All quiet on the ATI front

Labrador

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jan 19, 2002
Messages
1,930
All I hear from the ATI camp is crickets chirping in the night ? Why have we not heard one word on their brand new ground breaking next generation [H]ardware code named R520 ? First it was supposed to be officially announced July26th, and now weeks later still nothing, while nVidia just sweepes the floor up with their 7800GTX.

Even myself a ATI !!!!!!, having owned a 9700Pro, 9800PRo and X850XT, went out and bought the eVga 7800GTX, and love it for BattleField2 1920x1200res gaming :) But I couldnt wait for the new card, with no hopes of it coimgn it this month still ?

whats the real word ?
 
Labrador said:
All I hear from the ATI camp is crickets chirping in the night ? Why have we not heard one word on their brand new ground breaking next generation [H]ardware code named R520 ? First it was supposed to be officially announced July26th, and now weeks later still nothing, while nVidia just sweepes the floor up with their 7800GTX.

Even myself a ATI !!!!!!, having owned a 9700Pro, 9800PRo and X850XT, went out and bought the eVga 7800GTX, and love it for BattleField2 1920x1200res gaming :) But I couldnt wait for the new card, with no hopes of it coimgn it this month still ?

whats the real word ?

They are working hard but they are having problems, as for details, no one really knows what the heck they are doing, even if someone knows he/she is most likely under NDA. I agree with you, nVidia's done it right this round.
 
I would go back the ATi, and sell my 7800GTX to my Brother, but the ATI x950XT or what ever they name it, will have to be at least 10-20% faster fro them to get people away from nVidia, or $100 cheaper ?
 
Labrador said:
I would go back the ATi, and sell my 7800GTX to my Brother, but the ATI x950XT or what ever they name it, will have to be at least 10-20% faster fro them to get people away from nVidia, or $100 cheaper ?
The performance probably matters more than the price. People will forget about the delay if it takes out nvidia for 10-20%. However, they'll have to do it soon because the 7800GTX is Clear King right now.
 
Labrador said:
I would go back the ATi, and sell my 7800GTX to my Brother, but the ATI x950XT or what ever they name it, will have to be at least 10-20% faster fro them to get people away from nVidia, or $100 cheaper ?

well ..... I dont know.. but IT BETTER BE FASTER than the 7800gtx lol.... be kinda sad if it wasn't..
 
I am worried if Crossfire will not be out for another month, they wont release the R520 at the same time, that would hurt sales, so this sounds like a longer delay ? Maybe Oct/Nov ?
 
lots of rumors are out about how its having a lot of leakage problems and 90 nano meter problems.

also rumored is it may not be a 24 or 32 pipeline but rather a 16 due to the fact they are trying for 600-700 mhz on it.

but who knows.

by the time they get it out nvidia will counter w/ an ultra and better drivers.
 
Sounds like nVidia already won this round before it started ? I mean lets say the R520 is kick ass, once ot comes our retial, nVidia will see how it really performs, and a month later the 7800Ultra will be out at like 550mhz 1400memory ? which should be enough to beat the R520 ?
 
maybe ATI will hold back the XT or XTPE's to try and fight the ultras....

but it seems that most people who have the cash are ready to jump no the 7800GTX.
 
DryFire said:
maybe ATI will hold back the XT or XTPE's to try and fight the ultras....

but it seems that most people who have the cash are ready to jump no the 7800GTX.

One thing they did great on the 7800 GTX is the optimizations for resolutions 1600x1200~2048x1536. Until 7800 showed up, performance took huge hit once you go above 1600x1200, so those of us using LCDs with native resolutions above that were pretty much screwed, I don't know about anybody else but that was one of the biggest selling point on the 7800 for me.
 
