anyone NOT using Service Pack 2?

ThomasE66 said:
Super Mario,

Nobody said he was automatically going to become a spam zombie. What was pointed out is that he is vulnerable to such exploits until he installs SP2. Even that isn't a guarantee as new exploits are being discovered on a monthly basis.
I'll append one thing: SP2 is increasingly a prerequisite for patches. Consequently, a pre-SP2 system will become even more vulnerable over time.
 
lomn75 said:
I'll append one thing: SP2 is increasingly a prerequisite for patches. Consequently, a pre-SP2 system will become even more vulnerable over time.

QFT. Someone without SP2 might not even know what they are missing with regards to patches.
 
lomn75 said:
I'll append one thing: SP2 is increasingly a prerequisite for patches. Consequently, a pre-SP2 system will become even more vulnerable over time.
Doubly so when they make SP2 mandatory, and stop patching SP1.
 
ThomasE66 said:
QFT. Someone without SP2 might not even know what they are missing with regards to patches.
im not missing anything..they make updates that are sp2 really but update SP1...when i go into safemode..i see everywhere it says SP2..but i know i have SP1..( boot uppscreen, system properties..i know)..and ive installed SP2 before after having all the updates..and nothing came after them..there is no more updates..everything is patched..and i got 2 firewalls running hardware and software...and if i do become a "spam zombie"..be rest assured that you wont get hurt cause you have the all mighty SP2...
 
Phoenix86 said:
Doubly so when they make SP2 mandatory, and stop patching SP1.
then thats cool..i got a SP2 Windows FULL install CD..ill be fine..and ill have crossed over...
 
Warrior said:
im not missing anything..they make updates that are sp2 really but update SP1...when i go into safemode..i see everywhere it says SP2..but i know i have SP1..( boot uppscreen, system properties..i know)..and ive installed SP2 before after having all the updates..and nothing came after them..there is no more updates..everything is patched..and i got 2 firewalls running hardware and software...and if i do become a "spam zombie"..be rest assured that you wont get hurt cause you have the all mighty SP2...
Even assuming you're right about "not missing anything" -- how have you gotten all the fixes in SP2 itself?

Besides, Windows Update only shows you eligible updates. When you visit, do you see drivers for the hundreds of pieces of hardware not in your system? Of course not. Along similar lines, do you see the patches requiring SP2? Nope, because you don't have it.

And pray tell, how is any OS patch preventing me from receiving spam?

//edit: at this point, I really don't care whether or not you use SP2. I'm quite certain you'll find ways around any benefit it conveys. That said, would you at least stop posting utter nonsense? I'm afraid you'll entice other people into this particular form of stupidity, and I'm tiring of refuting it.
 
Warrior said:
then thats cool..i got a SP2 Windows FULL install CD..ill be fine..and ill have crossed over...
I'm not sure the exact date, but it's coming pretty soon. Windows update is already offering SP2 in the downloads and is forcing SP1. Why wait?
 
A bit of clarification is in order here. You don't have "all the fixes" of SP2, what you have are the security fixes, but you are missing the "re-architecting" for lack of a better word. Technically it could be said that you will have to get MORE patches because they will release patches for issues that affect SP1 but that are irrelevant in SP2. See, SP2 changed a lot of networking code in the "internal organs" of XP. Its not just a matter of patches that are released for both SP1 and SP2. You don't have any of the new safeguards (not just talking security center, upgraded firewall, etc) that SP2 has. And that long list of "SP2 patches" you have listed in add/remove are things that are included in SP2 if you had installed it. They label them that way to keep the "patch generations" organized. So you're right in a way that you are still staying up to date in terms of patching. But you can fully update all you like and you will STILL be more vulnerable to viruses, etc., then an SP2 machine.
 
Oh, and I also wanted to point out there *are* a few cases where SP2 cannot be applied. They are rare, and I have yet to see someone pull out the ace card with this argument. Not that I see it here either...

