Any dummy's guide to windows and mac server setup?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am not following you at all. I am sure plenty of people don't have a dedicated firewall when they are setting up openvpn.

I don't have my server connected directly to the internet. I have a no-ip.org account. Just trying to figure out how to configure OpenVPN.

All the no-ip account does it change your home ip address into a name that auto resolves, and automatically syncs with your ip that changes at home.

I think before you do "ANYTHING" you should read more about what your goals are and what exactly you are trying to do,a nd do it step for step, not half ass, or backwards.
 
All the no-ip account does it change your home ip address into a name that auto resolves, and automatically syncs with your ip that changes at home.

I think before you do "ANYTHING" you should read more about what your goals are and what exactly you are trying to do,a nd do it step for step, not half ass, or backwards.

Listen, while I appreciate your input and your opinions; there is no need to be rude. I am not trying to half ass anything. The title of the thread included the words "dummy's guides"; meaning I don't know the first thing about how to setup a VPN, let alone a dedicated firewall.

I wasn't trying to ignore your advice. If you got offended I really don't know what to tell you.
 
Update: got Logmein Hamachi2 working on my server, my gaming PC and both macbooks. Tested it out on an outside network and it works exactly the way I want it to. Will stick with Hamachi for now.
 
Listen, while I appreciate your input and your opinions; there is no need to be rude. I am not trying to half ass anything. The title of the thread included the words "dummy's guides"; meaning I don't know the first thing about how to setup a VPN, let alone a dedicated firewall.

I wasn't trying to ignore your advice. If you got offended I really don't know what to tell you.

My advice, if a post says Dashpuppy at the top, completely ignore it and just skip down to the next one.
 
Running17: Hamachi is pretty good. I've personally had a few stability issues with the connections staying up, which is why I was hesitant to suggest it. If Hamachi is working for you, that's great. Hamachi has the advantage of being pretty easy to set up and manage. At some point, if you're interested in trying something else, then look into OpenVPN.

Glad to hear that you've got something working, and I'm sorry that this thread hasn't been as productive as you would have hoped.
 
Running17: Hamachi is pretty good. I've personally had a few stability issues with the connections staying up, which is why I was hesitant to suggest it. If Hamachi is working for you, that's great. Hamachi has the advantage of being pretty easy to set up and manage. At some point, if you're interested in trying something else, then look into OpenVPN.

Glad to hear that you've got something working, and I'm sorry that this thread hasn't been as productive as you would have hoped.

it's good that it's working. I was trying to guide him down the road to do it properly and not do this all over again.

Having your server/computer directly connected to the internet, with a vpn server running on it is a bad idea. BUT if he is just using it for testing purposes then try it out.
 
Did you even read the thread? At no point did he say that he was using the fileserver as the network gateway/nat box. The server was never going to be 'directly connected to the internet', it was going to live behind the nat router with a static PAT directing vpn traffic to the server. This kind of configuration is only vulnerable if there is a security hole in OpenVPN. Furthermore, if there was a security hole in OpenVPN, then UNTANGLE WOULD BE JUST AS VULNERABLE. The tun driver has to be installed as administrator, but the actual openvpn access-server would be running as a limited user, which, fwiw, is how nearly every server daemon in existence is configured. By your logic, every network-accessible daemon around is vulnerable, simply because holes have to be punched in the firewall (which is hardly the only way to attack a computer).

There is going to be little functional difference (from a usability perspective) between openvpn running on the WHS and openvpn running on a linux install (which just happens to be Untangle-branded). If you are just going to regurgitate YeOldeStonecat's comments, please, make sure that they are at least relevant to the discussion before going on a thread-crapping rampage that only serves to confuse the hell out of the OP.
 
Did you even read the thread? At no point did he say that he was using the fileserver as the network gateway/nat box. The server was never going to be 'directly connected to the internet', it was going to live behind the nat router with a static PAT directing vpn traffic to the server. This kind of configuration is only vulnerable if there is a security hole in OpenVPN. Furthermore, if there was a security hole in OpenVPN, then UNTANGLE WOULD BE JUST AS VULNERABLE. The tun driver has to be installed as administrator, but the actual openvpn access-server would be running as a limited user, which, fwiw, is how nearly every server daemon in existence is configured. By your logic, every network-accessible daemon around is vulnerable, simply because holes have to be punched in the firewall (which is hardly the only way to attack a computer).

There is going to be little functional difference (from a usability perspective) between openvpn running on the WHS and openvpn running on a linux install (which just happens to be Untangle-branded). If you are just going to regurgitate YeOldeStonecat's comments, please, make sure that they are at least relevant to the discussion before going on a thread-crapping rampage that only serves to confuse the hell out of the OP.


Sure this all makes sense, but if you read his first "POST" you will see that he wants his wife & friends to be able to backup / be able to connect to his storage unit.

SOOOO,,, what do you do when a friend A or friend B has a virus on their computer and connects to his nice WHS box at home with ALL THAT storage and files, and OPPS has a virus and now transferes it to his nice precious box, not only does the file server have a virus but his wife's laptop and any other machine are most likly going to get the virus too.

Having a untangle unit infront of it will let him cure that issue not only that issue allow him to have more than one VPN ( open ) connection to his box, also having Untangle as a dedicated unit he is not bogging down the WHS server.

Letting the firewall / UTM box do all the natting, plus VPN connections & virus / spyware protection for ALL users, would be the best choice.

Get my idea ?

Another reason why i suggested it is because he can put all his efforts into getting the untangle unit running instead of what he has now, that way it's setup and working :)

I wasn't trashing the thread only helping.
 
I wasn't trashing the thread only helping.

I will have to disagree. You were short tempered and rude in more than one post. Like I said, I appreciate your attempt at helping, but in the end you didn't help.

You kept saying "use untangle, use untangle". When found out I would need a dedicated box to run the firewall, I decided against that route at this time.

Then you called me crazy for "not running a firewall"; which was completely false. I was using my router firewall. My server was never "directly connected to the internet". You were plain wrong and yet you still can't admit the fact that you were wrong.

Stop hijacking my thread. Let other people inform me of the proper way to do things. I don't think I will be needing anymore of your advice dashpuppy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top