Android Apps May Pass Apple's by August

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
If the current trend remains the same, Android Market is scheduled to surpass Apple’s App Store total number of Apps available sometime around August. The reason is quite simple: Android is increasing the number of Apps and the App Store numbers are decreasing.
 
Having had the opportunity to jailbreak a friends iPhone, I can really see why this trend is moving in the Android direction. The process to jailbreak isn't as easy as the Android, and in the end it's like you turned the iPhones iOS into Linux. Cydia provides a repository system for god sakes.

Eventually there's going to be a point when Apple completely blocks jailbreak. At least for a few months. That will certainly be the death of the iPhone. All jailbreak even does is give you features that Android users already enjoy. Like, being able to change the image in the background.

Most Android phones are easy to root. Z4root takes care of most devices. Custom roms seem almost like a luxury, compared to iPhone. The process of doing this to Android phones is usually pretty straight forward. The iPhone needs special tools for each release of the iOS version. While jailbreaking is almost guaranteed with each iOS version, the ability to unlock isn't. Which can be problematic if you're using an iPhone with a different carrier.

Though Android phones seem SOL with upgrades, the community mostly takes care of that. Hell, even the G1 got Gingerbread. iPhone 2g though is only able to get 3.1.3, while iPhone 3g can get iOS 4. Despite both phones having the same ram and CPU.

Life on the Android is much simpler then that on the iPhone. Unless you don't jailbreak the iPhone, then it's all peaches and cream. Though, IMO it might as well be a cell phone with terrible battery life, without the jailbreak.
 
Number of apps is a completely worthless indicator of anything. I have an iPod touch and 99% of all iOS apps are complete garbage. Too bad there isn't a decent way to quantify "good" apps.
 
Happily using my Thunderbolt with 4GLTE.. a necessary technology even for browsing on a phone.. the extra 'push' mobile browsing needed to make it truly usable/bearable.

I certainly welcome a 4G iphone, till then it's dead to me.
 
Eventually there's going to be a point when Apple completely blocks jailbreak. That will certainly be the death of the iPhone.
When Apple discontinues the iPhone, that will be the death of the iPhone. It won't happen any sooner.

All jailbreak even does is give you features that Android users already enjoy. Like, being able to change the image in the background.
You can do that without jailbreaking.
 
Eventually there's going to be a point when Apple completely blocks jailbreak. At least for a few months. That will certainly be the death of the iPhone. All jailbreak even does is give you features that Android users already enjoy. Like, being able to change the image in the background.

Yes, because as we all know nobody uses the iPhone without jailbreaking it. :rolleyes:
 
App quality trumps app quantity, regardless of platform.
 
Number of apps is a completely worthless indicator of anything. I have an iPod touch and 99% of all iOS apps are complete garbage. Too bad there isn't a decent way to quantify "good" apps.

What defines a "good" app though, that is part of the problem.
 
I didn't realize the Android App market was growing so quickly.

Hopefully the WP7 market will grow just as fast or faster.
 
App quality trumps app quantity, regardless of platform.

Which makes it a good thing that the money is being spent in the Apple App Store, where there is not only currently the highest quantity but easily the highest quality.

I have probably a dozen prominent iOS developers "Like'd" on Facebook, and you constantly see posts by people begging them to bring their stuff to the Android OS. I'm sure the day will come when major releases happen on both platforms (or both platforms at the same time), but the spending needs to come to Android for that to happen.... not to mention having OS updates that are somewhat universal (lol @ selling brand new phones for $200 on contract and then shipping them with an OS version that's over a year old) and hardware that's either centralized or that doesn't need to huff and puff to do simple stuff like scroll through a menu screen.

Even on 1Ghz powered devices, using a custom UI 99% of the time results in your phone having lag in a task as simple as scrolling through home screens or your app list.

This is coming from somebody who has owned seven different Android phones, as well as an iPhone 3GS/4, FYI. ;)
 
Having had the opportunity to jailbreak a friends iPhone, I can really see why this trend is moving in the Android direction. The process to jailbreak isn't as easy as the Android, and in the end it's like you turned the iPhones iOS into Linux. Cydia provides a repository system for god sakes.

Eventually there's going to be a point when Apple completely blocks jailbreak. At least for a few months. That will certainly be the death of the iPhone. All jailbreak even does is give you features that Android users already enjoy. Like, being able to change the image in the background.