Anyways, don't be so quick to assume.

edit:

But you can fully update all you like and you will STILL be more vulnerable to viruses, etc., then an SP2 machine.
...Such as? AFAIK there are patches to all *known* exploits for SP1 that SP2 fixes. However, new stuff sometimes will run on SP1, but not SP2 because of the architectural differences until SP1 is patched.
 
Phoenix86 said:
Oh, and I also wanted to point out there *are* a few cases where SP2 cannot be applied. They are rare, and I have yet to see someone pull out the ace card with this argument. Not that I see it here either...

Anyways, don't be so quick to assume.

edit:

...Such as? AFAIK there are patches to all *known* exploits for SP1 that SP2 fixes. However, new stuff sometimes will run on SP1, but not SP2 because of the architectural differences until SP1 is patched.

My thinking is the situations where an exploit is discovered that doesn't affect an SP2 machine. You have the time between discovery and patch release, etc., that SP2 people just don't have to worry about. That and they have the added protection of NX, etc. Its technically more protection from the unknown then anything.
 
I'm gonna ask a serious question, sorry to break the conversation here.

I'm the network admin, where i work. I have 5 servers None have SP2. (for the record i'm not happy about this. This was the neglect of the admin i replaced). I've been here 5 months. I've installed SP2 on almost all of the clients. But i am very nervous about doing the servers. These server really have to be up 24/7. I bring them down for maintence but not long. Now the guy before me had written a bunch of apps. Useing old FoxPro 16-bit. Which they are still useing now. On a few of the client machines the 16 bit programs didn't run after the update. Because of Autoexec.nt disappearing. Which is used for 16 bit subsystem. That can't happen on my servers. Have any of you guys ran into this?? What do you think i should do to prevent broken 16-bit programs??
 
flboad said:
I'm gonna ask a serious question, sorry to break the conversation here.

I'm the network admin, where i work. I have 5 servers None have SP2. (for the record i'm not happy about this. This was the neglect of the admin i replaced). I've been here 5 months. I've installed SP2 on almost all of the clients. But i am very nervous about doing the servers. These server really have to be up 24/7. I bring them down for maintence but not long. Now the guy before me had written a bunch of apps. Useing old FoxPro 16-bit. Which they are still useing now. On a few of the client machines the 16 bit programs didn't run after the update. Because of Autoexec.nt disappearing. Which is used for 16 bit subsystem. That can't happen on my servers. Have any of you guys ran into this?? What do you think i should do to prevent broken 16-bit programs??

Forgive me for not understanding this, but if your the network admin, shouldn't you know that SP2 is for XP....which is a client OS? You wouldn't happen to be running XP on servers, would you? I hope this is a type or an early morning brain fart....your giving us PA'ers a bad name! ;)
 
Yes you are right that post stunk, let me re-word

The servers running(server 2003) are handling 2 16-bit programs (and other things i'm not worried about) that the previous admin had wrote for our traders to use. And they are critical for our ever day business.

Now in time i have been here i have been upgradeing each machine(all xp pro clients) 1 at a time to SP2. Why? Because they all use different programs and felt better sitting with it to make sure it worked instead of deploying useing SUS since I am the lone network admin here Anyway. As i was updateing a few of the client machines that use the 16-bit prog, after the SP2 upgrade the 16-bit programs didn't work. Because autoexec.nt gets deleted. Everytime i put it back in the proper folder when the user logs off it gets deleted. So temporarily, i wrote a script that when the user logs on, the file will be copied to the folder. And the 16-bit progams will work. This is ok for a client but not for a server

Now what i'm worried about is the server that runs the 16-bit program. After the upgrade? Do i take the risk of upgradeing and breaking the programs, or run the risk of everything that's involved with not haveing SP2 (again for the record i want SP2).

P.S i'm in philly too
 
You're confusing XP SP2 with Server 2003 SP1 which will include a lot of the stuff SP2 does for XP. SP1 isn't out quit yet (close) so just stay up to date on all your windows updates for now. THEN you can start worrying when SP1 hits. :D

Or you can try the SP1 release candidate which is out now. Try it on a test server though.
 
I was running SP1 on my laptop for a while, had SP2 downloaded, never installed. I didn't feel like dealing with it. Just recently it crapped out on me, had to re-install. So I just put 2K on instead.

