Antec Skeleton Put to the Test

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
We’ve been telling you guys about the new Antec Skeleton case for a while. HardwareSecrets got one and gave it a thorough going over. If you’re interested at all, you should check it out. I’m thinking [H]ard about picking one up.

It is impossible to be indifferent to Skeleton. It uses a complete different design, being completely opened for a better airflow. Our news editor, Cássio Lima, thinks it looks like a portable stove. We think it looks like a spider. This is one of the unusual products that you will either love it or hate it.
 
Gah, I was actually hoping they'd have some nice hardware inside to test temps and stuff, but they didn't :(
 
I really think they missed the point.
Its a given that a paperclip or liquid can damage a PC but why should that stop you making your PC into a showcase?
Put it on a shelf out of harms way.
I clean my PC of dust about 4 times a year, I cant see this being much worse.

If you have young kids, it isnt wise to use this case but if you want your PC to look snazzy, well hey, tadaaaa.
 
Is it just me, or did they just talk about the case and not actually test it out to see how the temps were? Plus they keep mentioning about knocking into it with your chair etc. Really, if you had an open case like that, why would you put it in that position where it is vulnerable? Would serve you right, its as stupid as leaving a case next to a sink or oven.
 
Just an addition since we cant edit: I wanna see a true [H]ard review on this, the ratio of chit chat to actual reviewing in this one is very high :)
 
i think this case works much better as an overclocking test bench then as a functional case.. but it still looks good.. and the cleaning issue isnt that big of a deal.. just leave a can of air near it and clean it out every couple weeks.. makes it much easier then cleaning out a normal case.. i give props to antec for releasing something thats beyond different from the traditional case market..
 
Why did they put a quarter of a paragraph of information on each page? This could have been 2 pages instead of 7
 
Nothing beats my sideless case with boxfan technology utilizing hole in the wall to spare room innovation!
 
They're talking about protection of components, etc... but what about temps, and (I'm most interested in) noise? With all the drives hanging out and fans out in the open, how would these components sound "in" the Skeleton vs. a traditional case? Would it be so loud as to be distractive and annoying?
 
Just think, If You put one of these in Your Closet, You'll really have a skeleton in Your Closet. ;)
 
Where do they get their reviewers?

Now, what is the weirdest thing about this case is how it supports extra hard disk drives: they need to be installed on the exterior of the case. This is simply ridiculous. You have to screw you hard drive to a small frame and then this frame is simply hung on holes available on the case side panels. Not only the hard disk drives are completely exposed to any sort of physical damage (we can clearly see the wheels of a chair smashing one of the hard disk drives if this case is installed on the floor) but they can fall from the case during transportation.

First of all, who would put this case on the floor, it's more for sitting somewhere with everything easily accessible so you can swap stuff on a regular basis. Second of all, it already has two internal 2.5" drives, so it's only if you have a 3 or more hard drives that you're putting them on the side of the case. Even then, if your case is on your desk or work bench, you're not going to be running your chair into it.
 
Pretty much the worst review ever. If all you're gonna do is bitch and complain about the thing, don't review it.
 
I HATE websites that break a "review" up in to little tiny chunks just so they can serve more advertising to you while you are reading their crappy article. So it seems like there are a few good and bad things about the design..too bad the site has people that are concerned about pontificating around trees and the paper industry.

That review just needs to get aboard the failboat and set sail...hope I never have the need or opportunity to visit that website again. :(
 
I really think they missed the point.
Its a given that a paperclip or liquid can damage a PC but why should that stop you making your PC into a showcase?
Put it on a shelf out of harms way.
I clean my PC of dust about 4 times a year, I cant see this being much worse.

If you have young kids, it isnt wise to use this case but if you want your PC to look snazzy, well hey, tadaaaa.

Really, I think this would be a bit easier, in a way. In order to dust off my current case, I have to unhook everything, take it outside, take off the side panel, then spend a good several minutes trying to hit every nook and cranny. This thing would certainly attract dust faster (electronics love dust, and here they're all exposed), but all you would have to do is take it outside and give it a quick shot of air. Since everything is easily accessible, you'd have no trouble getting all the dust out, and there would likely be less "traps" for dust too.

I could see hitting it with canned air while it's off also..... it'd be much easier to get to all the dusty spots in this case.

Is it just me, or did they just talk about the case and not actually test it out to see how the temps were? Plus they keep mentioning about knocking into it with your chair etc. Really, if you had an open case like that, why would you put it in that position where it is vulnerable? Would serve you right, its as stupid as leaving a case next to a sink or oven.

I would really like to have seen temp comparisons and for them to at least install a system in there. I think how difficult this is to wire would be a big factor in a buying decision on a $160 case....

