Aircool or Watercool???? Server/HTPC

Aircool or Watercool the box0r

  • Watercool

    Votes: 5 45.5%
  • Aircool

    Votes: 6 54.5%

  • Total voters
    11

J4M3S0N79

Gawd
Joined
Jul 25, 2002
Messages
812
Hello,
As seen in my sig, I am currently engaged in a really cool project that I am documenting over at http://apttech.blogspot.com and I really need your advice. I am building a home server/htpc based on an Intel p4c 2.4ghz and IC7-MAX3 combination. This setup will have an amazing 840GB of storage across 5 drives. So the issue is this.

P4C 2.4 will be at 3.0 with a 250mhx bus at 1:1

CPU = HOT (intel duh)
Ram = HOT (OCZ PC4000 Gold) 2.8ish volts
5 HDDs = HOT
i875P = HOT
9800PRO = HOT

I have in my posession an EXOS2 that I like a lot, but that will cool my performance box and I need to know what to cool my server with. The idea is that this will be a 24x7 machine and I need something that is stable, cool and quiet. To complicate matters, I have the GPU, NB and CPU coolers for the intel setup, but I only lack the exos (original) unit itself. Options:

1) Get the original EXOS to keep it cool and quiet

or

2) Put MORE fans into the setup with a beefy air cooling solution.

Thanks,
M
 
Well for the most part your cooling is fine, Northwoods are pretty easy to cool down (thank god you're not using a Prescott).

CPU cooler: http://www.jab-tech.com/customer/product.php?productid=2581&cat=46&page=1
Video card cooler: http://www.sidewindercomputers.com/arcoatisi1fo.html

The motherboard on the other hand is going to be hard, the OTES system isn't suitable for HTPC due to noise levels and the chipset fan would have to be replaced. This might work well.

For a PSU go with a Seasonic S12, the 120mm fan will help pull air out and it's the onlt PSU to use for an HTPC setup.

Are you using Digital Cable or Sat (I'm asking if you use an STB)?

For a setup like how you describe I think you'd be better served by getting two TV tuners, one tuner is highly impractical.

I would suggest this: http://www.pcalchemy.com/product_info.php/cPath/54/products_id/171
 
i say air cool it, ambient temps are gonna be pretty high with all the hard drives and water cooling doesnt really help in that department.

might i also suggest the xp90 if it'll fit your application? the zalman gets dust build-up between the fins pretty quickly and it kills it's cooling abilities. canned air will rememdy the issue, but low maintenance is a good thing.
 
Mysogonist said:
did you take a look at apttech.blogspot.com? if so...thoughts? I really plan to start to beefing it up as i get closer to purchase day, but after the HW builds, I still have to go into the software layer....should be really cool.

M
What you have to remember is is that an HTPC is about 20% hardware and about 80% software With that said the hardware part looks good, just have to change out the cooling for something alot quieter (as I mentioned before the OTES might be problematic in this area), you intend for this to be an HTPC server right? If so MCE might not be your best option since it's able to do this kind of stuff is really lacking. IMO I would go with SageTV for this since out of the box it lets you configure it in a server/client setup, this is the PVR app that I use and I think it's well worth the cost of it. But I should say that SageTV shines brightest as a PVR app everything else like music and DVD playback feel sort of tacked on. This doesn't bother me since I perfer to use seperate apps to do that stuff (iTunes for music and TheaterTek for DVDs and video) but the problem with this is that you need another app to "glue them all together," it's called a frontend. Ones I would look at are Meedio, MediaPortal and Xlobby.

Wait- Did I mention not to use the Seagate HDDs if they're the 7200.8 series? Well yeah, performance wise they're not that great (but really who can notice a fraction of a second?) but they're noise level is terrible as well as running hotter, my friend has one in her rig and it's pretty damn annoying for even a desktop system. Check out SilentPC Review's storage forum for some really good suggestions on good quiet HDDs.

A note on TV connections, do try and use the DVI/HDMI port on your TV for the best possible connection but you should know that ATI's DVI to HDTV drivers are rather lacking in tweaking options, I do understand that ATI is making some progress with their drivers though so you might get lucky and have your TV work right away. But if it refuses to work you might want to pickup a 6800 series card (I'm skipping past the 6600 series cards since the AGP ones have no way to quiet them down), NV's support for DVI to HDTV is much more mature.

What do you intend to do about/for sound?
 
CrimandEvil said:
What you have to remember is is that an HTPC is about 20% hardware and about 80% software With that said the hardware part looks good, just have to change out the cooling for something alot quieter (as I mentioned before the OTES might be problematic in this area), you intend for this to be an HTPC server right? If so MCE might not be your best option since it's able to do this kind of stuff is really lacking. IMO I would go with SageTV for this since out of the box it lets you configure it in a server/client setup, this is the PVR app that I use and I think it's well worth the cost of it. But I should say that SageTV shines brightest as a PVR app everything else like music and DVD playback feel sort of tacked on. This doesn't bother me since I perfer to use seperate apps to do that stuff (iTunes for music and TheaterTek for DVDs and video) but the problem with this is that you need another app to "glue them all together," it's called a frontend. Ones I would look at are Meedio, MediaPortal and Xlobby.

My attraction to MCE is that I use MS for almost everything. WMP10 for movie playback and for music as well. I like the fact that it's integrated and covered in the auto update feature. I do have an IPOD but I only use iTunes for sync. I find that Apple's implementation of windows software is shabby at best. Though I hope that changes now that the OSs are going x86/intel

CrimandEvil said:
Wait- Did I mention not to use the Seagate HDDs if they're the 7200.8 series? Well yeah, performance wise they're not that great (but really who can notice a fraction of a second?) but they're noise level is terrible as well as running hotter, my friend has one in her rig and it's pretty damn annoying for even a desktop system. Check out SilentPC Review's storage forum for some really good suggestions on good quiet HDDs.

I would say that the 7200.7s that I have are near silent. I was toying around with the notion of putting the 250s in 5.25" enclosures to keep em quiet and cool, but that is even more fans to the setup, and my apt does get dusty at time. At anyrate, I will look around for quiet drives, I had always thought that th segates with the fluid ball bearings were pretty quiet.

CrimandEvil said:
A note on TV connections, do try and use the DVI/HDMI port on your TV for the best possible connection but you should know that ATI's DVI to HDTV drivers are rather lacking in tweaking options, I do understand that ATI is making some progress with their drivers though so you might get lucky and have your TV work right away. But if it refuses to work you might want to pickup a 6800 series card (I'm skipping past the 6600 series cards since the AGP ones have no way to quiet them down), NV's support for DVI to HDTV is much more mature.
]

Right now I have my sever hooked up via DVI on a TI4200 and it looks great on my Samsung DLP set. From what I understand it's a good set to have for HTPCs though I hope that the 9800pro behaves with the latest catalyst drivers. If the 9800pro doesnt work, I will likely go with a 6800 non-pro though the budget is getting thin.

CrimandEvil said:
What do you intend to do about/for sound?

Right now I have an NF2 board with soundstorm but I have no 5.1 surround system for the TV. I will use the onboard sound of the MAX3 when I do get it up and running and do a analog 5.1 connection to the logitech z5500s. This leave the coaxial and optical open for my consoles.

Hey, thanks for all your help on this!!!
 
Back
Top