Another, "How's this build look" thread (with some questions)

Kuo

Gawd
Joined
Jun 7, 2001
Messages
641
Heh, I guess we're just all insecure in finalizing our decisions w/o consulting the collective minds of the [H] community :)

Although this time, I'm not completly finalized yet - got some grey areas I'm hoping for some suggestions about.

To start, this system is for a friend who doesn't intend on upgrading in 5 years. His current machine is a 500 mhz p3 or something, and he really hasn't had many complaints about it (just to give you an idea that when he says 5 years, he generally means it). He uses the machine mostly for office stuff, watching movies, and very light gaming (I just recently got him hooked to World of Warcraft though, but he use to only play games from the early 90s, the good old days).

His budget is $750 bucks and he does NOT need a monitor, speakers, input devices, and hard drive (so that's 750 for CPU, RAM, Mobo, Case+PSU, HSF, Optical Drive, misc).

This is what I'm looking at;

ANTEC SLK3700AMB Case w/ 350W PSU - $62
NEC 16X Double Layer DVD±RW Drive, Model ND-3520A BK - $63
Corsair Value Select (Dual Pack) 184 Pin 512MBx2 DDR PC-3200 - $134
GIGABYTE "GA-K8NS Ultra-939" NVIDIA nForce3 ULTRA Chipset Motherboard For AMD Socket 939 CPU -RETAIL - $116
AMD Athlon 64 3000+, 512KB L2 Cache, Socket 939 64-bit Processor - Retail - $162
MSI nVIDIA GeForce 6600GT Video Card, 128MB DDR3, 128-Bit, DVI/TV-Out, PCI-Express, Model "NX6600GT-TD128E" -RETAIL - $187

Shipping - 23
Total - 747

Now, before people comment, I do know that the Gigabyte board is AGP, while that card I have specced is PCIe.

Here's the decision I'm facing. 754 vs 939, PCIe vs AGP (I'm sure actually this is everyone's decision at some point). If he was going to upgrade, I'll go 939 and PCIe. However, in the case that he isn't, i'm debating on these alternatives:

754 + PCIe, so in the case that 2-3 years from now he finds himself wanting to play some new game, he can grab a good video card, which wil probably be PCIe, and just plug it into his machine.
939 + AGP, just because I like the dual channel support for 939 and whatever scalability it might provide him (although what, I'm not sure), and AGP because in 2 years, today's high end AGP will be a cheap upgrade.

Right now, I'm leaning on keeping that build but replacing the card w/ the old, but trusted ATI 9600XT, which will shave off 20-30 bucks for him (afterall, I'm still using a GF4 TI4200 with no problem, so I can see him using the 9600XT in 4-5 years too).

Any suggestions, input, and other things I should take into account? Thanks.
 
I'd get a better case and PSU for starters. Get 939 whatever you do. PCI-E vs AGP won't be important for a long time anyway.
 
I'll echo what BossNoodle says to a degree. If your friend doesn't upgrade very often, maybe get him to spend a bit of extra cash on a case that he can be happy with 5 years from now. I'm guessing the case you specified comes with an Antec PSU though, which I would suggest should be ok for use with a 6600GT.

Go 939 and PCI-e if you can. After all, he may not want to upgrade for a long time, but what's the point in shooting himself in the foot in advance? Requirements change, so at least leave the option open if it's not throwing the budget out too much. Socket 754 is limited to a 3700+, while with a 939 the sky is currently the limit.

The 9600XTs seem to command a hefty price still for some reason, even though they are comprehensively outgunned by the 6600GT. The gamer in me screams for you not to make this concession by dropping to the XT, but if your friend is really unlikely to ever want to play games, the 9600XT will still play older stuff pretty well. On the other hand, if he's spending a lot of time on WoW, the 6600GT may well pay for itself in terms of the added enjoyment of running higher resolutions and more smoothly to boot.

The 1Gb RAM is a definite.

You seem to know your products, so I'm sure your friend will get the right system for his budget in the end :)
 
BossNoodleKaboodle said:
I'd get a better case and PSU for starters. Get 939 whatever you do. PCI-E vs AGP won't be important for a long time anyway.

Could you explain why he should get 939? I'm facing the same dillema that he is with 754 vs. 939 and AGP vs. PCI-E. I don't plan to upgrade for quite awhile. I had my last computer for 4 years and the only reason I'm upgrading now is because my motherboard just died. Right now I am thinking about going 754 and getting a 3400+ which will lastme longer than a 939 w/3200+ at the same price. As far as AGP vs. PCI-E, I don't plan on upgrading my video card right this moment. I would like to save up, wait for prices to come down a little, and get myself a good video card that'll last me awhile. If I go PCI-E, that means I'll be without a video card because I won't be able to use my AGP card. If I go AGP, I'm afraid I'll miss out on a future video card (such as Radeon X800 XL which is PCI-E only). Any reccomendations?
 
