Another One Bites the Dust

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
ExtremeTech is "changing?" Getting rid of the long list of well respected guys below is not a change, it is an execution. I know a few of these guys personally. Jason and Loyd and myself have had many good exchanges. Joel Durham gave me my first print job I ever had. Good luck guys. Y'all did a lot of good things over there at ET. I can say with confidence that it will never be but a shell of its former self.

ExtremeTech is changing. The current staff: writers Jason Cross and Joel Durham, producers Jeremy Atkinson and Mike Nguyen, our enthusiastic forum moderator, Jim Lynch, plus your truly, will be leaving Ziff-Davis at the end of this week.
 
That would be a lot of writers for h i imagine... but i'm not with them.

i quit last year while the advertising/publishign industry started going to shit and went into healthcare IT instead. our company would fire highly productive employees and keep the ones they had crushes on.

so i left before it got bad. now they lost most of their talent and the company is barrily swimming, lost dozens of their advertisers.
 
Should bring them on here.

I am trying my best to keep from having to fire the writers we have now. You would think HardOCP happens by accident and for free of charge? Just because you get it all for free don't think it does not cost a pretty penny to produce.
 
I will miss ET for their peripheral reviews. Their recomendation got me into my MX Revolution desktop which I LOVE.
 
Loyd, Joel and Jason, I am familiar with and will be missed. Jim, OTOH, is one writer I WON'T miss. I hope he finds a job, but in another field. I'd love to see the guys end up at Revision 3. :D
 
I'm sure if you started charging a fee here there would be a lot of users, myself included, who would pay it. You could also take up donations. something I am sure a lot of users here would give.

I paid for my lifetime genmay sub last year, and was well worth it...
 
ExtremeTech was a super not cool/bad website.
Simply based on their mouse reviews.
Which were terrible/awful as could be.

They gave the G5 good scores, and it's a terrible mouse.
They gave the IME 3.0 a horrible score, and it's a contender for best mouse of all time.

All coming from a gamers perspective of course, but that's the perspective they were supposed to be reviewing from since they were released as "gaming mice."

Mice reviews need skip tests (like ESR) lift off distance tests, MS Paint precision tests, and determination if the mouse has prediction enabled (which is a bad thing if it is, like in MX518, and DeathAdder's case)
None of which happen at ExtremeTech.

So IMHO it wasn't a very Extreme site.

HardOCP is the place to be.
 
AFAIK, [H] gets so much more in advertisement that subscription doesn't make sense. I doubt donations would work because it is such a small part of the [H] revenue. What would help though is if you click on the newegg advertisement and actually purchase an item.

</2 cent>
 
ExtremeTech was a super not cool/bad website.
Simply based on their mouse reviews.
Which were terrible/awful as could be.

They gave the G5 good scores, and it's a terrible mouse.
They gave the IME 3.0 a horrible score, and it's a contender for best mouse of all time.

All coming from a gamers perspective of course, but that's the perspective they were supposed to be reviewing from since they were released as "gaming mice."

Mice reviews need skip tests (like ESR) lift off distance tests, MS Paint precision tests, and determination if the mouse has prediction enabled (which is a bad thing if it is, like in MX518, and DeathAdder's case)
None of which happen at ExtremeTech.

So IMHO it wasn't a very Extreme site.

HardOCP is the place to be.
I guess it comes down to opinion, I loved the G5, I wish I had of bought one over my Razer Lachesis.
 
AFAIK, [H] gets so much more in advertisement that subscription doesn't make sense. I doubt donations would work because it is such a small part of the [H] revenue. What would help though is if you click on the newegg advertisement and actually purchase an item.

</2 cent>

Sorry, Newegg charges me more for the same part than my local stores up here, I can't justify it.
 
I'm sure if you started charging a fee here there would be a lot of users, myself included, who would pay it. You could also take up donations. something I am sure a lot of users here would give.

They do in a way as you can pay for access to more parts of the site.
 
Sorry, Newegg charges me more for the same part than my local stores up here, I can't justify it.