I love the fact that on a fresh install of 2K, you go to Windows Update, and have 8 Criticals. Fine no prob. Until you install service pack 4, then you have another 39. :(
 
Ahh i see. Well then i'm not so worried Feel awfully stupid. But not so bad. Give me a break though this is my first admin job. And just out of school :D

Hey atleast i patch my machines with xp clients with sp2 right???

Anyway thank you OldPueblo
 
flboad said:
Ahh i see. Well then i'm not so worried Feel awfully stupid. But not so bad. Give me a break though this is my first admin job. And just out of school :D

Hey atleast i patch my machines with xp clients with sp2 right???

Anyway thank you OldPueblo
good thing you came here first....
 
nuclearfly said:
I love the fact that on a fresh install of 2K, you go to Windows Update, and have 8 Criticals. Fine no prob. Until you install service pack 4, then you have another 39. :(
And this is the exact reason we're saying that service packs are not optional. Windows Update with an old SP does not fully patch your machine!

(I'm not trying to call you out in particular -- it's just the exact illustration is all)
 
Got some forced SP1/2K stuff at work I have to deal with. We've got a lab with some older logic analyzers from Agilent that would run about $10k to replace. The interface to them is entirely PC based & the drivers will not work under SP2 and, since the product's been EOLed, they never will.

Of course, this is nothing new if you spend much time around engineers - I've gotta keep one guy running win95 'cuz it's the only thing he can run some 'essential' software on.
 
flboad said:
Ahh i see. Well then i'm not so worried Feel awfully stupid. But not so bad. Give me a break though this is my first admin job. And just out of school :D

Hey atleast i patch my machines with xp clients with sp2 right???

Anyway thank you OldPueblo
Don't forget your backups. That's what they're for. When time comes for a server upgrade, be sure to have those full backups ready just in case you need to revert back after the upgrade.
 
I just received this list in my email from one of my subscribed email lists.
It deals with the top 10 reasons for implementing SP2. You can argue about a number of them but #5 is a pretty important one in my book.

10. Security hotfixes rollup--One of the least talked about--but most
important--points of XP SP2 is that it contains a rollup of the
previous XP security patches. For users who are spotty about keeping
their systems patched, the security hotfixes rollup is reason enough to
install SP2 right away.

9. Security Center--One of the most prominent new features in XP SP2 is
the Security Center. Appearing as a shield icon in the system tray, the
Security Center provides a graphical indicator that shows the current
state of your system's antivirus protection, firewall, and Automatic
Updates settings. It also provides links that let you change these
settings.

8. Internet Explorer (IE) Add-on Manager--IE's new Add-on Manager lets
you easily see all the add-ons that you've installed to enhance the
functionality of IE and lets you enable or disable any of them. You
access the Add-on Manager from IE by choosing Manage Add-ons from the
Tools menu.

7. Outlook Express image blocking--Like Microsoft Office Outlook 2003,
Outlook Express automatically blocks the display of images in message
preview windows after you install XP SP2. Image blocking prevents rude
Web sites from running uninvited code on your system and
surreptitiously retrieving your personal and system information.

6. Popup blocking for IE--Another nice enhancement in SP2 is the Pop-Up
Blocker for IE. After you install SP2, when you visit Web sites that
attempt to send pop-ups to your system, Pop-Up Blocker suppresses the
pop-ups and displays the message "Pop-ups were blocked" in the IE
toolbar.

5. Data execution prevention (DEP)--Designed to put an end to buffer
overflow exploits, the XP kernel was recompiled for SP2 using the No
Execute (NX) flag. The NX flag lets XP mark memory as either executable
or nonexecutable, preventing malware such as MSBlaster from running in
memory that's designated as nonexecutable. Both AMD 64-bit processors
and Intel's 64-bit Extended Memory 64 Technology (EM64T) processor
support the NX attribute.

