Another Lawsuit Over Negative Comments

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Another lawsuit has been filed over negative comments made on the internet. Yesterday it was a model suing Google, today it is a chiropractor against Yelp. I'm almost scared to see what other lawsuits pop up by the end of the week. :eek:

"If Christopher loses then anyone on Yelp who writes a negative review better be careful," said Michael Blacksburg, an attorney representing Norberg. "This strikes at the heart of Yelp's business model and other Web sites that provide a bulletin board for people to state what they think of businesses in their community."
 
Just be very careful what you say on your website, Steve ;-)
 
As for the lawsuit, the doctor would have the rights to sue for defamation or slander if the patient posted made-up stuff about him. But if the doctor DID screw up and the patient is dissatisfied with his service, then he has the rights to post his opinion.

That pretty much goes for any form of speech. Slander, libel, and defamation of character is against the law, and has been for a long time.
 
As for the lawsuit, the doctor would have the rights to sue for defamation or slander if the patient posted made-up stuff about him. But if the doctor DID screw up and the patient is dissatisfied with his service, then he has the rights to post his opinion.

That pretty much goes for any form of speech. Slander, libel, and defamation of character is against the law, and has been for a long time.

It's a Chiropractor NOT a Physician.
 
Chiropractors are shady anyhow. I am not surprised. He thought the negative review cost him business before, he has no idea what he's getting himself into.

Heck, I would contact the auto insurance company and show them the disparity of the claim amounts. That's trying to scam insurance right there.
 
Heh - bill to a person $150, bill to an insurance company $550

"Biegel later called Norberg and explained that his office bills insurers at a higher rate than patients who pay for service directly."

"I did not do anything unethical or illegal in our entire dealings," Biegel wrote. "It has never been my policy or intention to take advantage of an individual or insurance company."

LOL, bill insurance at over 3x the rate you bill a noninsured person claiming it's because of the extra "paperwork" then say you never took advantage of the insurance company.
 
Heh - bill to a person $150, bill to an insurance company $550

"Biegel later called Norberg and explained that his office bills insurers at a higher rate than patients who pay for service directly."

"I did not do anything unethical or illegal in our entire dealings," Biegel wrote. "It has never been my policy or intention to take advantage of an individual or insurance company."

LOL, bill insurance at over 3x the rate you bill a noninsured person claiming it's because of the extra "paperwork" then say you never took advantage of the insurance company.

Um, for medical (not Chiropractic) actually yes you do bill insurance more than you bill cash pays. The reason is insurance always negotiates back and forth to a lower rate than what you originally billed. So in order to actually cover expenses by the end of the negotiation you have to bill them higher to begin with. That is unless they have medicare/medicaid or other government programs...then you are just fucked because you are going to get paid what the government wants which often doesn't cover the actual care costs.
 
I can see how this legally applies, but still sucks.

The internet is consumed by the masses so now it gets protection from the masses.
 
Well, I suppose it's a matter of opinion if you believe that trying to charge one person over 3 times as much as you would another person would be considered "trying to take advantage of them." I think that is trying to take advantage of somebody, apparently some people don't.
 
Well, I suppose it's a matter of opinion if you believe that trying to charge one person over 3 times as much as you would another person would be considered "trying to take advantage of them." I think that is trying to take advantage of somebody, apparently some people don't.

I think it is just more of a case of that is how it always works so people are viewing that as the normal practice instead of fraud. Its no different than a used car salesman or somebody selling a home jacking up the price as they know people are going to talk them down. They might send the insurance a bill for $500 but none would pay them that. They pay them what they think is fair so more likely than not they would only get $150 - $200 anyway from the insurance company.

Next time you go to the doctor look at what they charge your insurance and what they actually pay. A few years back I had my lip slip open and had to get stitches, due to its location the work had to be done by a plastic surgeon (or at least it was greatly suggested) to help ensure that my lip looked correct when it healed. To get the stitches removed I had to go to his office twice, they removed half one day let it heal a little more for a few days then removed the rest. That came to about $1800 for two visits. The insurance only paid about $900.
 
As for the lawsuit, the doctor would have the rights to sue for defamation or slander if the patient posted made-up stuff about him. But if the doctor DID screw up and the patient is dissatisfied with his service, then he has the rights to post his opinion.

You mean Libel as it is written not spoken.


But if the comments are infact true, that means no tort has been commited and as such, no case to sue.
 
I always wondered; why can libel be prosecuted, while some other more outrageous statements - written or spoken - are covered by your right to free speech?
 
Dentists, chiropractors, optometrists charging more for people who have insurance has been going on for years. Nothing new.
 