Where do they get their reviewers?

First of all, who would put this case on the floor, it's more for sitting somewhere with everything easily accessible so you can swap stuff on a regular basis. Second of all, it already has two internal 2.5" drives, so it's only if you have a 3 or more hard drives that you're putting them on the side of the case. Even then, if your case is on your desk or work bench, you're not going to be running your chair into it.

I thought that was a bit of a silly point too...... I've never put a computer case somewhere where I could simply bump into it. It's at the very least on the bottom shelf of the desk, and my chair can't just hop up there....

Really, I think the HD mounting is actually a decent idea. Sure, it will be noisy and they will be exposed, but it would likely cut down on the difficulty of wiring and installing them. For this case, at least, it'd be a pain to have them inside.
 
I think their review was on the standpoint of a case you buy, build, and sit for 3 years. Some of us have a box or two that we change hardware out in regularly (REAL regularly). And I would like to see a review from that standpoint.
 
Yea as far as running into it with your chair, I agree wtf? I never understand people who use those tiny desks where their computer is actually under the desk and they keep kicking the computer because it is right next to their feet. Then I suppose next they go and complain that the HDD failed after only 2months lol
 
I HATE websites that break a "review" up in to little tiny chunks just so they can serve more advertising to you while you are reading their crappy article. So it seems like there are a few good and bad things about the design..too bad the site has people that are concerned about pontificating around trees and the paper industry.

That review just needs to get aboard the failboat and set sail...hope I never have the need or opportunity to visit that website again. :(


thanks for saving me my 5 minutes, just from reading the responses here, I can get the "cliff notes" :D

personally I think it's absolutely hideous, but each his/her own
 
I would like to see Hardware Secrets change the title of this from "Review" to a preview. Without any hardware being installed/run/benched, this 7 pages is nothing more than someones rant about how an open air system is "a joke" with a handful of pictures.

To actually list lack of protection from outside elements as a fault on this case is like reading a motorcycle review and find motorcycles are unsafe under the cons column.

Don't get me wrong, he suprisingly made a couple valid points (like the flimsy drive quick release) but I can assure you that anyone with a handful of sense won't base their purchasing power on the this "Review". I feel dirty even using that word.
 
I would like to see Hardware Secrets change the title of this from "Review" to a preview. Without any hardware being installed/run/benched, this 7 pages is nothing more than someones rant about how an open air system is "a joke" with a handful of pictures.

To actually list lack of protection from outside elements as a fault on this case is like reading a motorcycle review and find motorcycles are unsafe under the cons column.

Don't get me wrong, he suprisingly made a couple valid points (like the flimsy drive quick release) but I can assure you that anyone with a handful of sense won't base their purchasing power on the this "Review". I feel dirty even using that word.

completely agree with you on every point..
 
+1
This review is a joke.

I could have written this just by looking at pictures of the unit.
 
I thought they had several valid points though. The case is a skeleton of a case and is highly overpriced for what you get.
 
Thinking about it more, I disagree with them on the dust issue. In a traditional closed case, you're forcing air through a convoluted wind tunnel where, of course, dust is going to settle in dead spots. You've also got much much more surface area for the dust to stick to in a traditional case.

With this thing, you're not going to be swirling dusty air around in dead spots. At most, you're going to end up with about the same dust build-up in your heat sinks as you would before and dust naturally settling on things like it would for anything sitting in a room. And with the case being so open, it'll be much easier to take the canned air to 'er and blow that dust away.
 
It's halloween early, this review was a horror. :)

Seriously, I'll wait for Kyle and the gang to install a real system in it and rev it up.
 
It's halloween early, this review was a horror. :)

Seriously, I'll wait for Kyle and the gang to install a real system in it and rev it up.


true to that.. but just think how good of an overclocking benchmark case this would be for cpu overclocking.. talk about the ultimate cooling solution.. especially since most hardware reviews on here are in an open environment .. this case would own for that..
 
Cool case, but if I wanted to "show off" my stuff that much, I'd probably just build my own case or a desk that incorporates the parts. Silence is golden for me, I don't hate it, but it is impractical to say the least.
 
I think that the issue with this case is that it simply isn't practical. That said, in the right environment with the proper care, its probably going to be fine. Its not for me as I put my rigs on the floor so its not for me.
 
Cool case, but if I wanted to "show off" my stuff that much, I'd probably just build my own case or a desk that incorporates the parts. Silence is golden for me, I don't hate it, but it is impractical to say the least.

Agreed.
 