Most Android phones are easy to root. Z4root takes care of most devices. Custom roms seem almost like a luxury, compared to iPhone. The process of doing this to Android phones is usually pretty straight forward. The iPhone needs special tools for each release of the iOS version. While jailbreaking is almost guaranteed with each iOS version, the ability to unlock isn't. Which can be problematic if you're using an iPhone with a different carrier.

Though Android phones seem SOL with upgrades, the community mostly takes care of that. Hell, even the G1 got Gingerbread. iPhone 2g though is only able to get 3.1.3, while iPhone 3g can get iOS 4. Despite both phones having the same ram and CPU.

Life on the Android is much simpler then that on the iPhone. Unless you don't jailbreak the iPhone, then it's all peaches and cream. Though, IMO it might as well be a cell phone with terrible battery life, without the jailbreak.

Did this guy really just say rooting is EASIER than jbing?

Hold on for a second...


K back.. I was busy rofling, I'm better composed now.

Listen, I dunno what method you used to jb your friends phone. Jbing takes all buy 30 seconds. You DL the jb from the millions of places on the web. You connect your phone, start the jb program, put your phone in DFU mode and your done.

Yes that is ever so complicated.
:D
 
Having had the opportunity to jailbreak a friends iPhone, I can really see why this trend is moving in the Android direction. The process to jailbreak isn't as easy as the Android, and in the end it's like you turned the iPhones iOS into Linux. Cydia provides a repository system for god sakes.

Eventually there's going to be a point when Apple completely blocks jailbreak. At least for a few months. That will certainly be the death of the iPhone. All jailbreak even does is give you features that Android users already enjoy. Like, being able to change the image in the background.

Most Android phones are easy to root. Z4root takes care of most devices. Custom roms seem almost like a luxury, compared to iPhone. The process of doing this to Android phones is usually pretty straight forward. The iPhone needs special tools for each release of the iOS version. While jailbreaking is almost guaranteed with each iOS version, the ability to unlock isn't. Which can be problematic if you're using an iPhone with a different carrier.

Though Android phones seem SOL with upgrades, the community mostly takes care of that. Hell, even the G1 got Gingerbread. iPhone 2g though is only able to get 3.1.3, while iPhone 3g can get iOS 4. Despite both phones having the same ram and CPU.

Life on the Android is much simpler then that on the iPhone. Unless you don't jailbreak the iPhone, then it's all peaches and cream. Though, IMO it might as well be a cell phone with terrible battery life, without the jailbreak.

The original iPhone (aka "2G") is also nearly four years old.

At least they aren't selling brand new phones for $200 on contract (*cough*Samsung Epic*cough*) that up until a month ago came with Android 2.1, when 2.2 came out literally almost a full year ago.
 
I think it's more of a principle than anything else. 2.3 came out nearly half a year ago, 2.2 a year ago, and 2.1 a year and a half ago. Why a brand new phone can't come out with a six month old piece of software I don't know, but it wouldn't kill Android to be a little less so-called "open" in that respect.
 
Can't wait till I get my grubby hands on that EVO 3D. F the IPhone crap.
 
Not only is the # of total apps not very significant (google isn't a picky about approving and controlling apps as apple is so naturally there will be more total apps), the graph is kinda fishy. They are assuming the acceleration (aka rate of growth increase) is going to continue as it was. Generally those kinda things level off at some point, you can see apple's is mostly just a linear line now, so a constant increase. Androids is projected to continue to keep growing almost exponentially.
 
What is this "basic menu lag?" I've never seen it...

We have an ipad2 here at the house (not mine), and it's operation is smooth, but no smoother than the android devices I've seen. Although those devices were operated by people like us here...who know what they're doing...

Is there actually a well-known "lag" issue on Android phones? Or perhaps this was strictly an early-android problem? Maybe it was a result of multi-tasking?

As for app-selection... I suppose I haven't found anything impressive for the ipad2, but then this is coming from a guy who would rather have a 13" or so nearly ultra-portable laptop.

Perhaps there's no convincing a guy who isn't particularly fond of android or iOS... I can't say which is better until I develop a NEED for such a device.
 
Android's scrolling performance tends to be sub-par due to a lack of full GPU acceleration. It's a well-documented issue. That being said, Android is seeing improvements as time goes on.
 