Well I guess if paying a tiny bit more to support the websites you use is not in your character, I am OK with that. Just don't be pissed when there are no more free sites for you to use.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, Newegg charges me more for the same part than my local stores up here, I can't justify it.
It's still beneficial for you to click the ads, even if you don't buy anything. Newegg will take into account the click-through rate to gauge the overall effectiveness of their campaign on [H].
 
i click the ads, not because most sites that say "click the ads asshole" but because well the ads are cool and informative and directed to the readers.

thats why i dont use google ads on my site 5secondnews.com, i only use amazon ads since well i shop there and can point it to useful products.

if they are not good enough for you, probably not good for your readers.

i sometimes forget to click the newegg ad before making an unrelated newegg purchase. so if your going to shop newegg do it.

i live in wisconsin, not one store in this state is as affordable as newegg.com
 
That's too bad about ExtremeTech. They've had good stuff over the years. Loyd Case was one of the 1st columnists I remember when I started getting into building PCs, around 96/97. Heh, reading that article and their mention of Alex Ross took me way back. [H] and SharkyExtreme used to be required tech reading for me in the late 90's and early 00's until SE was sold and Ross left the site.
 
sorry kyle i should be more specific.

on my site 5secondnews.com i have tried alot to have targeted specific ads, even creating lists of domains only to allow on my site... google ignores them.

i meant for the general websites out there, google ads are often generic and unrellevant. for instance if i write an antivirus guide ill get 50 fake ads befor ea legit one, for removal tools that are not even useful or used in the IT industry.

YOUR GOOGLE ADS ARE MUCH MORE DIRECTED TO US!!!
 
another pain in the arse as google.com\webmaster is that their lists you can modify have a hidden limit (time out at least).. so if you collected 50,000 sites never to have on your ad list... they sitll will get listed. its like google ignores them. more power to you guys in figuring out google lol
 
google is based on how much the company wants to pay per click aka ppc.. so it depends on the ad.. .

but for custom newegg those details can be found on newegg's site unless they have a special contract.

with amazon.com ads its 4% revenue sharing, if 11 items+ are sold in a timeframe, its 7%-11% depending on items.

you can post links, create a store, or create an ad... all creating same 4% revenue.
hardocp doesnt have amazon ads just an example
 
I didn't use any ad filter but the ad banner is always white for me for quite some time already, Newegg ads used to be there and I always clicked the banner to go to Newegg from here.
 
I'm sure the writers will band together and start their own review site.
 
Ok, this blows. ExtremeTech's gone now; felt the same way when Sharky left Sharky... *sigh* There goes another bookmark in my "hit these daily" folder. Didn't agree with everything on their site, but I gotta say they had some seriously good monitor reviews...
 
I enjoed reading ET for many years.
Sorry to see the site go.
Hope the guys will keep contibuting to the industry and keep us entertained and well informed.
 
I guess it comes down to opinion, I loved the G5, I wish I had of bought one over my Razer Lachesis.

I've had both. And I returned the Lachesis for the G5. The G5 is simply the most comfortable mouse I've ever used... but I admit to it being a bit crap since my previous (rustmetal coloured) one just quit working properly after 3 years. Ended up getting and 2nd G5 anyway because I just could NOT get into any other mice. Most were either too touchy, too slim or not heavy enough.
 
I've had both. And I returned the Lachesis for the G5. The G5 is simply the most comfortable mouse I've ever used... but I admit to it being a bit crap since my previous (rustmetal coloured) one just quit working properly after 3 years. Ended up getting and 2nd G5 anyway because I just could NOT get into any other mice. Most were either too touchy, too slim or not heavy enough.

My main problems with the Lachesis is simply shape and feel. I have never really got used to the shape. It also has some spotty detection where it will act like there is dirt in it or something blocking the laser, but it is fine.
 
My main problems with the Lachesis is simply shape and feel. I have never really got used to the shape. It also has some spotty detection where it will act like there is dirt in it or something blocking the laser, but it is fine.

I remember thinking my fingers were being 'stretched' along the mouse instead of just resting comfortably on top, and that the back end of the mouse dropped off too quickly to provide any support. I felt like I had to reach my fingers out to click. It was also a fairly shallow feeling mouse... like there wasn't much of anything to have a feel for under it. IIRC, the wheel also moved without much tactile feedback at all. A big no no for me. I just wasn't impressed.

The G5 feels like it fits the natural shape of my hand and slopes off feeling I'm not putting my wrist in a position that is unnatural for it to be in. That and I like heavier mice. I've wanted to find a different brand to try (Logitech -is- crap) but nothing beats the G5 for me. Yet.
 
