Amazon Should Be More Like Apple

It makes sense, anyone with 11 brain cells should know that a fad is only a fad because it's temporarily sexy. If you try to make it completely practical and cheap, you're missing the point of a fad.
 
Great. They can start shipping products in golden boxes made in China by suicidal sweatshop workers guarded by armed thugs. Shipping charges will skyrocket into the hundreds and you'll see them arriving at the tents of political protesters who lament "the corporations, man".

Then they'll be just like Apple.
 
Neither company should be like the other since they each have their niche and brand well established ... Apple uses software and services to sell hardware (a very high margin activity for them) ... Amazon uses hardware to sell software and services (a much lower margin but still acceptable business model) ... neither company could really do what the other does successfully and it would be foolish for these two archetypes to emulate the other

Whether other companies should be emulating them is a different question completely ... Walmart certainly has some elements they would like to steal from Amazon and Microsoft has dangerous aspirations to become another Apple (although I don't think the Apple model really works for MS) ... it is always fun to see analysts argue how one company's success means that same model can be copied by other companies ... that is rarely the case except in some very narrow markets ;)
 
Despite throwing a higher-resolution screen and more bells and whistles into the new Kindle Fire HDX, it's still no iPad.

Thank god. I hate iPads. Oh, they're pretty, but pretty doesn't pay the bills. I prefer function over form, not the other way around.

iPads remind me of a building I once visited to do a repair on a laptop, many years ago. The building had no ground floor! The whole thing was built 2 stories over 4 stairwells. It also had no front entrance, and all 4 stairwells were secured by key card. Very, very unfriendly to visitors. However, they had 16 parking spaces for visitors, most of which were unfilled at the time. I had to have someone meet me in the entrance area (the bottom of the building area was also walled in on all sides, blocking off any view from the outside) to let me in to do the repair. It was quite possibly the stupidest building design I have ever seen.

On top of that, Apple extensively uses standard business practices just like any other profitable corporation, but try their best to project this liberal anti-corp type image. It's completely hypocritical. I prefer honest companies where you know what you're going to get up front. That glossy white plastic or brushed aluminum finish they have used so much over the years now just reminds me of hypocrisy. It's totally lost any sense of "pretty" to me. Now I just see whitewashed tombs, if you know what I mean.
 
Twisted Kidney said:
It makes sense, anyone with 11 brain cells should know that a fad is only a fad because it's temporarily sexy. If you try to make it completely practical and cheap, you're missing the point of a fad.

230 million tablets are shipping this year, outselling notebooks and laptops. They are expected to outsell PCs by 2015. Cars stopped being a fad a long time ago, but don't let that keep you from clutching your buggy whip.

Oh, they're pretty, but pretty doesn't pay the bills.

The $146 billion in Apple's bank says pretty pays the bills.
 
The ONLY thing Kindle tablets has to offer is Amazon Prime.
That's it.
They already come with just one estore, Amazon.
You can't have an Amazon account without a prepaid gift card or credit/ debit card.
Most of the stuff you get for free in the Play Store they charge for.
Sure its "Android" but its forked so far off it may as well not be.
Really, outside of being way cheaper than Apple they're not too far apart.
Its the only "mobile" device you can watch your Prime videos on.
Kindle software is available for anything that lets you read Amazon E-Books.
 
The $146 billion in Apple's bank says pretty pays the bills.

I don't think Amazon is prepared to compete on pretty; they're pretty good at competing on appearance of low cost and functionality.
 
Amazon does not need to make their devices sexier. I think they need to make their software better--the hardware is excellent. And also, I would like it (others would disagree) if they went with a standard-looking Android UI vs. their carousel-oriented UI. Keep their FireOS as their own--not even asking for a standard android OS--just not their UI.

Others will have opposite testimonials, but my experience with my KFHD 7" was quite disappointing. It was super speedy out of the box, but within a few days the unit was beyond laggy. Apps would freeze, stop responding, and even built-in apps (email, silk--silk is the worst, by the way). This wasn't due to the problem of the storage being near capacity, or a TRIM support issue. I had multiple interactions with Amazon's support stating that OS OTA updates would address my software issues. But update after update, the problems continued. I think what amazon needs to work on is not making their devices sexier, but rather improving their OS. That's what killed it for me, and made me go with a nexus 7 (KFHD went to the wife).
 
Well, it is a little difficult to take seriously someone who lists "She enjoys feasting, merrymaking, checking her Gmail, and reading on her Kindle." in her byline :D
 
On top of that, Apple extensively uses standard business practices just like any other profitable corporation, but try their best to project this liberal anti-corp type image. It's completely hypocritical. I prefer honest companies where you know what you're going to get up front. That glossy white plastic or brushed aluminum finish they have used so much over the years now just reminds me of hypocrisy. It's totally lost any sense of "pretty" to me. Now I just see whitewashed tombs, if you know what I mean.

I think you are entirely wrong on this.

