amd user switching to conroe. things ive learned. TRUE or FALSE?

Joined
Apr 30, 2005
Messages
935
Ok. ive been doing a TON of reading on here lately about conroe, and ill say that i am jumping the AMD ship to go to it. Ive read a lot of things, some i dont know if they are FACT or FICTION (i.e. speculation / fanb0y / misc)

So if people could shed some light on these things, that would be GREAT!

1. All Conroe chips get CRAZY Overclocks! (im planning on an E6600) There are no 'steppings' or things like that that make certain processors (other than models) better than another.

True or False

2. 965 Chipset is 'better' because of the newer ICH8 (not sure what that exactly means) and that 965 was DESIGNED for the Conroe. 975 was not and needs to be biosed, etc.

True or False

3. Its better to go with a NON- nforce5 (570 / 590) chipset board since ATI/Intel are buddies (and AMD/Nvidia) and the intel chipsets are generally more stable.

True or False

4. Although 965 chipsets are 'better' the 975 chipsets are the only ones currently to have dual PCI-E slots. Is this something PERMANENT...or just wait it out for a 2x PCI-E 965 board?

True or False

5. DDR2 800 Ram is the way to go even though the new mobo's have a FSB of 1066 too. Timings arent that important with an Intel Core 2 Duo build, and these high of speeds.

True or False




...as of now i think im going to go with the Asus P5W-DH mobo and switch to ATI for my next gen card(s) setup. Reading some stuff about nvidia's stance on unified shaders, yadda yadda yadda...maybe time to give ATI a try again.
 
1.) Depends on your defintion of overclock like crazy. Lets say on air cooling. But 40 to 50% O/C seem possible on aircooling. However, you will need a good motherboard if you really want to O/C conroes.

2.) ICH8 seems to have better I/O performance for the sound, IDE/SATA.. However, it does't support dual video cards. If you really want the best platform for Conroe. I would wait for the products from Nvidia or ATI. To be honest, i975 seems inflated. 965 prices also seem abit steep given its feature set. (at least with the current premium boards that have been released.)

3.) Nvidia boards are stable nuff for most home uses . There are however concerns on the amount of heat that the 590 intel edition will produce. This may have implications of overclocking. but, we will have to wait and see..

4.) 965E won't support dual video cards in X-fire of SLI...at least not officially. I think the key differnce is with the 965 is the ICH8 south bridge.. I belive that has been improved. However, the ICH8 lacks P-ATA !!! If you want to best conroe M/B. I suggest you wait for the ATI of Nvidia offerings.

5.) There is no need to go DDR2-800 right now. Don't pay hugh amounts of money for it unless you really plan major overclocks.
 
A bit of a related question. It is possible to use slower DDR2 RAM (667, for example) with a setup such as this, correct? In my building experience I've just thrown PC3200 RAM with an AMD 400mhz FSB chip, so things like RAM/CPU ratios are new to me.
 
MJCfromCT said:
A bit of a related question. It is possible to use slower DDR2 RAM (667, for example) with a setup such as this, correct? In my building experience I've just thrown PC3200 RAM with an AMD 400mhz FSB chip, so things like RAM/CPU ratios are new to me.

Yeah, standard on the new Core processors is DDR2-667. This is basically just a 5:4 multiplier, in AMD's terms. Since the Core processors have a 266MHz bus, and DDR2-667 runs at 333MHz, the RAM has a slightly higher ratio than the bus.
 
Yes, even though ICH8 does not have a P-ATA on it, all 965 boards come with a P-ATA connector on them, so you don't need to worry about that.
 
1 - True, Conroe overclocks like crazy, but higher-end ones will overclock better due to Intel's highly effective speed binning.

2 - According to [H]ardOCP, the higher-performance was marketing BS. 965P will be the budget, single PCIe interface (think nForce 4 Ultra), and the 975X will be the high-end Crossfire interface (think nForce 4 SLI X16). 965P also lacks PATA, which is both good and bad.

3 - The biggest attraction for Intel is the Intel-stability. Can't beat and Intel CPU and chipset ;)

4 - 965 will never be dual-video.

5 - Corect, DDR2-800 will also help that E6600 break the magic 4GHz barrier.
 
holy crap ive heard so much conflicting stories on this 'it has P-ATA' 'it DOESNT have P-ATA' thing.....

