Android Tablets are a Failure

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Isn’t it a bit premature to say Android tablets are a failure? I have to admit though, I laughed a little when the author of the article said Android phones are “not open source at all, but carrier crapware.”

This is the lesson Google needs to learn, and learn fast. Don’t trust your competitor to treat your customers right. Never bet your company on carrier goodwill or carrier promises.
 
He's just plagiarizing what Steve Jobs said in last month's Apple conference call, almost word for word.

Sad when "journalism" has shrunk to such levels, truly sad.
 
actually android tablets have pretty much been a complete failure so far... I ordered a bunch of different ones to test for a client and they were all garbage... half of them BARELY work, the rest are either too slow or too crappy to be of any use... dont know wtf lord steve (jobs) said but this is from personal experience
 
actually android tablets have pretty much been a complete failure so far... I ordered a bunch of different ones to test for a client and they were all garbage... half of them BARELY work, the rest are either too slow or too crappy to be of any use... dont know wtf lord steve (jobs) said but this is from personal experience
Hopefully the outlook is different when 3.0 is released.
 
The two critical features of tablets are that they are held in your hands and they are bigger than a phone. This means to me that not everyone wants to carry them around with them == no need to pay a carrier ungodly amounts of money each month. This also means that as long as you are getting data from wifi instead of 3G, carriers are irrelevant.

Second. This is where the non-open source crowd gets to learn that "open" does not mean OSI approved and why it should matter to them. GPLv2 is all well and good (and it is essentially impossible to change the linux 2.x kernal to GPLv3), but allows hardware makers to lock down the product to only accept signed images (Tivo is famous for this). GPLv3 puts an end to such foolishness and is what end users should want. "More free" licenses (such as the Apache license 1.x used in Android) usually mean that anyone building on this software (especially via hardware) can remove all said freedom from the end user (there is one so far that has locked Bing as the search engine: good job google). This is what Microsoft meant when they said "good open source", i.e. they get high quality debugged code for no cost and charge their users monopoly pricing (see BSD TCP/IP stack, internet explorer 1.x, and others).
 
I wouldn't say they are a failure just yet. I would say that there hasn't been an android tablet that has succeeded. They are all trying to play catch up to the iPad. Unfortunately, no one has released anything that works as nicely for the consumer while still being in the same price range.

Apple had a distinct advantage. It had all of these developers clamoring to release apps. Even if someone releases an android tablet that has the same specs for the same price, Apple still has the apps to break the tie. It's going to be an uphill battle for android in this field.
 
Funny... all the android tablets I have seen do all the things the ipad does...... for half the price. And the apps are cheaper usually too on android.

Not to mention the BEST of the android tablets are set to come out VERY soon (Archos Android is all you need to google). Archos has made quite a few reputable, well reviewed tablets.....

So yeah, whoever wrote this article is either

A) Apple fanboy and/or a shill for Apple

B) Idiot whom is talking out of his rectum
 
Laughable...

This part definitely shows the writer does not know squat about android much..

This follows the growing awareness on the part of cognescenti that Android phones are not open source at all, but carrier crapware. Android as a whole is being seen as a failure.

That is just laughable.... hahahah so wrong
 
I have to agree with the rest. Android just isn't strong on the tablet as it is. This should (hopefully) change with 3.0 since it was designed with the tablet in mind.

I'll love to see what comes out in the next year or so once 3.0 has been established. Hopefully it'll be cheaper then the ipad and just as competitive in available software.
 
The issue with android tablets (and any open-source platform) is that there is a rush to market by cheap providers.
Just look at the tablet you can get at Walgreens.... A poor implementation of the android OS reflects poorly on android itself (at least in the minds of most consumers)
Android is a great option but needs some quality hardware, and thoughfully designed hardware, in the tablet market before people will see its capabilities.
 
That article was full of fail. Android phones are, in my personal experience and everyone I have talked to, better than the iPhone. It is easier to customize and get rid of software and it can be rooted partially to get rid of crapware and add even more functionality. So right off the bat I see this article going downhill when the author can't even get his base premise started.

Now with the Google tablets, they are brand new and haven't been fully invested in. No carrier is going to have a polished product right off the bat. It took a little bit to get Android phones more polished and it will be the same with the tablet. The key is that it is still a far more accessible and versatile platform than the iPad. So I really don't buy into any of the jibberish spoken in the article. Comparing the Google to Hayes? That is ridiculous. Saying crapware is going to be the downfall of the tablet? That is just as ridiculous to me. Many people buy computers with crapware and oh btw, since when "doesn't" Apple include crapware on their devices when they come with all the Apple bloatware programs...
 
actually android tablets have pretty much been a complete failure so far... I ordered a bunch of different ones to test for a client and they were all garbage... half of them BARELY work, the rest are either too slow or too crappy to be of any use... dont know wtf lord steve (jobs) said but this is from personal experience

You're aware that Google itself has said that the current Android OS is not suitable for tablets, yes? And that most of what has been released has been low end crap from off brand makers, yes?

