AGEIA PPU - My opinion....

PC

Bad Trader
Joined
Mar 13, 2000
Messages
1,960
Isn't this basically the same situation that happened when the original 3D accelerators were launched? Same attitude? They were add on cards, and a few games supported them, then they were required, now they are mainstream and even onboard video has some (very limited) 3D capabilities. Most new technologies need an intro similar to this. If it takes off, I see onboard PPU's emerging within 3 years. If programmers don't support it, or if it just doesn't give the benefits that it is supposed to, then I see it as a dead end technology. I hope it does well, as we have awesome eye candy, great sound, a few games have great gameplay, some AI is great, and physics are just a natural progression on this. And with Doom3, Half Life 2, and other newer games trying to improve the physics of the environment, I see it as a sign.

Of course, with a $300 price tag just for the physics, I'm not game. If the price drops <$100, I will pick one up to improve the game. Of course, my system is built around gaming. Nothing else. I have other systems for music, movies, web design, etc... (Not one for each, of course!). Joe Sixpack doesn't care about that. He didn't care for the $400 3D Voodoo card, either. Now, if he wants to buy a game, even Monopoly, he needs a 3D card.


I see the PPU emerging as a new technology, and hopefully filling the niche market, and moving into the mainstream with the programmers support. I would LOVE to see this natual progresssion take place, and look forward to seeing some actual in-game video's soon. I DO want to see a nice improvement over what can be done now, and I want it to be fairly noticeable. Moving grass in games, moving trees, etc. all add to the immersion factor. The more the merrier. I'm all for eye candy. Little things help with that.
 
This should have been placed in the ongoing thread on AGEIA in I believe it was the video card section.

Anyways, yes I too believe it is very similar to GPU introduction, and am very excited to see games start to take the next step in immersion....realistic physics.

If you search there are a couple of nice demos of the technology, I like the plane crashing into the warehouse.
 
Erasmus354 said:
This should have been placed in the ongoing thread on AGEIA in I believe it was the video card section.

Anyways, yes I too believe it is very similar to GPU introduction, and am very excited to see games start to take the next step in immersion....realistic physics.

If you search there are a couple of nice demos of the technology, I like the plane crashing into the warehouse.

I didn't put it in the video card thread because ... well... the PPU isn't a video card. Physics aren't necessarily graphical. Flight Sim you can't really SEE the physic's....

dust
 
I wasn't saying the ppu thread belonged in the video card section, just that there was already a lengthy discussion there about the ppu, and you could have simply posted there instead of making your own thread. Its not like there is a Physics Card area of the forums yet.

Then again some people like to feel special
 
What is probably going to happen is it will be an add on card for a few years. And when all games start to "require" it, then the GFX Card companies like ATi And NVidia will either incorporate the tech onto their GFX Cards, or make it part of their GFX cores....

Either way, im sure it is here to stay. No one wants fake video games forever. As we are moving forward this is just the next step.
 
USMC2Hard4U said:
What is probably going to happen is it will be an add on card for a few years. And when all games start to "require" it, then the GFX Card companies like ATi And NVidia will either incorporate the tech onto their GFX Cards, or make it part of their GFX cores....

Either way, im sure it is here to stay. No one wants fake video games forever. As we are moving forward this is just the next step.

You are the second person I have seen to suggest that, I dont know where you people get this idea from. The boards and cores are crowded enough as it is. The PPU has something like 130million transistors, and the next gen GPUs will have over 200million, you cannot combine those, it just isn't feasible, the chip would be frigging ginormous. Not to mention there isn't room to have 768mb of GDDR3 RAM on the board, or the enormous power requirements.

Bottom line, PPU will never be integrated into a GPU, period....I wish people would see the logic as to why that wont ever happen.
 
Erasmus354 said:
You are the second person I have seen to suggest that, I dont know where you people get this idea from. The boards and cores are crowded enough as it is. The PPU has something like 130million transistors, and the next gen GPUs will have over 200million, you cannot combine those, it just isn't feasible, the chip would be frigging ginormous. Not to mention there isn't room to have 768mb of GDDR3 RAM on the board, or the enormous power requirements.