I think the reviewer's constant bitching about this product is possably due to him not installing some hardware propperly, spilling a cup of coffee, dropped a paperclip, and or hit the case with is rolling chair.
I don't think that this article was especially objective. Of course a open case like this one isn't focused on "protecting" your hardware. This is all about COOLING, AIR FLOW, and SHOWING OFF HARDWARE.
 
No hardware installed in this case? Phail!
 
I HATE websites that break a "review" up in to little tiny chunks just so they can serve more advertising to you while you are reading their crappy article. So it seems like there are a few good and bad things about the design..too bad the site has people that are concerned about pontificating around trees and the paper industry.

That review just needs to get aboard the failboat and set sail...hope I never have the need or opportunity to visit that website again. :(

You're missing out then. They have the best reviews of PSUs as well as some other really informative articles on just about everything.

A lot of you are poo-pooing the entire site for this one review. It's your loss.
 
I own this case and I built a LAN gaming box out of it w/ a 9800gtx card 4gb ram Quad AMD Phenom 9750 in it and it is very quiet and most people who have seen have been amazed by it..

Most the things talked about in that article were blown out of proportion and about the only problem I have with the case is it doesn't really allow for a Card Reader in the front because I would never build a computer without 2 harddrives..I would never hang any drives on the side of the case anyway so that was dumb, I would use my external 2bay SATA enclosure just like I always do lol.

It's difficult to wire it up and hide cables etc...but the fact that it's so diff. that anything I've ever built was the joy in building it.


I highly recommend this box if you are an enthusiast overclocker which I believe a majority of you guys probably are... :)
 
I don't think a case like this is better for airflow. Airflow indicates that the air "flows" over your components, like in a wind tunnel. With an open case, it's hard to get any air movement at all over your components.

It does prevent heat from getting trapped to some extend, but without air movement, the cooler air above the open case might actually trap the hot air underneath since there's so little air movement across the components. That's not nearly as effective as air being forced over components and exhausted out the rear and top of a case. This is why wind tunnels are built like a tunnel and not just a big fan in open space. Dust around your components is good..it indicates that lots of air is flowing over your components and settling on the leeward side of the component being cooled.
 
I don't think a case like this is better for airflow. Airflow indicates that the air "flows" over your components, like in a wind tunnel. With an open case, it's hard to get any air movement at all over your components.

It does prevent heat from getting trapped to some extend, but without air movement, the cooler air above the open case might actually trap the hot air underneath since there's so little air movement across the components. That's not nearly as effective as air being forced over components and exhausted out the rear and top of a case. This is why wind tunnels are built like a tunnel and not just a big fan in open space. Dust around your components is good..it indicates that lots of air is flowing over your components and settling on the leeward side of the component being cooled.

I guess the 250 mm fan sucking air out isn't really doing anything then?
 
Yea I agree, pretty crappy Review he did complain alot that is for sure. [H]ard will do review hopefully!!

1 thing I really do have to agree with WTF!!!! were the thinkin of mounting the Hardrives on the outside of the case?....I mean I have 4hd's, and I WILL NOT PUT a raptor drive or any drive on the outside of the case....I was really interested in this case, still am...but IF they fix the part of mounting HD's on the outside, I will would be VERY interested in this case..
 
I am undecided on the case, it would be nice to get some proper temp and noise comparisons.

And as a test rig case there are better, cheaper and more pratical ones available.
 
Yea I agree, pretty crappy Review he did complain alot that is for sure. [H]ard will do review hopefully!!

1 thing I really do have to agree with WTF!!!! were the thinkin of mounting the Hardrives on the outside of the case?....I mean I have 4hd's, and I WILL NOT PUT a raptor drive or any drive on the outside of the case....I was really interested in this case, still am...but IF they fix the part of mounting HD's on the outside, I will would be VERY interested in this case..

They have, te review clearly states you can mount 2 drives inside.
If you need more and object to hanging drives outside, use a USB drive.
 
It's a cool concept and all that, but:

-$180??? What the....
-Asinine hard drive mounting!!!

Maybe they could do a V2 of this case and charge something reasonable.
 
They have, te review clearly states you can mount 2 drives inside.
If you need more and object to hanging drives outside, use a USB drive.


Eh ill stick with my antec 900 which supports 6 HD inside the case...

I like the case, just not the extra HD mounting spots
 
They have, te review clearly states you can mount 2 drives inside.
If you need more and object to hanging drives outside, use a USB drive.

can even use an esata external hdd case as well since it has an esata port on the top front of the case.. plus if you have a board that comes with 2 or more esata ports on the back.. issues solved.. heck im sure you could also find other means of mounting a drive on that case without it being an issue since the onboard sata connections would be quite easy to access..
 
Back
Top