to do at once with not enough time in the day to get them all done" to "enough time to do everything". It's hardly been dull.

Did you play the EE or the original?
I disagree, I remember going to the castle town and heading to the island right away. You are forced to do the quests in a certain linear order...if I remember right, the only quests on the island are talking to villagers to gather info which is triggered by an event in town, fighting the golem which is triggered by a town event and something about hunting those swamp monsters which is triggered by an event. I dont remember there being a single quest on that island unless you performed the town trigger action. Dont get me wrong, I thought it was really fun at first and I actually quite enjoyed the first mission but it just got boring to me.
 
I disagree, I remember going to the castle town and heading to the island right away. You are forced to do the quests in a certain linear order...if I remember right, the only quests on the island are talking to villagers to gather info which is triggered by an event in town, fighting the golem which is triggered by a town event and something about hunting those swamp monsters which is triggered by an event. I dont remember there being a single quest on that island unless you performed the town trigger action. Dont get me wrong, I thought it was really fun at first and I actually quite enjoyed the first mission but it just got boring to me.

I guess I got lucky in that case, I like to explore each new area fully before going elsewhere so I spent about 5 hours in the town doing as much as I could before ever even going to the Dike, let alone the swamp.
 
I tried the demo and thought it was a little too cheesy for me. The voice acting was terrible, as well. Mass Effect 2 has spoiled me.

Oh yeah, the dialogue and clunky throughout. Maybe not as bad as Oblivion but still bad. I never took the game seriously enough for that to ruin the fun of it.
 
61 hours to finish first play through. Definitely want to go again, maybe with a mod or two - there are a couple of things that still need addressing in the EE, such as the talismans repelling enemies but still putting you in "combat mode" so you can't click anything or go anywhere until you kill the enemies that aren't attacking you. I ended up getting a little irritated by how long it took to loot/click after ending combat, you have to wait about 5 seconds for it to be enabled.

If there are any mods that change those two things and maybe ramp up the difficulty (played on medium and I ended up untouchable by chapter V) I would put this as one of my top five games.
 
Anyone happen to know whether there's a mod that just shows everything that's lootable without having to move the mouse around to hover over every little thing? Also an auto-loot-all mod? The lack of those two are pretty irritating to me after playing for maybe 40 minutes. Don't think I will go on with the game unless I can fix this. I checked http://www.moddb.com/games/the-witcher/mods but came up with nothing.
 
some nudity is an understatement, in the enhanced edition you go around collecting picture cards of all the women you sleep with. It is an epic game though even though the combat system left room for improvement I would say for 5 bucks its worth picking up, especially with the next one coming out this year.
 
Anyone happen to know whether there's a mod that just shows everything that's lootable without having to move the mouse around to hover over every little thing? Also an auto-loot-all mod? The lack of those two are pretty irritating to me after playing for maybe 40 minutes. Don't think I will go on with the game unless I can fix this. I checked http://www.moddb.com/games/the-witcher/mods but came up with nothing.

Not sure what you mean about the first point, if you hold left Alt it'll show all the remains and plants around you that are to be looted. The second one I want to know about, it's a bit stupid clicking on a plant and opening the menu to click "take all" on a single leaf or something. Much better if you could just click once and take the contents automatically.
 
I'm on that point right now and there has been heaps of stuff to do in Vizithing and the swamps. I'm actually just tabbed out of the game having killed the golem this very moment and the only point it's slowed down for me was after I paid the druids my last 500 coins to summon a storm and then they didn't due to a bug, and even then it slowed down from "five things to do at once with not enough time in the day to get them all done" to "enough time to do everything". It's hardly been dull.

Did you play the EE or the original?

Spoiler hint:


You don't have to pay the druids
 
Not sure what you mean about the first point, if you hold left Alt it'll show all the remains and plants around you that are to be looted. The second one I want to know about, it's a bit stupid clicking on a plant and opening the menu to click "take all" on a single leaf or something. Much better if you could just click once and take the contents automatically.

Ctrl + click on any container loots all of the contents as long as there is room in your inventory.
 
Picked up the Enhanced edition in the steam sales for £3.25 and have enjoyed every minute of it. At first I found the combat system a little tricky in the Prologue but as soon as I realised that you have to let the combat animations play through it all fell into place. Chapter one was enjoyable for me but I found the beast quite a challenge. I enjoyed exploring the city of Vizima in Chapters 2 and 3 but I felt that Chapter 4 was less interesting. Chapter 5 was ace and tonight i'll hopefully finish the Epilogue and wrap things up.

I've found the voice acting to be fine and i'm impressed that all text dialogue has accompanying spoken dialogue. I'm not so keen on American accents in "ye olde" type RPGs but there were only a few that got under my skin. The Dwarven dialogues were nice and gritty especially the blacksmith in Chapter one!

The quests have been interesting, I always explore an area fully so I haven't had any trouble with doing things out of order and i've found little if no bugs to be had. The inventory and the journal system work for me as well as the alchemy and levelling system. The game didn't feel too linear to me and is the campaign is nice and long.

The Witcher is definitely my favourite RPG i've played yet and i'm looking forward to the sequel immensly. As a previous poster mentioned i'm always impressed how Eastern European developers are producing high-calibre "proper" PC games.
 