4. Integrated Bluetooth support--XP SP2 Bluetooth supports multiple
devices, including cell phones, printers, keyboards, and mouse devices,
as well as Palm and Pocket PC devices. You install Bluetooth devices
using the Control Panel's new Bluetooth Devices applet. Of course, your
system must have Bluetooth hardware to take advantage of this support.

3. Improved wireless support--The new Wireless Network Connection
dialog box is another welcome networking enhancement. This dialog box
provides a user-friendly view of the available wireless networks and
lets you connect to or disconnect from them. To view the dialog box,
select the View available wireless networks option on the Network
Connection dialog box.

2. Secure wireless configuration--The XP SP2 Wireless Network Setup
wizard walks you through the creation of a Wired Equivalent Privacy
(WEP)!or Wi-Fi Protected Access (WPA)!secured wireless network and can
save the configuration to a USB key, which you can then use to
configure compatible network devices. To start the new wizard, open the
Wireless Network Connection dialog box and select the Setup a wireless
network option.

1. Windows Firewall--Unlike the old Internet Connection Firewall (ICF)
found in pre-SP2 XP, Windows Firewall is both useable and essential.
Some of the important features of Windows Firewall are that it's turned
on by default, prevents system access at boot time, and prompts you to
enable access on a per-program basis.
 
You know using the excuse, "my 3d mark score went down 10 points after the upgrade" is a pretty lame excuse. If gaming is your only concern, get a console. There's more to a computer than gaming. With it there should be some responsibility involved. There also should be some interest in protecting yourself and preventing problems for others.
I've said for a long time that there should be a quiz or certification involved before allowing someone to buy a pc.
 
I think SP2 is a great update and anyone should install it as long as it is applied on a clean system or a clean install of XP slipstreamed. However, on an existing installation, maybe one should wait to install it. But on a clean slipstreamed install of Windows XP SP2, it works great for the most part once you strip out all the bloated junk it contains. I like the added security features like the internal changes made to make it more fool proof against exploits. However, I hate the security center, but that can easily be disabled or removed. SO there isn't really much excuse not to use SP2 if you plan on doing a clean install of Windows XP. I can see why someone would not want to upgrade an existing WIndows XP installation because that's where problems often happen. The best bet is to backup everything and install Windows XP slipstreamed with SP2 on a clean installation. There is absolutely no performance differences if SP2 is applied on a clean installation and setup properly. That is what I've seen.

But wouldn't a system without SP2 be safer behind a good hardware firewall with all ports closed than an XP system with SP2 connected directly to the Internet with all ports opened? Because isn't a hardware firewall one of the best forms of security? But either way, XP SP2 is good for eveyone.
 
Super Mario said:
But wouldn't a system without SP2 be safer behind a good hardware firewall with all ports closed than an XP system with SP2 connected directly to the Internet with all ports opened? Because isn't a hardware firewall one of the best forms of security? But either way, XP SP2 is good for eveyone.
Neither is "good," both scenarios have security holes. That's like asking what's better, lose a foot or a hand, when you have the option keep both (run firewall and SP2).
 
phoenix86 said:
Neither is "good," both scenarios have security holes. That's like asking what's better, lose a foot or a hand, when you have the option keep both (run firewall and SP2).

Lets put it this way. Neither is good, or at least neither one is the most secure. What do you think would be more secure? A Windows 2000 SP4 system fully patched with all security fixes up to date, or a WIndows XP SP1 system fully patched with all security fixes up to date? Assume both systems are maintained exactly the same, have the same software installed, and both checked equally well for viruses, trojans, and spyware and both used for the same tasks. This would include they are both with the same firewall either hardware or software based firewall.

The reason I use this example is because what about for the ones who don't have Windows XP and run WIndows 2000? WHo is more vulnerable them, or users of WIndows XP SP1 who won't install XP SP2, but keep all critical security patches for XP SP1 up to date. I think that is an interesting senario to point out and see what everyone thinks?

But never the less for all XP users, there is no reason not to go with SP2 because it is by far the most secure and it is great if setup properly and configured on a clean install.
 
