Another iPhone App Rejection

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Another week, another iPhone app store rejection. The crime this time? The ability to read ‘objectionable’ material like The Kama Sutra.

To give a bit of background about Eucalyptus itself, it doesn’t ‘contain’ books any more than a newly bought iPod ‘contains’ songs. It provides an easy-to-use way to find and download classic books, then presents them a beautiful, readable (I would say the most beautiful, and most readable, but I’m biased of course) way. Check out the videos at eucalyptusapp.com if you haven’t seen them. The books are all text-only, and are directly downloaded from the archives of the well-respected Project Gutenberg.
 
Books are the most offensive part of the internet, lol. Especially text only.

Burn the internet.
 
What? You mean Apple couldn't find objectionable material for the Kindle app, or any of the other book readers that have been approved?
 
This is akin to book burning on the part of Apple.

It is no such thing.

It is Apple’s store they can sell what they wish, if you do not like the policy then do not buy Apple products… pretty simple huh.
 
What? You mean Apple couldn't find objectionable material for the Kindle app, or any of the other book readers that have been approved?
Odds are the guy who rejected this app just so happened to wake up on the wrong side of the bed that day. That's pretty much the only logical explanation for such a rejection.

The App Store really is completely out of control. You can't have developers pouring money into developing apps simply to have them be rejected because of restrictions that aren't universally enforced or because of restrictions that are entirely undocumented and undeclared.

Essentially, if your app is able to pull in external online data in any way, you need to be prepared for it to be rejected. At that point you'll need to contact various news organizations. Then Apple may re-evaluate the submission, and probably approve it, in an attempt to not look entirely foolish to its informed customers. Absolutely disastrous.
 
It is no such thing.

It is Apple’s store they can sell what they wish, if you do not like the policy then do not buy Apple products… pretty simple huh.
Na its about the same rules applying for every one, whit safari can you find mouths more and higher xxx rated content then this TEXT copy of the Kama Sutra.

Were talking here a bout classic text about love and sex, not pr0n photo's ore films i can find whit safari.

There freaking mad at apple, trying to be holier then the pope.
 
Censorship is un-fucking American... Apple, you should be ashamed of yourself.
 
You know what will stop this Apple Crap?

Someone develop a way to add apps to the iPhone WITHOUT the App Store.

Apple, screw thyself.
 
Man, I get shivers whenever I see someone write something like this.

Ok, fine. No one should ever speak their mind. After all, nothing ever changes when people speak their minds now, does it

It is no such thing.

It is Apple’s store they can sell what they wish, if you do not like the policy then do not buy Apple products… pretty simple huh.
 
You know what will stop this Apple Crap?

Someone develop a way to add apps to the iPhone WITHOUT the App Store.

Apple, screw thyself.

They already have, that's why Jailbreaking is such a popular thing - not that Jailbreaking makes it easy to do it, but it makes it possible. Actually adding the apps can require a bit more effort but still entirely possible.
 
It is no such thing.

It is Apple’s store they can sell what they wish, if you do not like the policy then do not buy Apple products… pretty simple huh.

Exactly, because book buring on the other hand is illegal.

oh.... wait....
 
How about we get an online movement going to remove Safari, because we can google the Karma Sutra? http://www.apple.com/webapps/feedback/ I can't believe that this app has been rejected three times now, because you can search for the keywords Karma Sutra. I am pretty sure you can search for the Ovid as well, is that going to be a reason to ban the app when they filter out the keywords Karma Sutra? I swear we are moving back into the middle ages. I love my iPhone, but I don't want my morals filtered and dictated to me by some douche at Apple HQ. My contract is coming up and I will be watching the Palm Pre a lot more closely, even if I hate Sprint. Obviously my defection means nothing, but since I am early adopter that a lot of people seem to follow, I can gurantee that if I defect at least 20-30 people will follow fairly quickly (AT&T gave me $700+ in kickbacks from all the people who switched when I switched to the iPhone, in those stupid ATT gift things... all of which expired almost immediatly). Hopefully, Sprint has a better referer program this time round.
 