Ok, this blows. ExtremeTech's gone now; felt the same way when Sharky left Sharky... *sigh* There goes another bookmark in my "hit these daily" folder. Didn't agree with everything on their site, but I gotta say they had some seriously good monitor reviews...

At least Sharky got PAID when he bailed by his OWN choice.

Forget I said anything then, and thank you for making the assumption that I did not think it costed anything to produce what comes out of this website.

Na, I just used a terribly worded and half thought of a post to springboard to something I wanted to say. You might have well of had a target on your keyboard.
 
When this many people leave an organization at the same time, that is very bad news.
 
That's too bad about ExtremeTech. They've had good stuff over the years. Loyd Case was one of the 1st columnists I remember when I started getting into building PCs, around 96/97. Heh, reading that article and their mention of Alex Ross took me way back. [H] and SharkyExtreme used to be required tech reading for me in the late 90's and early 00's until SE was sold and Ross left the site.

Damn now that is taking me back too....
 
I guess it comes down to opinion, I loved the G5, I wish I had of bought one over my Razer Lachesis.

No, it's not an opinion.
It's not that the G5 isn't extremely comfortable, or doesn't have the right features (I mean, that blue lava grip is awesome) it's that the performance is terrible.
The G5 has positive acceleration, at slow, normal movement speeds...and if you attempt to use the G5 as a gaming mouse, in a FPS, at low sensitivity like good players do, you'll quickly find yourself looking at the sky when you try to do a 180 turn.

This is because of the laser sensor in the mouse.
The G5 also has a high lift off. 3.6 mm...which is three times as high as you have to lift a Microsoft Intellimouse 1.1 or 3.0

You test this with CD's...
1 CD = 1.2mm

Intellimouse 1.1 or 3.0 will not move the cursor when sitting on 1 CD.
However, the G5 will move the cursor even when on 2 CD's, and sometimes 3 CD's...this is high lift off, and not desired in a gaming mouse.

Key words here are gaming mouse.
You can use a G5 as an awesome desktop mouse, as long as you get used to the positive acceleration.

Take the Microsoft Habu, same mouse basically, still 2000 dpi, still 7 buttons, but no positive acceleration. Still skips though, that's a problem.

OK then, you guys mentioned the Lachesis, that's another mouse ExtremeTech gave a good review to.
Except, they didn't point out any of the flaws the mouse had with it's sensor...how it has a problem that the mouse picks up sound vibrations through cloth mouse pads and translates it into movement data, and your cursor moves.
Or how for some reason it tracks on the Z axis, god only knows why that happens...

If you want to know about gaming mice...you go to razerblueprints.net or http://hardware.gotfrag.com/portal/forums/64/ or maybe ES Reality.

TechPowerUp review mice, they find some of these problems...they don't cover all the areas I'm talking about, but they at least hit some of them.

I know they don't talk about lift off, or prediction.
Both of which are more on the minor side.

However when a mouse, like the G5, makes you look at the sky or the ground when you try to do a 180 (because you moved the mouse too fast, and it went crazy insane) that's a biggy, and other tech review sites picked that up. Not ExtremeTech...and then they get good mice to review, and give them low scores.

It's all due to poor tech knowledge of gaming mice though.
 
I'm going to miss ET, and the podcast. I always thought of them as one of the "grown-up" sites that didn't go nuts about being extreme for the sake of being extreme, but looked at practical ways to get the most performace from your dollar.

That's why I like H too. Neither site was going to tell you to spend $100 more on a card to score better on a synthetic benchmark.

They also wrote good articles, not just reviews. I didn't always agree with them, but I could always read and understand them - unfortunately that is not a given in this day and age.

Ziff Davis publishing has been in financial difficulty for awhile so I wasn't surprised, but it doesn't make it any easier to see ET close up shop.

And mice? Really? That's like saying you won't read Road and Track because they test too many silver cars.
 
I got their daily e-mails, but i hardly browsed the site unless the e-mails had enticing reads.
Their site design makes me wanna run over a box of kittens with a lawnmower.

Some of those names go way back in the PC world, the good thing about it all. You take what you learn from the failures, and you build something that will come back better than the previous. Thats how progress takes place and how bigger badder and better will ultimately come from it all.

If money's tight Kyle, can we maybe get Steve to pose in the bra for a 12 month calendar ? :D
 
Back
Top