What is this "basic menu lag?" I've never seen it...

We have an ipad2 here at the house (not mine), and it's operation is smooth, but no smoother than the android devices I've seen. Although those devices were operated by people like us here...who know what they're doing...

Is there actually a well-known "lag" issue on Android phones? Or perhaps this was strictly an early-android problem? Maybe it was a result of multi-tasking?.
It's not much of a problem anymore, especially with this new crop of phones. What they're complaining about is a little bit of lag that is present in the phone in the time between a button press and when the action opens. That millisecond pause is enough to enrage people apparently. When GUI acceleration is finalized in Android the iOS guys will still bag on Android for it...it's just the nature of this rivalry.
 
I think the whole number of apps deal is beyond pointless. Windows Phone has gone from 0 to 16,000 in six months so all of the major platforms are going to have far more apps than anyone will ever use. It's really about the quality, usefulness and performance of these apps. I'd say that Apple has a good edge there but it is shrinking. The bulk of apps on all platforms are useless junk anyway.
 
Listen, I dunno what method you used to jb your friends phone. Jbing takes all buy 30 seconds. You DL the jb from the millions of places on the web. You connect your phone, start the jb program, put your phone in DFU mode and your done.

Yes that is ever so complicated.
:D

On Android, you put Z4root onto your phone, and install it. Run it, and it's rooted. No need for any mode, or getting out of that mode.

On the iPhone, it should be nearly as simple, and I'm sure iPhone 3GS & 4 owners get the most attention. The problem I had trying to jailbreak and unlock the iphone, was while under a T-Mobile carrier. If you install 3.1.3 on a iPhone 3G, then you can't unlock the phone. On the iPhone 2G, you can use 3.1.3, but you need older software to jailbreak and unlock. Once the phone was jailbroken, YouTube wasn't working anymore. Apparently I needed to download something off Cydia to get that working too.

Is there a big difference between 2.1 and 2.2?
Froyo has support to install applications onto the SD card, plus better performance for phones that come with a FPU. It has a much better JIT.

I think it's more of a principle than anything else. 2.3 came out nearly half a year ago, 2.2 a year ago, and 2.1 a year and a half ago. Why a brand new phone can't come out with a six month old piece of software I don't know, but it wouldn't kill Android to be a little less so-called "open" in that respect.
It's not Androids fault, but cell phone manufacturers. Motorola is the worst when it comes to updates. Usually, the community relies on CyanogenMod and their derivatives to get updates for Android phones. My old G1 was suppose to have 1.6, but thanks to the community I can have 2.3. Not that I'm using that phone anymore, but you get the idea.
 
What is this "basic menu lag?" I've never seen it...

We have an ipad2 here at the house (not mine), and it's operation is smooth, but no smoother than the android devices I've seen. Although those devices were operated by people like us here...who know what they're doing...

Is there actually a well-known "lag" issue on Android phones? Or perhaps this was strictly an early-android problem? Maybe it was a result of multi-tasking?

As for app-selection... I suppose I haven't found anything impressive for the ipad2, but then this is coming from a guy who would rather have a 13" or so nearly ultra-portable laptop.

Perhaps there's no convincing a guy who isn't particularly fond of android or iOS... I can't say which is better until I develop a NEED for such a device.

You know i never really had many performance issues with android. I had some but it wasnt terrible as some people claim. However one big issue is that a poorly coded app can REALLY fuck android up and make it slow as hell.

Now i will say my wifes epic runs like total ass. My old optimus S felt so much faster than her epic and its a much slower phone. I dont know what it is about it or why because she dont want me to fuck with it but im sure in my hands it would be fine. Its the exact same thing for my brother and his wife. His android phones where always nice and smooth but his wifes ends up running like shit. Theres also some serious battery life issues at play with the womens phones.

Thats the problem with android in a nutshell. Unless you get a purely stock experience (N1 or NS) without tweaking/rooting/custom roms android is pretty fucking terrible. I have seen it over and over again, without some tweaking and maintenance the phone will eventually slow to shit and the battery life will disappear. Its getting better as phones get more horsepower but besides pure android the OS is holding the hardware back.

I love android and like what it has to offer but it has some pretty serious issues and it all comes back to googles original game plan of "do whatever the hell you want" for carriers and manufacturers.

