AMD vrs INTEL!!!

amd or intel in the long run?

  • amd

    Votes: 91 85.0%
  • intel

    Votes: 16 15.0%

  • Total voters
    107
  • Poll closed .

militaryman1010

Weaksauce
Joined
Nov 21, 2004
Messages
88
I am building a new machine either intel or amd which one ....
uses..... some gaming......and home office stuff.....
 
i personally am an AMD guy..but for your use a p4 with HT would be best.

/me puts flamesuit on and readies the hoses to put out the inferno thats about to erupt here..
 
but is 64 bit windows going to be a big deal its set to come out in late january because my friend is a beta tester and that what they told him???
 
If you do a lot of multitasking I would really look into a P4...

As for 64 bit computing, its coming, but it is still in its infancy. I would not base my decisions on my computer being 64 bit or not, at this time.
 
i agree with paradox....64 bit is overrated at this time, except for gaming at MAXIMUM detail, and even then a p4 3.4+ghz could do that...
so go with a p4 with HT if your gonna be doing alot of multitasking (multipile programs/windows open at a time. etc)

64-bit isnt worth it. and wont be worth it until a few months (AT LEAST) after XP64 bit comes out
unless your gaming of course...then 64 bit is worth it.
 
I would go AMD, Just so I can move to 64bit. But then again ill probably upgrade a few more times till then. :p
 
I think that AMD just gives a better all around value for the $
 
Jasonx82 said:
I would go AMD, Just so I can move to 64bit. But then again ill probably upgrade a few more times till then. :p

if he goes AMD now he has at least a few months for windows 64 bit...and he heard from a friend who heard from some guy that XP 64 bit is coming in late january...so how reliable do you think that info is? with 64 bit he may have to wait a 6 months to a year if that info is false. so with a p4 with HT he can do the multitasking he needs (assuming that "home office stuff" refers to checkinig email, paying bills. surfing the web, and doing MS office work all at the same time) and will be relatively cheap compared to an a64, which would be overkill for just office work and light gaming.
like i said...im an AMD guy myself and i would go A64 just because i am a moderate to heavy gamer. but for what he wants/needs to do a p4 with HT would do just fine.

:edit: decided to add onto this instead of making a new reply.
RancidWAnnaRIot said:
AMD cause i'm a poor college student... if i had the money.. i would go intel....
From my understanding he wants to either get an intel and wait for 64 bit. or he wants to get a 64 bit now and be ready when XP 64 bit comes out.
so an A64 would exactly be cheaper than a p4 with HT...
but i would get an athlon XP in your case, oh wait! i just did yesterday...since i am in basically the same dillema as you...it sucks :(
 
If you can wait, you should wait... prices will drop more and more for the older 64bit lines. That's when i plan to jump on ><!
 
i am a moderate gamer im 15 but i do alot of multi tasking stuff ALOT but will the amd 64 handle multi tasking if i am going to pump a 3500+ 90nm to 2.8ghz???? or maybe a 3200+ 90nm to a 2.6ghz
 
why don't you just title the thread

"FAN-BOYS HERE" ? Seriously. Doubt this will last long

But I'll give you my take. I've owned a 3.0C @ 4ghz rock solid. Great proc, multitasking is untouchable, and gaming was good.

However, I've done a LOT of research lately because its time for my yearly system overhaul, and it appears clear to me that the only choice is the amd 64 line this time around.

And I'm not happy about it; the motherboards all suck (socket 939), no mature chipsets, they don't overclock much for the most part unless you get 90nm which is a minefield in itself (dealing with compatability issues and the perplexing below 0 issues), no hyperthreading.

But regardless of all that, I'm not willing to sacrifice 30-100fps in games and thousands of points in benchmarks and choke my x800xt-pe because I go Intel. So AMD it is for me.
 