I don't think you NEED SP2 on your machine, but it does offer some nice benefits which I think warrants serious consideration. Simply saying, man fuck SP2 without any real basis besides you don't like MS, well it doesn't really have teeth. There are legitimate hardware compatibility issues, although not common, they do exist as well as some software issues. For a home user, I think there are some very basic security steps people can and should take which would negate their need for the added security SP2 does offer. There are still plenty of people running Win98 on a daily basis and do fine. However, it's always once you've been hit with a virus or trojan that hindsight is 20/20. I would rather be safe all around on top of practicing basic security.
 
Super Mario said:
Lets put it this way. Neither is good, or at least neither one is the most secure. What do you think would be more secure? A Windows 2000 SP4 system fully patched with all security fixes up to date, or a WIndows XP SP1 system fully patched with all security fixes up to date? Assume both systems are maintained exactly the same, have the same software installed, and both checked equally well for viruses, trojans, and spyware and both used for the same tasks. This would include they are both with the same firewall either hardware or software based firewall.

The reason I use this example is because what about for the ones who don't have Windows XP and run WIndows 2000? WHo is more vulnerable them, or users of WIndows XP SP1 who won't install XP SP2, but keep all critical security patches for XP SP1 up to date. I think that is an interesting senario to point out and see what everyone thinks?

But never the less for all XP users, there is no reason not to go with SP2 because it is by far the most secure and it is great if setup properly and configured on a clean install.

Just think of Win2k as inferior to XP in all scenarios except running on really old hardware. It can be made as secure patch-wise, however it still hasn't had the re-engineering that XP has had with SP2. Thats not an opinion.
 
Super Mario said:
The reason I use this example is because what about for the ones who don't have Windows XP and run WIndows 2000? WHo is more vulnerable them, or users of WIndows XP SP1 who won't install XP SP2, but keep all critical security patches for XP SP1 up to date. I think that is an interesting senario to point out and see what everyone thinks?

But never the less for all XP users, there is no reason not to go with SP2 because it is by far the most secure and it is great if setup properly and configured on a clean install.
First you sound like 2K/XPSP1 doesn't get the same security patches XPSP2 has, which is incorrect (SP1 will stop getting patched soon, then your argument will apply to XPSP1, but not 2K). Both 2KSP4 and XPSP1 should be on par, with XPSP2 slightly better security. SP2 just as additional *features* that help make it secure. Most of these features can be done with 3rd party software (ie zone alarm for the firewall). Outside that, the files themselves are still patched.

After XPSP1 is not longer patched it'll go XPSP1<2KSP4<XPSP2. However, I wouldn't put the difference in 2K and SP2 that far off. Both are essently just as secure, if setup properly.
 
lomn75 said:
And this is the exact reason we're saying that service packs are not optional. Windows Update with an old SP does not fully patch your machine!

(I'm not trying to call you out in particular -- it's just the exact illustration is all)

Oh, believe me, I agree. I'm mostly Linux now, but I still have my laptop on Windows for compatibility issues. The only reason I didn't install SP2 on it, is because I was lazy. :rolleyes: I was just pointing out how "great" it is that one fix opens 39 more..... :D
 
nuclearfly said:
Oh, believe me, I agree. I'm mostly Linux now, but I still have my laptop on Windows for compatibility issues. The only reason I didn't install SP2 on it, is because I was lazy. :rolleyes: I was just pointing out how "great" it is that one fix opens 39 more..... :D

I think what you're missing is that on a clean install of any 2K+ OS it offers you the latest service pack that contains all the previous fixes instead of a huge list of all the previous fixes. Installing the latest service pack gets you almost fully updated and the rest is stuff that came out after. So basically, you are getting SP4 first and then all the stuff that came out after SP4. Try ignoring the SP4 update (don't know if you can anymore) and see how many you have to do. :eek:
 
First you sound like 2K/XPSP1 doesn't get the same security patches XPSP2 has, which is incorrect (SP1 will stop getting patched soon, then your argument will apply to XPSP1, but not 2K). Both 2KSP4 and XPSP1 should be on par, with XPSP2 slightly better security. SP2 just as additional *features* that help make it secure. Most of these features can be done with 3rd party software (ie zone alarm for the firewall). Outside that, the files themselves are still patched.

