All-in-One Watercooling advice needed.

Agrippa

n00b
Joined
Jan 28, 2006
Messages
13
I've never touched water cooling due to the added hassle, but these days, with the plethora of well-performing all-in-one sets available, I've started thinking about getting one of them. The many reviews available are all well and good, but what they naturally never mention is the longevity of such sets.

What I'd like to know, if anyone can tell me, is how long I can count on a water cooling set to go on working without needing intervention or a swap. The reason I've never bothered with water before is because I want my computer to be as no-hassle as possible. Every air cooler I've ever had has worked flawlessly for years; the last one for almost five years of continuous operation. And that's what I'm wondering if, say, a Corsair Hydro, Cooler Master Seidon or a NZXT X60 will also do.

Anyone?
 
I have had a corsair h80 for nearly 2 years now and has been pretty flawless. It came free when I bought a 3930k and motherboard from Microcenter. Only thing I had to do was change the thermal paste once and use different fans. Mine came with two non pwm fans that surge and make a ton of noise. I believe the corsair units now all come with pwm fans that can be controlled. They aren't designed to be maintained like a normal water cooling setup.
 
So why would you want to switch to water now over air if air has been reliable? I personally like the unit(s) I have have used for how quiet they are/were and for moving the hot air out of my case. Todays air coolers are as quiet or more quiet than the AiO water units though and have the added longevity of no pump failure. If you want your system as hands off as possible, I would just stay with a solid air cooler.
 
I had an H70 on my machine since when was launching in the market, I used for years and its still working great in my secondary/Home-Server Machine. also one of my brothers have an h80i, the other a Kraken X60 and i use an h100i.. which i had a factory issue with the pump, i got swaped one the same day in the store i bought it, and its still working since last year.. the only thing you have to check its the dust (as every other air cooler). the AIO radiators are dust magnet due to the low space between fins, if you check constantly and you clean it you will be fine for years.. they are made to last very a long time.. my h70 are using 24/7 and work flawless..
 
I had an H70 on my machine since when was launching in the market, I used for years and its still working great in my secondary/Home-Server Machine. also one of my brothers have an h80i, the other a Kraken X60 and i use an h100i.. which i had a factory issue with the pump, i got swaped one the same day in the store i bought it, and its still working since last year.. the only thing you have to check its the dust (as every other air cooler). the AIO radiators are dust magnet due to the low space between fins, if you check constantly and you clean it you will be fine for years.. they are made to last very a long time.. my h70 are using 24/7 and work flawless..

Yeah totally a must to check for dust or if you have pets check for pet hairs. Mine was clogged up completely. Caused for some hair raising temperatures.
 
I have had a custom water cooling set working for 5+ years with little to no maintenance. Also have had both the H80 and the H100 since release and both are still running great with no maintenance. If you keep the fans and resevoir clean then you shouldn't have any issues. I greatly prefer them over air coolers and have set up many systems for others with water cooling.
 
So why would you want to switch to water now over air if air has been reliable? I personally like the unit(s) I have have used for how quiet they are/were and for moving the hot air out of my case. Todays air coolers are as quiet or more quiet than the AiO water units though and have the added longevity of no pump failure. If you want your system as hands off as possible, I would just stay with a solid air cooler.

The only real reason is noise. My Thermaltake Silver Shadow is (usually) the loudest thing in my system and although it's not extremely noisy, it'd be nice to lower the sound level even more.

Thanks to everyone who chimed in; it sounds like this might just be worth considering further. Thanks for the tip on keeping the radiator clean too. I've no pets, but there are usually a few dust bunnies hiding here and there, so that's useful to know.
 
The only real reason is noise. My Thermaltake Silver Shadow is (usually) the loudest thing in my system and although it's not extremely noisy, it'd be nice to lower the sound level even more.

Thanks to everyone who chimed in; it sounds like this might just be worth considering further. Thanks for the tip on keeping the radiator clean too. I've no pets, but there are usually a few dust bunnies hiding here and there, so that's useful to know.

Yeah the front fan on my H80 didn't have much, but the rear fan pulling the air in had a lovely layer of fur embedded in it. Needless to say cooling performance was horrible :( I am pretty impressed with corsair's AIO kit and am considering bumping up to the h100i. Plus the quietness the H80 has offered I can barely tell the system is running.
 
I have had my H80 and previous 620 running for years with no dust build up at all in the raven case in sig. I'm actually amazed at how clean these cases are with cleaning the filters like three times a year. Haven't cleaned the case in over 2.5 years and it still doesn't need it yet.
 
Yeah the front fan on my H80 didn't have much, but the rear fan pulling the air in had a lovely layer of fur embedded in it. Needless to say cooling performance was horrible :( I am pretty impressed with corsair's AIO kit and am considering bumping up to the h100i. Plus the quietness the H80 has offered I can barely tell the system is running.

That's what I wanted to hear! I'll keep the dust issue very much in mind, although I have filters fitted to every "orifice" of my Lian Li PC-D8000 and don't expect it to become a major issue despite the dust bunnies which hide here and there. My previous case, another Lian Li, was also fully fitted with filters and I never cleaned it inside in five years, only washed the filters when they seemed to need it. When I built my new system this spring there was only a very, very slight layer of dust inside. The current filters are better than the old ones, so it ought to be even less of an issue with this machine.

Thanks for the info folks, much appreciated! Time to sit down and really check those water cooling reviews I guess.
 
Hmmm. Having done some reading, I think probably the Corsair H110 would be a far better choice for me. It appears to be within easy spitting distance of the X60 in terms of performance, while at the same time being far less noisy. It's also a shade cheaper and the PC-D8000 will let me mount a 280mm radiator with ease.
 
Kraken X60 and corsair H110 are basically the same product made for the same manufacturer, the only really different are the pump, wich its slightly better than H110 and also have USB header to monitoring and and control RPM via included software, the H110 are directly controlled by the mobo. so more user friendly the X60 the rest are 99% the same.. buy the cheaper you can find of those and you will be perfect..
 
(Double Post, sorry Delete it. keep receiving 502 Bad Gateway Error)
 
Last edited:
If you want quiet, the best thing would be to get the biggest/best AIO cooler so it will not need as much fan speed.
 
Back
Top