MAKE UP YOUR MINDS PEOPLE! LOL
 
thenixhex311 said:
holy crap ive heard so much conflicting stories on this 'it has P-ATA' 'it DOESNT have P-ATA' thing.....

MAKE UP YOUR MINDS PEOPLE! LOL
ICH8 does NOT HAVE PATA!

Motherboard makers are adding PATA by means of an external PATA controller, connected via the PCI bus. You will have PATA, but you will have to load drivers using F6 when installing Windows, and you will also have limited performance due to the constrained PCI bus. There will be PATA, but it will be a low-performance hack-job to provide a little backwards-compatibility. Time to buy SATA ;)
 
Motherboard makers are adding PATA by means of an external PATA controller, connected via the PCI bus. You will have PATA, but you will have to load drivers using F6 when installing Windows, and you will also have limited performance due to the constrained PCI bus. There will be PATA, but it will be a low-performance hack-job to provide a little backwards-compatibility.


Do you have a source to backup that the PATA on the 965 boards will have limited and low performance?
 
00ber_m00 said:
Do you have a source to backup that the PATA on the 965 boards will have limited and low performance?
Personal experience? I used a PCI PATA controller when I ran out of PATA slots, and the performance sucked. Don't even get me started on that Adaptec PATA RAID controller, that was the biggest waste of $80 EVER. It's still sitting under my desk...
 
Well, the typical PCI bus you find today runs at 33MHz and 32 bit wide.. It works out to 133MiB per seconds.

A decent 7200 RPM can push up 80 to 90MB transfer rates. It doesn't take much to saturate the PCI bus any more.

Almost all the makers of the i965 boards will implement P-ATA with a third party chip. There simply isn't any S-ATA optical drives out there. That P-ATA port should work find with those thou.
 
evilmedic said:
Well, the typical PCI bus you find today runs at 33MHz and 32 bit wide.. It works out to 133MiB per seconds.

A decent 7200 RPM can push up 80 to 90MB transfer rates. It doesn't take much to saturate the PCI bus any more.

Almost all the makers of the i965 boards will implement P-ATA with a third party chip. There simply isn't any S-ATA optical drives out there. That P-ATA port should work find with those thou.


so are you saying that it isnt necessary to pick up a SATA optical drive, or is this something that you think people should start doing anyways...would hate to have all my components ready and find out that i have to wait and order a SATA dvd-rw to load up XP
 
InorganicMatter said:
ICH8 does NOT HAVE PATA!

Motherboard makers are adding PATA by means of an external PATA controller, connected via the PCI bus. You will have PATA, but you will have to load drivers using F6 when installing Windows, and you will also have limited performance due to the constrained PCI bus. There will be PATA, but it will be a low-performance hack-job to provide a little backwards-compatibility. Time to buy SATA ;)
Since we're on the subject of going full SATA, are there any cheap SATA optical drives out there yet? I'm not going to give up my PATA DVD Burner to spend $100 on a SATA model.
 
Lich said:
Since we're on the subject of going full SATA, are there any cheap SATA optical drives out there yet? I'm not going to give up my PATA DVD Burner to spend $100 on a SATA model.


amen to that, brother!!!! :D
 
InorganicMatter said:
ICH8 does NOT HAVE PATA!

Motherboard makers are adding PATA by means of an external PATA controller, connected via the PCI bus. You will have PATA, but you will have to load drivers using F6 when installing Windows, and you will also have limited performance due to the constrained PCI bus. There will be PATA, but it will be a low-performance hack-job to provide a little backwards-compatibility. Time to buy SATA ;)


You are only half right. Would I use IDE to hook up a boot drive? No way... but for a storage drive or optical the 3rd party controller will be fine. Besides.. who boots from IDE any more? This is the first step in getting rid of PATA.... which is a natural progression. They need to get rid of old out dated hardware.
 
InorganicMatter said:
Is it even possible to boot off a drive that is on an offboard PATA connector though?


Of course it is... you might have to use "F6" drivers when installing windows though and your performance will suffer probably.
 
InorganicMatter said:
Is it even possible to boot off a drive that is on an offboard PATA connector though?

That's the "Boot from other device" setting the BIOS is for.
 
thenixhex311 said:
Ok. ive been doing a TON of reading on here lately about conroe, and ill say that i am jumping the AMD ship to go to it. Ive read a lot of things, some i dont know if they are FACT or FICTION (i.e. speculation / fanb0y / misc)

So if people could shed some light on these things, that would be GREAT!