They don't use standard business practices just like other profitable corporations, they use WAY WORSE business practices than almost anyone out there. The closest business model to theirs in the last 50 years is that of Big Tobacco companies... Sell it as sexy, get your customers addicted, keep on selling to them for the rest of their lives because they don't know any better.

Apple goes out of its way to treat its customers like idiots, and it works. They are all about repression.... Keep your customers ignorant and they will never leave you, and it works too, as evidenced by the fact that so many people think Apple is anti-corporate when they are exactly the opposite. It is basically the same idea any number of dictators have used in the last two centuries to hold down the populace of entire nations.
 
Terrible article by Cnet and very wrong at the same time. I'm sure if Amazon (which is worth quite a lot more then Cnet) wanted to lose money, they'd listen to the hack-site.
 
Um, here's the thing. Amazon's stuff looks terrible *and* the software is shit.
 
Definitely, Donna Tam, the author of the CNET article has had no experience actually trying to market or sell a product.

Really, her advice is "Be like Apple."

Easier said than done. It's like telling me that to succeed with the ladies, I have to be more like Tyson Beckford... ain't gonna happen. Amazon will never be as sexy or a "fashionable" brand as Apple no matter what "hype" can be generated.

Well, let's see, Microsoft tried to "be like Apple" with their Surface marketing promotions... what happened there? Total failure.
The Surface had lots of "cool" (or what MSFT thought would be cool) ads and had the up-market pricing. And of course sales were FANTASTIC, right? :rolleyes:

Also, Amazon is already doing better than ANY OTHER iPAD competitor. The Kindle Fire HD is the second best selling tablet model PERIOD. (Samsung sells better if you add up all their models put together.) They should continue on with their current path... appealing to the people that use amazon.com. (That's predominantly the non-technical middle class part of the US population.)

I think that Amazon's Mayday button is pure genius for the market that they're targeting. It's absolutely useless for HardOCPers, but for the majority of the US population, it's a godsend. INSTANT personal tech support 7/24! No need to rely on a stinky geek "friend" to help you out.
 
Definitely, Donna Tam, the author of the CNET article has had no experience actually trying to market or sell a product.

Really, her advice is "Be like Apple."

Easier said than done. It's like telling me that to succeed with the ladies, I have to be more like Tyson Beckford... ain't gonna happen. Amazon will never be as sexy or a "fashionable" brand as Apple no matter what "hype" can be generated.

Well, let's see, Microsoft tried to "be like Apple" with their Surface marketing promotions... what happened there? Total failure.
The Surface had lots of "cool" (or what MSFT thought would be cool) ads and had the up-market pricing. And of course sales were FANTASTIC, right? :rolleyes:

Also, Amazon is already doing better than ANY OTHER iPAD competitor. The Kindle Fire HD is the second best selling tablet model PERIOD. (Samsung sells better if you add up all their models put together.) They should continue on with their current path... appealing to the people that use amazon.com. (That's predominantly the non-technical middle class part of the US population.)

I think that Amazon's Mayday button is pure genius for the market that they're targeting. It's absolutely useless for HardOCPers, but for the majority of the US population, it's a godsend. INSTANT personal tech support 7/24! No need to rely on a stinky geek "friend" to help you out.

Their mayday button could help them make the jump into Enterprise as well ... Microsoft should take note of that mod ... Apple isn't really Enterprise centric so they wouldn't care about such niceties ;)
 
Amazon is an online store, the whole point of Kindle is to sell their online services. Why would they aspire to be like Apple?
 
I've often believed that people who dwell on a gadget's outer case, it's texture, color, shape, and so on, do so as a defense mechanism. They're hoping no one will ask them what they like about the stuff on the inside of the case, because about that they have no clue...;) Yep, that's how Apple has always looked to me. Like Microsoft, the reason Amazon doesn't copy Apple is that it would be highly detrimental its business. Amazon sells thousands of products besides tablets; Microsoft does much more than just write x86-compatible operating systems. Apple, on the other hand, is firstly a cell-phone maker, secondly an MP3-player maker, and a distant thirdly, an x86-clone computer OEM. And that's the whole show for Apple, more or less.

Sexy is something I like in my women...;) (Oooowwwww! My wife just heard that and clobbered me.) It's not something I require in my hardware...what I want out of my hardware is compatibility, function, and price. Cosmetics is my last consideration and only comes into play if someone tries to sell me, say, a mouse shaped, colored, and scented like a pool of vomit. I might have to say no at that point.
 
The texture, shape and weight of an object that you will be handling is functional, is it not?
 
While the main article is just more Apple hype than anything there's one thing Amazon can learn from Apple.

Apple has global market penetration while Amazon is still basically USA-centric. The Amazon experience in markets outside the US leaves much to be desired leaving the Kindle pretty much neutered.

Sure there are ways to go around that but it's added effort/time/expense for something that should just work out-of-the-box.
 
Back
Top