Bottom line, PPU will never be integrated into a GPU, period....I wish people would see the logic as to why that wont ever happen.
Logically, It will be integrated on one card eventually. Since the PPU has no use outside of the games department, the GFX card and the PPU card go hand in hand.

Also, You are talking about not fitting all this on one card. True it would be crowded now. But as you see, i said years from now. When things are much smaller, much more condenced and the PPU processor is nearly a requirement to run 3d game. 3 - 5 years from now. I am not talking about anytime soon...
 
Erasmus354 said:
You are the second person I have seen to suggest that, I dont know where you people get this idea from. The boards and cores are crowded enough as it is. The PPU has something like 130million transistors, and the next gen GPUs will have over 200million, you cannot combine those, it just isn't feasible, the chip would be frigging ginormous. Not to mention there isn't room to have 768mb of GDDR3 RAM on the board, or the enormous power requirements.

Bottom line, PPU will never be integrated into a GPU, period....I wish people would see the logic as to why that wont ever happen.


Yeap, and computers will never need more than 640k of memory, and no one will ever need more than 5 megabytes of storage.

There is no way to tell where the computing world will go. While 3dfx was putting out the voodoo series of cards, no one thought that having a 2d/3d chip was feasible(They did put out the voodoo rush but it performed horrbily, feeding that myth even more. Nvidia being the first 2d/3d card on the *consumer* market). Math co-processors used to be an addon chip because,"not everyone needed them." etc etc....
 
Erasmus354 said:
You are the second person I have seen to suggest that, I dont know where you people get this idea from. The boards and cores are crowded enough as it is. The PPU has something like 130million transistors, and the next gen GPUs will have over 200million, you cannot combine those, it just isn't feasible, the chip would be frigging ginormous. Not to mention there isn't room to have 768mb of GDDR3 RAM on the board, or the enormous power requirements.

Bottom line, PPU will never be integrated into a GPU, period....I wish people would see the logic as to why that wont ever happen.

You will eat those words.
 
GPU's will never contain a PPU unit at today's .09um process... Maybe in the future. But as a second core chip on the card itself? Probably. Physics make a BIG part of the immersion factor. Red Faction had environments that could be manipulated. HL2 does big time. So does Doom 3. I think that a PPU unit has potential, if the programmers will utilize it.

And I feel that instead of graphics cards, we will move to gaming cards. Graphics, Physics, etc. on one card. The technology will be licensed, not the PPU itself. In my opinion, of course.

Imagine Far Cry with next-next-gen graphics (whoa!) with all the physics handled with a PPU with a dual core 4.5 GHz processor and 2 GB of RAM... Fucking awesome. Walking in the sand with everything moving realistically, looking awesome, movements perfect, AI perfect. If the monitor was big enough (remember the wrap around monitor that was supposed to come out), it would be FUCKING AWESOME!!!! :)

I just think the next logical step is the physics. We have the graphic horsepower, the CPU horsepower; lets take the next step.

We just need the game support. Otherwise the technology is dead in the water. :(
 
IMO, the PPU thing is a great idea, but, atm, useless. Firstly, as was mention, the pricetag is a little on the incredible side. They must be pricing to sell to CG designers or something to maybe integrate into their systems to accelerate things even more because the end user is NOT going to want to spend $300 for something that right now current CPUs are still ahead of (I mean, come on, I can still play games like Doom 3 just fine on my mere barton!)

I think it's a good idea though, and I can see it taking root a few years from now maybe. It has a lot of potential for any game really, even something as simple as an RPG can potentially make use of it. Physics are physics whether it's the weight and speed of a sword as it flies through the air or the effects of a bullet against a steel wall or how a bomb should fly through the air with wind sheer affecting it's trajectory.

One card though? I don't see that happening. We LIKE to keep things seperate. For example, you don't see sound integrated into graphics cards. (Don't use the integration into MBs argument as the same could be applied to graphics, and we all have seen the horrible results of THAT. Ok, sound is less problematic, but, nonetheless, it's still far better to have a real soundcard.)
 
I think PPU's will probably be in all gaming PC's in 2 years and will be in all PC's within 6 years.