1. All Conroe chips get CRAZY Overclocks! (im planning on an E6600) There are no 'steppings' or things like that that make certain processors (other than models) better than another.

True or False

2. 965 Chipset is 'better' because of the newer ICH8 (not sure what that exactly means) and that 965 was DESIGNED for the Conroe. 975 was not and needs to be biosed, etc.

True or False

3. Its better to go with a NON- nforce5 (570 / 590) chipset board since ATI/Intel are buddies (and AMD/Nvidia) and the intel chipsets are generally more stable.

True or False

4. Although 965 chipsets are 'better' the 975 chipsets are the only ones currently to have dual PCI-E slots. Is this something PERMANENT...or just wait it out for a 2x PCI-E 965 board?

True or False

5. DDR2 800 Ram is the way to go even though the new mobo's have a FSB of 1066 too. Timings arent that important with an Intel Core 2 Duo build, and these high of speeds.

True or False




...as of now i think im going to go with the Asus P5W-DH mobo and switch to ATI for my next gen card(s) setup. Reading some stuff about nvidia's stance on unified shaders, yadda yadda yadda...maybe time to give ATI a try again.

Please let me try.
1.True. The end results of overclocking an E6600 to 3.3GHz (modest) might only be similar to a P4 at 5GHz or a Athlon64 FX at or about 4GHz.

2. False. Intel thought the market might be using all kinds of SATA devices by now.
Two are out there and they're both exspensive compared to the rest of the market.

The problem some folks were having problems getting to where the F6 option is give. If the boot floppy can't stall the 3rd party drivers for the PATA-IDE device, how in the hell do you setup the system without the Optical Drive?

3. True. IMHO, Intel chipsets for Intel Processors is the best=P Though I'd take a shot at ATI if given the chance.

4. Tie not true or false. Each has advantages according to folks using them at XS. I might be wrong but I don't think these (Chip Sets) are Intel's best efforts for folks in THIS market sector.

5. DDR2 667 for lite overclocking and DDR2 800 for general and DDR2 1066 for extreme.

Just do some smart shopping and don't just stop at the first place like Newegg. I like them the most, but as they proved with X6800, they're NOT always the best place to shop.
 
Donnie27 said:
Please let me try.
1.True. The end results of overclocking an E6600 to 3.3GHz (modest) might only be similar to a P4 at 5GHz or a Athlon64 FX at or about 4GHz.

2. False. Intel thought the market might be using all kinds of SATA devices by now.
Two are out there and they're both exspensive compared to the rest of the market.

The problem some folks were having problems getting to where the F6 option is give. If the boot floppy can't stall the 3rd party drivers for the PATA-IDE device, how in the hell do you setup the system without the Optical Drive?

3. True. IMHO, Intel chipsets for Intel Processors is the best=P Though I'd take a shot at ATI if given the chance.

4. Tie not true or false. Each has advantages according to folks using them at XS. I might be wrong but I don't think these (Chip Sets) are Intel's best efforts for folks in THIS market sector.

5. DDR2 667 for lite overclocking and DDR2 800 for general and DDR2 1066 for extreme.

Just do some smart shopping and don't just stop at the first place like Newegg. I like them the most, but as they proved with X6800, they're NOT always the best place to shop.


i agree with the newegg price gouging.

would it be in my best interest to preorder an E6600 now at a 340ish price , assuming they might be price-gouged at release too?

I think im going ATI-crossfire for the next-gen/mobo setup. Time to give ATI a try. All that b.s. about nvidia-stubbornness-comatibility issues. I want to put something together that all blends well. this will probably be my most $$ build yet. As i plan on getting a 30" lcd (when benq EVER releases their model!) and want something able to drive it at full rez w/ eye candy. Dual cards has to be the only way to go.

I've got the PSU, CPU, cooler, picked out. other than the parts i have now, all i need are some good reviews of some 975 boards and RAM, and see some positive oc results.

i think it will be easier this time around to OC since there are all these freakin' cpu's (like amd) and all these steppings and shit to worry about

CABGE, blah blah blah

it seems like (other than the $$$ extremes) that people will be going with the E6600 and good ol DDR2800 Ram.
 
Back
Top