AMD Radeon RX Vega On Linux

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
To add further diverse coverage here on what has officially become AMD Radeon RX Vega Day, phoronix has an excellent write-up that covers the ins and outs RX Vega and Linux. Get your penguins ready my fellow neckbeards. Thanks cageymaru.

While the RX Vega performance on Linux may not be as good as some of you would have liked to see on day one, this is even now the fastest discrete GPU available with fully-open driver support. NVIDIA simply has no competition to provide when it comes to open-source driver support with their Maxwell/Pascal GPUs not even allowing re-clocking support, so they are limited to running at their boot clock frequencies, which is very slow.
 
Pretty fantastic that the 56 seems to be running on par or better then the 1070 in Linux with fully open source drivers. Now amd just needs to open source their vulkan driver.

I know most of the windows reviews show these cards are still lacking vs NV. AMD made a good decision open sourcing their Linux driver clearly the work being done on the Linux driver and the mesa library is paying off. The performance deltas are still a bit inconsistent, still hard to miss the wins for Vegas opensource driver in games like bioshock vs the 1080ti. The NV linux driver is solid and every bit the = of the nv windows driver so that is no minor feat.
 
Pretty fantastic that the 56 seems to be running on par or better then the 1070 in Linux with fully open source drivers. Now amd just needs to open source their vulkan driver.

I know most of the windows reviews show these cards are still lacking vs NV. AMD made a good decision open sourcing their Linux driver clearly the work being done on the Linux driver and the mesa library is paying off. The performance deltas are still a bit inconsistent, still hard to miss the wins for Vegas opensource driver in games like bioshock vs the 1080ti. The NV linux driver is solid and every bit the = of the nv windows driver so that is no minor feat.

That is what I was hoping for with the Vega 56 was a GTX 1070 level GPU that was an open source option. Looks like that's what i'll be getting more or less. Hopefully there will be a MSI GamingX, XFX DD, Aus Strix, etc version of it in the next month and a half.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChadD
like this
That is what I was hoping for with the Vega 56 was a GTX 1070 level GPU that was an open source option. Looks like that's what i'll be getting more or less. Hopefully there will be a MSI GamingX, XFX DD, Aus Strix, etc version of it in the next month and a half.

Me too, then I found a damn 64 at 1070 price!!!!

Seems like these will be going cheap, also on another note; seems like I won't be needing any central heating this winter!

saved 50 bucks on heating too as I won't be needing any heaters - good thing since I live near the artic shithole where power is practically free.
 
Last edited:
That's because, I believe, there's simply no real money to be made in Linux gaming compared to Windows. Or at least not yet, if you're the optimistic type.

Either way, I laud AMD for supporting the open-source community.
but "linux gaming" isn't the only reason to have a GPU. the likes of Pixar et al all use linux and all heavy consumers of gpu's.
it is great that AMD have embraced open-source but there are a couple of things to remember

1) ORIGINALLY AMD drivers were rubbish & this was consistent on windows w.r.t. OpenGL. This is one area that nvidia had got right
2) They were losing market share "but noone loses linux" ... there are some very big spending industries & equally being completely kicked out of a sector is bad marketing..

it was a gambit by AMD ... they couldn't write drivers and were losing share -> embrace FOSS and the FOSS advocates would lap it up & that worked. Even when the FOSS drivers were rubbish compared to nvidia, there were advocates loving it. nivida... why do they have to? they already have the performance and fantastic support (they have some BS that there are some patents limiting their ability to FOSS ...).


Also note the RX Vega isn't 100% FOSS... hybrid Radeon Linux driver relying upon AMD's closed-source OpenGL driver that's also shared with the Windows OpenGL driver
 
but "linux gaming" isn't the only reason to have a GPU. the likes of Pixar et al all use linux and all heavy consumers of gpus
I fully agree! However, do they buy the consumer versions or the workstation versions? That's why I explcitily said "linux gaming."
 
but "linux gaming" isn't the only reason to have a GPU. the likes of Pixar et al all use linux and all heavy consumers of gpu's.
it is great that AMD have embraced open-source but there are a couple of things to remember

1) ORIGINALLY AMD drivers were rubbish & this was consistent on windows w.r.t. OpenGL. This is one area that nvidia had got right
2) They were losing market share "but noone loses linux" ... there are some very big spending industries & equally being completely kicked out of a sector is bad marketing..

it was a gambit by AMD ... they couldn't write drivers and were losing share -> embrace FOSS and the FOSS advocates would lap it up & that worked. Even when the FOSS drivers were rubbish compared to nvidia, there were advocates loving it. nivida... why do they have to? they already have the performance and fantastic support (they have some BS that there are some patents limiting their ability to FOSS ...).


Also note the RX Vega isn't 100% FOSS... hybrid Radeon Linux driver relying upon AMD's closed-source OpenGL driver that's also shared with the Windows OpenGL driver

I think you're misunderstood some things here.

Lemme quote Michael here:
"The AMDGPU kernel driver is shared by both the fully-open and AMDGPU-PRO hybrid driver... No duplication of effort there.

The only real duplicate is the AMDGPU-PRO OpenGL user-space code and RadeonSI. But the AMDGPU-PRO OpenGL driver is shared with Windows OpenGL code-base and they need to maintain that code for workstation users needing OpenGL compat profiles, etc."

OSS opengl driver rocks, and the improvements each other month is fine wine indeed!
Vulkan and opencl OSS driver is another topic at the very moment same with DC\DAL stuff is also touchy...
 
I think you're misunderstood some things here.

Lemme quote Michael here:
"The AMDGPU kernel driver is shared by both the fully-open and AMDGPU-PRO hybrid driver... No duplication of effort there.

The only real duplicate is the AMDGPU-PRO OpenGL user-space code and RadeonSI. But the AMDGPU-PRO OpenGL driver is shared with Windows OpenGL code-base and they need to maintain that code for workstation users needing OpenGL compat profiles, etc."

OSS opengl driver rocks, and the improvements each other month is fine wine indeed!
Vulkan and opencl OSS driver is another topic at the very moment same with DC\DAL stuff is also touchy...
The follow on post covers more about this
http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=vega-gallium-pro&num=1
Of the many interesting findings from this morning's AMD Radeon RX Vega 56 / 64 Linux review was how the open-source AMDGPU+RadeonSI driver stack with OpenGL actually outperforms AMDGPU-PRO driver, the hybrid Radeon Linux driver relying upon AMD's closed-source OpenGL driver that's also shared with the Windows OpenGL driver. Here are more benchmarks of the RX Vega 56 and RX Vega 64 showing the margins by which AMDGPU+RadeonSI can outperform AMDGPU-PRO.
 
Pretty fantastic that the 56 seems to be running on par or better then the 1070 in Linux with fully open source drivers. Now amd just needs to open source their vulkan driver.

I know most of the windows reviews show these cards are still lacking vs NV. AMD made a good decision open sourcing their Linux driver clearly the work being done on the Linux driver and the mesa library is paying off. The performance deltas are still a bit inconsistent, still hard to miss the wins for Vegas opensource driver in games like bioshock vs the 1080ti. The NV linux driver is solid and every bit the = of the nv windows driver so that is no minor feat.

If you're into rendering with Blender, the 2.79 beta has a bunch of OpenCL updates that allow for GPU renders that are faster than the CUDA branch. I may finally get off the AMD/nVidia box I've had for years and go Threadripper/Vega! Just have to convince my wife that only one of the kids needs to go to college! :whistle:

Edit: had the wrong version number
 
Last edited:
Back
Top