Antec Skeleton Put to the Test

can even use an esata external hdd case as well since it has an esata port on the top front of the case.. plus if you have a board that comes with 2 or more esata ports on the back.. issues solved.. heck im sure you could also find other means of mounting a drive on that case without it being an issue since the onboard sata connections would be quite easy to access..

You know what would be neat, if they had some clear, perforated (for air) plastic covers that would protect those drives on the outside. Put holes or vents or whatever so they will get some air, but use clear plastic or plexi of some kind as a cover over those drives. That would show off your raptor if you had one, keep them cool, yet still protected.
 
I thought the review was terrible (and even posted in the forum there telling the guy he should stop doing reviews).

I am interested in this case and know no more about it now than I did before reading the review. The only thing more I know about it now is that the reviewer did not like it.

I wanted to see a review of someone building a computer on it, running the computer on it, showing some tests on it, like temps, fan noise at speeds, how big a cpu heatsink would fit, etc.

Now I'm waiting for another review to come out that hopefully I can get some good info on.
 
I thought the review was terrible (and even posted in the forum there telling the guy he should stop doing reviews).

I am interested in this case and know no more about it now than I did before reading the review. The only thing more I know about it now is that the reviewer did not like it.

I wanted to see a review of someone building a computer on it, running the computer on it, showing some tests on it, like temps, fan noise at speeds, how big a cpu heatsink would fit, etc.

Now I'm waiting for another review to come out that hopefully I can get some good info on.

Like I said before, everyone is basing an entire site and an author's entire work on this one article; your loss. The author, Gabriel Torres, is the editor-in-chief. http://www.hardwaresecrets.com/bio/1 If you liked [H]'s PSU reviews, you'll like their's; all the same info and testing methodology plus more, and they've done far more brands and models out there (for instance they've done three or four of just Corsair's line). The depth and scope of their articles exceeds the vast majority of websites out there.
 
Like I said before, everyone is basing an entire site and an author's entire work on this one article; your loss. The author, Gabriel Torres, is the editor-in-chief. http://www.hardwaresecrets.com/bio/1 If you liked [H]'s PSU reviews, you'll like their's; all the same info and testing methodology plus more, and they've done far more brands and models out there (for instance they've done three or four of just Corsair's line). The depth and scope of their articles exceeds the vast majority of websites out there.

I don't think mikey made any generalizations, at least in the quoted post, about how the hardware site sucks, just the review.
 
That's correct, I made no assumptions about entire site or all the reviews. I was only referring to the one review and I'll stand by what I said about it.
 
That's correct, I made no assumptions about entire site or all the reviews. I was only referring to the one review and I'll stand by what I said about it.

Thought so. And I agree. It is nice to hear someone else's opinion, if for nothing else to gain at least one perspective, so the review is by no means useless. Even if it gives us the chance to point out where we disagree with the reviewer, guess what, we're thinking about the product and already deciding what we like and don't like. Disagreeing with a review for practical reasons is never bad thing on a forum like this. Part of the territory!
 
.... Unless you disagree with me!! Then you're definitely WRONG! :p

Just messin!
 
Who would purchase a case like this to stick it on the floor or carry it around??

Since when does mobility count as a plus or minus for a desktop case?

The reviewer completely missed the point of this case.
 
Who would purchase a case like this to stick it on the floor or carry it around??

Since when does mobility count as a plus or minus for a desktop case?

The reviewer completely missed the point of this case.

There are two things this case is made for. To A.) show off hardware and be different while doing so. B.) To be a Technicians Workstation, not so much a case, but and open and easy mounting point for various hardware for testing.
 
Where do they get their reviewers?



First of all, who would put this case on the floor, it's more for sitting somewhere with everything easily accessible so you can swap stuff on a regular basis. Second of all, it already has two internal 2.5" drives, so it's only if you have a 3 or more hard drives that you're putting them on the side of the case. Even then, if your case is on your desk or work bench, you're not going to be running your chair into it.

I'm thinking that the reviewer needs to invest in an eSATA RAID enclosure so the hard drives would have it's own housing and be kept away from this case.
 
I'm thinking that the reviewer needs to invest in an eSATA RAID enclosure so the hard drives would have it's own housing and be kept away from this case.

Or just some kind of transparent vented enclosure or protective cover for those external drives. Wouldn't that be a cheap and easy solution?
 
Back
Top