The reason they will become so common is because the prices will drop quickly and stay low, even through many improvements in the cards, for many years. The prices will drop because Ageia needs to get them into as many hands as possible to make this thing work.

I also think that within 4 years an AI add-on card will be announced and within 10 it will be completely ubiquitous as well.
 
Hmm, I don't know about AI. That's a little too hard to standardize I'd bet.

You may be right though about them becoming popular. I believe more than two years, but, I can see it happening. For one thing, they HAVE to get them out there fast. If it works, they will have competition. Probably from the video card companies I'd imagine as they already are close to that same sort of technology. Right now it's in their best interest to get people using them and build up a base of trust as well as get what profits they can before those margins get smaller thanks to competition. On the other hand, that's if they are that smart about it. If they just look at the no competition factor, they might just let it stagnate and overcharge until there is competition. (Let's hope they are smart about it, eh?) Don't believe me? Lol, just look at ATI and nVidia... Nothing new REALLY, just old stuff with different clocks/etc. Maybe more memory thrown in there for good measure.
 
Such a device will have a purpose eventually, but not now. If it came out now, its implementations would come as a result of its existence. For instance, there isn't anything to indicate that today's games would be worse without thousands of physics calculations that would be impossible without a PPU. However, it would be pointless for developers to just throw in complex avalanches just because there's something out there that allows them to.
 
I think the idea is for it to make it possible to do things that if done now would end up adding such complexity that it's just not viable. For example, the idea of the bullet hitting the wall and chipping the paint, sending out shrapnel peices that interact with each other, and so on. Adding all the complexity that this could supposedly do might well bring down a powerful CPU even. I don't know for sure. I will admit that current physics are well beneath the level of current CPUs, so the only real value I see in this is for that idea.

I see another advantage too. It would kind of standardize things. Right now you see lots of physics in a few games and next to none in some others. If this worked like some of us hope it would, it would make it not just easier for people to add certain features, but, maybe even make some of them so standard that they'd have to actually work to take them out (of course, it would have to be the sort of thing that you wouldn't WANT to take out...) Maybe we might see more realistic physics in games that wouldn't normally have thought of it like RPGs or whatever.
 
waddles said:
You will eat those words.

I dont think so, I mean really what the hell do ATi or Nvidia care about physics? At most you will see something like onboard video integrated into a motherboard, some crappy onboard physics. There is simply not much logical connection to draw the conclusion that PPU and GPU would be integrated onto the same board, just because they have a similar premise at launch they are still fundamentally different.

Also, yes as technology increases chips will get smaller, however, inevitably both GPU and PPU will each become more advanced, each require more memory, power, capacitors, etc...

High end video cards of today aren't much smaller at all than the high end video cards of 10 years ago, what makes you think 10 years from now it will be feasible to integrate PPU and GPU together without creating a behemoth like that dual 6800u prototype that looked like it was 2x as wide as a standard card, and 3x as long.
 
Er, seems to me like right now physics and graphics are pretty directly linked, though it probably ends up being the CPU doing the work. One still ends up doing huge amounts of figuring out what the other should do sometimes.

I still think it's nVidia and ATI that will step up to compete with AGEIA in the future. Just I still stick to the idea that it will be on a seperated card.
 
Apart from the problems of size and power requirements of putting a PPU onto a videocard, there's also the problem of bandwidth. Putting both things on one card means the GPU and PPU have to share the AGP/PCI-e bus, which could be far from optimal.
Also, I don't really see why the PPU should be on the videocard... they aren't directly related, although there will be people who will use both of them for games.
But it would be equally at home on a soundcard for example, which would not have such big problems as a videocard would, because a soundcard is not nearly as power- or bandwidth-hungry as a videocard.
And why are there no sound/videocard combo's? They'd be great for gamers too, but nobody ever thought of integrating the two, so we may never see the physics card integrated with something else either... except for a motherboard perhaps.

Anyway, I hope the PPU takes off, because it will offer a tremendous leap in realism... Today, a game is cutting-edge if you can move a few boxes or other objects in a room... A few years from now, you might be able to move every brick that the room was made of (PhysX is supposed to handle 30-40k objects in realtime already... far more than the 100-200 a high-end CPU can do).
 
arentol said:
I also think that within 4 years an AI add-on card will be announced and within 10 it will be completely ubiquitous as well.