If I remember correctly, 939's support dual channel memory and 754's do not. Thats the only reason I'd say 939. AGP vs PCI-E isn't going to be a factor until after AGP 4X is insufficient for the best cards... which it is still more than enough bandwidth for any modern card.
 
BossNoodleKaboodle said:
If I remember correctly, 939's support dual channel memory and 754's do not. Thats the only reason I'd say 939. AGP vs PCI-E isn't going to be a factor until after AGP 4X is insufficient for the best cards... which it is still more than enough bandwidth for any modern card.

That is what I thought too. However, I was also told that the difference using the 64-bit architecture is a lot less noticable than during the nforce days. Meaning, the need for dual-channel memory using 64 bit chips is not as important as back when we were choosing nforce chipsets.
 
BossNoodleKaboodle said:
I'd get a better case and PSU for starters. Get 939 whatever you do. PCI-E vs AGP won't be important for a long time anyway.


i agree, and its a shame i spent 300 dollars on a agp card, when there at the end of there span
LOL
 
Firebomb said:
i agree, and its a shame i spent 300 dollars on a agp card, when there at the end of there span
LOL

The problem is from what I'm seeing, 939 + PCIe is beyond the budget.
 
Buying any current socket CPU that will be outdated by the end of the year when dual cores come out isn' a good idea, in my opinion. If you really want it now, go cheap so you can get something worthwhile in a few months.
 
Kuo said:
That is what I thought too. However, I was also told that the difference using the 64-bit architecture is a lot less noticable than during the nforce days. Meaning, the need for dual-channel memory using 64 bit chips is not as important as back when we were choosing nforce chipsets.


The 64 bit amd chips love their memory bandwidth, the more you can feed them the better.
 
From my experience any time you upgrade a pc that is 2 to 3 years old you will have to upgrade nearly everything anyways.

Want proof just look at the p4 proc socket sizes changed what three times 4**, 478, 775.

Two years is a long time. Look to build yourself a good box and expect to replace most of the parts the next time you upgrade.
 
placeboFx said:
From my experience any time you upgrade a pc that is 2 to 3 years old you will have to upgrade nearly everything anyways.

Want proof just look at the p4 proc socket sizes changed what three times 4**, 478, 775.

Two years is a long time. Look to build yourself a good box and expect to replace most of the parts the next time you upgrade.

If that is the case, then wouldn't picking the 754 + AGP be a good choice? Or the 939 + AGP as I have provided as an option.

He says he won't upgrade in 5 years -- but if he does, I see the upgrade in 2-3 years. By your logic then, it won't make a difference if he goes 754 or 939, or AGP or PCIe for that matter.

So you just get the "best for your buck" in today's time, disregarding prospect of scalability in future (which I think is the argument FOR 939 + PCIe)
 
I'm now leaning towards 939 3200+ and AGP. It will allow me to do what i want now and if I ever decide to go to PCI-E, I can just swap out the motherboard without having to purchase a new CPU. It also gives me the option to overclock the 3200+ if I feel it is starting to become slow.
 
The comment about upgrading after 3 years and needing to replace everythign anyway struck home and had me thinking last night..

If that really is the case, how about just going 754 + AGP, saving the money, and possibly even upgrading the proc from 3000+ to 3200+.

Then there's the question: Which is better, having dual channel support (the 939), or the 200 Mhz difference w/o dual channel.
 
Dual channel is nearly irrelevant to anything but synthetic benchmarks, since the memory controller is on-die (I think)
 
Everyone knows this already, but the 939 is smaller. It generates a lot less heat, as well. It is just overall much better. It is, as stated before, the current size from AMD so you will have some really nice upgrade options in the future. Also, seeing as how AGP is still live and kicking right now, its not really an issue. However, in five years, that may (and most likely) will no longer be true.

So you can future-proof your friends machine and he will spend a LOT less in the future when it comes to upgrading. Shop around and you can find some really good prices on items to cut down on the cost. Shaving 10 bucks off of shipping helps, so use places like ZZF that offer free (2nd day which is even better) shipping on everything. I find a lot of items come out cheaper than newegg (which overcharges on certain items, but they are usually the best of the best in terms of service so its expected) even though ZZF may have that same item priced a little higher JUST because of the free shipping.

I just built myself a gaming machine and though I could have gotten what I needed for what I play right now, I went ahead and did that but also future-proofed (As much as one can when dealing with this type of ever-changing market) my machine as much as I can. So while I will pay more right now, a year or two from now when I go to upgrade (or 5 in your friends case), I will pay a lot less because I have all of the now-industry standards already such as PCI-E and 939.

Then again 5 years is a very long time for computers - its really hard to predict what will be the stanard, what will last, what will be here for a year with a lot of hype, and what will flop.
 
Kuo said:
If that is the case, then wouldn't picking the 754 + AGP be a good choice? Or the 939 + AGP as I have provided as an option.

He says he won't upgrade in 5 years -- but if he does, I see the upgrade in 2-3 years. By your logic then, it won't make a difference if he goes 754 or 939, or AGP or PCIe for that matter.