1. Don't base your decision on 64bit vs 32bit. It doesn't matter yet. Nor will it necessairily in the next few months
2. Base it on speed NOW. The AMD64 is better at gaming, the Intel at mixed apps, especially multitasking. AMD is generally cheaper for the same, single app performance.
 
lopoetve said:
1. Don't base your decision on 64bit vs 32bit. It doesn't matter yet. Nor will it necessairily in the next few months
2. Base it on speed NOW. The AMD64 is better at gaming, the Intel at mixed apps, especially multitasking. AMD is generally cheaper for the same, single app performance.

bingo! :D
 
how big of a diffrence on multi tasking????
will the new amd both 3200+ and 3500+ 90nm run faster than a p4 3ghz at multi tasking???
i need something in the 250$ range hoping for prices on the 3500+ 90nm to go down instead of rising
 
AMD = Better Gaming
I have a AMD 64 3200+ and I love it. It loads games/levels/ faster that my Bro's Intel 4 3.2Ghz.

Anyways, someone should make a thread, sticky it, that Says
AMD Vs. INTEL READ THIS:

And inside it will say

AMD for Games + Cheaper

Intel for Mass Multitasking.


That way we can avoid a thousand post like this :)


No offense to the poster in anyway.
 
pretty big since with HT the p4 emulates a second processor....essentially fooling windows into thinking you have 2 processors and distributing the load from each of the programs across both
 
militaryman1010 said:
how big of a diffrence on multi tasking????
will the new amd both 3200+ and 3500+ 90nm run faster than a p4 3ghz at multi tasking???
i need something in the 250$ range hoping for prices on the 3500+ 90nm to go down instead of rising

It's a 'feel' thing. It deals with context switching better, so everything seems to respond faster.

I don't know if the Intel or AMD is faster, depends on what apps you're running.
 
Spec3 said:
AMD unless your home stuff is photo/video editing

Wrong. For multitasking, Intel is better, not just photo/video editing. Also for most scientific work...
 
really depends on how heavily you multitask, I got a p4 3.0Eghz right, thought it would be hot shit, ( I really only got it because I got the mobo free) I was really expecting to see a difference in speed but there wasn't. I hate intel, I just sold my p4 and going back to amd, 3500+ winchester all the way baby!
 
not much video or photo editing AT ALL...mainlt gaming and like aim,firefox,outlook express, and other microsoft things....also i do alot of downloading for patches for games and updates and freeware and ect....
 
how much are you looking to spend, I myself, steer clear of intel and never advise it. But that's just me, been working with computer for like 8 or so years now. Yeah yeah, ("I've been working on computers for 20 years" - work like word and excel?) I'm 19 also. Look I loved my AMD Athlon XP 1800+ ran everything just fine, only reason I upgraded was for gaming. I say buy a 3200+ winchester, or even a 3000+. I'm actually building my brother a pc for x-mas using the 3000+ winchester, more than he'll ever need, in college too. I upgraded to a p4, as you can see in my sig, it was like no difference at all, truth is AMD kicks intel's ass in a lot of apps, and even if intel beats them out it's by a SMALL, I mean tiny margin. Everything is more complicated than it needs to be on an intel chip anyway. I'm confident you'll be happy with an amd64.
 
Intel Pentium® 4 550 Processor Prescott 3.4GHz, 800MHz FSB, Socket 775, 1MB Cache
or

AMD Athlon 64 3500+, 2.2 GHz, 512KB L2 Cache 64-bit Socket 939
????
from what i said i needed earlyer
 
get the 3500 amd, you won't regret it. Is it the winchester though? I advise to look for one of those, new chip, cooler, better oc'ing ability. And get an Asus A8V Deluxe to go with it.
 
you dont NEED an SLI mobo to have pci-e....sli mobos come with 2 pci-e slots instead of one..thats really the only difference

unless im mistaken...
 
I currently have a 2.53GHz P4 and if I had to pick right now, it would easily be AMD. The gaps in performance for gaming are nothing to laugh at. AMD is just crushing Intel in gaming which is the only really intensive thing I do.
 
i want to see some action whats wrong???????isnt it the right settting and place and time because of the new nf sli mobo's that will whip any of intels @$$es......lol
 
im an amd !!!!!!, amd has to inovate and improve product to gain market share, whereas intell just has to raize mhz and add cache to sell, which in the longrun bottlenecks the cpu industry. Thank god for amd for growth and inovations to this beautiful industry
 
militaryman1010 said:
not a sli mobo???i want pci-e

I'm not really into pci-e right now, I bought my 6800GT before the mobos and cards were actually available. I see now performance increase over AGP to go with it right now and I doubt AGP will be going anyway anytime soon.
 
Back
Top