These are big reasons i moved from android to WP7. I like rooting and playing with roms and OC kernels etc. but not on my damn phone, I need it to be reliable. WP7 is missing a few features but its rock solid and smooth as shit.
 
We've had 7 or 8 in the past year (had a few on Verizon then realized we hated the phones, cancelled and got iPhones, loved them to death, moved to an area with crap AT&T coverage so figured we'd try Sprint, five phones later we said we'd rather have great phones and poor reception than the worst phones on the planet and decent reception) and all have had one form of lag or another, whether it's lag between home screens, 1-3 second delays scrolling a web page or in the app menu, stuttering and other lag when opening programs, when playing simple games (Angry Birds, for example), scrolling through a list of pictures, etc.

Some of the lower end stuff is so bad there's a visible at least 2-3 second delay between when you type a word when texting and when it shows up, or when dialing a number. We're talking everything from 500-800Mhz phones, here. Some $100 on contract, nothing TOO low end.

Samsung and Motorola are both horrible with updates, LG isn't quite as bad, but the fact that there isn't a standardization is just plain stupid. The fact some phones are brand new with 2.1, or 2.2, and will never see an update ever is also stupid. The lack of hardware standardization is also horrible. You guys will appreciate that more than most - an app, be it a game or some other app, isn't going to run as good (or even usable in some cases) at 500Mhz as it will at 1Ghz. What does the developer do, develop for the $200 on contract phones and alienate the rest (vast majority) of the user install base, or do they dumb their stuff down for the $0-79, $100 on contract crowd and actually have a sizable user base with which to sell their applications? This is why you don't see Unreal Engine 3 or idTech powered stuff on Android, and if you ever do it won't be for a while.

My understanding is manufacturers who use a shell for a UI on top of the standard Android UI are what slows the phone down. You have to hack the phone to change this - you shouldn't have to buy a $200 on contract phone, "root" it and do other crap to it to make it not be slower than dirt.

Using an app killer religiously doesn't help, they all slow down to a crawl.

All I'd ask is for some standardization. If you can't afford to put more than a penny toward your phone when you sign up for a contract, maybe you don't need a smart phone. Get a regular cell phone. If you want a smart phone that runs apps, and honestly you can afford the $20-30 a month extra for data, than you can spend $99 on a freakin' phone is all I'm saying. Have a standard for hardware (like "don't make a FREE phone with crappy specs"), and enforce something for your resellers RE: the OS and it's updates. You should not be able to spend $200 on contract and get a phone that has 1 1/2 year old software. That's ridiculous. That's partially why you see 1-1.2Ghz dual core CPU's in these phones, and 1GB of RAM. Android is like the Windows Vista of mobile OS's, and it's disgusting.

If they can fix those two things, the software and other crap will follow, naturally.

Sorry for the rant, it just frustrates me, the direction Android is going in.
 
This is why you don't see Unreal Engine 3 or idTech powered stuff on Android, and if you ever do it won't be for a while.

Android has dungeon defenders, which is an UE3 title. Runs like shit on anything but heavily overclocked hummingbird/snapdragon chips or tegra 2 devices though.

Using an app killer religiously doesn't help, they all slow down to a crawl.

Using an app killer is the single WORST thing you can do on android and is a trap many people fall into that dont know any better.

Otherwise i agree. The lack of standardization and googles "Do what you want" stance towards carriers and manufacturers ruins android.
 
Wow, the amount of FUD and false information being slung around in this thread is amazing. I'd love to see these phone that take 3 seconds to register type. I'm calling B.S. on that.

Unreal Engine 3 games are already on Android and more are on they way. Developers aren't staying away from them because of standardization, they're simply slow getting to the game. Gameloft just signed on with Unreal at the end of Februrary and there are others that are already under development. The iOS gaming platform had a huge head start on Android and that's whey things like Unreal Engine are just now catching up.

And if you're using an app killer you're the problem, not Android.

As far as seeing dual core cpu's...it's not because the software is shitty, it's for other reasons like battery life. When an Android phone adds a dual core it's because it's a piece of shit that isn't coded properly but the moment Apple adds a dual core it will be a revolutionary way to do tasks faster :rolleyes:

I do agree that Google needs to step in and get these carriers to stop dicking around...they're really killing the positive perception the OS needs to gain support.
 
And if you're using an app killer you're the problem, not Android.