There are a lot of subtleties people don't appreciate in the combat system. Most of them don't matter unless you are playing in the hardest difficulty level. For example, all those talents that give you enhanced damage if your opponent is on fire, etc, start to matter more. Chaining is always good, and done by clicking again when you see the yellow streak on the weapon (and hear the sound, which I think is a better indicator), but if you are right on the ball you will not only chain, but do it in such a way that your opponent will not have a chance to hit you.

The fun really starts when facing multiple opponents though, having to use rolls, jumps, and your environment to avoid being surrounded is great. Also, switching between styles in the middle of a fight becomes important. Group style improves with the number of opponents, especially after you have certain talents, but at the hardest difficulty you won't be using it very often. Instead, you will be moving around to avoid facing more than you can handle. Aard becomes super important both for crowd control and instant stun kills (though it can be frustrating when Geralt decides to go into one of the longer fatality animations in the middle of a big fight).

I played through "blind" the first time on medium difficulty and enjoyed it quite a bit. This time I am using the wiki to make sure I explore everything the game has to offer.

Witcher 2 worries me a bit. They are sacrificing character and uniqueness for a more mass market appeal. You can see it even in the way Geralt's face has been made more "masculine" to the point where it looks a bit silly. I enjoyed that the original did not fall so easily into these stereotypes.
 
Geralt was always a masculine testosterone-rich man. At least especially in the EE with the voice acting. Not sure if the non-EE was different. Ignoring graphics, his personality was total man's man.
 
Last edited:
Witcher 2 worries me a bit. They are sacrificing character and uniqueness for a more mass market appeal. You can see it even in the way Geralt's face has been made more "masculine" to the point where it looks a bit silly. I enjoyed that the original did not fall so easily into these stereotypes.

I'm happy with the new design I've seen in the sequel. I dislike the appearance of Geralt in the first one, some horrible JRPG-style hero with giant hair and all that nonsense. I prefer a more down-to-earth character, anything too fantastic gets a bit weird for my liking.
 
As much as I am thoroughly enjoying the first game, I'm not a big fan of Geralts design whatsoever. :(
 
I am having alot of fun right now in the game. I am not far in the game right now I am finishing the Potion for Triss. So far the game is keeping my interest & thats hard to do. The story so far keeps you really involved.

I didnt think I would like this game just because of the Click style fighting but overall its awesome. The movement is a bit stiff in my opinion but I can get around that.

The one thing that bothers me is all the Load times. Im not that far into the game & its already bugging me
 
I am having alot of fun right now in the game. I am not far in the game right now I am finishing the Potion for Triss. So far the game is keeping my interest & thats hard to do. The story so far keeps you really involved.

I didnt think I would like this game just because of the Click style fighting but overall its awesome. The movement is a bit stiff in my opinion but I can get around that.

The one thing that bothers me is all the Load times. Im not that far into the game & its already bugging me

For me it seems that after a few loads, much of the game is already in memory so subsequent level loads are extremely fast, maybe 1-2 seconds.
 
The 1.5 patch should alleviate much of the loading problem, though it still loads a bit slow after.
 
its not the fact is how slow it loads it just how many Load spot there are. its just annoying. I cant complain I paid $5.00 for a great game in my eyes. Im not used to this style of game either so its a good change for me. I would of never thought this game was this good because to be honest I thought it was a crappy game just from looking at screen shots. I was way off
 
I reinstalled (repurchased on steam I also have a copy imported from England) the game and it is night and day better then it was at launch. The amount of improvement added into the EE/Directors cut version is pretty impressive. The storyline is well done, and most of the voice acting is pretty good (better with the EE version).

Anyone who bases their views of the game off the "original" version is really missing out.

In regards to the load screens, I do agree, but given that the game is based of a modified version of the Aurora engine (NWN, NWN2, etc) they are not too bad.
 
hrm, the game as originally released was impossible at the section where the old lady keeps throwing you out of her house. 5 seconds of dialog then 60 seconds of loading screens each way.
 
hrm, the game as originally released was impossible at the section where the old lady keeps throwing you out of her house. 5 seconds of dialog then 60 seconds of loading screens each way.

Aaaarg that old lady!!! Rest assured I was happy when... well, I won't spoil it.
 
hrm, the game as originally released was impossible at the section where the old lady keeps throwing you out of her house. 5 seconds of dialog then 60 seconds of loading screens each way.

Heh, she deserves a good slap, coming between me and Shani - it's just not on I tell you.
 
Last edited:
The Witcher Wiki is quite good. I am glad I played without it for my first play through but it was really fun to go back and do some of the stuff I missed on my second run. There is a library guide that you can use to avoid buying expensive books (tells you where to get them for free or if you have to buy them) and a shopping list so you don't end up having to buy back that red shawl you just sold for 5x the price.
 
I just started playing the Witcher EE Director's Cut this weekend. I have to say that the fighting takes a bit of work to get used to. I'm not used to having to do so little to fight. It reminds me of Diablo without the intense clicking. I do miss the ability to jump but it is not that bad. It feels like a good game so far. Hopefully I can finish before the Witcher 2 is released.
 
Yeah, the fighting was far from my favorite, but after a while it gets better and by the end of the game, you forget the feelings of disgruntlement with the system. I had fun. I like how they did a lot of things with the game. Combat mechanic was probably my least favorite part of the game but it's definitely not a dealbreaker.
 
I'm loving every minute of this game. I'm almost to the end of Chapter 2. Really looking forward to the sequel now as well.
 
Back
Top