Amazon Fights Demand for Customer Records

How about NC just drops sales taxes all together and gets their resident's money with a monstrously huge property tax. Surely all of that beachfront property would mean a lot of money right?
 
I don't live in N.C., but I hope Amazon wins!

This could affect even non-NC residents if NC wins against Amazon. So everyone in America, or at least those who live in states that have a sales tax, should watch this case and hope that Amazon wins the good fight.
 
As a business owner I have the wonderful joy of dealing with all the bullshit associated with the new privacy laws. I believe keeping client and customer info private is very important and we take very good care of our records. However, if we ran our business exactly like the privacy laws requires, we would not even be able to access our own customers. Then the State (I too live in NC) turns around and demands this shit. Then on top of that I received a letter from the state tax collectors and my SSN was clearly visible through the envelope window, sitting right next to my name and address.
 
Amazon still collects tax on NY purchases, btw. And the wrong amount (higher) to boot.
 
I don't know, I guess handing over customer records is one thing, but I find it hard to applaud Amazon when they still comply with collecting sales tax for NY just because "they said so". I would have pulled out of the state long enough for the constituents' angry wrath to make them reconsider or tell them to go to hell a la Newegg.
 
How about NC just drops sales taxes all together and gets their resident's money with a monstrously huge property tax. Surely all of that beachfront property would mean a lot of money right?

The ones that decide when and how much property taxes should be levied are the biggest property owners. They don't want to pay more taxes themselves. They want the masses to pay their public services bill for them.
 
The thing that is most worrisome is the past purchases. Theoretically, if NC wins, they could get records from essentially any online retailer and then post purchase demand years and years worth of sales tax that they were not paid. This could be thousands of dollars for some people (myself included) that they are now tax delinquent with all the "perks" of not paying taxes on time which may include fines for not paying in the first place.
 
How about NC just drops sales taxes all together and gets their resident's money with a monstrously huge property tax. Surely all of that beachfront property would mean a lot of money right?

I feel that we already pay a high property tax. They just re-evaluated our property and it more than trippled what it was before. However I can not compare what I pay to what others pay in a different state.
 
Prett much. States can only enact and enforce laws within their own territory. Anything that crosses state lines is Federal. There is no Federal sales tax therefor purchasing online from an out of state e-tailer means no taxes.

Hmm, isn't the act of purchasing done from a computer at a residence within that state giving them maybe very-slight juristicion? (I know the spelling there is horribly wrong).

It seems in this case, if the 'crime'(not really a crime imo...) is tax evasion of the 'use tax', one could make an argument that the tax-evasion occured when I clicked 'submit' with the opting out of paying taxes on my home-computer's Internet Browser which would have been locally in my state. As opposed to saying it happened out of state when the amazon server received the request from my computer/Internet Service Provider and was stored on a server somewhere. That's a bit of a chicken before the egg delima almost. When exactly does the crime of not paying 'use tax' occur over the Internet? In the electronic transmission or in receiving of that transmission by the business?

Its almost akin to saying if I am threatening bodily harm against someone over the phone if the harm occurs when I speak into my phone or when the words come out of the receiver on the other end. If those two places are in different states, I think I'm still commiting a crime regardless and which police authority charges me would seem somehow irrelevant maybe?
 
The thing that is most worrisome is the past purchases. Theoretically, if NC wins, they could get records from essentially any online retailer and then post purchase demand years and years worth of sales tax that they were not paid. This could be thousands of dollars for some people (myself included) that they are now tax delinquent with all the "perks" of not paying taxes on time which may include fines for not paying in the first place.

This ^^. Potentially, it could bankrupt some people or cause mortgage foreclosures if they put a lean on our property, garnish your wages, etc. It would be sick if it caused a local economy crash in the state of NC assuming say 20% of the population/businesses of NC has made enough online purchases that paying the taxes might cause financial hardship.
 
Hmm, isn't the act of purchasing done from a computer at a residence within that state giving them maybe very-slight juristicion? (I know the spelling there is horribly wrong).

It seems in this case, if the 'crime'(not really a crime imo...) is tax evasion of the 'use tax', one could make an argument that the tax-evasion occured when I clicked 'submit' with the opting out of paying taxes on my home-computer's Internet Browser which would have been locally in my state. As opposed to saying it happened out of state when the amazon server received the request from my computer/Internet Service Provider and was stored on a server somewhere. That's a bit of a chicken before the egg delima almost. When exactly does the crime of not paying 'use tax' occur over the Internet? In the electronic transmission or in receiving of that transmission by the business?

Its almost akin to saying if I am threatening bodily harm against someone over the phone if the harm occurs when I speak into my phone or when the words come out of the receiver on the other end. If those two places are in different states, I think I'm still commiting a crime regardless and which police authority charges me would seem somehow irrelevant maybe?

I'm going to say the onus lies on the taxpayer. They have to pay use taxes when the item is being used by them in NC. And they are not going to prosecute individual taxpayers; it would be way too politically unpopular. I don't think they have a leg to stand on going after Amazon since it has no presence in NC.
 
Hmm, isn't the act of purchasing done from a computer at a residence within that state giving them maybe very-slight juristicion? (I know the spelling there is horribly wrong).

