AGP, suck to be me..........

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dr. Righteous

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 1, 2007
Messages
3,163
I'm stuck hunting a replacement AGP card for my Linux machine.
I migrated all my work stuff to an older AGP 8x machine that runs Ubuntu pretty well and all is snappy on everything except video.
The old Radeon 8500 cannot handle the resolution for my dual monitor setup. It won't span both 1440x900 monitors with an expanded desktop, but it will if I drop the resolution. That works, but it looks like CRAP.

Well, I got to looking and the prices on AGP cards and the prices are high.
I noticed that AGP Nvidia cards are much cheaper than the ATI cards for some reason.
I have anways been a ATI man, so I am familiar with the Radeon cards since the beginning, but I know little about Nvidia cards.
What I need is a AGP card with 512M or memory with dual DVI out. For an ATI I looking for a HD3xxx card. It doesn't have to be a gamer card, but it must have good OpenGL performance and enough memory to support the 2880x900 desktop.
So anyone know what would be the equivalent in a Nvidia card to a ATI HD3xxx card?
 
Well I think part of the reason you will find Nvidia AGP cards to be cheaper is that they are lesser cards of an older generation. Nvidia bailed out on AGP support much earlier that ATI (though ATI support is really through 3rd party manufacturers using their chips, no ATI namebrand units). My memory is kind of fuzzy on this, but I think about the most "advanced" chip family that Nvidia got on AGP was a 7800GS.

By the time you get into the old stock of 7600GT or 7800GS range of Nvidia AGP cards, you may be paying about the same as what you would for an ATI 4650. The 4650 offers more bang for the buck. I simply don't think there is an Nvidia equivalent to the ATI 3000 series you are looking for in AGP.
 
Last edited:
Why do you need a 512MB video card? 256MB should be more then enough.

My suggestion, search the forums for a used AGP card or start a WTB thread.

Nvidia does not have an AGP card that matches the HD3850 or HD4650.
Nvidia fastest AGP card is the 7900GS and that is slower than the ATI 1950pro.

A used AGP x800pro/xt, x1650pro/xt, 2600pro, HD3650, 6600GT, 6800GS/GT, 7600GS should fit your needs. You should be able to find them for $20-40. Most of these will be 256MB card though.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: N4CR
like this
ATI x850 is a good card.
Just be careful if you find one, that it's agp and not pcie since they made both!
 
I'm staring at my Sapphire 3850 512mb AGP card over on my work desk.

Make me an offer....
 
i have a firegl (9700 pro 128 mb) and quadro fx 3000 256 meg, both apg. doing nothing lol
 
I was able to score a HD2600 AGP card for $25 shipped on Ebay. Not bad.
Installing that card solved my extended desktop issue. When I installed the driver it enabled all kinds of weird desktop effects in Ubuntu. Some cool, some kind of stupid. I turned off the stupid ones :)
One thing I still have a bit of a problem with is full screen video playback. Not how good the driver support is. Plays fine windowed, but full screen it stutters.
 
I'm stuck hunting a replacement AGP card for my Linux machine.
I migrated all my work stuff to an older AGP 8x machine that runs Ubuntu pretty well and all is snappy on everything except video.
The old Radeon 8500 cannot handle the resolution for my dual monitor setup. It won't span both 1440x900 monitors with an expanded desktop, but it will if I drop the resolution. That works, but it looks like CRAP.

Well, I got to looking and the prices on AGP cards and the prices are high.
I noticed that AGP Nvidia cards are much cheaper than the ATI cards for some reason.
I have anways been a ATI man, so I am familiar with the Radeon cards since the beginning, but I know little about Nvidia cards.
What I need is a AGP card with 512M or memory with dual DVI out. For an ATI I looking for a HD3xxx card. It doesn't have to be a gamer card, but it must have good OpenGL performance and enough memory to support the 2880x900 desktop.
So anyone know what would be the equivalent in a Nvidia card to a ATI HD3xxx card?

Just to recap I believe the reason you can't find an Nvidia equivalent is because Nvidia never made a card that supported beyond Direct X 9.0 and whatever was the most recent version of Open GL they stopped supporting on AGP as well, so you won't find DX10 or higher and higher OpenGL support with Nvidia. However, you will get higher default clockspeeds and wider memory buses of 512-bit versus 128-bit or 256-bit that ATI cards had at that time. If you want DX 10 support you'll have to go with the 3850 from ATI and their partners.
 
Just to recap I believe the reason you can't find an Nvidia equivalent is because Nvidia never made a card that supported beyond Direct X 9.0 and whatever was the most recent version of Open GL they stopped supporting on AGP as well, so you won't find DX10 or higher and higher OpenGL support with Nvidia. However, you will get higher default clockspeeds and wider memory buses of 512-bit versus 128-bit or 256-bit that ATI cards had at that time. If you want DX 10 support you'll have to go with the 3850 from ATI and their partners.
 
Still have m evga 6800 (256mb) ultra agp in a storage bin. 20 bucks if you want it lol
 
I think i have an ATI X700 pro AGP lying around i could sell you for super cheap if youre interested?


edit- i should look at the original post date, didnt realize someone summoned this 6 year old thread....
 
This reminds me of my old 2006-2009 rig:

Athlon 64 X2 4400+
GA-K8U-939
4GB DDR 400
3850 512MB
Audigy 2

Twas a mighty fine rig back in it's day. Fallout 3 was the last triple A game that it ran well heh.
 
I got an old Geforce 6600GT card lying around if you need it. Can't confirm that it works though, although when I took it out it was still working. Its yours for 10 bucks!
 
I assume I know the answer, but is this in any way used for gaming? If not, then you could buy two cheap USB 2.0 Video Adapter devices and go about it that way instead of hunting down another AGP card.

I am not sure about Linux driver support for those type of devices, but I know I have seem them on Windows and Macs.
 
Sounds like you'd be better off simply buying a more current, lower end mobo/CPU combo with integrated video.
 
I have a spare AGP 6600GT right here ... in case of emergency break glass. As with the age of this necro thread, it may finally be time to discard this last agp card.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top