Labrador said:
Sounds like nVidia already won this round before it started ? I mean lets say the R520 is kick ass, once ot comes our retial, nVidia will see how it really performs, and a month later the 7800Ultra will be out at like 550mhz 1400memory ? which should be enough to beat the R520 ?
i always thought that the next one in the 7x00 was gunna be the 7800GT, the GTX younger brother....but now that i think of it, taht just dusnt make sense :rolleyes:
 
I have my r520 right here, it's pretty nice (it's blue and silver) but since I'm under NDA I can't tell you that it's 2 pipes at 1200mhz gpu speed and 512bit ram at 800mhz ddr speed. Nope, can't tell you that at all.

~Liar
 
ATi will have the R520 ready for release when DNF goes gold which should be very soon.
 
I sort of given up waiting, I'm going for a 7800GTX

unless ATI releases something VERY good (A large speed boost, or something like Dx10 support) then I doubt I'll trade it in.
 
geekcomputing said:
lots of rumors are out about how its having a lot of leakage problems and 90 nano meter problems.

also rumored is it may not be a 24 or 32 pipeline but rather a 16 due to the fact they are trying for 600-700 mhz on it.

but who knows.

by the time they get it out nvidia will counter w/ an ultra and better drivers.

No the rumor was that their yields are poor with 32 and even 24 pipe models, therefore they may be forced to pump the clock frequency up to 600-700mhz in order to be competitive. They aren't shooting for high clock, they would much rather have high pipelines, but the rumor is that they may not be able to pull that off quite yet until they can solve the yield problems.
 
sakurakana1003 said:
One thing they did great on the 7800 GTX is the optimizations for resolutions 1600x1200~2048x1536. Until 7800 showed up, performance took huge hit once you go above 1600x1200, so those of us using LCDs with native resolutions above that were pretty much screwed, I don't know about anybody else but that was one of the biggest selling point on the 7800 for me.

There is no optimizations with the 7800 for higher resolutions, simply more power to push the greater number of pixels needed for higher resolutions. :rolleyes:
 
Erasmus354 said:
There is no optimizations with the 7800 for higher resolutions, simply more power to push the greater number of pixels needed for higher resolutions. :rolleyes:

Then whatever article I read regarding this issue must have been lying then, just can't remember where that article was from.

I'll be sure to post back when I come across that article again, I don't tend to BS about things, if the article was wrong then I'm wrong.
 
sakurakana1003 said:
That is it! Thank you so much this is the second time you've come to my rescue now! :D
lol, how could I forget - you're the guy with my computer :p
 
Who gives a *shit?* Buy what you like. 3DFX went under and the world still turned. For GOD SAKES, MATROX is still in business!!!!!! If MATROX can survive, ATi sure will.

All these video card intrigues are gay. Buy whichever one has the best performance you can afford at the time, which right now is nvidia. When I had my 9500 Pro it was Ati. A year and a half from now ATi will probably be on top again if they make it through this dry spell, which they will. They are not gonna go under becuase they dont have a gaming card that <1% of the total computer user population is gonna buy right now.
 
PRIME1 said:
ATI is now a paper company.
Sure, nVidia won this round, but some of us need to start learning from the past and start seeing more than 2 months ahead. Remember when the 9700PRO came out, the rumors about nVidias impending death in 1-2 months started flying. I´m sure the war will rage on. ATi will counter with a better card in a cycle or two, and nVidia will counter with a better card to that one. That´s how it´s been working for years now.
 
Killa|3yte said:
Sure, nVidia won this round, but some of us need to start learning from the past and start seeing more than 2 months ahead. Remember when the 9700PRO came out, the rumors about nVidias impending death in 1-2 months started flying. I´m sure the war will rage on. ATi will counter with a better card in a cycle or two, and nVidia will counter with a better card to that one. That´s how it´s been working for years now.
And that's a good way for each company to keep their prices up! Whoever has the fastest chip at a given time can charge a premium for it.

Kinda makes one wonder how much R520 and Crossfire will cost if it bests the G70 by a decent margin.
 
