Am I a big minority?

ShoeLace

Gawd
Joined
Apr 5, 2006
Messages
650
To me this is a perfect computer display:

20"
1600x1200 native (4:3)
decent color reproduction
0ms to absolute minimal input lag
none to absolute minimal ghosting
quite good non-native image scaling

I'm beginning to think my tastes in a display must be way off from what most people want since there doesn't seem to be a single display that fits the above (other than a CRT of course -- I'm talking about LCDs here).

Is anyone else interested in such a display, or do you like your laggy widescreens or decent widescreens that can't do 4:3 perfectly?
 
I think a lot of peoples tastes are the same (except for the non-widescreen bit)...its just the plain and simple fact that no amount of consumer want is going to make LCD's get any better. I think LCD's are getting close to the peak of what is possible with the technology and until we have FED,SED,OLED, or whatever other technology comes along next you wont have the option available for the kind of display you are looking for.

I think LCD can offer close to what you want with a VA based technology or IPS based but really I do not see any way an LCD could do exactly what you are asking....CRT is going to be your best bet if you can deal with the bulk....
 
That's the reason I still haven't switched to LCDs. Unfortunately, I've had my 22" iiyama for a while now and I fear that when it goes it'll be difficult to find a comparable replacement at a reasonable price.
 
different strokes different folks. Id rather have 16:10 than 4:3. 4:3 just seems too "square" ever since I switched
 
Yes, but put a nice 4:3 20" on its side and you have a great full page document reader that is great as a second monitor next to a 22 or 24 inch widescreen.

I think a widescreen tilted 90 degrees is just too tall and narrow comparred to a nice 1600 X 1200 20".

I also agree. If you don't use Photoshop, Dreamweaver, or other Desktop Publishing program, I find that the wide monitors have too much dead space on the sides. It is great for photoshop, but is useless for Word or the internet. Lastly, Excel is great on a WS monitor.

Just a little input..
 
I had a 4:3 20" 1600x1200 monitor. The panel was defective and the manufacturer refused to allow me to RMA it.

Response time was 20, more like 30. Really bad, you aren't going to find near 0 response time monitors in 4:3 anymore, manufacturing has switched to widescreen. Also, as a gamer, widescreen is much better for gaming.
 
Dell 2007FP? Its as fast as any TN panel and has superior color accuracy.
 
So you want a 20" LCD... that is perfect in every way, from color to response time to ghosting to scaling.

Good luck finding those qualities in *any* LCD.
 
Also, as a gamer, widescreen is much better for gaming.

Depends on the game I guess. What if a game isn't capable of running above 640x480 or 800x600 and requires absolutely perfect geometry @ 4:3 (otherwise it's a waste of time)?

Widescreen isn't an option then. Even with blackbars the geometry is a little off on widescreens. I don't know why, but it is. I haven't tested every single widescreen of course, but I have looked at a few.

So you want a 20" LCD... that is perfect in every way, from color to response time to ghosting to scaling.

Nope, I just want a nice 20" that'll do 1600x1200 with minimal input lag/ghosting and can scale an image to an acceptable quality level at non-native resolutions. In the end I really don't care about the color accuracy as long as isn't so far off that I'm mistaking orange for purple. :D

It just seems like now every single LCD is widescreen. There's a bunch of 19"s that'll do 1280x1024 but that's pretty weak for general desktop use (especially as a programmer).

Dell 2007FP

Panel lotto. It was one of my considerations, but I can't find a local one to try out first hand.
 
im curious as to how you dont find a widescreen beneficial for programming?

I enjoy having 2 and 3 windows side by side to reference eachother. This is especially handy for web development... (a browser to test, the source, and another source (ie CSS while the other is the page and so forth). I dont do much other programming, but I just dont see how a widescreen causes problems in this instance.

I could never go back to 4:3 after 10 seconds on my nice new 22" at 1680x1050. Its fine with gaming (in regards to response time and ghosting...never noticed a thing), the color reproduction is great, and the extra width is wonderful in all instances for me. I suppose to each their own - perhaps some people may notice "ghosting" and so on...but it works wonderfully for me. no complaints whatsoever...I guess being a happy widescreen user I just dont see how you can still prefer a 4:3 :p
 
Depends on your height, weight and what your race is vs the country you live in.:p:D

Seriously though...yes, people who prefer 4:3 monitors are in the minority now...but everything else you want sounds great even if it can't be found in any one single model of monitor.
 
im curious as to how you dont find a widescreen beneficial for programming?

That anti-programmer comment was geared towards using a 19" 1280x1024 display (since there's a bunch of these monitors to choose from as opposed to very little that do 1600x1200). Visual Studio is nearly unusable without at least 1680x1050 or 1600x1200.

Ghosting isn't too big of a deal. It'll happen, but I think a majority of the newer LCDs do a decent job at preventing it.

It's the non-perfect 4:3 geometry and input lag that's killing it for me on the current generation widescreens. The only game I play has about a 250x250 pixel circle located in the corner of the screen. There's an arrow drawn at a specific degree (1-360, in addition to decimal degrees). If this circle is not perfectly round it skews my perception of what the angle really is. In almost every case if I read it incorrectly it will result in a "miss" which isn't acceptable at the level I play at.

I haven't met a widescreen that'll display this circle as round as my CRT (even with blackbars) at 640x480. It's either skewed horizontal slightly, or has such poor non-native resolution support that it's gross looking.

The game I'm referencing is Albatross 18 (or Pangya). Millions of people play this game (world wide).
 
Back
Top