It seems in this case, if the 'crime'(not really a crime imo...) is tax evasion of the 'use tax', one could make an argument that the tax-evasion occured when I clicked 'submit' with the opting out of paying taxes on my home-computer's Internet Browser which would have been locally in my state. As opposed to saying it happened out of state when the amazon server received the request from my computer/Internet Service Provider and was stored on a server somewhere. That's a bit of a chicken before the egg delima almost. When exactly does the crime of not paying 'use tax' occur over the Internet? In the electronic transmission or in receiving of that transmission by the business?

Its almost akin to saying if I am threatening bodily harm against someone over the phone if the harm occurs when I speak into my phone or when the words come out of the receiver on the other end. If those two places are in different states, I think I'm still commiting a crime regardless and which police authority charges me would seem somehow irrelevant maybe?

Jurisdiction doesn't matter. I could be sitting in a coffee shop in Florida, make an online purchase of something from Georgia to ship to my NC home address. As long as I use that item in NC, I have to pay the use tax. Hence the term "use tax". However, I could purchase something from my home in NC. Right when I get it, I bring it to my beach house in South Carolina (I don't really have one :p ) where it stays there. Then I don't have to pay the use tax, because I'm not using it in North Carolina. (I think I'm right about that, but not 100%)
 
As unpopular as this sounds, it is perfectly legal for them to require you to pay the taxes on internet purchases. Most of the tax software asks you if you purchased anything online and then prompts you to enter a number.

With so many states in debt, they are turning to things like this, increased ticketing, legalizing marajuana (CA), etc. The money has to come from somewhere. Internet sales did more to hurt states than a lot of things because they depend on the sales taxes.
 
As unpopular as this sounds, it is perfectly legal for them to require you to pay the taxes on internet purchases. Most of the tax software asks you if you purchased anything online and then prompts you to enter a number.

With so many states in debt, they are turning to things like this, increased ticketing, legalizing marajuana (CA), etc. The money has to come from somewhere. Internet sales did more to hurt states than a lot of things because they depend on the sales taxes.

It doesn't have to be an internet purchase. The use tax covers anything you bought anywhere and no matter where you were sitting/standing when you purchased, so long as you use it in North Carolina.

As for state budgets... rather than find new sources of revenue, they need to TRIM their current budgets, just like the rest of Americans are doing.
 
It doesn't have to be an internet purchase. The use tax covers anything you bought anywhere and no matter where you were sitting/standing when you purchased, so long as you use it in North Carolina.

As for state budgets... rather than find new sources of revenue, they need to TRIM their current budgets, just like the rest of Americans are doing.

You're correct. I was just pointing out the most obvious violation of the use tax ;). And I completely agree. Here in PA, we have the most bloated state legislature in the country (253 members of the house/senate). Why don't they trim half of that out and you'd save millions? They recently tried to make I-80 a toll road meaning all East/West interstates across the state would be toll roads. Plus, they legalized gambling to help them deal with budget issues, and obviously they are still in debt.
 
As unpopular as this sounds, it is perfectly legal for them to require you to pay the taxes on internet purchases. Most of the tax software asks you if you purchased anything online and then prompts you to enter a number.

With so many states in debt, they are turning to things like this, increased ticketing, legalizing marajuana (CA), etc. The money has to come from somewhere. Internet sales did more to hurt states than a lot of things because they depend on the sales taxes.

No it's not. INTRASTATE COMMERECE is regulated by the federal government. End of story.
If it's a deficit problem, then the governments need to cut spending. Not raise taxes.
 
You're correct. I was just pointing out the most obvious violation of the use tax ;). And I completely agree. Here in PA, we have the most bloated state legislature in the country (253 members of the house/senate). Why don't they trim half of that out and you'd save millions? They recently tried to make I-80 a toll road meaning all East/West interstates across the state would be toll roads. Plus, they legalized gambling to help them deal with budget issues, and obviously they are still in debt.

Heh.... NC has an education lottery now. Now when you buy a ticket it goes to education. Can't forget the kids! The problem, is that normal tax revenue that used to go to the kids now has been diverted to other programs. And less than 35% actually goes to the kids. Most likely a lot less than that. heh, the poor tax. Bev Perdue, champion for the poor in NC!
 
Can you imagine on day getting a bill from your State on back taxes owed for your Amazon purchases. Yeah, they are about desperate enough (taxation without representation). Too bad the nutzos have already taken the "tea party" name, how about "don't tread on me".
 
No it's not. INTRASTATE COMMERECE is regulated by the federal government. End of story.
If it's a deficit problem, then the governments need to cut spending. Not raise taxes.

Governments do need to cut spending...I completely agree. But a use tax is something that the state can or cannot require. Just because you're buying it from out of state, if you're using it in your state, they tax you. However, it is hard to keep track of, hence, there is no "sales tax" for internet purchases.

You're pretty smug for someone who is entirely wrong.

I thought the same thing, but oh well. Don't get me wrong, I'm against paying this, but states are going to try to get money from everywhere/anywhere they can get it due to the economy.
 
Back
Top