Aluminum transformers in UPS units

michalrz

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
4,943
Hi there

A funny thing happened on my way to salvage enameled copper wire from the transformer of a dead UPS unit.
As I cut some of the primary wiring I noticed it's actually... Aluminum. Same on the secondary. Its insulation is copper-coloured but the cross-section is all Al.

The device in question is an 'ActiveJet Energy'. It's probably a local brand here so you might not know them. I haven't had any particular problems with them in the past.

This particular model claimed 650VA, 360 Watts.
First of all - isn't that a pretty bad power factor (W/VA)?

If so, can it be because the Aluminum transformer? Have you guys made a similar discovery in other UPS units or PSUs?

Can any power guru chime in and explain the pros and cons - like how much efficiency is lost due to not using copper?
 
That's a power factor of 0.55, which is bad, but typical of a switch-mode power supply without power factor correction.

There is no loss in efficiency from using aluminium wire in a transformer - its lower conductivity can be compensated for by using thicker wire. The main problem with aluminium wires is that it's difficult to make reliable connections to it, because the oxide that forms on the surface is non-conductive, and the metal creeps over time. This makes reliability harder to acheive.
 
Thanks for your input!

Yes I've read older aluminum house wiring wouldn't have been so unreliable if proper care was taken with interconnects. I wonder if the people who assemble them actually take precautions.

However could you clarify what you meant by the metal 'creeping'?
 
If you clamp down on a peice of aluminium, over time it will flow away from the pressure, like pressing down on a lump of plasticine. This reduces the clamping pressure and eventually leads to a loose connection. Such slow deformation under pressure is called "creep".
 
One more thing though if you'd be kind enough:

So, because of the need for thicker wire in Al windings, a copper counterpart would be noticeably smaller - yes?

The transformer in question was quite bulky and made up a good chunk of the unit's interior.

Overall, is this something one should be concerned about while planning a bulk purchase of UPS units? Would it be wise to point this criteria as a requirement for potential sellers, or would it be nit-picking?

Do high-end vendors follow this practice?
 
A copper transformer will be smaller, but heavier.

I wouldn't worry about which material has been used; with proper construction, it shouldn't make any practical difference.

I have no particular experience with UPS's, so I don't know if aluminium transformers are common.
 
One more thing though if you'd be kind enough:

So, because of the need for thicker wire in Al windings, a copper counterpart would be noticeably smaller - yes?

UPS transformers are so large because they run at mains switching frequency (50/60 Hz) and have to deal with lots of amps, which requires thicker wire. Switching the windings to copper would allow the transformer to be slightly smaller, but not by any significant amount.

If you wanted to considerably reduce the size of the transformer, you'd have to crank up the switching frequency to like 10-30 kHz. This is why computer power supplies have such small transformers in them.

I have no particular experience with UPS's, so I don't know if aluminium transformers are common.

If I were to guess why aluminum windings were used in a transformer, I'd say it's because of cost cutting.

Right now:

1 lb of copper is $2.30-$3.00
1 lb of aluminum is ~$0.69

Even if you had to make the aluminum wire slightly bigger to make up for efficiency losses, it'd still be cheaper.
 
Back
Top