When you buy crap, you get crap.
 
The author to me is a biased idiot. I agree with all the above comments. Give it some more time. Then we can see how well android can flex its muscles. 2 years is young in terms of an os. How long has apple been working on there operating system(s) for?
 
You're aware that Google itself has said that the current Android OS is not suitable for tablets, yes? And that most of what has been released has been low end crap from off brand makers, yes?

When you buy crap, you get crap.

Yes...which is why what has been put out so far is a complete failure. The article isn't claiming they always will be a failure. It's saying that it's been 7 months since the ipad release and the android offerings are still terrible.
 
The author to me is a biased idiot. I agree with all the above comments. Give it some more time. Then we can see how well android can flex its muscles. 2 years is young in terms of an os. How long has apple been working on there operating system(s) for?

The iphone OS is only 3 years old.
 
Many people buy computers with crapware.../QUOTE]
Are you making the argument here that because people buy computers with crapware, the pre-installation of crapware on brand new devices is an acceptable practice?
 
This follows the growing awareness on the part of cognescenti that Android phones are not open source at all, but carrier crapware. Android as a whole is being seen as a failure.

Well, that Android is being seen as a failure is total bullshit but I actually have to agree with his point that Android phones arent open source. The Android OS itself is open source, true, but the phones arent. Remember the locked Motorola bootloader? Sucks big time!
If Android phones werent carrier crapware we would be able to get our updates directly from Google and wouldnt have to pray to our carriers for updates.
Yea, I know there are exceptions like the Nexus One, but sadly there only are a few...
 
Funny... all the android tablets I have seen do all the things the ipad does...... for half the price. And the apps are cheaper usually too on android.

Not to mention the BEST of the android tablets are set to come out VERY soon (Archos Android is all you need to google). Archos has made quite a few reputable, well reviewed tablets.....

So yeah, whoever wrote this article is either

A) Apple fanboy and/or a shill for Apple

B) Idiot whom is talking out of his rectum

Definitely. A.

To further prove the point.... look at the obvious paid-for Apple Mac article on the front page of zdnet. "I'm switching to Mac" ----- ahhahaha, what a shitty site zdnet is.

I will never, ever (rarely do anyways) use zdnet for anything now.

Failure article, the guy has been writing for years and sadly does not know jack all about android's capabilities in its open source fashion.


(((PS STEVE: please quit posting articles from biased, or outlandishly horribly writen websites PLEASE)))
 
Apple most definitely has a hand in this websites' pocket (zdnet you are not good).......

Just look at the numerous frontpage articles, so obviously paid for by Apple.

"Google is stealing your webpages"
--- ??? wtf? ahhaha

"I am switching to Mac"
---- obviously paid for by mac, its the FIRST thing on the main page (with a huge pic of course!)

"Apple brings beatles to itunes" ---- come the F&@#K on zdnet... be more obvious that Apple pays you guys!

ZDNET = Failure, hands down, Captain Obvious, Apple Shill of a site

You might as well just change it to APPLENET
 
You know, the article may be a bit scattered and confused, but the guy is not completely wrong at all. Comm Carrier's are the most short-sited, quick-profit, anti-consumer group of people I can think of in today's world.
 
The two critical features of tablets are that they are held in your hands and they are bigger than a phone. This means to me that not everyone wants to carry them around with them == no need to pay a carrier ungodly amounts of money each month. This also means that as long as you are getting data from wifi instead of 3G, carriers are irrelevant.

Second. This is where the non-open source crowd gets to learn that "open" does not mean OSI approved and why it should matter to them. GPLv2 is all well and good (and it is essentially impossible to change the linux 2.x kernal to GPLv3), but allows hardware makers to lock down the product to only accept signed images (Tivo is famous for this). GPLv3 puts an end to such foolishness and is what end users should want. "More free" licenses (such as the Apache license 1.x used in Android) usually mean that anyone building on this software (especially via hardware) can remove all said freedom from the end user (there is one so far that has locked Bing as the search engine: good job google). This is what Microsoft meant when they said "good open source", i.e. they get high quality debugged code for no cost and charge their users monopoly pricing (see BSD TCP/IP stack, internet explorer 1.x, and others).


nice thing is the device can be rooted and de-binged just as easily
 
the real android tablets havent even come out yet. everything out now is a hack that google doesn't even endorse. they use a phone OS.

we are still two steps away.

android 2.3 gingerbread has to come out. but no, that isn't for tablets either. then after that, android 3.0 honeycomb with the new gui and tablet support will come out.

so only in Q1 will there be real android tablets to judge. not just big phone hacks.
 
Yes...which is why what has been put out so far is a complete failure. The article isn't claiming they always will be a failure. It's saying that it's been 7 months since the ipad release and the android offerings are still terrible.