Physics can be viewed as a heavy floating-point load, or even more specifically, you can create hardware to solve differential equations and thereby have a monster physics processor. I'm not sure an AI processor would be so clear-cut. And if it ended up just being a general-purpose design, we've already got one of those - the CPU.

Anyway, I'd take a risk and pay $100 for a PPU, but more than that, and I'll wait and see. I'd need to see some games that truly require it and make use of physics in gameplay, and support from a few different physics API vendors - I don't want another Glide.
 
Circuitbreaker8 said:
I think the PPU is the biggest waste of technology....ever.

Oh yeah absolutely. This is the most intellectual addition to this thread yet. :rolleyes:



Personally I would like to see this kind of physics unit take off and become integrated technology in CPUs themselves. As time goes on this is something that I see really taking off...especially as games become more and more "realistic". You can't just add eye candy in the form of pretty colors and lights without adding in the rest over time. I think the PPU will finally add another "evolutionary" layer to the gaming world.
 
Not to debate if it will be integrated into GFX cards in the future, but one item to consider.

The PPU core requires it's own 128MB of memory, the AEGIA product is spec'd for 128MB of GDDR3 memory. Since it's doing it's own set of calculations and needs to address it's memory exclusively, it will need it's own direct connection to this RAM. The logistics to ensure that a GPU and a PPU won't attempt to use the same bus at the same time and possibly overwrite the others content is a big design hurdle.

In dual-core processors, this is somewhat mitigated due to the processors being identical and peforming the same instruction sets, still not trivial but Intel and AMD have worked it out successfully.

Since this would be a large amount of reengineering each time a new core was being proceduced by each company (ATI or nVIDIA), the advantages would be reduced or we'd see less innovation each year in contrast to what we've seen in the past.

Granted, they could place it on the card with it's own separate memory, etc, but even with the small chips as currently available, the methods for cooling the materials have yet to "shrink", in fact I see the opposite with more outrageous cooling systems every year. welcome to the realities of dealing with thermal issues versus the increasing density of chipset cores.
 
I really dont get why there are so many people who think / want the ppu to be integrated into something else. I dont think I ever heard someone say "Im looking forward to them integrating a videocard into my p4" Yet every other post in here is someone saying they cant wait for the ppu to be integrated into something else.....I think people here are just cheap and dont want to have to pay for another add-in card.
 
Erasmus354 said:
I really dont get why there are so many people who think / want the ppu to be integrated into something else. I dont think I ever heard someone say "Im looking forward to them integrating a videocard into my p4" Yet every other post in here is someone saying they cant wait for the ppu to be integrated into something else.....I think people here are just cheap and dont want to have to pay for another add-in card.

That's because video processing and physical processing are wholly different. With the VPU/GPU scene there are new tricks, bells, and whistles that come out all the time. There's no room, power, or heat dissipation overhead available to put a GPU/VPU onto a CPU.

With the PPU I can see it coming and going the way of the arithmetic units of old. They will be add on cards initially, possibly have seperate sockets in the future, and eventually will be CPU integrated and taken for granted as the arithmetic units are now.

Do you really see the field of physics processing growing like the 3D field? It almost doesn't seem possible to me however I could be wrong.
 
Wolf-R1 said:
That's because video processing and physical processing are wholly different. With the VPU/GPU scene there are new tricks, bells, and whistles that come out all the time. There's no room, power, or heat dissipation overhead available to put a GPU/VPU onto a CPU.

With the PPU I can see it coming and going the way of the arithmetic units of old. They will be add on cards initially, possibly have seperate sockets in the future, and eventually will be CPU integrated and taken for granted as the arithmetic units are now.

Do you really see the field of physics processing growing like the 3D field? It almost doesn't seem possible to me however I could be wrong.

Hard to say, but the GPU is really only pushing arithmetic functions around with the end result of a processed video image. Your point would indicate that CPU's would eventually integrate this function as well. I think though that the trend shows that having this separate and speciallized will always result in better performance. If PPU support in software takes off, I think it may follow a similar trend.