It is no such thing.

It is Apple’s store they can sell what they wish, if you do not like the policy then do not buy Apple products… pretty simple huh.

You're right, and that's why more people don't. :) However, that isn't the focus of the problem. The problem is that Apple has hypocritical standards as to what flies and what doesn't.

You can go to iTunes and download movies chock full of sex and violence and other "adult scenarios". You can go to iTunes and download songs that are also chock full of graphic language consisting of sexual and violent content. But you can't read books of your choice on your iPhone, whether its Dr. Seuss or the Kama Sutra. the iPhone itself can play back any kind of material regardless of its content, yes? So theoretically it is no better than an app being rejected because you can use it to do a number of 'objectionable' things. The same applies to Macs. Yet those get put on the shelf without a second thought.

It's dumber than a box of hair to censor one thing and yet you will continue to serve up product that does what you censor others for.
 
Maybe the guy or woman responsible over at Apple for rejecting the app is a prude and doesn't like all that dirty talk of other sex positions than plain ol missionary. :D
 
This one time, I agree at this level. It sucks. There some things that are blalantly hipocritical like beeping curse words or a nipple but making tons of money on violent films, which most of the time just give criminals more ideas on how to cause more and more damage.
I'm tired of repeating this. No matter if its communism or capitalism. Freedom is being lost each day, in everywhich way you can imagine. The saddest part the most technology you get the easier it is to take freedom away.
Damn, Orwell was so right that even after I lived my entire chidlhood on a system like the one he describes I was amazed on the text of the fictituous book 1984 lead character reads on his "hideout room". Mostly the part on technology and the leveling of the society layers and how to avoid it.
 
It is no such thing.

It is Apple’s store they can sell what they wish, if you do not like the policy then do not buy Apple products… pretty simple huh.

Yep the problem is that thanks to that "Democratical Posture" you're so easily encouraging, most people do it anyways, because most PEOPLE DON'T CARE ABOUT BEING FREE. They just want their survival problems solved.

Check some history books and tell me how many societies and for how long have had something similar to Democracy.

Ergo, in a Democratical system. People are choosing NOT to be free. It's too much responsability over your shoulders. Not everyone can/want to be an alpha.
 
Yep the problem is that thanks to that "Democratical Posture" you're so easily encouraging, most people do it anyways, because most PEOPLE DON'T CARE ABOUT BEING FREE. They just want their survival problems solved.

Check some history books and tell me how many societies and for how long have had something similar to Democracy.

Ergo, in a Democratical system. People are choosing NOT to be free. It's too much responsability over your shoulders. Not everyone can/want to be an alpha.

Democratical isn't a word
 
The person that wrote the program is just whining. All he has to do is make the book search filter not include pornographic text.

“Applications must not contain any obscene, pornographic, offensive or defamatory content or materials of any kind (text, graphics, images, photographs, etc.), or other content or materials that in Apple’s reasonable judgement may be found objectionable by iPhone or iPod touch users.”


It breaks it, so just add a filter in and if it comes with 2000 ebooks make sure none of them are pornographic readings.
 
The application itself does not contain any objectionable material. There's a difference between creating an application that reads eBooks one can download and an application that's includes the Kama Sutra or some other "pornographic" content. The Kindle application can download the exact same book, but it was never rejected by the App Store. Why?

If Apple's going to make judgements about app submissions based on so-called objectionable content, they need to be both reasonable and fair. If this app isn't allowed, the Kindle app should be removed. If the Kindle app is still okay, then this app needs to be approved. This constant inconsistency (oxymoronic a bit, yeah) is what's driving app developers away and, ultimately, hurting the iPhone/touch platform.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
It is no such thing.

It is Apple’s store they can sell what they wish, if you do not like the policy then do not buy Apple products… pretty simple huh.

this made me shiver with disgust when i read it.
 
I do not believe this is about censorship of "objectionable" content. I believe it is about Apple seeing Eucalyptus as a competing 'text browser.' No, it doesn't make any sense but then, Apple and Microsoft still believe they can direct the development of computing and the internet.
 
Back
Top