Huh... complete means finished, done, at the end... To say a "complete failure" at this point is absurd, words means things and Android tablets are in their infancy and not complete is any way or form. Goggle has stated Android is not even ready for tablets yet, hardly complete huh.

The author of that drivel is clearly a Apple tool or a moron.
 
Huh... complete means finished, done, at the end... To say a "complete failure" at this point is absurd, words means things and Android tablets are in their infancy and not complete is any way or form.
"Complete" is also synonymous with "total". As in encompassing every component or aspect. In that respect the description could be accurate because, to this point, no Android tablet has proven successful.
 
"Apple brings beatles to itunes" ---- come the F&@#K on zdnet... be more obvious that Apple pays you guys!

ZDNET = Failure, hands down, Captain Obvious, Apple Shill of a site

You might as well just change it to APPLENET

Itunes (which has almost 90% digital music marketshare) getting the beatles albums (arguably the most popular music ever) is one of the most popular stories on google news at the moment (only eclipsed by the prince william engagement) and when a tech site reports it they must be getting paid? You may want to re-evaluate who's the shill.
 
(several posts of ravings)

someone piss in your Cheerios this morning? This forum is just as biased as some other review sites in case you haven't noticed.

The guy's right. You see iPads everywhere but nobody's got Android tablets. So yes, so far, Android tablets are failures.

Doesn't mean they might improve down the road, and I hope they do because competition also brings improvements. Who knows, some features in the iPhone 4 might not have surfaced if Android phones weren't around to up the ante. Android hardware manufacturers need to get on the ball and come up with something better. Perhaps talk to HP about making an Android Slate lineup.
 
Tablets as a whole seem like a dumb idea to me, I could never find use for one.

For some they may be a dumb idea, but as components shrink, use less power, produce "more GB's" :D they will chip into the netbook market and possibly crush them completely. These are commoditized pieces of hardware that in 2 to 3 years won't be worth $50. For people who just want to read, surf, email, and do light - medium duty work, these devices will fit the bill. They are simply a transition from smaller handheld devices like mobiles now to larger versions with more power and more battery.
 
someone piss in your Cheerios this morning? This forum is just as biased as some other review sites in case you haven't noticed.

The guy's right. You see iPads everywhere but nobody's got Android tablets. So yes, so far, Android tablets are failures.

Doesn't mean they might improve down the road, and I hope they do because competition also brings improvements. Who knows, some features in the iPhone 4 might not have surfaced if Android phones weren't around to up the ante. Android hardware manufacturers need to get on the ball and come up with something better. Perhaps talk to HP about making an Android Slate lineup.

The Android OS, as it stands right now, isn't really good for tablets. Won't be until Google releases 3.0, which is what Google is promising will be the one to use in Android tablets. So unless the manufactures make custom UIs (ugh) for the tablets they're not likely to be a hit.
 
The Android OS, as it stands right now, isn't really good for tablets. Won't be until Google releases 3.0, which is what Google is promising will be the one to use in Android tablets. So unless the manufactures make custom UIs (ugh) for the tablets they're not likely to be a hit.

Yeah I know, but as you said, unless a manufacturer makes a really nice GUI that makes up for 2.x's lack of Tablet-friendliness it might be forgivable. HP's a great example in my post because their TouchSmart GUI isn't too shabby and can probably be accommodated to work with Android since it's probably Flash or Java based.
 
Hopefully the outlook is different when 3.0 is released.

The Samsung unit is quite nice.

Don't like the build on your crap from some Chinese no name sweat shop? Sync and build your own flavor. Or don't buy Chinese crap.

As to not open source. LOL. I'm running Cyanogen 6.1 RC1.

Quick fanboys. where do I get the community's best iOS build? Oh. Wait.
 
You're aware that Google itself has said that the current Android OS is not suitable for tablets, yes? And that most of what has been released has been low end crap from off brand makers, yes?

When you buy crap, you get crap.

thats nice, but when a customer says I want an android tablet because I read about it in some magazine for CEO's and you give them one of those crap tablets thats on the market right now... well, it wont end well

so android tablets are a complete failure right now...

maybe when 3.0 comes out and someone makes some hardware that does not suck or cost more than an iPad things will be different (I hope so as I like the idea of an android tablet a lot more than an iPad... I still <3 my G1)
 
thats nice, but when a customer says I want an android tablet because I read about it in some magazine for CEO's and you give them one of those crap tablets thats on the market right now... well, it wont end well

so android tablets are a complete failure right now...

maybe when 3.0 comes out and someone makes some hardware that does not suck or cost more than an iPad things will be different (I hope so as I like the idea of an android tablet a lot more than an iPad... I still <3 my G1)

Lenovo is releasing an Android 3.0 tablet before the end of March. So maybe they'll get it right.
 
Back
Top