After XPSP1 is not longer patched it'll go XPSP1<2KSP4<XPSP2. However, I wouldn't put the difference in 2K and SP2 that far off. Both are essently just as secure, if setup properly.

That is not what I meant. What I meant was Windows XP SP1 is really the same as Windows 2K SP4 in terms of security if they are both fully patched. However, nothing is more secure than Windows XP SP2. But it doesn't mean a Windows 2K system fully patched is not secure enough if setup properly. The same would apply for a fully patched Windows XP SP1 system. However liker you said, that same will no longer apply once XP SP1 stops getting patched. But how much longer will Windows 2000 SP4 get patched. I believe Windows 2000 SP3 is still being patched? What I meant when comparing Windows XP without SP2 behind a good hardware firewall with all ports closed to Windows XP w/SP2 connected directly to the Internet with all ports opened, which would be more secure assuming the XP SP1 system behind a good hardware firewall is fully patched? I didn't mean an XP system without SP2 that is not fully patched. I would have to guess that any Windows 2000 SP4 or XP SP1 system fully patched would definitely be more secure behind a good hardware firewall (assuming no other boxes infected are connected to the LAN with the hardware firewall) than a Windows XP SP2 box connected directly to a WAN port with all ports opened. After all, isn't a good hardware firewall with all ports closed one of the best methods to prtect your PC from outside attacks because it is hidden from the WAN by sharing a common IP address with many other PCs via NAT?

But still never the less, Windows XP SP2 is the most secure out of anything when setup behind the same hardware firewall or connected directly to the NET. But being connected directly to the Internet with all ports opened would seem to be very RISKY and NOT secure no matter what kind of OS or setup you use, unless you have a good software firewall on your system.
 
OldPueblo said:
I think what you're missing is that on a clean install of any 2K+ OS it offers you the latest service pack that contains all the previous fixes instead of a huge list of all the previous fixes. Installing the latest service pack gets you almost fully updated and the rest is stuff that came out after. So basically, you are getting SP4 first and then all the stuff that came out after SP4. Try ignoring the SP4 update (don't know if you can anymore) and see how many you have to do. :eek:

I don't think I'm missing anything. I realize that they are collective, and the others were released after SP4 was, but some of the security fixes are viewable before and after the SP4, and I know that SP4 fixes some holes and opens others, which subsquently are closed by more and more patches. This is getting way to serious for a joke I started 5 pages ago. :D
 
I put it on the system in my sig and it was not a pretty picture. Took if off and don't really plan on putting it back on anytime soon.
 
Spiff1333 said:
I put it on the system in my sig and it was not a pretty picture. Took if off and don't really plan on putting it back on anytime soon.

I'd suggest creating a thread with the issues your having. SP2 is necessary, and soon Microsoft will make it so. We can help top get your issues resolved. Chances are, someone else had the same issue, and it's a simple fix.
 
Windows XP SP2 completely fux0r'd my HP xw4000 workstation that I was using at home... I had to wipe/reinstall it since I was too lazy to troubleshoot. So far my clean Win XP/SP2 slipstream installation is working great though.

Luckily I anticipated huge problems in advance and moved everything to the spare HDD in the computer.
 
Ok I'm not gonna spend the time to read through this whole thread, but to answer the question, I am NOT using SP2, have no urge to install it, and I lost the whole "GOTTA GET THE LATEST UPDATE" itch a loooonngg time ago. Drivers on the otherhand, are a different story. But any update to Windows is a risk. I hope a lot of SP2 bandwagon jumper-on'ers (made that one up) that had an update go bad have learned that if it ain't broke, don't fix it. Ok, I know this post may anger some, but honestly, for a GAMING MACHINE, you don't need your damned SP2, I'm behind a router, and I'm smart with what I execute on this machine. Oh, and I don't let any assholes using this PC unless I'm sitting behind them.

As far as a client's computer or the workplace, yes, DO have SP2 installed. But on a personal at home only PC, no, I fucking stay away from that shit.

Oh yeah, Spread Firefox for me too.
 
Back
Top