But it could all change with the parallism that is now starting to come to the market, we could even see the integration of the GPU back into a future highly parallel core.
 
HighTest said:
Hard to say, but the GPU is really only pushing arithmetic functions around with the end result of a processed video image. Your point would indicate that CPU's would eventually integrate this function as well. I think though that the trend shows that having this separate and speciallized will always result in better performance. If PPU support in software takes off, I think it may follow a similar trend.

But it could all change with the parallism that is now starting to come to the market, we could even see the integration of the GPU back into a future highly parallel core.
*cough* Cell *cough*
 
After seeing Half-Life 2 I'm really looking forward more physics in games. Heck, Oblivion alone will justify a $250 expenditure. :D
 
HighTest said:
Exactly, I just didn't state the obvious, just refered to a highly "parallel" core. :D
Cell is not all that different from a PPU. I imagine some dev's are going to go nuts with the physics in PS3 games, especially in PS3 exclusive titles. Ageia is going to pump NovodeX(Ageia's physics engine) into many PS3 games.

I'm really like the idea behind the PPU. Ageia does face the classic 'chicken and the egg' type problem.....nobody's going to buy one unless games really benefit from it, and no dev's are going to make games that require a PPU until there is enough of a userbase to sell their games to. While this is a big problem for Ageia, these types of problems have been overcome before.

The biggest thing Ageia has going for it is Unreal Engine 3. There are TONS of games being built with UE3, and the smartest move Ageia has made so far is to get Epic to embrace NovodeX in their engine, which can make use of the PPU. The advantage NovodeX has over something like Havok is its optimised for multithreading...something most physics engines today are not. You are going to see lots of future games NovodeX. Ageia is practicly giving away licenses to developers. They see themselves as a hardware company, not a software company. NovodeX is their foot in the door.
 
mashie said:
Who is talking about avalanches?

The way things are ment to blow up :D

Okay, that was pretty cool. But really, how does that enhance gameplay? There aren't that many situations in which I would be able to justify spending $300...it would make a few more sequences in a few action games more believable, that's it. To me, anyway.
 
Considering some people have no problem buying a 2nd $500 video card for advanced video performance, I can see where this product might actually be a better placement. I'm guessing that with proper support, (this is in the future) you'll find that in many situations a VPU + PPU might give you better gaming than say 2 VPU's
 
Thing is, how much can that core TRULY be taken advantage of? There was a little discussion a while back that grew rather heated about whether the cell would take over the X86 world, and the general consensus tended to be to the effect that the cell is absolutely wonderful for the most mindless repetitive tasks, like video processing tends to be, but that the X86 is designed the way it is for a good reason and that being the simple fact that it has to be capable of doing so many different types of operations at it's best, not just really good at things that are parallel only. I mean, just look at the dual cpu systems that have been out for incredibly long. I once had a Pentium 3 350 (or was that P2? Can't remember after these years) that was dual cpu. It never did all that wonderfully better than a single 350. Sure, it was better, but, I was terribly dissapointed at the results in the end. The fact is, tasks end up not being very good at parallel in the end so that having multiple processors, multiple cores, or whatever just ends up being bottlenecked by one so often.

Most people agreed that what the cell is good at is video. Thing is, from what others were saying, it sounds like video cards have already been using some vague bit of this sort of technology for quite a while yet. In fact, apparently the cell is based on an already existing thing or something from what they were saying.

So don't expect greatness out of it. In the end, it's probably still for the best to have an actual video card, and actual soundcard, an actual cpu, and so on, all seperated. Not only does this make it possible for each individual one to take the work off the others freeing them up for tasks more suited to them, but, one important thing that people tend to forget when thinking to integrate the heck out of everything is the simple fact that when seperated you have the option to replace the one component you want with a much much better one down the road without having to change the other stuff too. Which would you rather do, spend $500 for a $300 value video card with a $100 value PPU unit integrated (the extra $100 being for the extra memory, the cost of squeezing that ppu unit in there, and so on down those lines as well as a bit extra just on principle because they always like to overcharge) or, would you rather get a $300 video card and a $200 value PPU or perhaps a $400 video card and a $100 ppu, only to replace the $100 ppu with a better one when it becomes outdated. The first method requires you to spend another $500 later on to get a proper upgrade. The second requires you to spend $100 someday, $300 another, and so on. I would just like to add that, if the PPU is used in the sort of way they are talking about, it may well be adding more strain to video cards in the end (right now they are ahead, so more strain is probably a good thing -- but, look at that video and you'll see that there are probably a LOT more polygons being used in the PhysX demonstration than in the normal one) which may well mean you'll want to upgrade that video card more quickly.


