Android Is Almost Impenetrable To Malware

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Android is almost impenetrable to malware? That is exactly what this guy is saying and he has charts, graphs and other stuff to prove it.

Until now, Google hasn’t talked about malware on Android because it did not have the data or analytic platform to back its security claims. But that changed dramatically today when Google’s Android Security chief Adrian Ludwig reported data showing that less than an estimated 0.001% of app installations on Android are able to evade the system’s multi-layered defenses and cause harm to users.
 
Genetid diversity makes things resistent to viruses. Android devices. No two are alike.
 
This is the sort of article that makes me squirm.

- Headline is a statement/insinuation that is not actually made at all in the article.

- The article is largely based on someone with an agenda. Gee, Google director/employee claiming Google's Android has high security. Big news there!

- The image of the layers of defense is annoying. From left to right: Google play is fallible (and has been). Unknown Source Warning can be clicked through by the user. Install Confirmation can be clicked through by the user. Verify Apps Consent and Verify Apps Warning same deal. I mean, seriously, no user I know has ever looked at such warnings, and been informed enough to back out of a potential problem install/app.

- Article claims Apple's track record is excellent for being locked down, which is weird since for a long time almost everything ran with local root-equiv privileges. I don't think their "locked" culture has anything at all to do with security.

- Verify Apps is cool, but let's not get all fappity-fapping about it. It's still a data set of signatures of known malware. The same sort of thing the industry and IT (and other lame articles) have complained about for the last 20 years.


I will say, at least Ludwig has a good point that he's trying to make, which is just that he has data to illustrate the frequency of malware installations, and it's not as large as most researchers assume, since they lack this sort of data. In some ways, Google's amassing of data on our behavior/devices can serve good purposes and not just be used to drive profits with users as products.
 
I think that that whole statement is retarded.

I can almost guarantee you that this person has never just gone and willy nilly installed free apps from the play store.

A lot of the crap programs seem to not do any real harm except pop up ads all the time, constantly spam you with stuff, and slow the phone down to a crawl.

That being said, it is still malware and any publisher/person that submits that type of crap to the play store should be banned for life.
 
less than an estimated 0.001% of app installations on Android are able to evade the system’s multi-layered defenses and cause harm to users.

How many cause harm to users without evading the multi-layered defenses?

How many app installations fail to report home? (and may or may not case harm to users with or without evading multi-layered defenses)
 
Genetid diversity makes things resistent to viruses. Android devices. No two are alike.

I wouldn't call Android secure, because you can root any phone. Then again, you can jailbreak any iOS device. With Android though, each device needs it's own exploit to get it rooted. With iOS though, once a jailbreak is released then it'll work for all devices with the exception to iPhone 4's and under which have a CPU exploitation.

Android's diversity no only annoys app developers, but malware developers more so. Cause you probably need root to be effective, and not every device roots the same. Even then, the user still has to allow root access to the application. Anyone smart enough to get root on their phone is probably smart enough to never give root to applications they never installed.
 
I can agree with this statement, but the whole appeal of android (vs ios) is all the stuff you can do after you have enabled root access, and bypassed the biggest parts of security.
 
If you create a subset of what's generally called "malware" I guess you can exclude all kind of malicious apps. :p At least he mentions this half-way into the article, well beyond what an average news posting aggregator would read :p:

Based on the data from tracking over one and a half billion app installs Google obtained convincing evidence that the rate of “potentially harmful apps” installed is stable at about 1,200 per million app installs, or about 0.12%. The classification “potentially harmful apps” include both malware and false positive detections of malware. Often benign software apps have behaviors or characteristics resembling malware.
 
Cool stuff, but I won't be surprised if someone proves them wrong in the near future though, I'm just wondering if the claims are true because of the different versions of android out there too. :D, anyway with the popularity of the OS I really won't be surprised if he is proven wrong.
 
I think they are correct. Goggle pays hackers to find exploits in it's products. Go goggle!
 
If you create a subset of what's generally called "malware" I guess you can exclude all kind of malicious apps. :p At least he mentions this half-way into the article, well beyond what an average news posting aggregator would read :p:

That's a superset, not a subset, as it included false positives.

But there really isn't a general definition of "malware", it varies so much it's absurd. Hopefully Google clarifies what they are considering harmful applications and other AV vendors do the same.

- The article is largely based on someone with an agenda. Gee, Google director/employee claiming Google's Android has high security. Big news there!

Well sure, but the ones claiming Android is malware infested also have an agenda - those reports are put out by AV companies whose very existence hinges on there being malware.

I mean, seriously, no user I know has ever looked at such warnings, and been informed enough to back out of a potential problem install/app.

And yet: "Only 0.12% of users chose to ignore the warnings and install potentially hazardous apps."

So you either know particularly stupid people, or you don't know a representative sample of people.
 
Cool stuff, but I won't be surprised if someone proves them wrong in the near future though, I'm just wondering if the claims are true because of the different versions of android out there too. :D, anyway with the popularity of the OS I really won't be surprised if he is proven wrong.
his claims are based on how much malware comes from the google play store
that is, how much malware is installed when people go through official sources

it doesn't include all of the cracked versions of those apps...where we'd tend to find most of the malware

those apps don't call back to google and aren't counted in the official data he's using.
he's saying a popular app like Titanium Backup isn't going to get past their multi-layer security if it's downloaded from the google play store. but some small sliver of people are going to find TitanyumBackup on a search and install it with whatever malware it has so it's really not a huge problem. But ignores all of the cracked TitaniumBackup installs out there with unknown code slipped into them.
 
Back
Top