So you just get the "best for your buck" in today's time, disregarding prospect of scalability in future (which I think is the argument FOR 939 + PCIe)


I built my first pc trying to make it last for at least five years. Well after spending around 3000
I have two 500 celerons, 512mg stick sdram, tnt2 video card, mobo etc. which sit nicely in a box somewhere.

BTW I use the 99 dollar Chaintech zn-250 or something and the amd s754 300+, that plus
some corsair 512 pc 3200 was like $256.
I sometimes think about why I didn't get the 939, but the 939 owners will be saying "Why didn't I wait for the blah blah socket with dual core tech" It never ends.

I'm not dissing the UBER system builders! You guys kick booty. I just can't afford it.

I bought the s754 platform amd64 with AGP gf6800 gt. It will play doom3, hl2, farcry and whatever else I throw at it. As far as holding the performance crown forget it.

I would look at what you want to play for the next year or so. Build a system to match then save up about $50 a month an in a year you have six hundred to help you upgrade. Or just blow most of you tax return like i do.

Hope this helps.
 
After much consideration of all the wonderful input and suggestions here, I've revised my specs and come up with an almost final decision.

Took me a while cause someone else messaged me an equivalently budgetted Intel build, and it became a direct comparison between Intel 3.0 and AMD 3200+, where I picked the 3200+ for the same price.

ANTEC Solution Series Super Mid Tower Case with 350W Power Supply, Model "SLK3700AMB" - Retail 62 + 13 = 75
NEC 16X Double Layer DVD±RW Drive, Black, Model ND-3520A BK, OEM 64 + 3.5 = 67.5
Corsair Value Select (Dual Pack) 184 Pin 512MBx2 DDR PC-3200 - OEM 134 + 4 = 138
DFI "Lanparty UT NF3 250Gb" NVIDIA nForce3 Chipset Motherboard for AMD Socket 754 CPU -RETAIL 106 + 3 = 109
Rosewill ATI RADEON 9600XT Video Card, 256MB DDR, 128-Bit, DVI/TV-Out, 8X AGP, Model "RW96XT-256D" -RETAIL 149 + 5 = 154
AMD Athlon 64 3200+, 512k L2 Cache, The Only 64-bit Windows Compatible Processor - Retail 191

Total: 734.50
 
BossNoodleKaboodle said:
I'd still get a better PSU than the one that comes in that case.

Do you have any personal experience w/ this case's PSU? I always was under the assumption that Antec PSUs were good (one of the reasons I actually picked this case) - this one comes w/ an Antec Smart Power 350W PSU
 
You should see the forum section for PSU's. I've only used one Antec in a build I did for someone, but it wasn't the Smart Power, it was a True Power, which is what I'm pretty sure that case comes with. The Smart Power series from Antec is their low-end and might be too weak if you upgrade further.

The case is just plain nasty on the outside though. I do have experience with that. The door is easy to break right off. You'd be better off with the $140 or so SOHO Server case from Antec with a True Power 430 installed if you want Antec that much.

You could even get a good little Enermax 350W PSU which has a 26A 12v line and stick it in whatever case you want, if you want a good budget PSU.
 
I know it seems like I'm asking everytime I make a change, but after sleeping on the case/psu question for some time, I've decided to make the suggested change. Looking around at other reviews/forums/etc., I've switched to a more "generic" case (yet awarded Editor's Choice for budget cases from Anandtech) and a reliable 350W Fortron PSU (recommended from [H]'s PSU forums).

Here's the final build with links:
Codegen case 6209
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=11-182-048&depa=0 32 + 16 = 48

Power Supply
Fortron 350W ATX12V Power Supply 42 + 7 = 49
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=17-104-966&depa=0

NEC 16X Double Layer DVD±RW Drive, Silver, Model ND-3520A, OEM 61 + 3.5 = 64.5
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=27-152-040&depa=0

Corsair Value Select (Dual Pack) 184 Pin 512MBx2 DDR PC-3200 - OEM 142
http://www.zipzoomfly.com/jsp/ProductDetail.jsp?ProductCode=80098-21&ps=ho1

DFI "Lanparty UT NF3 250Gb" NVIDIA nForce3 Chipset Motherboard for AMD Socket 754 CPU -RETAIL
http://www.newegg.com/app/viewProductDesc.asp?description=13-136-147&depa=0 106 + 3 = 109
http://www.buyxg.com/store/item.asp?key=MB-145-127 98

Rosewill ATI RADEON 9600XT Video Card, 256MB DDR, 128-Bit, DVI/TV-Out, 8X AGP, Model "RW96XT-256D" -RETAIL 149 + 3 = 152
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=14-164-027&depa=0

AMD Athlon 64 3200+, 512k L2 Cache, The Only 64-bit Windows Compatible Processor - Retail 190
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=19-103-483&depa=0

Total: 743.50 or 754.50
(depending on which vendor for mobo)
 
Back
Top