Anyway, I saw that video. I have to admit I'm impressed. It's a perfect demonstration of just how they can do all that at once with the PPU versus being limited to just a little bit when it's going to have to run on a low end pc with a slow CPU. I wonder about things like dual core and the cell being great at physics, but, the fact is we need that central processor for other things, such as AIs too, so that's going to limit them. As I understand it, the problem here is that since those objects are supposed to be able to interact, it would mean a lot of parts depending on other parts to finish before they can continue, which would mean a single very powerful processor would be better than multiple weak processors.
 
finalgt said:
Okay, that was pretty cool. But really, how does that enhance gameplay? There aren't that many situations in which I would be able to justify spending $300...it would make a few more sequences in a few action games more believable, that's it. To me, anyway.

:rolleyes: You can't be serious.

Go back and read the forums on HL2 and D3 and see why the added physics would benefit gameplay.
 
Yep,

I can see the need. But I was also able to see the need for EGA, instead of the original capabilities that most stated was just fine for Ultima 1 (no not online version, but the real original from the early 80's).

I was then able to see the need for VGA and then finally for a 3D accelerated card. Yep, we've come a long ways!

Trust me, you'll understand once you see the new capabilities in yet to be released titles.
 
HighTest said:
Trust me, you'll understand once you see the new capabilities in yet to be released titles.
You know, that's what it always comes down to isn't it? In the end, we just can't really say much about a brand new technology that hasn't even so much as hit the stores yet, much less been put to use outside of a lab.

We can cross our fingers though. That's what I'm going to do. I like the idea of accelerating another aspect of gameplay. And, I can see how physics acceleration might well make it's way into other fields like CG or maybe just maybe some vague uses in things like CAD.

I don't know about you, but, I want to see it succeed just because I liked to see technology progress in a positive manner like this promises. If it's what they promise, it will be like the 3d accelerated video card was back in the SVGA days. (My problem with the cell is that I'm not 100% certain it IS a positive step for a REAL PC.)

And, no, integrating everything into everything else is not a positive step. It's putting things in a box so they get more limited in the end.
 
Nazo said:
Thing is, how much can that core TRULY be taken advantage of? There was a little discussion a while back that grew rather heated about whether the cell would take over the X86 world, and the general consensus tended to be to the effect that the cell is absolutely wonderful for the most mindless repetitive tasks, like video processing tends to be, but that the X86 is designed the way it is for a good reason and that being the simple fact that it has to be capable of doing so many different types of operations at it's best, not just really good at things that are parallel only.

I think you missed part of the point of the Cell then. It's basically a standard PPC at 3.2 GHz (which would be quite competitive with high-end x86 CPUs), and the extra parallel units ADDED to that. So it's still as good at general processing as an x86 is.
 
That's not what they were saying. Yes, it's based on PPC, but, that's not really the question.

I would like to point out the consideration that if it's so much work and everything that a normal CPU even at such tiny processes as Intel and AMD are making these days and they are so heat sensitive, it's not promising that this so called cell can manage to have 8 different units and even still promises to be extremely heat insensitive.

Anyway, in the end, the only way we'll know is to wait and see just what happens.
 
Integrated = mainstream. Not always, but as a generallity. Even a very basic model integrated would be decent. Similar to onboard video. Basic.

Erasmus354 said:
I really dont get why there are so many people who think / want the ppu to be integrated into something else. I dont think I ever heard someone say "Im looking forward to them integrating a videocard into my p4" Yet every other post in here is someone saying they cant wait for the ppu to be integrated into something else.....I think people here are just cheap and dont want to have to pay for another add-in card.
 
Back
Top