The fuck are these peoples problems? Yeah, I think you're a piece of shit...the fuck are you gonna do about it? Sue me? Try. :eek:
 
This is precisely why "health care" costs are skyrocketing... and bankrupting this country. Don't believe me? Medicare/Medicaid spending by the US Govt is now over $670B annually. That is more than 22% of the entire budget! Stack on top of that all these "questionable" billing practices going on for private insurers (which we are paying for!), and it is sickening. Our healthcare system is riddled with fraud, impropriety, waste, etc. It hurts every single one of us. :(
 
This is precisely why "health care" costs are skyrocketing... and bankrupting this country. Don't believe me? Medicare/Medicaid spending by the US Govt is now over $670B annually. That is more than 22% of the entire budget! Stack on top of that all these "questionable" billing practices going on for private insurers (which we are paying for!), and it is sickening. Our healthcare system is riddled with fraud, impropriety, waste, etc. It hurts every single one of us. :(

Actually no. Billing insurance at a cost higher than you bill cash pay is not why health care costs are sky rocketing.

Medicare/medicaid/government programs underpaying however does contribute to our operating costs that are then passed along to insurance and to cash pay since we have to make up that deficit or go out of business because we can't break even with large portions of our patients under paying.
 
that whole lawsuit thing is a complete waste of time. Good attempt at scare tactics....
 
Dentists, chiropractors, optometrists charging more for people who have insurance has been going on for years. Nothing new.

Depends on the place & insurance. I know my dentist that I've gone to and pay out of pocket charges me one rate, however my girlfriend who has MetLife (or something) negotiated rates with that same dentists that are significantly cheaper, and I'm not talking about the part she pays. Something like a deep cleaning on all 4 quadrants cost around $1000, however for her $600 is what the total bill is before the insurance company pays it's 80%
 
Actually no. Billing insurance at a cost higher than you bill cash pay is not why health care costs are sky rocketing.

Medicare/medicaid/government programs underpaying however does contribute to our operating costs that are then passed along to insurance and to cash pay since we have to make up that deficit or go out of business because we can't break even with large portions of our patients under paying.

Respectfully, I disagree. Are you telling me that there aren't huge amounts of practitioners out there who are over-billing the insurance companies and (especially) the govt? How can insurance filing administrative overhead justify 3x the cash payment method? How many needless tests are being run, or procedures with marginal benefit being executed? What you describe smacks of the Madoff ponzi scheme - just keep hitting up insurers for more $$ because opex exceeds revenue.

Seems to me there's a giant gravy train in healthcare and costs have exploded because of so many hands in the supply chain, and really ineffective auditing of the process. If consumers (especially those govt insured) had to pay the real costs, there would be a huge turnaround in the industry. Demand would drop like a rock. People would really start to scrutinize if procedures were necessary. Use generics vs. brand names drugs. This whole thing is ripe for reform... Tom Daschle certainly has his work cut out for him.
 
Respectfully, I disagree.

You can disagree all you want it doesn't make you right, and it certainly doesn't mean you know how the system works.

Are you telling me that there aren't huge amounts of practitioners out there who are over-billing the insurance companies and (especially) the govt?

The government, no we get our rates dictated to us. I already told you that. Did you chose not to read it?

How can insurance filing administrative overhead justify 3x the cash payment method?

I don't have this individuals books to see what his billing rates and codes are. Different codes bill at different rates. Now do we routinely bill at greater than cash pay or up to 2x to insurance companies? Of course and I already explained why. We have to negotiate to get paid AT ALL. If we start by billing at the base rate to just break even and not make any money when we bill insurance by the time we get paid after negotiation we would LOSE money. We lose money and go out of business, you suffer. Fat lot of good we can do you if we are out of business, no?

How many needless tests are being run, or procedures with marginal benefit being executed?

Can't speak for everyone but very few. You know why? We have to justify to insurance why in order to get paid. And you know what? Most people at the majority of insurance companies have a very limited grasp on what is actually needed. When we order things that are required but they won't pay and people fall through the cracks then WE are the bad guys for missing it. :rolleyes:

What you describe smacks of the Madoff ponzi scheme - just keep hitting up insurers for more $$ because opex exceeds revenue.

Well then you have no idea what a Ponzi scheme is. Listen one more time, Insurance NEVER pays us the billed at rate. It is a negotiating tool.

Seems to me there's a giant gravy train in healthcare and costs have exploded because of so many hands in the supply chain, and really ineffective auditing of the process. If consumers (especially those govt insured) had to pay the real costs, there would be a huge turnaround in the industry. Demand would drop like a rock. People would really start to scrutinize if procedures were necessary. Use generics vs. brand names drugs. This whole thing is ripe for reform... Tom Daschle certainly has his work cut out for him.

If the government had to pay real cost of health care then the cost of health care would go up. As for the rest of it, I am glad you have an opinion, now go work in the medical field where you have to see the books and run the business in addition to providing the services and come back to us. Then you will have an idea where the real problems are.

Edit: Also I am not saying this chiropractor isn't committing insurance fraud but discounting cash pay or negotiating fixed fee payments from the patient is not fraud.
 
If i were in this guys shoes my only defense to the judge would be ....LOL?!.....
 
Back
Top