Am i crazy for even thinking about this switch?

rxteenager

Gawd
Joined
Apr 20, 2007
Messages
557
So a friend of mine wants to buy my gpu+mobo+cpu i have the following stuff
e8400
p5q pro
sapphire hd 4850
he's offering 350 for all that and well i been wanting to go quad for a while.

Would it make any sense to go from that to this
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131366
and a phenom 2 x4 940

I would really love to go amd to support them, but does it make any sense to anyone to have such twisted desires? and would i see any performance? oh and i would have to live on the intergrated graphics the card has for a while, until i save up for my hd4890.
 
Sell the mobo and CPU , keep the 4850. Then get the CPU and motherboard you are looking at.
 
So a friend of mine wants to buy my gpu+mobo+cpu i have the following stuff
e8400
p5q pro
sapphire hd 4850
he's offering 350 for all that and well i been wanting to go quad for a while.

Would it make any sense to go from that to this
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131366
and a phenom 2 x4 940

I would really love to go amd to support them, but does it make any sense to anyone to have such twisted desires? and would i see any performance? oh and i would have to live on the intergrated graphics the card has for a while, until i save up for my hd4890.

It's not crazy, I had such thoughts, but figured that the costs outweigh the benefits. But I'm getting old and lazy... That being said, if both platforms offer similar performance, check the power consumption parts in [H] reviews and consider your electricity bill.
 
The 940 is an AM2+ CPU and will not work with that AM3 board. You'd need an AM3 CPU. Compared to the 940, the 810 is a step down or the 955 is a step up.

Remember that the PhII is designed to compete with the C2Q's. The i7 still beats it pretty good in most CPU tests. http://www.techspot.com/review/162-amd-phenom2-x4-955/page12.html shows the i7 920 beating the PhII 955 overclocked to 3.7GHz by 22-27% in Sandra and WinRAR. If you're basically buying a completely new system, the i7 is going to be a better performer, but it will cost more too.
 
I wouldn't.. the benefit would be minimal. If anything I would get an Intel Quad then OC it. I would only go AMD if I needed a budget system.
 
yeah i don't know why i got that sick though into my head last night. Thanks for helping me stick with the right decision.
 
Back
Top