DejaWiz said:
And that's a good way for each company to keep their prices up! Whoever has the fastest chip at a given time can charge a premium for it.

Kinda makes one wonder how much R520 and Crossfire will cost if it bests the G70 by a decent margin.

Well if either of these two companies was in monopoly, you'd be paying a lot more money for a lot less performance.
 
sakurakana1003 said:
Well if either of these two companies was in monopoly, you'd be paying a lot more money for a lot less performance.
True that!

But as far as 7800GTX vs R520 goes, nVidia does seem to have somewhat of a monopoly...
It's funny. I can remember when nVidia put the hurt on with the TNT2 and again with the GeForce 256. Those sold for about $299 upon introduction. Here we are 6 years later and video card prices have now doubled.
 
As I've understood it, look for late August/early September for an announcement.
 
DejaWiz said:
True that!

But as far as 7800GTX vs R520 goes, nVidia does seem to have somewhat of a monopoly...
It's funny. I can remember when nVidia put the hurt on with the TNT2 and again with the GeForce 256. Those sold for about $299 upon introduction. Here we are 6 years later and video card prices have now doubled.

Producing 300+ millions of transistors on much smaller processes and at higher clocks (or better work efficienty) all costs a lot of money. Also don´t forget the expensive memory bus and memory itself, all the extra components to keep these power hungry beasts stable and last but not least the more expensive cooling solutions. And at last the big R&D bill that we customers have to pay as well.

Sure it would be really interesting what type of profit margins the IHV´s have on their cards, lets say a GTX costs them about a $100 per unit, in that case the profit margins aren´t bad but there are other industries that have MUCH larger profit margins on their products.

I didn´t like the higher MSRP when NV released the GTX either, but they knew that people are able to pay so much especially since they saw how people paid $800+ on the paper launched cards. I like the current price of the GTX, its totally reasonable for the performance it offers and its been a little more than a month.
 
karl76 said:
I didn´t like the higher MSRP when NV released the GTX either, but they knew that people are able to pay so much especially since they saw how people paid $800+ on the paper launched cards. I like the current price of the GTX, its totally reasonable for the performance it offers and its been a little more than a month.
I concur. The initial price was pure shock and awe for a lot of us. But now, at just over a month old, the GTX price has dropped considerably. $100-$120 below what the inception price was is an impressive decline.

And I feel for manufacturers like ATI that have to dump a huge quanity of money into R&D as well as refined fabrication. It's not cheap. And it's not easy. And problems such as yield issues aren't without a price tag, as well. I'm happy they were able to get the Microsoft contract. Chances are it means that they now have more revenue to help advance the R&D and fabrication refinements that they have been planning for probably what is a very long time now.
 
sakurakana1003 said:
One thing they did great on the 7800 GTX is the optimizations for resolutions 1600x1200~2048x1536. Until 7800 showed up, performance took huge hit once you go above 1600x1200, so those of us using LCDs with native resolutions above that were pretty much screwed, I don't know about anybody else but that was one of the biggest selling point on the 7800 for me.

Yeah, the 7800GTX does wonders for my 2005FPW.

What really did it for me what supersampling antialising.
 
aZn_plyR said:
well ..... I dont know.. but IT BETTER BE FASTER than the 7800gtx lol.... be kinda sad if it wasn't..

Just releasing it would be a major accomplishment...................
 
Everyone forgets ATI is in both the Xbox 360 and the Rev.

If they can get a 90nm 332million transister chip that runs at 500mhz and cool enough for a console out then im rather confident they can do the same with R520.
 
DejaWiz said:
True that!

But as far as 7800GTX vs R520 goes, nVidia does seem to have somewhat of a monopoly...
It's funny. I can remember when nVidia put the hurt on with the TNT2 and again with the GeForce 256. Those sold for about $299 upon introduction. Here we are 6 years later and video card prices have now doubled.


the FX line was retailing for 450-500, i think thats more of a travesty.
 
Back
Top