The fact that something like this exists for a phone is at the core of Android's challenges. I've had my HTC Arrive Windows Phone for five weeks and I'm done with dicking around with phones other than to write packaged apps. I was "rooting" my Windows Mobile devices long before Android and it's a serious time waster. I just want my phone to work without any effort, I've got too many other gadgets that need attention these days.

That said Android's future looks EXTREMELY bright and it's biggest enemy is itself.
 
The fact that something like this exists for a phone is at the core of Android's challenges. I've had my HTC Arrive Windows Phone for five weeks and I'm done with dicking around with phones other than to write packaged apps. I was "rooting" my Windows Mobile devices long before Android and it's a serious time waster. I just want my phone to work without any effort, I've got too many other gadgets that need attention these days.

That said Android's future looks EXTREMELY bright and it's biggest enemy is itself.

Im with you got my arrive and couldnt be happier. I will leave the rooting/custom rom stuff for my nook color and leave my phone alone.
 
The fact that something like this exists for a phone is at the core of Android's challenges. I've had my HTC Arrive Windows Phone for five weeks and I'm done with dicking around with phones other than to write packaged apps. I was "rooting" my Windows Mobile devices long before Android and it's a serious time waster. I just want my phone to work without any effort, I've got too many other gadgets that need attention these days.

That said Android's future looks EXTREMELY bright and it's biggest enemy is itself.

Task killers exist because some developers are just stupid. Android's SDK included ways of killing apps (probably a mistake), and some developers decided to go crazy using those SDKs to basically ruin people's phones. Task killers hurt battery life, they hurt performance, and they are annoying to boot. Doing what you desire, not messing with it, is by far the better choice on Android as well. Android can manage itself just fine.

Android's scrolling performance tends to be sub-par due to a lack of full GPU acceleration. It's a well-documented issue. That being said, Android is seeing improvements as time goes on.

Fixed in Honeycomb ;)
 
Task killers exist because some developers are just stupid. Android's SDK included ways of killing apps (probably a mistake), and some developers decided to go crazy using those SDKs to basically ruin people's phones. Task killers hurt battery life, they hurt performance, and they are annoying to boot. Doing what you desire, not messing with it, is by far the better choice on Android as well. Android can manage itself just fine.

For some phones with low memory the way android handles things is not that great. For that you get an app to change the default memory profile and things get much much better. (IIRC a free one is autokiller something or other) It requires root but can be a real life saver for low end phones.
 
The fact that something like this exists for a phone is at the core of Android's challenges. I've had my HTC Arrive Windows Phone for five weeks and I'm done with dicking around with phones other than to write packaged apps. I was "rooting" my Windows Mobile devices long before Android and it's a serious time waster. I just want my phone to work without any effort, I've got too many other gadgets that need attention these days.
I think the thought that Android phones needs to be dicked with is part of the problem. That is simply not true. Out of the box every Android phone will work just fine and will work every bit, if not better, than the iPhone straight out of the box. The problem is that people get it and start wanting more so they begin messing with roms and tweaks when they don't have to. It's them complicating things just for the sake of complicating them. The iPhone has the same problem....the moment you jailbreak and start messing with it things get more complicated.

The simple fact is that the phones work just fine without tweaks and if people leave them alone they'll have years of happy use out of them. You can't blame Android because users bring it upon themselves by tweaking the OS with half baked roms, apps, and other unnecessary additions. I had my fair share of apps that crashed my iPhone....it's not iOS's fault.
 
I think the thought that Android phones needs to be dicked with is part of the problem. That is simply not true. Out of the box every Android phone will work just fine and will work every bit, if not better, than the iPhone straight out of the box.

I'm not saying the Android phones need to messed with to work well, but I also think that it's bit of a stretch to say that EVERY Android phone works as well or better than the iPhone. That's a LOT of phones and not all of them are created equal and this kind of the issue with Android phones these days.
 
I'm not saying the Android phones need to messed with to work well, but I also think that it's bit of a stretch to say that EVERY Android phone works as well or better than the iPhone. That's a LOT of phones and not all of them are created equal and this kind of the issue with Android phones these days.
My comments assumed that we were at least talking about comparable phones since I don't see the point of comparing an iPhone 4 with the lowest end Android phone. Even still those low end Android phones work just fine. I think these claims of Android self destructing under its own power are exaggerated if not completely baseless even if we are talking about the lower model Androids.
 
Back
Top