Anandtech does it better

I think this article is a great example of what asmielia is talking about, and what we'd like to see more of from [H].
 
We are working on getting a memory review/comparison together now. Funny thing is about most of those, the memory makers supply the ram and it gets cherry picked for reviews. We are currently working on getting 100% retail "off the shelf" samples for such an article. The reason we have not done ram articles like that in the past was the ram we saw come in, in sample form, in no way reprsented what YOU could buy. Overall the ram makers represent a pretty dog eat dog industry with few rules.
 
asmielia said:
Here's my wishlist for an overclocking section:
-Best 1:1 1T speeds using many different types of memory CHIPS (Samsung TCCD, Winbond BH-5, Hynix, etc). Use the most popular RAM used by enthusiasts these days, like OCZ PC3200 EL Rev2 or GE Skill LE PC4400. Don't forget timings as those make a big difference.
-Best OC on CPU possible, ignoring RAM
-Test locking of all SATA ports, PCIe bus, PCI bus
-Check that voltage, multiplier and FSB settings work properlyAdrian
You can see it here at [H].....http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=835569&page=11
 
Mysogonist said:
For me....the OCP (which I had always thought stood for Over Clockers Paradise) M

I am still waiting for their [H]ard Oatmeal Cream Pie recipe.

==>Lazn
 
Well, today's review on the DFI Lanparty Ultra-D completely let me down.
You'd think that after everyone spilling their guts out, they'd change something.
Yeah, they changed something all right. Got the OC section down to ONE sentence (and two screen shots).

"Using a Koolance EXOS water cooling system, we were able to propel the nF4 Ultra-D to a 375MHz FSB, with the system memory running at 439MHz."

And then in the closing comments, Kyle tells fans to talk about it in the forums. How can that happen, you gave fans nothing to discuss. Now, if you had talked about voltages, temps, benchmark scores OCed, then fans would have something to go on.
 
NoGodForMe said:
Well, today's review on the DFI Lanparty Ultra-D completely let me down.
You'd think that after everyone spilling their guts out, they'd change something.
Yeah, they changed something all right. Got the OC section down to ONE sentence (and two screen shots).

"Using a Koolance EXOS water cooling system, we were able to propel the nF4 Ultra-D to a 375MHz FSB, with the system memory running at 439MHz."

And then in the closing comments, Kyle tells fans to talk about it in the forums. How can that happen, you gave fans nothing to discuss. Now, if you had talked about voltages, temps, benchmark scores OCed, then fans would have something to go on.


That review was done before this conversation ever took place. Reviews of that depth are not built in a day. In fact it is usually a multi-week process.

I have already moved to adding real OC results with a 3200+ and high end ram. Certainly the CPU will be the bottle neck, but we will show results. ALso we will certainly show what the board was capable of when teh FSB was not hindered by the CPU as well.
 
CrimandEvil said:
Quiet honestly thats one of the most stupid suggestions I've ever seen. Just because your not interested in how a board performs at stock speeds doesn't mean that anyone else isn't, you go on to talk about how the board performs when OCed with different speed memory could show that the board isn't "up to snuff" so what if the board doesn't work or performance is really low when at stock yet when OCed it performs incredibly? Wouldn't the fact that it's a low performer at stock speeds mean it isn't "up to snuff?" :rolleyes:

I know theres alot of people out there at don't OC every god damn thing in their PCs that also read HardOCPs reviews, hell I find many of H's reviews to be an incredible asset when choose parts for something like an HTPC, it's one thing to know how your hardware is suppose to perform out of the box and it's another thing to know just how far your hardware could go.

I couldn't agree more. Some hardware performs better than others when not taking OCing into account. For those of us that build stock systems that need to retain their warrantees, this is great stuff. Just because it isn't important to one person doesn't mean it isn't important to others.

There are some boards that do very will with OCing that have to be tinkered with to get really stable. Many OCers are quite willing to tinker away for hours. But many times I want to know if I have an out of the box solution or not. Some of us simply can't spend a lot of time tweaking RAM timings and such just to get a board to run out of the box at stock speeds. People that build custom systems for a living can't put a crapload worth of hours into a single system and expect any financial gain. This is why covering the basics is just as important as getting into the [H]ard stuff. :D
 
Not to mention, some of us just want to run stock and stable. Old Dude's who can't be bothered. :D

barely have the energy to game as it is. :(

(gotta confess though, i picked stuff from Anand's midlevel guide. Motherboard and memory)
 
I don't read reviews anymore. I look at highlights, I look at the pictures and I look at the benchmarks. Rest is a waste of time as I don't care about personal opinions. The only opinion that matters to me is my own. ;)
 
solofly said:
I don't read reviews anymore. I look at highlights, I look at the pictures and I look at the benchmarks. Rest is a waste of time as I don't care about personal opinions. The only opinion that matters to me is my own. ;)

You are much different than about 95% of our readers. They care pretty much only about our opinions and look at little else.
 
FrgMstr said:
We are working on getting a memory review/comparison together now. Funny thing is about most of those, the memory makers supply the ram and it gets cherry picked for reviews. We are currently working on getting 100% retail "off the shelf" samples for such an article. The reason we have not done ram articles like that in the past was the ram we saw come in, in sample form, in no way reprsented what YOU could buy. Overall the ram makers represent a pretty dog eat dog industry with few rules.


Isn't it safe to assume that this happens with most products that are sent to reviewers?

Other than the brevity of [H] reviews, I like them, and find them interesting and different than others. The BIOS section always bores me though :)
 
Andrew_Carr said:
Isn't it safe to assume that this happens with most products that are sent to reviewers?

Other than the brevity of [H] reviews, I like them, and find them interesting and different than others. The BIOS section always bores me though :)

Not if you handle your products and representatives correctly. Actually with the assumption that everything IS cherry picked, then our content would have no value.

I have yet to see a BIOS that gives me wood either. ;)
 
I always hoped that cherry-picked products would all equal out the cheating in some odd way. Good to hear there's not usually cause to worry about this at all then.



P.S. Maybe having the BIOS run in hot pink thong color would help that section ;)
 
FrgMstr said:
We are working on getting a memory review/comparison together now. Funny thing is about most of those, the memory makers supply the ram and it gets cherry picked for reviews. We are currently working on getting 100% retail "off the shelf" samples for such an article. The reason we have not done ram articles like that in the past was the ram we saw come in, in sample form, in no way reprsented what YOU could buy. Overall the ram makers represent a pretty dog eat dog industry with few rules.
As we all know, a "good" memory maker always rigorously speed binned their products and advertised it accordingly. Imo, all retail versions of these memory are the same...no cherry picking. Its all depend on the end user's other components such as psu, cpu and mobo chipset. For instance..... 2x512 DDR 600 tccd ram will have a hard time to run @ the rated speed stable with AMD64 3000 and Nforce3 mobo. I could only imagine how busy the rma dept. @ OCZ or Gskill.. ;)
 
Back
Top