Advise on a nix server board please

TechLife

Weaksauce
Joined
Apr 13, 2006
Messages
109
Hey all,

I have been out of the game for quite some time and am fairly confused. What I am looking for is an inexpensive board that I can use for a Fedora server build. I need to support 12 drives, all at 6GB SATA. Config will be JBOD with Grayhole. No RAID. I am having a hard time figuring out what exactly I need here. I know I will have to add additional cards to support that many drives which is cool, I just want to make sure I have the right number of slots of the right type to support the full throughput rates. Speed is of utmost importance. Any size board is fine, I have a huge case. I don't want to overspend as I know this can be done fairly inexpensively.

I am currently looking at the following:
1x - GIGABYTE GA-Z87MX-D3H
2x - SYBA SI-PEX40064

I figured I throw and i3 on there with 4GB and rock out. Again, I always seem to wind up with way overkill when I build stuff. I would like to not do that this time. Any suggestions will be greatly appreciated!!



Thanks in advance...
 
Last edited:
I'd check out the HDD forum here, you might get better information. Although if you just want lowest possible cost I guess, but sever and Syba don't really mix.
 
Spinning drives? Sata 3 isn't necessary, and the Syba cards can't push a full 6Gbps over an X1 link. Probably still ok for mechanical drives, but I'm not sure how good the Marvell SATA controllers are.

The board is fine, and includes an Intel network adapter, although you probably don't need a Z87 chipset and could save money going with H87 or even B85 instead. Grabbing an IBM M1015 or Dell H200 (both rebadged LSI 2008) is a popular option for driving an additional 8 drives without using the controller's RAID functions. Do you see yourself needing multiple network interfaces?
 
Thanks for the replies so far.

Yes, they will all be spinners. I will probably do 2x250GB Raptor system drives in RAID 1 (reliability is key) and 10x4TB storage drives.

When I say I want to do it on the cheap, I'm not saying I'm afraid to spend money. I want this to last me the next 5 years at least. I just mean I don't want to waste money. I tend to way overdue things. For instance, I wouldn't have an issue dropping an i7 in there but it would be way overkill for the build. I just want to make sure I don't have any bottlenecks anywhere.

Maybe the question should be if I even need to rebuild? I have an Athlon II X2 250 (which NEVER breaks 50% usage) on a Gigabyte GA-MA770T-UD3P which has 6x3GB SATA connectors and I am using 2x Syba SD-SATA-4P with 4x1.5GB SATA each for expansion. The whole purpose of the rebuild is to make sure I am getting all of the performance possible out of the drives I have and there is no bottleneck anywhere. Maybe I should just stick with that and upgrade the SATA cards if I don't need 6GB for the spinners?

Thanks again for your time. Maybe time to move to the storage forum at this point?
 
I'd go make a post on HDD forum, more people doing this type of stuff there.

Nicer wouldn't be an i7 rather a Supermicro motherboard, Xeon CPU, ECC ram and LSI SAS controllers. Its not THAT much more expensive. Motherboard is $160, CPU is ~$200, ECC RAM is almost same cost as non-ECC, and an 8 port SAS controller is $100 on ebay (IBM M1015 you can flash to LSI firmware) and you'd only need 1 at first (8 + 6 onboard).

Performance isn't usually a huge importance because in the end you have a GbE limited to 100MB/sec. Unless you want a Plex server that is doing transcoding CPU isn't all that important, other than getting ECC. Oh and above build can be slightly cheaper going AMD as you can get cheaper CPUs that will use ECC ram.

But yeah, hard to justify this over using something you already have that works
 
Thanks. Posted over there. The i7 was just an example of what would be a waste of money and why I am asking you guys to keep me on track. I am definitely going to look into your suggestions. It isn't Plex and isn't doing any transcoding but is serving media. I recently tried a Synology NAS and media was spooling up much faster. Unfortunately it trashed a lot of my data so it's history. Point is, I must have a bottleneck here somewhere. That's what I'm trying to find and fix.

Thanks again!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top